A 5 year old boy, Austin Haley, fishing on a boat with his grandfather, was shot and killed on Saturday. The shots came from a Noble, Oklahoma police officer, who was shooting at a snake in a tree.
“Then two officers came out of the brush over there,” he told The Oklahoman. “They didn’t tell us they were the ones who had been shooting or that they had shot him. They didn’t admit a doggone thing.”
The Noble City Manager, Bob Wade, while admitting that they were “pretty sure” the office fired the shot that killed young Austin, nevertheless promised an investigation just to be sure. Apparently, the police received a call of a large snake in a tree. When the police arrived, there were numerous ways to get the snake down, but the homeowner urged the police to shoot it. And so they tried. And tried. Without recognizing that the bullets that missed the snake had to go somewhere.
Wade, the City Manager, refused to name the cop who shot Austin Haley.
The first part of this story is fairly straightforward. It’s a basic accidental tragedy. A 5 year old boy shot dead by an errant bullet. Granted, one may question the thought that went into shooting at a snake in a tree in a populated area. In New York, this might well be the foundation for a charge of reckless endangerment, the classic example being shooting into a crowd without the intention of killing anyone in particular. A particularly aggressive District Attorney might seek a “depraved indifference” murder charge. But that, of course, might be the case when the shooter is a regular person.
This killer was a cop. Normally, the first thing done when a cop kills a person without obvious excuse is to heavily investigate the person to smear their memory. If the cops are really lucky, they will dig up some drug crime history, or maybe even some violence, so that the news stories that follow talk about how the police officer shot a vicious drug dealing murderer. But it’s hard to pin much on a 5 year old. They just haven’t had the time yet to do anything really bad.
Also curious is the reluctance to concede that the cop killed Austin. Unless the magic bullet from the Kennedy assassination is still sailing through the air, there were no other bullets around. They know it. They don’t exactly deny it. But they won’t just admit it either. It’s nice to see offialdom having some doubts that a person killed another, even when the situation leaves little. But then, the shooter is one of their own.
But most striking about this situation is the reluctance to name the cop who shot and killed Austin Haley. Protecting the identity of the victim is the usual response. Protecting the shooter is not. Except this time. Do we really need to know the name of the cop to appreciate the tragedy of what happened to Austin? No, of course not. The name is a detail of little consequence to the story. But that’s true so many times, but honored only here. The concern shown for the cops sensibilities, as I have no doubt that he’s heartbroken by what happened, and his reputation, which will be ruined by his stupidity if not his actions, is endearing. It’s a shame that this concern is so rare.
And so the death of 5 year old Austin Haley provides only two lessons. First, even on a pond, fishing with your grandfather, there are risks that could take a young boy’s life. Second, if you’re going to do something really stupid that ends up with your killing a young boy, it’s good to be a cop.
“Then two officers came out of the brush over there,” he told The Oklahoman. “They didn’t tell us they were the ones who had been shooting or that they had shot him. They didn’t admit a doggone thing.”
The Noble City Manager, Bob Wade, while admitting that they were “pretty sure” the office fired the shot that killed young Austin, nevertheless promised an investigation just to be sure. Apparently, the police received a call of a large snake in a tree. When the police arrived, there were numerous ways to get the snake down, but the homeowner urged the police to shoot it. And so they tried. And tried. Without recognizing that the bullets that missed the snake had to go somewhere.
Wade, the City Manager, refused to name the cop who shot Austin Haley.
The first part of this story is fairly straightforward. It’s a basic accidental tragedy. A 5 year old boy shot dead by an errant bullet. Granted, one may question the thought that went into shooting at a snake in a tree in a populated area. In New York, this might well be the foundation for a charge of reckless endangerment, the classic example being shooting into a crowd without the intention of killing anyone in particular. A particularly aggressive District Attorney might seek a “depraved indifference” murder charge. But that, of course, might be the case when the shooter is a regular person.
This killer was a cop. Normally, the first thing done when a cop kills a person without obvious excuse is to heavily investigate the person to smear their memory. If the cops are really lucky, they will dig up some drug crime history, or maybe even some violence, so that the news stories that follow talk about how the police officer shot a vicious drug dealing murderer. But it’s hard to pin much on a 5 year old. They just haven’t had the time yet to do anything really bad.
Also curious is the reluctance to concede that the cop killed Austin. Unless the magic bullet from the Kennedy assassination is still sailing through the air, there were no other bullets around. They know it. They don’t exactly deny it. But they won’t just admit it either. It’s nice to see offialdom having some doubts that a person killed another, even when the situation leaves little. But then, the shooter is one of their own.
But most striking about this situation is the reluctance to name the cop who shot and killed Austin Haley. Protecting the identity of the victim is the usual response. Protecting the shooter is not. Except this time. Do we really need to know the name of the cop to appreciate the tragedy of what happened to Austin? No, of course not. The name is a detail of little consequence to the story. But that’s true so many times, but honored only here. The concern shown for the cops sensibilities, as I have no doubt that he’s heartbroken by what happened, and his reputation, which will be ruined by his stupidity if not his actions, is endearing. It’s a shame that this concern is so rare.
And so the death of 5 year old Austin Haley provides only two lessons. First, even on a pond, fishing with your grandfather, there are risks that could take a young boy’s life. Second, if you’re going to do something really stupid that ends up with your killing a young boy, it’s good to be a cop.

