Author Archives: SHG

If You Thought Legalese Was Garbage

Jargonism by business makes lawyers look absolutely comprehensible, and that’s not easy to do.  So, in the spirit of fun and games, special kudos to anyone who can define the following terms:

Processing, as in “we are processing your order.”

Investigating, as in “we are investigating your problem.”

Escalated, as in “we have escalated the problem to level 17.”

Then there are the phrases crafted to make people feel all warm and fuzzy:

Working on the problem, as in “our development team is working on the problem.”

Awaiting a Response, as in “we have sent this to our tech support and are awaiting a response.”

Doing everything we can, as in “we have taken your money, provided no service, but won’t give you what you paid for.”

What makes me think of this today?  About 6 months ago, I made the mistake of going hi-tech with my office telephones.  The promise of flexibility using VoiP was too attractive to ignore, plus the cost-savings was quite extraordinary.  Unfortunately, my choice of companies was Sunrocket, the only telecom to go out of business overnight, leaving my phone number in techno-limbo.

But a savior appeared by the name of Packet8.  They would be the preferred successor to Sunrocket, and the lovely young woman with whom I spoke absolutely, positively guaranteed that they would have my telephone numbers “ported” over to then within 7-10 days (though she told me on the sly that it would likely be less and definitely be done by the seventh day).  Well, I felt quite fortunate indeed.

So the 7th day came and went, and then the 10th, but my number wasn’t “ported”.  As an aside, I have no idea what is involved in “porting”  a number, other than somebody somewhere in the bowels of some business flipping a switch.  Nobody I’ve ever spoken with knows exactly what “ported” means or entails, but they do so love to use the word.  I’m sure someone out there knows what is involved, and I would very much appreciate this bit of info.

Ultimately, my office number had a recording, “number deactivated.”  Exactly what every client, prosecutor and judge wants to hear.  Well, perhaps the prosecutors were happy, but the clients most assuredly were not.  And so I call, and call, and call, the nice folks who took my money.  And I ask them, what happened to their guarantee.  That’s when the song and dance happens in earnest, with the apologies for my “inconvenience”. 

After speaking with almost every person who ever served ice cream at Dairy Queen and graduated to become a CSR, I was finally escalated to the official corporate glad-hander.  He gave me his full name, a real direct telephone number and an assurance that he would do “everything possible” to get my number ported.  He was very encouraging, without every saying a single thing of substance.  He stroked me.  He was calm and authoritative.  It was wonderful.

Until the next day, when my number still had the dreaded “number deactivated” message.  And so I called the official glad-hander back, and left him a message.  After a second, message, he called me back to “update me.”  I was told he did everything possible and I’ve been escalated to the highest level.  I felt very important.

But, I inquired, my phone number still didn’t work.  It was my understanding, I told him, that you had some clout here, the ability to get something done.  But nothing’s been done.  Suddenly, Mr. Glad-hander’s tone changed.  “Well, we’ve done everything we can.”  But, but, but, says I, the number still isn’t working.  “We are awaiting a response,” he says. “There’s nothing more we can do.”

I could recite the rest of the conversation from heart, as I’ve had it before.  But you’ve probably had it too.  Here are the hard, cold facts.  We pay our money for a service.  We don’t receive the service.  We get locked in to a product or service that we cannot get out of.  We are fed nonsense.  We are put on hold, day after day, only to enjoy the wonders of being fed nonsense.  We give up in frustration, because there is nothing to do short of suing the bastards.

So why do I bother to blog about this?  This happens because we let it happen.  We’ve given up.  We take it.  This has got to stop, or we become the permanent patsies.  This has got to stop.

From the Office of Propaganda

When Lance Armstrong was winning his 49th Tour de France, it occurred to me that it was probably not appropriate for the United States Postal Service to be the sponsor of the cycling team.  Shirts, commercials, tires, whatever it is that a sponsor does, really shouldn’t be where a government agency spends its money.  Granted, it wasn’t exactly my tax dollars, but still my little stamp was supporting a sports team.

But that was child’s play, as I now learn.  There is what appears to be a blog called Pushing Back.  Except it isn’t really a blog.  It just looks like one.  It’s message is “Making the drug problem smaller.”  Well, that’s a fair enough reason to blog.  There are a lot worse, right?

With a hat tip to Jamie Spencer at Austin Criminal Defense Lawyer, and Robert Guest at I was the State, it appears that Pushing Back is a front for the Office of National Drug Control Policy.  Your tax dollars at work.  Mine too. 

In fairness to the ONDCP, it doesn’t hide its connection to Pushing Back or pretend that it’s some legitimate reflection of public sentiment.  But it also doesn’t function like a real blog, where readers are permitted to comment and engage in a dialog that challenges or supports its editorial stance.  Robert Guest calls them Drug War Cowards for the refusal to allow the public (that would be people like us who pay the freight for this phony blog) free speech.

So we’re left with two issues generated by our Government’s entry in the blogosphere:  first, is this what our government should be doing?  Do we want the executive branch putting out fake blogs to promote its point of view on our dime?  The second issue is why our Government likes to tell us what to do, but doesn’t want to hear anything back from us.  The lack of free speech, decried by both Jamie and Robert, reflects the Government’s lack of interest in what the public has to say.

In the Gettysburg Address, President Lincoln spoke of  “government of the people, by the people, for the people…”  Today, one would be hard-pressed to explain how the Government wants nothing to do with the people.  Except take their money to fund it’s blog, amongst other things.

Lawyer Fashionista: Critical Data

As any of you who have had the good fortune to see me in action know, I am a fashion plate.  Cutting edge.  The height of style.  If the year was 1984.

But as my daughter (a true fashion connoisseur) says, there’s nothing wrong with looking good.  And so I try my best not to break any of the standard fashion rules.  No white socks with black shoes.   No white shoes after labor day.   I was once informed by an ADA during a bench conference that it was wrong to wear a poplin suit on September 9th in 90 degree heat.  It was just wrong.  I hung my head in shame.

But, while I will not discourage readers from making fashion inquiries here, and I will certainly endeavor to provide sound advice to all comers, I have just learned that one of my favorite things to do has fallen completely out of fashion.

That’s right.  I wear my cellphone clipped to my belt.  Yes, the batman utility belt look.  And now it’s gone.  Verboten. Taboo.  Unfashionable.

My wife has been telling me I look like a geek for years, but what does she know?  After all, she’s married to me.  I always knew where my phone was.  It was readily available.  It was just so darn utilitarian, and doesn’t form follow function?  What am I, a slave to fashion?

But once it hits the front page of AOL, where everyone will see it, it’s too late.  I’m a marked man.  Everyone will point and laugh at me, as if my pants were ready for the flood (or I lived in New Jersey, same thing). 

Of course, it’s not as if I use my cellphone.  Out of the 500 minutes I get every month, I generally leave 479 on the table, and I only use that much because my train is late 3 times a week.  Even my phone itself isn’t thin enough or cool enough.  I ordered this really cool motokrazr, but my daughter swiped it from me within minutes after it arrived.  She told me it was wasted on me.  I would take pictures with my phone, but I still don’t understand why anyone would want to.  Isn’t that why we have cameras?

But I digress.  Henceforth, cutting edge lawyers like me will no longer wear their cellphone on their belts with little clip-ons.  Thank goodness there was no mention of clip-on ties.  Only kidding.

Fat: The New Black

While Overlawyered is often disappointing, they’ve actually got something this time with The most expensive bill ever written?  A new Massachusetts law has been proposed to eradicate discrimination against overweight and short people.

Now don’t get me wrong.  I’m neither particularly tall nor slim.  In fact, my Columbian clients have long called me “bajo y gordo,” which they told me meant “brilliant lawyer” in Spanish, although I know otherwise.   But for crying out loud, this has got to stop. 

Eradicating discrimination on certain bases (sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability, medical condition, marital status, and sexual orientation), even though these may well push the limits beyond the rational and into the fashionable.  Fat, however, is not in this league.

It is foolhearty for any person or business to decide that they won’t have a fat person do a job for which they are eminently qualified.  The same is true of ugly people.  Trust me, I know from ugly discrimination.  So why isn’t ugly included in the new list?  We all know that ugly people are perceived as less worthy than beautiful people, paid less and treated like dirt.  Hey, aren’t they human too?

And then there are people who are lazy.  They sure don’t get a fair shake.  The list is as long as people’s imagination and ability to whine.  Yes, the world is full of discrimination, and a great deal of it is vital to our existence.  If a good looking guy doesn’t ask out a fat ugly woman, should she have a cause of action?

More to the point, weight has real negative ramifications.  It’s not my place to be concerned with another person’s girth, but when I’m sitting in coach on a flight, you can be I’ll be concerned when it’s come over the arm rest and into my space.  Yes, that’s right.  I want my space free from the excess of my neighbor.  Nothing personal, but keep your belly to yourself.

The health ramifications are well know.  Obesity amongst children is a national epidemic.  So the answer is to give it legal protection?  At least ugly doesn’t have health consequences. 

No doubt there will be overweight people who will hate this view.  Perhaps some will let me know how wrong I am, and how prejudiced I am, and how dangerous it is to endorse bias against the poundage challenged.  To you, I say that I am no chubby hater, but this insanity of giving legal protection to every group that feels bad about their lot in life cannot continue.  The clumsy are different from the graceful, and I don’t want to watch them perform ballet.  The artistically challenged do not have a right to have their paintings in the Louvre. 

I would not be so arrogant and condescending as to suggest that if you don’t like being fat, lose weight.  But I will say that we all go through life less than perfect, and bear the consequences of failings.  Live with it and deal with it.  The list of groups deserving legal protection has come to an end.  Fat is not the new black.

What’s Worse Than A Violent Sociopathic Criminal?

A violent sociopathic criminal who’s getting paid with your tax dollars and protected by the FBI.  It’s like a little army of sick, weasels who can do whatever they please, provided they do one little thing:  Rat out somebody to the Feds every once in a while.  That’s the get out of jail free card.  They free meal ticket.  It’s almost like they’re American heroes.  At least to the FBI agents who love, care and feed them.

Grits for Breakfast has long been recapping the world of snitching for us, and brings us this post from Stop The Drug War.  Don’t let the name fool you.  It’s not some crazy, lefty organization dedicated to rebirth of drug-induced hippidom.  The post is about Congress questioning the FBI for assurances that they weren’t supporting our little army of rats, wreaking violence amongst the population and protected by their unfailing willingness to say whatever pleased their FBI handlers.  An FBI Assistant Director refused to do so.

There is something very wrong when the institutions that pretend to stand for honesty, integrity, law and order are at the forefront of crime.  There is something very wrong when we turn a blind eye to the very real fact that this is how the feds operate because we are willing to let them take a pass on truthfulness.  Who out there is willing to let trials become lying shams if someone in a building in Washington wants to “get” somebody?  Raise you hands.

For those who can rationalize this bizarre flip of right and wrong in the name of safety, consider this:  Once we knowingly remove the expectation of truth from the criminal justice process, there is absolutely nothing left to stop the powerful people from using this to subjugate all of us.  It starts with the alleged criminals.  It goes on to the purported “terrorists”.  Then the unsavory elements, and political enemies.  Does any of this sound even remotely familiar?

You say this can never happen.  It’s one thing to lie about criminals, after all they deserve it.  But political enemies?  Hah.  Well, think about it this way.  You won’t know realize it when it happens.  It will come under the guise of some societally palatable excuse.  They will tell you that they’re on the take.  That they’re doing some nefarious deed.  It will be a headline in the papers about how somebody is a bad guy.  And you won’t know if it’s true or just another sham.  You will believe it’s true because you don’t want to believe that they are just plain lying about everybody. 

But when it becomes so easy, so acceptable, for witnesses to just perjure their way to conviction, there’s no way to stop it or distinguish real from “acceptable” fiction. 

As I write, there are American kids dying for the “American Way”.  Is this what we want them to die for?  We’ve been going out of control for almost two decades, with the American public willing to hide its head in the sand so that they can wave the flag without having to feel bad about it.  How much longer, and how much deeper?

Ah, Technology

Mark Bennett’s internet disappeared.  My VoiP telephone got lost in the ether.  Ah, technology.  Isn’t it grand?

But the one that strikes me as particularly troubling is the Visa debit card commercials.  You know the ones, where everybody sails through cafeterias, sandwiches flying through the air, until some miscreant wants to pay with cash.  These are the Visa cards where you just swipe them over the sensor, no receipt, no muss, no fuss.

And no way to know how much you’ve spent.  And no way to tell if you’ve been debited correctly. And no way to tell if something has gone wrong.  Imagine how wonderful the world would be with every $2.39 purchase painlessly done with a swipe.  But who would remember all the itty bitty buys, the amounts, the simple number of them on any given day. 

Multiply a dollar here and there, or even a penny, but millions every day.  Have you ever wondered why your fixed cost phone bill comes out to a different number every month?  That shouldn’t happen, right?  Yet, somehow it does.  We don’t really look, because it’s all done by computers and we’ve come to trust and rely on computers.  They couldn’t go wrong, could they HAL?

Lawyers do their legal research online.  People get arrested because computers spit out warrants for people with the same name.  Defendants get sentenced because rap sheets from other states show prior felony convictions.  Fingerprints and DNA match victims with their killers via computer analysis.  But they can’t keep Mark’s internet working or my phone number activated. 

And when something with some distant company does go wrong, assuming your capable of even catching it, you end up on a 37 minute hold to speak with a lovely Customer Service Rep who was working at Dairy Queen last week, and is very sorry for your inconvenience.  But more often than not, she can neither answer your question or resolve your problem because she just doesn’t have the authority.  No authority?  What do they know about her that we don’t?  Besides, is it really worth your time to sit on hold for 37 minutes for $2?  They are counting on you to say no.

Technology has given us incredible opportunities, and opened vast new horizons.  But it’s not perfect.  Not even close.  Just ask Mark.  Or me.  And ask us before you swipe your Visa for that Starbuck’s mocha frocha caramel flappacino. 

Paid His Debt to Society

Somewhere in the back of my mind, I recall a saying that “he’s paid his debt to society.”  A person did something wrong.  He got caught.  He was convicted.  He went to prison and did his time.  Upon release from prison, he would be allowed to re-enter society with a fresh start.  All this because he paid his debt to society.  This was the circle of criminal life. 

I can’t recall the last time anyone used that phrase. 

Gideon, at A Public Defender, posts today about how Hawaii is considering a Murder Registry, akin to the Sex Offender Registry that has become all the rage.  Why a murderer registry is not clear, since the rationale for sex offenders is their recidivism rate and the belief that sex offenders cannot control themselves, and hence do not leave prison either deterred or rehabilitated.  Thus, while prisons may be forced to let them out, they still present an omnipresent threat.

Is this true for murderers as well?  After they’ve tasted blood, can they no longer control themselves and are doomed to kill again?  I’ve never seen anything to that effect, and don’t believe it to be true at all.  Indeed, murders, the various permutations that all fall under the homicide heading, span a very broad gamut.  From crimes of passion between spouses to road rage to drug killings, there is little commonality amongst “murderers” except that human life has been lost.

So does society need a Murder Registry, other than a means of sordid paranoia should reading the morning papers not be sufficient?  Of course not.  This is another example of remembering the rubric but forgetting the rationale.  If one registry is good, two is better.  Why not a registry for all crimes?  You know, just in case.

The whole registry concept is deeply troubling.  We are creating an underclass that will be permanently tainted and denied any possibility of re-entering society with a clean slate.  This is the scarlet letter on steroids.  What do we do with these people?  We would probably be kinder to put them on a deserted island somewhere to start their own community, where at least they could form some sort of society.  Instead, we let them move about ours, but in a way that makes it impossible to reintegrate and lead a useful life.  They are forever tainted, and some are tainted for the most ridiculous reasons bearing no connection to the purpose of the registry.  Is the 20 year old who has sex with his 16 year old girlfriend a crazed sex fiend who will molest children?  But he’s still on the Registry.  Forever and ever.

Registries appear likely to be the new flavor of the month.  The new “three strikes” magic bullet that will save society for the evil criminals.  Politicians will grasp them and hold them dear to their breasts, convincing a public desperate for the next new weapon that will rid society of crime and fear that they have the Answer.  Hooray for Registries!

But of course, this simple solution will fail, and we will be left to suffer the unintended consequences of another bone-headed idea, that offers enormous societal costs without any commensurate societal benefit.  And another basic precept of America will fall by the wayside.  When is the last time you heard anyone say, “he’s paid his debt to society.”  Yes, it’s been a very long time.

Diggers of Dirt

In a comment yesterday, Steve called me a “digger of dirt.”  A dirt digger!  Okay, so I was a little offended.  But hey, I’ve been called worse.  Sometimes in my own home.  But a digger of dirt.  That’s pretty low.  And the way he said it made it sound so…pejorative. 

But upon further reflection, I realized that Steve was right.  I was a digger of dirt.  Sure, it doesn’t sound anywhere near as official as an investigator of the truth, but that’s just a matter of perspective.  From the other side, digger of dirt pretty much nails it.

When the credibility of a witness against my client is in issue, you can bet that I will dig dirt.  I will dig as much dirt as I possibly can.  I will dig dirt wherever I can find it, and I will look in every nook and cranny to find whatever dirt exists.  If there’s dirt somewhere, dig I must.

Criminal defense lawyers don’t dig dirt for its own sake.  We don’t practice law with the intention of smearing people’s credibility and reputation whenever possible.  We are not gratuitous reputation smearers.  No, no.  Dirt diggers, yet, but hardly gratuitous.  We dig dirt surgically, making us doctors of dirt digging (though it would be inappropriate for lawyers to call themselves doctors, since it would upset chiropractors).  It is the strategic use of dug dirt that defines our goal.  We engage in the Strategic Dug Dirt Initiative, also called “Dirt Wars” during the Reagan era.

Do we get dirt under our finger nails?  Sometimes, sure.  It’s hard to be around all that dirt without getting a little on you, and stuck in places where you would rather dirt not be.  But getting dirty is part of the dirt digging game, and we often find our Gucci loafers (or Vito Genovese cowboy boots, if one happens to dig Texas dirt) covered in dirt.  Sometimes up to our knees.

Am I proud of being a dirt digger?  Well, it’s honest work, from a lawyer’s standpoint.  If we have witness who’s dirty, what else should we dig?  Do we let him hide the dirt behind him, or keep the dirt under hat?  Imagine the damage that would do if the dirt got into our eyes.  We’d be blind!  Blind dirt diggers do no one any good.

So Steve, I concede the point.  I am a dirt digger.  I dig and dig and dig.  And if I find dirt, and its use will fit within my strategy to provide my client with effective and zealous reputation, I am glad that I dug.  And since I’m on a rant of glasnost, let me tell you one more thing.  Not only am I a dirt digger, but I’m a mud slinger too.  Hey, I’ve got to do something with all that dirt.  Just add a little water, stir and toss.

Mandatory Arrest and Gaming the System

As a by-product of some very high profile, and very tragic, cases, police in many jurisdictions have instituted mandatory arrest policies.  This has happened in areas such as domestic and child abuse, where they are determined not to have another Joel Steinberg case. 

The problem was that the decision to arrest was previously left to police discretion, which turned out not to be a very good method.  Police tended too often to excuse or overlook cases of abuse, seeing it as something that the individuals should work out on their own, or perhaps being unduly sympathetic to the usually male abuser and unwilling to go any further than stop the immediate problem.  They just weren’t willing to interfere with the family dynamic, even if that dynamic involved a few beatings now and then.

To prevent these front page disasters from coming back to haunt the public’s vision of police competence, policies were developed that required police officers to arrest someone whenever they found a domestic assault.  With children, mandatory reporting laws were enacted (since the abuse at home was almost never reported and was only learned of when the ambulance arrived) and police were required to take extreme measures.

Naturally, the law of unintended consequences kicked in as a result of these policy changes.  First, as the New York Times op-ed today by Radha Iyengar notes, it has resulted in fewer calls to police by domestic partners who may want to the abuse to stop, but do not want an arrest made.  Having come to realize that by calling police an arrest was inevitable, they have chosen not to do so.  In these states, murders of domestic partners has increased.

But another development has grown out of these mandatory arrest policies: People have come to realize that by making the right complaint, they can guarantee the arrest of someone who, for whatever reason, is the target of their ire.  They have learned how to game the system.

The distinction here is that the “abuser” is the purported victim.  Scorned women can now get their revenge on men by merely saying the right words, knowing that at the very minimum they will be taken into custody for the period until arraignment.  Ha! That will show them. 

In one particularly egregious incident, I saw an adult use this against a child, claiming an assault of his child to fudge the arrest of another child.  It was a set-up from the word go, and the cops knew it.  It stunk all around, with a school-yard “injury” bootstrapped into a deliberately false claim of an attack in order to teach the parents of the “perp” child a lesson in who has more clout. 

Worse yet, the adult complainant had become so adept at gaming the system that he had done it to his spouse during a vicious divorce (where he was able to keep custody of his children via a series of restraining orders obtained on false claims) as well as obtain civil settlements from no less than 7 others in the year preceding the criminal complaint against the innocent child.  There are people who will lie and cheat.  Sometimes, the system will allow these people to claim to be the victim and will do their dirty work for them.

Does this happen with enough frequency to say that the system is broken?  It appears unlikely that the problem is that pervasive, although it’s impossible to say since we can’t tell how many false victims abuse innocent defendants in this system.  But if you or your child happens to be the victim, it doesn’t really matter how widespread the abuse is.  Your focus tends to be on your own situation, and this is how it should be.  Nobody really wants to take one for the team when it comes to being prosecuted.

This is not to say that police should return to the old days of absolute discretion, leaving wives to be beaten by their husbands, or children to be beaten by their parents.  But policies that are so inflexible that they do not permit the police to refuse to arrest when the believe that the complainant is a liar using the system for improper purposes go too far.  This all or nothing approach is another knee-jerk reaction that shift the burden of harm from one party (the abused spouse or child) to another party (the innocent spouse or child). 

Politicians love magic bullet solutions, which is why they pass a law with someone’s name on it whenever there is a particularly horrific tragedy on the front page of the tabloids.  It resonates with people, who want answers without too much thought.  But after the backslapping dies out, cooler and more thoughtful heads need to consider the simple solutions and address the secondary harm left in their wake.  We need to find answers that resolve the first problem without creating the second.  And society has enough warped people that we should anticipate how they will find a way to abuse the system.

Incentive For Inefficiency

Scott Turow, at the ABA Journal, writes that the billable hour must die.  In his fairly prosaic yet interesting fashion, Turow gives a bunch of really good reasons, though it’s unclear whether he is urging murder or suicide.  You know how these former lawyers who become big shot novelists can be so unclear.

But the point that he makes about inefficiency is important, and far broader than just the billable hour.  As a lawyer spends more time performing a task, he is (theoretically) able to bill the client for more hours worked and hence collect a fee for each one of those hours.  What so bad about this?  Didn’t Abe Lincoln tell us that a lawyer’s time and advice is his stock in trade?  Is Turow a Lincoln hater?

His point is obvious:  If it takes you 2 hours to do something that I can do in 1, and you get twice the fee for it, then you are rewarded for taking longer than you should to accomplish the task.  Most people who bill hourly are well aware of this phenomenon, not to mention the client’s expectation that certain tasks take certain lengths of time.  They know this because they get billed the same number of hours for the same task over and over. 

So hourly billing served to reward the less competent inefficient lawyer and punish the lawyer who improves with experience.  But the reality, of course, is that the billable hours don’t really change once a period of time has been established for performing a particular task.  So the experiences lawyer ends up becoming the lying lawyer or the poorer lawyer. 

As posted here before, I won’t do billable hours.  It’s not fair to the client.  It’s not fair to me.  It’s a sham and a scam, neither of which is the way I chose to practice law.  But Scott Turow’s moral goes beyond the billable hour.  The law is replete with areas that reward inefficiency and punish the diligent.  It’s a problem, particularly if you’re the diligent.

For example, as we all know, procedural laws provide lawyers with time limitations to perform certain tasks, whether it be the demands for discovery, submission of motions or readiness for trial.  The laws create a certain degree of predictability and orderliness in a process fraught with uncertainty.  It’s not that I have a love of time limits, but I have an appreciation of the role they play in the process and I make sure that I work within them.

Shockingly, this makes me fairly unique.  It’s my experience (though I’m sure I’ll hear from someone, probably from Texas, who will tell me that they do too) that most (note, Texas boys, the word “most”, not “all”) ignore them.  They’ve always got a half dozen ready excuses, but the fact remains that they just can’t seem to get anything done on time.  This is particularly true of prosecutors, who believe that they are so busy that they are excused from complying with anything, time limit or direct judicial order.  And, very rarely does anyone hold them to it.

So here’s the diligent lawyer, sending out his demands timely, only to be ignored by the other side.  Sending in his subsequent motions, only to be ignored by the other side.  Staying up late at night during a trial because the paperwork has to be done.  After all, if I didn’t get it in on time, there would be nothing for the prosecution to ignore.

So where are the courts in all this?  Ironically, if I failed to get my papers in on time, I would have a 50/50 chance of some judge jumping down my throat, calling me names and demeaning my ancestry.  In some instances, I might even be precluded from completing the task late, unless I can come up with some outrageous fabrication about dogs and homework (rewarding the imaginative?), 

But when the other side shows up empty handed, they get…an adjournment.  That’s right.  The punishment is more time, while the defendant rots in jail (this is a bit hyperbolic since rarely does a client of mine remain in detention pending trial, but it happens to other lawyers’ clients so I feel comfortable borrowing it).  How’s that for an incentive?  Do it now, or get more time to do it whenever it’s convenient for you.  Ouch.  Hate to be on the receiving end of that rebuke.

But of all the situations where lack of diligence is rewarded, none is more painful than starting trial.  In New York criminal cases, the starting date of trial is one of the great mysteries of life.  Clients believe that lawyers are just holding out on them, but the truth is that we have no clue whether a trial will start today or three months from today.  Maybe the judge is busy.  Maybe the cops are on vacation.  Maybe the ADA is clueless.  It doesn’t matter.  There are a hundred reasons why trial won’t start. 

The judge may have adjourned the matter to a particular date “FOR TRIAL,” as he announces with great pomp and circumstance.  He gives the defendant the Parker warnings (don’t show and trial goes on without you).  The defendant’s adrenalin is pumping.  It’s going to be show time.  Do or die.  And then…

On the return date, nothing.  Maybe it’s the calendar assistant (this is an assistant district attorney who reads the note from a piece of papers) who announced “People not ready.”  Maybe the judge has forgotten all about it and isn’t in the mood to start a trial.  Remember that whole pomp and circumstance thing that shook the poor defendant up?  Well, the appearance before the judge could not be more mundane.

But for the lawyer, it means that the time he spent preparing to start trial is shot.  It means that his plans for the next month are blown.  You see, there’s a lot that goes in to being ready for trial, if it’s you intention to win.  And when I appear in court ready for trial, you can bank on it that I am indeed ready.  My witnesses are lined up and available.  My other cases are covered.  I have prepared and prepared and prepared.  All for nothing.

When this happens, the trial judge will stand up high on his bench, look down on the prosecutor and, in a booming stentorian voice filled with anger and righteousness, announce to the assemblage

“You were ordered to be ready for trial today.  Your failure to proceed is an outrage, an affront to the dignity of this Court and to the Constitution of the United State of America!” 

In a slightly lower tone, but with knitted brow, the Judge will say,

“You cannot play with the life of this defendant as if he is meaningless and unworthy of your time.  You dragged him in here to answer your allegations.  Now you must be ready to prove them or let this man go.  I will not tolerate a government that will abuse its citizens.  CASE DISMISSED!”

This happens.  In my dreams.  Instead of punishing the prosecution for its lack of diligence, it’s disrespect, it’s inefficiency, the judge poses one question:  “What date would you like?”