Author Archives: SHG

5 Year Old Boy Shot Dead. Cop Clams Up.

A 5 year old boy, Austin Haley, fishing on a boat with his grandfather, was shot and killed on Saturday.  The shots came from a Noble,  Oklahoma police officer, who was shooting at a snake in a tree.

“Then two officers came out of the brush over there,” he told The Oklahoman. “They didn’t tell us they were the ones who had been shooting or that they had shot him. They didn’t admit a doggone thing.”

The Noble City Manager, Bob Wade, while admitting that they were “pretty sure” the office fired the shot that killed young Austin, nevertheless promised an investigation just to be sure.  Apparently, the police received a call of a large snake in a tree.  When the police arrived, there were numerous ways to get the snake down, but the homeowner urged the police to shoot it.  And so they tried.  And tried.  Without recognizing that the bullets that missed the snake had to go somewhere.

Wade, the City Manager, refused to name the cop who shot Austin Haley.

The first part of this story is fairly straightforward.  It’s a basic accidental tragedy.  A 5 year old boy shot dead by an errant bullet.  Granted, one may question the thought that went into shooting at a snake in a tree in a populated area.  In New York, this might well be the foundation for a charge of reckless endangerment, the classic example being shooting into a crowd without the intention of killing anyone in particular.  A particularly aggressive District Attorney might seek a “depraved indifference” murder charge.  But that, of course, might be the case when the shooter is a regular person.

This killer was a cop.  Normally, the first thing done when a cop kills a person without obvious excuse is to heavily investigate the person to smear their memory.  If the cops are really lucky, they will dig up some drug crime history, or maybe even some violence, so that the news stories that follow talk about how the police officer shot a vicious drug dealing murderer.  But it’s hard to pin much on a 5 year old.  They just haven’t had the time yet to do anything really bad.

Also curious is the reluctance to concede that the cop killed Austin.  Unless the magic bullet from the Kennedy assassination is still sailing through the air, there were no other bullets around.  They know it.  They don’t exactly deny it.  But they won’t just admit it either.  It’s nice to see offialdom having some doubts that a person killed another, even when the situation leaves little.  But then, the shooter is one of their own.

But most striking about this situation is the reluctance to name the cop who shot and killed Austin Haley.  Protecting the identity of the victim is the usual response.  Protecting the shooter is not.  Except this time.  Do we really need to know the name of the cop to appreciate the tragedy of what happened to Austin?  No, of course not.  The name is a detail of little consequence to the story.  But that’s true so many times, but honored only here.  The concern shown for the cops sensibilities, as I have no doubt that he’s heartbroken by what happened, and his reputation, which will be ruined by his stupidity if not his actions, is endearing.  It’s a shame that this concern is so rare.

And so the death of 5 year old Austin Haley provides only two lessons.  First, even on a pond, fishing with your grandfather, there are risks that could take a young boy’s life.  Second, if you’re going to do something really stupid that ends up with your killing a young boy, it’s good to be a cop.

Sex Offenders Must Have An Option

There’s no offense that I less care to discuss than sex offenders.  I can’t bring myself to represent anyone who offends relative to children, as I can’t bear to be in their presence.  It’s a fault of mine, but it’s my reality.  They make me retch.

That said, this New York Times article leaves me no choice but to discuss it.  This can’t happen.  Sex offenders leave prison and have no place to turn.  We have closed them off from society.  They can’t get jobs.  They can’t get a place to live.  And we constructed a set of rules that are nearly impossible to meet.  And so we fault them for their inability to satisfy the impossible demands placed on them and toss them back into prison for the rest of their lives.

Now before you say so what, bear in mind that if society doesn’t give sex offenders an option that doesn’t involve the end of any hope, we will force the really bad ones into the position of being the worst they can possibly be.  We will provide an incentive to kill children so that there are no witnesses.  We encourage them to rape and murder.  We create the scenario that pushed them over the edge.  We don’t wan to do that.  It is horrific that these animals touch anyone, but at least let us give them a reason to leave them alive and otherwise unharmed.  As much as we can.

Gideon also raises this subject today at A Public Defender.  His quote is quite remarkable, that “homelessness is not an excuse.”  As if the sex offender chose homelessness to beat the system.  That’s like saying death is not an excuse.  We have made the situation so bad, so untenable, and then bootstrapped our imposed conditions into a violation that justifies our putting them back in jail. 

Gid comes up with a solution, put up tents in the police department parking lots, and save a fortune in monitoring costs.  I’ve got another option.  Every cop should take a sex offender into his home and keep an eye on him.  Not too palatable?  Then start thinking through the rules, the ramifications and the unintended consequences of what we are doing with them so we have a real system that protects our children from these animals.  Simplistic solutions are going to explode in our faces, and someone else’s stupidity is not a good enough reason for my children to be put at risk.

Shame as Punishment

When I first read at Lowering the Bar that some judge in Ohio offered defendants who were convicted of soliciting prostitution the option of jail time or walking about in a chicken suit with a sign, I blew it off as another stupid gimmick.  But after considering this “joke” in light of Florida’s new requirement that sex offender status be listed on drivers licenses, the joke may be on us.

The return to the Scarlet Letter may be much closer than we think.  It’s closing in on both ends, with actual laws (albeit from Florida, the “Hanging Chad” state) and goofy chicken suits from Ohio (what’s the capital of Cleveland?).   From a deterrent point of view, public humiliation is a time honored and, frankly, successful method of punishment.  Remember the stocks?  Putting the miscreant in the public square is a time honored Puritan tradition.

To many, we thought we had progressed beyond public humiliation as a method of punishment.  Not that it wasn’t necessarily effective as both a general and specific deterrent, but that’s where it stopped.  Drawing and quartering were pretty effective too.  I tad cruel, but nobody ever committed the same offense against.

While the rationale for putting “sex offender” on drivers licenses spans some additional interests, such as providing police with a ready means of identifying sex offenders (itself a major issue, but not the subject of this post), it clearly goes beyond that and into the realm of public humiliation.  After all, when you have to give your drivers license to get a refund a Wal-Mart, then the cashier will gasp as she sees that you’re a “gasp” SEX OFFENDER.   Is that necessary?  Is that the purpose?  Is that what we want, or do we just not care because we hate sex offenders so much that there is nothing that can happen to them that would bother us?

Before you go there, remember that “sex offender” doesn’t just mean rapist or child molester, but also 17 year old kid who got caught fooling around with his 16 year old girlfriend.  Does that change the equation?  What about 39 year old man who picked up a pros on the street?  A little more iffy?

Well, that’s the guy who is now wearing the chicken suit.  And that’s why public humiliation needs to be taken seriously.  It’s not just a joke anymore.

Harry Potter and Legal Scholarship. Give Me A Break!

A while back, we had some discussion with some of the law prof pioneers of the internet.  These are the old guard of blawgs, the ones who looked down their noses at the practical blawgosphere.  But being an inquisitive type of guy, I always check out what they have to say so I can pretend to be an intellectual, and not just a worker bee in the trenches.

So what are the law profs up to?  Legal analysis of Harry Potter!  I kid you not.  They are busy in their cubicles thoroughly dissecting, analyzing and cite-checking due process at the Ministry of Magic, according to William McGeveran at Concurring Opinions.  And it’s not just one article, kind of like a joke or a break from something useful.  No, no.  This appears to be one of the biggies amongst the law profs.

Check this out, and tell me if you can believe this:
[S]ee Harry Potter and the Half-Crazed Bureaucracy, 104 Mich. L.R. 1523 (2006)). The paper is pretty good (and a great read!) although I think he somewhat overstates the extent to which the Ministry of Magic represents a libertarian-oriented critique of all government. (Without revealing too much about the plot of Book Seven — published after his paper — I think I can say that some of the problems at the Ministry are the work of malicious Death Eaters, not public choice theory. Unless, I suppose, you consider the Death Eaters stand-ins for special interests.

This is what they are putting into law reviews these days.  And you wonder why courts no longer cite to law reviews.  Can you imagine an appellate court upholding a conviction on the basis of a Ministry of Magic decision?  Better yet, would it only be persuasive authority or precedent.

Now I’ve got nothing against law profs having some fun and messing around once in a while.  I’m sure they need a break from the serious just like the rest of us.  But publishing this in Law Reviews? 

Here’s the deal:  It’s a book.  It’s not real.  It’s a figment of J.K.Rawlings imagination.  There are real people being put in jail and executed based on erroneous identifications.  There are children being abused by a system that was meant to protect them from abuse.  There are people whose lives are lost the law can’t or won’t protect them.  Forget the Avada Cadavra curse.  It doesn’t really work.  Save the Law Reviews for real things and maybe they’ll be taken more seriously.

And by the way, it’s not as difficult to be a law prof as to try a capital case.  When we screw up, real people can die.  When you screw up, there is regime change at the Ministry of Magic.  Get it?

The American Dream: Marry Guiliani

It isn’t easy becoming Mrs. Rudy Guiliani.  Certainly, there are few on the inside track, given that it’s limited to close relatives.  But Judi Ann Stish Nathans, formerly of Hazelton, PA, has climbed the latter of marital success, in an article in Vanity Fair that skewers the nasty scheming little tart.

And even if you’re a liberal, abortion-loving, anti-death penalty Republican Guiliani sycophant, there’s a part where Judith’s body guards push Hillary out of the way that you’ll just love.  This chick knows how to use bodyguards, baby.  She’s almost shagadelic!

So for all of those who thought Rudy, on the balls of his ass heels on September 10th, 2001, hated by cops, firefighters, blacks, Hispanics and non-comatose New Yorkers everywhere, became the second coming the next day because he gave a decent speech, this article might not be for you. 

The good news is that it doesn’t go back far enough to show the ridiculous abuses of Guiliani’s days as United States Attorney, where he would call in the TV cameras to capture his arresting innocent Wall Street businessmen, or his attempt to prove that he and good buddy, the epitome of morality and ethics, Alphonse D’Amato, could dress up in pretend “bad guy” outfits and buy drugs in uptown Manhattan.  Of course, they could have saved the subway fare by buying the drugs from AUSA Daniel Perlmutter who was raiding the evidence safe, but let’s not talk about that unfortunate moment, shall we?

It’s not that I have issues with Rudy Guiliani, but I have to wonder whether his choice in women reflects some judgment problems.  Let’s see, while as mayor of New York, under a bit of scrutiny from the media about his ethical lapses, he decides to jettison former TV newswoman and actress Donna Hanover and start making out with this social climbing twice-divorced deceiving manipulating and fundamentally nasty and pompous woman, Judith “don’t call me Judi or I’ll kill you” Nathan.  Hey, Rudy’s a he-man and he should be allowed to mess with any chick that turns him on, right?

So let’s consider whether this, like the now eradicated comb-over that characterized Rudy to so many, will impact on his ability to perform the duties of President. 

Judith:  Rudy, press the button for me.
Rudy:  I can’t do that.  Thousand of people will mobilize and we will threaten world peace!
Judith:  Rudy, I said press the damn button.
Rudy:  No, no.  Judith Wudith,  I really can’t.
Judith: If you ever want to see the south of France again, you press the button NOW!
Rudy:  Just this once, my Judithy Spudithy.  But if anyone asks, say that my finger went into spasm and you used your nursing school training to save the world from annihilation.
Judith:  Just shut up and push it, bald boy.

Read the Vanity Fair article by Judy Bachrach.  This is how Rudy makes “important decisions in his everyday life,” and he can bring this same level of good judgment to our nation.  God help us.

Cognitive Dissonance: The Games Minds Play

For those who don’t know, I like to harken back to those academic days when professors used big words that we only had to remember until the test was over to explain human behavior.  Back then, the words didn’t mean a lot to us because we lacked any context or reason to consider how useful they could be in our own lives.  Years later, their purpose has become clear, but we’ve forgotten all about them.  Now that we’re older and wiser, these concepts have gone from boring to cool and sexy, right?  Okay, how about useful?

Cognitive dissonance is one such concept, and thanks to Jamie Spencer at Austin Criminal Defense Lawyer for reminding us of it.  Jamie’s definition, via Stephanie West Allen book review of Mistakes Were Made (but not by me): Why We Justify Foolish Beliefs, Bad Decisions, and Hurtful Acts by Carol Travis and Elliot Aronson appropriately titled Wrong? Me? No way! That’s not how I see it :

the feeling in your brain when you find that you are holding two inconsistent thoughts or beliefs; it’s like an itch that needs to be scratched.

It’s a good working definition.  Jamie discusses the phenomenon relative to how a jury squares away the lack of proof with their deep-seated bias that (1) the defendant must have done something wrong, (2) we should give cops the benefit of the doubt, and (3) the defendant was probably guilty, and if we have to make a mistake, we’d rather make sure that a bad guy isn’t put back of the street to commit more crimes.

The phenomenon of cognitive dissonance affects all of us.  We arrive at beliefs from independent experiences, and they make complete sense (to us) at the time.  But when we toss all of our beliefs into a big pile, we realize that they don’t all make sense together.  We’ve managed to come up with beliefs that are in direct conflict with each other.  And since we can’t possibly be wrong, our brain needs to make sense out of our conflicting beliefs. 

Doing so, however, may involve some serious mental gymnastics that result in some strange rationalizations.  In other words, really bad reasoning can result from cognitive dissonance. 

Aside from the jury, this flawed reasoning process applies to lawyers as well, and could be a prime reason why a strategy we belief to be utterly brilliant fails so miserably.  Steve Gustitis at The Defense Perspective has been putting together a fine series on building the persuasive case, and yesterday he wrote about brainstorming all the possible ideas to approach the defense (with the next installment about developing those ideas into a defense theory).

This is the juncture where we need to be on guard for cognitive dissonance on our own part.  The most obvious area for this to arise is where criminal defense lawyers, as law-abiding members of society, belief that crime is bad and that people who commit crimes should bear the consequences.  Yes, we really do believe this in our hearts.  We are not murderer-lovers, contrary to how the simpleminded may view us.

At the same time, we criminal defense lawyers are believers in due process and the rule of law, which tends to make us put a great deal of stock, often too much stock, into the significance of hard, clear, reliable evidence on the court and jury.  We tend to reject the Nancy Grace “where there’s smoke, there’s fire” view of the law because it’s ignorant and she’s a loud-mouthed twit.

Because of cognitive dissonance, we somehow arrive at a belief that the jury (like us) can distinguish between the desire to find and hold someone responsible and the often obtuse evaluation of evidence needed to arrive at a verdict.  To justify our own beliefs, we project them onto the jury.  Big mistake. 

Criminal defense lawyers need to come up with a mental solution that allows us to function as both a member of society and a lawyer.  Jurors do not share this need.  They are more than happy to take the path of law-abiding citizen and give up any thoughts of constitutional policy wonk.  It’s just not their problem.

Thus, in developing our own trial strategy, we need to be keenly aware of our own cognitive dissonance so that we can avoid projecting our “solutions” onto the jury and rationalizing our own inadequate stratagem.  The fact that we may be willing to accept a somewhat inconsistent or illogical explanation to close the gap between irreconcilable beliefs does not mean a jury will. 

Ask yourself, would a person with no particular reason to be concerned with the defendant’s rights, and who will feel no distress at the possibility that a person they believe is guilty, even if not exactly proven, will be convicted, find this strategy persuasive.  If you can’t answer that question without equivocation, then your strategy will likely miss the mark. 

Court to Ex-Louima Cops — Bend Over

It’s impossible for any senscient being in the New York metropolitan area to be unaware of what happened to a man named Abner Louima.  I refuse to describe it here because it sickened me to think about it then, and I am still beyond disgusted by the police conduct.

But two police officers, Bruder and Wiese (or the 2 Toms), won their appeals in the Second Circuit, renown for their fair treatment of defendant-appellants, as long as they happen to be police officers.  Since they were no longer guilty of a felony, the 2 Toms wanted their old jobs back.  Supreme Court Justice Ellen Branstondecided that wasn’t such a good idea, in Bruder v. Kelly.

Now cases such as this present a Hobson’s Choice for most criminal defense lawyers.  On the one hand, we stand for the right of an individual who has survived trial to go back to his role in society with his head held high.  The system threw everything it had at them, and they survived.  When they walk, doesn’t justice prevail too?

But, I have a problem with the 2 Toms.  A big problem. It may be personal, or it may be something that bothers others as well.  Here it is:

The fact that they did not personally shove the plunger into Abner Louima, like that sub-human Justin Volpe, but merely knew about it happening and did nothing, and then stood silent as the blue wall of silence closed around this outrage, does not make them heroes. 

While they may not have committed a crime, an issue that remains less than clear from a theoretical point of view, they were cops, sworn to protect, and allowed the animal Volpe to torture a human being without lifting a finger.  Yup, I have a problem with this.

And so these two “not guilty” Toms want the NYPD to give them back their guns and shields.  To serve and protect?  Because they only did what any other cop on the job would have done:  Protect their brother cop first, no matter what he did or to whom, and let a human being be subject to the handle of a plunger. 

There was so much wrong, and so much guilt, to be spread around the precinct that I believe that every cop who turned a blind eye, who stuck their head in the sand, who put cop above human, should be thrown off the force, lose their pension and held out to public scorn.  Of course, this didn’t happen.  The 2 Toms provide a limited exception.

Justice Bransten, to her credit, recognized the message that would be sent should the 2 Toms once again suck on the public teet.  There could be no message that would more endanger faith in the police than to allow these two to ever wear blue again.  She held that the public interest’s need for “trust and confidence” in its police officers trumped the argument that they were, at best, unconvicted.  Of course, they only lost their jobs.  I wonder if they would be willing to trade places with Abner Louima in the precinct bathroom. 

Good, Bad or What? Clientvision

In my stroll around the blawgosphere, I stumbled onto something called Clientvision, produced by the “Legal Television Network.”  So I decided to take a look around.  This was one slick model, with a lot of time and money behind it.  It’s clearly headed for commercialization, though I can’t quite tell how it intends to make money just yet.  Advertising, I suppose, will be its ultimate goal, but there’s nothing there just yet.

This website includes a variety of areas of law, so I naturally went to the criminal justice tab to see what it was all about.  I couldn’t believe what I found.  This is a website for lay-people to get a 60 second snapshot of the law and the variety of processes that one may go through in the course of the process, from arrest to plea.  In a very glossy package, I might add.  While I’ve never heard of the “experts” who appear as if being “interviewed” about the subject, it comes off as quite professional and knowledgeable.

Certainly, no one can question the need for regular people to have a place to go to gain a better insight into the legal process, and particularly the criminal process.  But is this the way to do it?  It isn’t easy to condense a complex system, with about a zillion variables, into a 60 second video.  There must, by definition, be a lot left out.  While it may illuminate somethings, it may give a false impression by omission.  It may leave people feeling empowered when they have only a tiny bite of the information needed to make a sound judgment.  But then, that’s more than they have now, in a grossly simplistic sort of way.

However, some of these videos are deeply disturbing.  One in particular (and I have not watched all of them yet, so there could be worse) about the burden of proof in criminal cases was really problematic.  In this video, some professor states that the burden means that jurors must be “85% certain” that a defendant is guilty to convict.  85%!  Where the hell did he get that crap from? 


To its credit, the criminal defense lawyer then comes on and says that he thinks that may be a little low.  But who would put out a video coming up with something so utterly baseless and wrong?  I was shocked.

I’ve gone back and forth on whether this clientvision concept is a good thing, a bad thing or what.  What do you think?

Beating the Lawyer, Part 3

Do we deserve to get beaten?  Have we gotten out of control and lost sight of who we are and what we do?  Carolyn, who comments here, thinks so.  But Mark Bennett disagrees in his comment to the same post.

Carolyn’s point is that criminal defense lawyers charge too much for the average person, who lives pay check to pay check.  While high legal fees may be fine for the drug dealer, they price good lawyers out of the market for the regular guy. 

Before criminal defense lawyers respond with knee-jerk defensiveness, explaining what it takes to become a lawyer, to run a law office, to put in the time necessary to provide a top defense (aside from the face time that clients see when we’re in front of the judge), let us consider the implications of Carolyn’s point.

We are not talking about indigent defense, or the defense of the wealthy.  This is about regular people who get mixed up in the system.  Sometimes they may be innocent.  Other times guilty.  But we are not talking about people who are professionals, or earn big bucks off crime.  These are the assaults, the non-sale weight drug possessions, the DWIs and endangering offenses.  There was no financial gain involved.  More often than not, it is evidence of exceptionally poor judgment, if there was any judgment involved at all. 

Are these ordinary people priced out of the market for top legal talent?  The simple answer is, they are.  Just like they can’t afford the diamond necklace in Winston’s window, they can’t afford the best lawyers money can buy.  Similarly, they can’t afford all the bells and whistles that may go along with a top flight defense, from investigators, polygraphs, reconstructions, engineering drawings, jury consultants, mitigation specialists, doctors, audio experts and whatever else may apply.  Clients are likely unaware of the full scope of litigation support services available, but they all cost money.

It’s not clear from what Carolyn has to say whether she feels entitled to everything that a Martha Stewart can afford, or whether she’s talking about a basic “K car” with a good lawyer at the wheel.  She may not realize that the tools available are part of the deal, and even a great lawyer is aided by these support services.  But a great lawyer is still going to provide a far better defense than a yeoman lawyer, even if he has to go into battle a few bullets short of a full magazine. 

My sense is that Carolyn’s vision is some sliding scale variation on Gideon, where it fine for lawyers to suck the blood out of the rich so that they can provide low cost representation to the working stiff.  It’s an entitlement thing, where the need for legal services coupled with the limits of their financial comfort dictate how much a good lawyer should charge.  It’s very much like doctors, but without insurance to cover the gap.

Now I bring Mark into this discussion because of his comment that he avoids the problem with collecting the trial fee by charging it up front as “trial insurance.”  Mark’s design, clearly, avoids the problem of being on the eve of trial when a rift develops between lawyer and client that undermines the relationship.  Plus, the lawyer gets paid. 

The flip side of Mark’s position is that it spreads the risk of trial across clients, by charging all of them more than they would pay if they do not go to trial so that the ones who do will not have to pay extra.  This, of course, is the basic idea of insurance, spreading the risk.  But would Carolyn be willing to pay more up front to pay less if she ends up going to trial, particularly when the vast majority of cases do not go to trial?  Or would she argue that she should pay no more than the minimum based upon the particular work involved in her case, and that others who go to trial should pay their own freight?  My bet is that Carolyn would not buy the insurance.

To be clear, I reject the basic premise that my fee structure, and hence my income, should somehow correlate to the financial circumstances of the regular guy.  It is not my fault that Carolyn lives hand to mouth, and that is not the measure of why I charge for my services.  Similarly, it’s not my fault that an ordinary person gets arrested, so I do not accept the burden of their unfortunate circumstances.  My job is to defend them from someone else’s accusations, not to be their surrogate and share in the misery.

There is a rather large group of lawyers available to the working guy, who will never let a client walk away if they have a few bucks in their pocket.  But these are the lawyers who prey on the misery of ordinary people, planning how quickly they can plead them out at the first meeting while telling the client how they guarantee a win.  Are the vultures of the criminal bar all that is left for regular people?

Given the option, I would take a indigent defender over a vulture (or V-6 as Mark calls them) any day.  The former may be less experienced, but does it from the heart with zeal.  The latter is in it for the quick buck, without any concern for the client after his pockets have been emptied.  But will Carolyn qualify for a legal aid lawyer?  Probably not, and hence she is left to the vultures like road kill on the highway of justice.

There really isn’t any good option for the regular people of the world.  Deplete every penny that they and everyone who cares about them may have, or do without.  The young but caring criminal defense lawyer offers the best chance of hope, but they aren’t easy to find for the regular person.  And what, you ask, about an old timer like me taking a big financial hit in order to represent Carolyn? 

I do.  Sometimes.  There are times that I will take a significantly reduced fee, or go without a fee.  Because I’m just a wonderful humanitarian and an all-around great guy.  But there are times I won’t, and the times I won’t far exceed the times I will.  This is true for two basic reasons:  First, this is how I earn my living, and I am entitled to earn as good a living as my skills, work ethic and reputation allow.  Second, I have a family, and they are entitled to enjoy whatever largesse I can provide.

So Carolyn, while I sympathize with you, I will not sacrifice for you.  But if you can afford to retain me and I am willing to take your case, I assure you that I will give you your money’s worth.