Author Archives: SHG

It’s Just Not That Hard to Grasp

Law Professor Dave Hoffman at Concurring Opinions goes out on a limb by admitting that he just doesn’t get why former Court of Appeals Judge (and current Fordham Law School Dean) Joseph Bellacosa urges the public to shun the 88 Duke professors who sponsored an attack ad against the Duke Lacrosse players.

Unfortunately, Bellacosa doesn’t say, and I don’t understand, exactly what was so wrong about this statement.

Let’s see what the problem might be:  Duke professors have jumped to conclusions, based upon politically correct assumptions designed to inflame racial conflict, at the expense of one set of students for the benefit of another.  These guardians of intellectual freedom, who acted precipitously and utterly without foundation, to taint the wealthy, white Lacrosse players as not merely rapists, but racists, and thereby condemn an institution for its quasi-covert but pervasive racism, seized upon a developing incident to foment hatred.  Oh yeah.  And they were completely, totally, utterly wrong about everything.

Judge Bellacosa speaks out for the integrity of those who are given the honor of shaping the minds of our youth in institutions of higher learning, by asking that those who, in their self-serving zeal, violated every precept of integrity by their attack first, learn the facts later, approach.  These 88 professors, caught up in the overwhelming opportunity to use the incident they so desperately wanted to believe happened to further a secondary agenda, were all too happy to sacrifice the lives of three innocent boys.

The thing that bothers me most here, however, is that Law Prof Dave is a very smart guy, and I’m sure could have figured this out on his own under other circumstances.  So why is this so difficult for him to grasp?  I have a suspicion.  Perhaps the problem arises from his being a professor, the 88 being professors, and some misguided circling of the wagons.  Though Judge Bellacosa is now a dean, he has let his ability to see be clouded by his new reference group. 

On the other hand, have the law profs found that their common ground (and mutual protection/admiration society) justifies ignoring intellectual integrity when it’s one (or 88) of your own, then the whole shebang falls apart.  Whether the answer is to shun the 88, as Judge Bellacosa suggests, or merely to note the egregious error of their way and rebuke them for their disingenuous attack, isn’t really the point.  Free speech is fine.  Speaking out against racism is great.  But inflaming blind hatred against innocent people, particularly without benefit of factual basis; that’s a problem.  It’s just not that hard to grasp.

Why White Murders Matter More

Both Gideon and Norm Pattis, Connecticut lawyers both, discuss here and here the issues raised by the media coverage of the horrific Cheshire murders, and lack of coverage of murders of black victims in urban Hartford.  Does the murder of white victims matter more than that of blacks?  Are the lives of white people more valuable, important, significant than black lives?

I had a long discussion of this topic with a buddy at ABC back when news coverage of Natalee Holloway went missing in Aruba.  You remember her, she was the subject of Greta Van Susteren’s Fox TV show for something like 3 months straight, as if nothing else happened in the world.  As a result, she was ridiculed by high-minded critics, but “her ratings continue[d] to shoot up, making her the most-watched personality on cable TV.”

There’s the rub.  News coverage is not what it used to be.  Walter Cronkite is gone, and there are only two reasons that we still have news on TV.  The FCC requires it, and it’s a mechanism to sell commercial time.  The evening news is about getting people to watch, not about reporting news.  They know this.  Don’t you?

So when an editor decides that a particular story will be of interest to viewers, thus increasing ratings and thereby increasing advertising revenues, that becomes the “news”.  Only a child would believe that the news deals with issues of substance and importance in our daily lives.  If that was so, they would open with war in Iraq every night.  But nobody would watch.  Remember the old Saturday Night Live bit, “Francisco Franco is still dead?” 

As shown by Greta’s numbers during the interminable Natalee coverage, it captured enough eyes to keep it going night after night.  It wasn’t about the value of her life, but about the public’s interest in watching.  At the same time as the Natalee story captured the “public’s imagination,” there were black women who went missing or murdered.  They had families who loved them and desperately sought media interest to focus attention on trying to find them or their kidnappers or killers.  Remember them?  No, of course not.  Because nobody bothered to report about them. 

From the media point of view, it’s just a matter of one being “news” and the other not.  After all, there are just too many mundane murders and kidnappings to report them all.  Fair enough, but why is it that the cause celebre is always about a white instead of a black?  “That’s not true,” I was told.  “Oh no?” I asked incredulously.  “Name one.” 

“Tawana Brawley” — White ADA accused of rape.
“Duke Lacrosse” — White wealthy lacrosse players accused of rape

This went back and forth for a while, but you get the point.  Is it a “man bites dog” thing, or perhaps a blacks aren’t our desired demographics, or maybe they think blacks only watch “soul train” on TV and wouldn’t be interested anyway?  Granted, I’m being a bit harsh, but the hard, cold truth is that a story involving a white, wealthy, interesting person is going to be a story, while the murder of a black person, without a white hook somewhere in there, will be invisible.  About the best you can say in the media’s favor is that not all murders of white people make the news either.  But at least they have a chance.

But the ugly reflection is not just of the media, but of the watchers of the media as well.  It’s neither fair nor right that the media’s view of what constitutes news is mired in bias.  But if it wasn’t, would you watch?  It’s harsh and it’s a disgrace.  But despite all, it remains the case.

Soundbites With A Side of Substance

Jon Katz at Underdog discusses campaigning by soundbites, relating it back to the use of soundbites at trial.  Of course, the most famous one is the late Johnny Cochran’s, “If it does not fit, you must acquit” in the O.J. trial.  In politics, the soundbite means all, recognizing that people generally lack the tolerance to pay attention to a position or argument that requires more than 10 second of focus. 

But at trial, we have a captive audience.  It’s not like our jurors can get up and go to the fridge, thus missing the balance of our brilliant oratory, right?  While true, it similarly doesn’t mean that the fact that they are forced to sit in one spot and look at us means that they are (1) paying attention or (2) processing what we are saying.  And for anyone sitting in on another lawyer’s trial, we all know how the mind has an uncanny ability to wander during their, ahem, speechifying.

Since we are all keen observers of politics, we are astutely aware of the fact that most political soundbites are vapid.  Jon uses a clip from my Senator, Hillary (who I’m a little displeased with at the moment for not responding to the invitation to attend my son’s Bar Mitzvah, which is just plain rude), to make his point.  Notably, by using Hillary, he removes any challenge of playing politics to make his point.  The soundbite in this clip is that “people are invisible to the current administration.”  Well, perhaps that’s true, but you can bet that you’re just as invisible to Hillary, who is a very important person and doesn’t have time to listen to your concerns either.  Nice sound bite.  No substance.

The difference at trial is that we have an adversary there to remind the jury when we employ a soundbite that lacks substance.  And they should.  Just as we are there to do the same when the prosecution relies on the old saws to suggest guilt and wrongdoing when the evidence doesn’t do the trick. 

One problem for lawyers is that most of us aren’t very good at soundbites.  We like to talk.  We like to talk at length.  We justify it by proclaiming the need to explain things to the nth degree.  We like to back it up with examples.  Sometimes lots of examples, even to “prove” the most obvious points, thereby treating the jurors like ignorant 3 year olds who can’t comprehend the slightest concept without belaboring the point ad naseum.

Recently, I took over a case on appeal from a younger lawyer, and asked him a number of very specific questions about the case.  He droned on with me, stating the obvious (though non-responsive) answers and then giving me examples of the obvious.  Numerous examples.  After giving him free rein for a few minutes, I finally told him enough, I understood his point without the ten minutes of examples. 

He bristled at my rebuke, telling me he was trying to help.  I thought to myself, if I was sitting on his jury, not only would I have zoned out on him after the first three minutes, but I would want to punish someone for making me listen to this dud.

When I teach a CLE on media training, I emphasize the need to express oneself in soundbites.  During an interview, we get maybe 30 seconds of air time, and 20 second will be eaten up with the question.   Someone will invariably tell me that it’s not always possible to answer a complex issue in 10 second.  True, but the other option is to be denied the opportunity to have any say at all.  Those are the only choices, so if you want to have any impact, find the core of your point and get it out.  Make it punchy, clear and brief, or don’t bother.

ABA Capitulates

The ABA’s Commission on Effective Judicial Sanctions and the Criminal Justice Section were all geared up to actually do something, which by itself is controversial.  But with its collective hearts in the right place, they prepared to take a position in favor of legislation that would limit access to conviction records so former convicts could actually get jobs and become law-abiding, contributing members of society. 

Alas, it was too good to be true.  As I’ve written in the past, they’ve paid their debt to society and need a way to avoid going back to crime.  Sure, it was controversial, as is any move that doesn’t put people in jail longer or make their lives impossible until they day they die.  But this is the ABA, made up of folks smarter than that, and who can appreciate higher order thinking.  Right?  Well, maybe not.  They abandoned the position.
The move comes after press advocacy groups protested the recommendation, with the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press saying such legislation “would roll back 40 years of First Amendment jurisprudence…”

After all, what really matters in this society.  The ability of a former convict to create a new life as a law abiding citizen, or the media to get their hands on old criminal records to bolster the latest piece of sensationalism so they can make their stories really, really juicy?  I mean, really, where are our priorities?

If you ever needed proof of the existence of the slippery slope, this is it.  When the first amendment jurisprudence developed, it was never for the purpose of branding former convicts forever and ever with the mark of Cain.  But according the media, denial of access to criminal records will “eliminate the ability of the public and press to act as watchdogs of the criminal justice system.”  Yeah, that’s why the want access.  They’re our watchdogs.  And apparently the ABA is their lapdogs.   And what are former convicts?  Mutts.

Happy Anniversary to Me

Today is the 6 month anniversary of Simple Justice.  It seems a lot longer.  I guess it’s kinda like marriage in that regard.

As of 10:00 am this morning,

132,714     Hits
40,968       Article Reads
955            The most article reads in 1 day
145,531     Words written on Simple Justice

That’s a waste lot of words.  Thanks to everyone who comes here to take a look, read an article or leave a comment.  Even the readers who disagree with me, like the diamond salesman who took issue with my Diamonds are Forever post or Harry the Bushy Reactionary with my What Real Americans Have to Say, have added to the critical mass of thought that proves that we are alive.  Cogito ergo sum.

For better or worse, the only thing that makes a blawg worthwhile is the dialogue that exists between writer, reader and commentator.  I appreciate that all of you took a few minutes out of your busy day to stop by.  But don’t be afraid to leave your comments.  We would all like to know what you’re thinking.

Get Ready for the Mortgage Fallout

Over the past few months, I found myself in a world that had previously meant very little to me: Mortgages.  For those of us who do white collar defense, start boning up now because this is going to be big.

Mortgages lenders and originators are crashing and burning all over the place.  American Home Mortgage, a huge mortgage house, whose CEO is a really nice guy named Mike Strauss, collapsed.  This made big news.  A lot of smaller mortgage houses have fallen in the past few weeks as well, though they may not have made the ticker.  It doesn’t matter.  The point is that they are failing in a way that has never been seen before.  The closest analogy is the collapse of savings and loans.  And just like the S&Ls, the next step is the federal investigations into criminal practices that is going to results in prosecutions.

Already, the fallout is happening.  The feds are busy investigating lending practices and scams that were pervasive in the good old days of rising real estate values and easy money.  Prosecutions are coming.  As I began to quickly learn, this business was far dirtier than I had ever imagined.

Remember the “no income verification” loans?  Well, that gave rise to the straw buyer, used to shift mortgages back and forth, monetize flips immediately and leave the investors (like hedge funds) who put up the money to finance these loans (and ultimately hold the paper) in the hole. 

When people thought real estate could never stagnate, no less decline, it really didn’t matter.  They were happy to be had, with scam appraisals that would overvalue property so that a guy could buy property for half a million today, sell it to a straw buyer tomorrow or a million, and pull 110% out of that $500k property.   The mortgage people knew all about the scams, and were often in for a piece themselves.  There was so much money to be made that it was crazy to let it just sit on the sidelines.

But when the boom stopped, and the mortgage had to be paid, and the hedge funds pulled their funding out fearing that there would be no more easy money, the house of cards collapsed.  Nothing new about pyramid schemes, but these were real companies with tons of money behind them involved.

And so this looks to be the new areas for criminal defense.  There will be the big names of CEOs and CFOs, and the little names of the guys at the bottom of the food chain, but the investigations will involve them all. 

I spend the past weekend in Philly for a wedding.  In the early morning on Sunday, I went outside for some air and met an old friend of my sister’s whose brother had done very well for himself.  He was CFO for a mortgage bank.  She told me he was scared.  His company was soon to close. He knew it.  The collapse was just a matter of time.  What he hadn’t thought about yet was the day after the collapse.  The day that the federal agents would go in the door and start seizing files to see where all that good clean money went.  The day they were going to scrutinize who knew what and when did they know it.  How many heads were stuck in the sand while all that money disappeared?

Like all fertile white collar areas, it will take some studying to learn the industry.  It will take a deal of cynicism to appreciate why your defendants profess total ignorance of any wrongdoing, as it swirled around them.  The feds will see criminals under every stone.  Ambitious AUSAs will never believe that every person in the shop isn’t filthy dirty.  Sometimes, the AUSAs will be right. 

Get ready, this is already in the works and it will be coming fast.  And if you’re a mortgage broker or executive, today would be a good day to line up the best criminal defense lawyer you can find.  He’ll teach you what to do tomorrow morning at 6:00 am when there’s a knock on your door.  You may have been a great salesman for years, but you’re not quite prepared to talk your way out of this one just yet.

The Fashion of Forfeiture

Windypundit and A Public Defender are having a great discussion of “free” punishments imposed by Legislatures on people arrested for crimes.  Without any malicious intend to step on their toes, one particular “free” punishment that has long been hugely troubling is forfeiture.

In the old days, the maxim “The Law Abhors a Forfeiture” was the rule.  But one day, somebody got it into their head that the government LOVES a forfeiture, and then everything changed.  Think about it.  Take a guy while he’s down, take his assets and sell them for cash, which then goes to the government.  What’s not to like?

For most people, their view of forfeiture relates to cars, seized during drunk driving arrests.  This is but one, albeit the most pervasive and prominent, form of forfeiture.  Forfeiture in other contexts can include homes, businesses and bank accounts.  Under the guise of “proceeds” of crime, or “substituted proceeds of crimes,” meaning where the money from crime went, or what was purchased with legitimately earned money over a lifetime when the money made from crime can’t be found, anything and everything can end up being the subject of forfeiture.

In New York City, forfeiture was a free-wheeling deal until a federal court put some limits on it in McClendon v. Rosetti, 460 F.2d 111 (2nd Cir. 1972).  It started with a 10 day period after a demand was made for the return of property, which later became 10 “working” days after a “proper” demand, which later just fell into another legal fiction to be routinely ignored.  Don’t the police work every day?  Not in NYC, apparently.  Ironically, by the time a vehicle was ready for forfeiture, it had sat for months, even years, in the open police pounds in Queens until the car was nearly worthless.  Leave it to the government to screw up a good thing.

But what became of forfeitures in New York City?  The proceeds went into the police pension fund, thereby reducing the City’s contribution and fattening the calf for elderly police officers.  Do you think this provided an adequate incentive for the Police to seek forfeiture?

In federal courts, the forfeiture procedure was far easier than anywhere else, and the state (CPLR  Article 17A) and local procedures fell into relative disuse since the deal with the feds made life easier for everybody.  Whether it was direct federal forfeitures, or what was euphemistically called an “adoptive forfeiture,” there was one overarching feature of federal forfeitures:  The burden of proof is probable cause.  That’s right, you don’t get any lower than probable cause. 

So the state and local police would send its paperwork over to the federal forfeiture people, who would require a 10% “bond” to allow citizens the right to challenge the forfeiture, and then proceed by alleging probable cause, which would shift the burden to the claimant.  Of course, to claim a forfeiture, the property owner would have to provide an affidavit (with the bond) to show his right to the property, which would happen while a criminal prosecution was ongoing, and serve as an admission in the criminal case creating the classic Hobson’s Choice.  It was a brilliant system for the government.

Assuming you got past the procedural hurdles to get into the game of claiming property, the claimant would then be required to submit to all the civil procedural discovery mechanisms while simultaneously defending against the criminal charges.  How could this be?  Another legal fiction.

In federal forfeiture cases, the “defendant” is not the person, but the “thing” (the “res” as us lawyers call it in Latin to make us feel special).  It is the “res” that offends the sovereign, and forms the basis for forfeiture.  So there is no jeopardy issues for the defendant person when the defendant thing is at risk.  That’s the beauty of legal fictions.  They may make no sense at all, but it allows the courts to pretend they do and, by inserting a bunch of legal platitudes where one might otherwise expect thoughtfulness and reason, feel good about themselves for taking property away from people who can’t fight back.

So why do the state and local governments like this adoptive forfeiture method?  Because the feds have be far the sweetest deal on forfeitures, so totally skewed in favor of the government and so fraught with criminal liability risk for the person defendant that the very thought of challenging the forfeiture is almost like begging the state to toss you in jail.  But the feds are not entirely greedy.  Not the citizens, but with state and local police.  They split the proceeds with their benefactors, letting the local cops have a small chunk of change while keeping the balance for their “services”.  Everybody makes out, except the people from whom it’s taken, or his family, business associates, acquaintances. 

As free punishments go, this is a big profit center for the government.  And because it puts money in the government’s (and particularly law enforcement’s) pockets without them reaching directly into the taxpayers, they just love it.  For those citizens who can’t possibly perceive themselves to ever be the victim of this little government game, it sounds like a good deal all around. 

But since anybody, ANYBODY, could end up getting snagged for going one beer over the line, consider how you would feel if your brand new Mercedes AMG was sitting in the Whitestone Pound for 22 months while you were fighting the “zero-tolerance” stance toward drunk driving.  Seems a bit excessive?  But it doesn’t seem too farfetched, now does it?

The Moment After The Guilty Verdict

From Malum in Se, a blawg by a young criminal defense lawyer who is trying his best, comes a very touching post about what to say when you lose a trial.  In this instance, he was second seating a murder trial in Mississippi, where the sentence will be life.  With minor differences, there is no criminal defense lawyer who actually tries cases who hasn’t felt what he’s feeling now.

To those readers who aren’t lawyers, or aren’t trial lawyers, the bottom line is that no trial lawyer wins every case.  No matter how good he or she is, no matter how well prepared, no matter how brilliant his strategy and how incisive his examination, he or she will lose at trial from time to time.  Juries are unpredictable, even though we do everything we can to make them less so.  Facts sometimes can’t be overcome.  Things just turn out bad for reasons no one can anticipate or explain. 

Even when we have our doubts that a case can be won, lawyers gird themselves for the fight.  We focus on doing our job like an Olympic athlete.  We believe we can win, because we can’t go into battle believing anything else.  When we stand up next to our client to hear the verdict, we feel what they feel.  If the word that comes out of the foreman’s mouth is “guilty”, our hearts crash and our heads spin.  Big tough lawyers like us may not want to admit it, but that’s the moment that makes or breaks us, just like you.

When I was younger, and believed so ferverently that I was going to win a trial, the guilty verdict would hit me like a ton of bricks.  It never bothered me if someone called me a name, or told me I was wrong.  But there was no arguing with a verdict.  It was the depth of depression, a soul-searching experience of where did I go wrong. 

But Malum’s essay isn’t about him, and differs from my experiences in one critical way.  He writes, “I could have apologized, but we didn’t do anything wrong.”  For me, it was not about doing anything wrong, but doing it right enough to win.  A human being relied on me to save his or her life, and I failed to do so.  I stood between the person and the State, and it was not enough.  It was my responsibility to do better.

Malum asks what to say to a defendant who has just been sentenced to life in prison.  In my experience, that conversation would be had before the trial, because I never go to trial without talking to my client about what losing means.  More often than not, we’ve had that talk a few times before the trial actually happens.  It’s the clients life, and the client must know what it all means to him or her.  Without a real appreciation of consequences, before the final decision is made, we have not fulfilled our responsibility to our client. 

Afterward a loss, most of my clients have told me that they appreciated the efforts I made on their behalf.  They felt that I gave them a great trial, did better than they could have imagined.  They comforted me!  And I return the sentiment with an honest appraisal of what happened and where it will head from there. 

Since I do appellate work as well as trial work, my view of where things will go is strong and frank.  But this means that sometimes the answer is that they have no meaningful chance of reversal on appeal.  Sometimes they got a great trial, no error, no misconduct, strong evidence, and I don’t see reversal on appeal in their future.  I won’t lie to my clients.  In this instance, I tell them that they must get another lawyer to do their appeal, to review my work for flaws to give them a chance when I see none.  And I hope that another lawyer can find error on my part, if no one else’s’.  There’s no concern for my reputation, only for the client’s chances.

But let’s assume that the trial is over and lost, and there’s just nothing good to say.  You look your client in the eyes, hold him by the shoulders and tell him to hang in there.  You let your client know that you understand what he’s feeling at the moment, so that he knows he’s not alone in the world.  Words aren’t necessary to do this.  The look is more important, that you can look him in the eye. 

No matter how tough your client is, no matter how many times he has told you that he’s man enough to take a guilty verdict, he needs to know at that instant that there is at least one person who understands what just happened.  When you go to see him the next day, there will be time enough to talk about details.  But for that one moment after the word guilty is spoken, no matter how evil the rest of the world views you client, let him know that you understand.  That’s what you do.

What Real Americans Have to Say

UPDATE:  For anyone who, as per an email I received, may be confused by this post, it’s friggin sarcasm.  Thank you.
__________
Finally, a cogent and thoughtful discussion of who is a real American and who is a traitor, From Noteworthy Economist to Traitor in One Post spells it out. 

Forget those lilly-livered, commie-symps like Bill Buckley.  With great clarity of thought, and remarkable use of adjectives, this blog skewers the leftist New York Times and its Freakonomics spokesman, Steven Levitt (a/k/a Benedict “Terror-Lover” Arnold):

To hell with the Bush-haters who can’t see past their simplistic, naive World view to give a damn about our Nation.

Yeah!  To H-E-Double Hockey Sticks with ’em! I guess us simpletons have it easy, since we don’t have to give a damn about our Nation.  That probably explains why we haven’t realized the importance of sending a check to Mitt Romney, the only real he-man running for President who will personally shoot each and every terrorist (and New York Times columnist?) who is intent on destroying the American way of life by disagreeing with our government.

The genius behind this blog is a web designer, Harry somebody, from Utah (which lags slightly behind New Jersey on the list of states where fascinating things happen).  So you know he’s got some serious credibility.  Enjoy, and remember that this man could be on your jury.  Oh yeah, and check out the posts under the category “lawyers suck” for even more illumination. 

Professional Courtesy

“Cops don’t write cops tickets. It’s called professional courtesy.”  Yup.  Another thanks to Robert Guest at I was the State. 

Just in case there was ever any doubt in your mind.  So if you’re kid is struck and killed by a drunken cop, you will know why.  I’m sure that this will make you feel much better about your loss.