Author Archives: SHG

The KISS Principle UPDATE

My post on the KISS principle apparently got some better heads than mine working.  Mark Bennett (with 2 “T”s) took it one step better, raising the hoary notion of Occam’s Razor (the simplest answer that accounts for all know facts is the correct one).  But Bennett, dissatisfied with mundane and, frankly, generic application, pushed the envelope.

We now have a new theory.  It’s good.  In fact it’s very good.  And best of all, it’s application is directed specifically at criminal law.

The name of this new theory is Bennett’s Chainsaw.  I even like the name.  It goes like this:

The more things you must contest and the more explanations you must provide in order to mount a defense, the more likely it is that you will be convicted.

I told you it was good.

Neatness Counts

Reading a story about a fellow who contends that he’s been the victim of discrimination by employers who refuse to hire him because he’s covered with tatoos, an argument that brings a reflexive chuckle for me, I thought about the appearance of defendants in court.

I recall going to trial with a defendant from New Jersey.  I instructed him how to dress (as is my way) before the jury.  My client, electing to ignore my instructions, or really to improve upon them in his own fashion, showed up for trial wearing what can best be described as a 1970s velvet orange pimp suit, complete with wide-brimmed hat.  He looked like Huggy Bear from Starsky & Hutch.  If he wasn’t my client, it would have been hysterical.  Alas, he was mine.

My sensitivity to clients’ attire began with a CCE case in Anchorage Alaska many years ago.  I came out from New York with my client’s wife, who was told to bring him clothing to wear in court.  My being young and inexperienced, I offered no specifics on what she should bring.  I left it up to her.

When we arrived at the jail in Anchorage, I pulled the clothing out of a bag.  It included some sort of silk black pantaloons.  A black silk shiny shirt and very pointy toed shows with metal toes.  If he was dressing to be Salsa King, he would have been perfect.  For court in Alaska, it was a bit much. 

When we appeared in court later that day, the Judge expressed “outrage” at the insult to him demonstrated by the defendant’s attire.  I explained that these were the defendant’s finest clothes, and while not of the taste that one would ordinarily pick for court, it was a sign of utmost respect by the defendant, no matter how tacky and inappropriate it was.  He bought it and we dodged the bullet. 

Today, I regularly see defendants show up for court in pants down below the hips, open shirts.  I see defendants and family with tatoos and piercings. Sometimes many piercings, and in unusual places.  I see defendants with huge flashy necklaces and diamond encrusted watches.  And their attorneys try to argue what normal, law-abiding, hard-working, average citizens they are. 

A few years ago, the phrase “dress for success” was the mantra of young entrepreneurs.  What is the message these defendants are sending the judge by their appearance?  Of course, when those tough, young defendants who swaggered their way into the courtroom walk out later all weepy and teary eyed like a little baby, sniffling and crying because they aren’t going to be nearly as cool in Rikers as they were on 125th Street, their choice in clothing and appearance strikes an interesting contrast. 

Lies and the Lying Lawyers Who Tell Them

Every profession and occupation has its share of liars and incompetents.  We may not like to admit it, or publicly acknowledge it, but we know it’s true.  And this applies to criminal defense lawyers.

Gideon, at A Public Defender, called them out today.  I don’t know what happened to him in court yesterday to push him to the point that he wrote what he wrote, but I’m glad he did.  It’s time that we had a real discussion about the fact that this little area of the law has its share of liars.  More than its fair share, I might add.

The false promises part really pisses me off. You know there are attorneys who make them but then when the client gets screwed, will swear up and down that they would never, ever say something like that. Bullshit. 

Well, yeah, bullshit.  It happens.  It happens regularly.  And begs the question why does it happen, and how do they get away with it.

The why is easy.  Many of our clients in criminal defense are poorly educated; some aren’t too bright.  It doesn’t make them bad people, but any real discussion has to begin with a foundation in reality.  The clients (and their families) have some difficulty grasping concepts.  They are much better with concrete assertions, and have no tolerance for ambiguity.  These are the ones who, after thoroughly explaining at an initial interview that we have no idea what the evidence against them will be, and how the variables at trial make it impossible to predict an outcome, then ask:  “But what are we gonna win?”

There are, more often then you would believe, clients who demand a guarantee that, in exchange for the legal fee, they will walk.  It reflects two inherent problems (and possible a dozen tangential problems).  First, they believe that a lawyer has the ability to make a guarantee.  Second, they perceive the lawyer to be on the other side (even though this may not be apparent at first), and thus the person with whom they should negotiate.  They don’t see the lawyers time or skills as worthy of compensation.  They see only outcome. 

A good lawyer understands that outcome is always what the deal is about, but similarly understands that the lawyer and client share the same interest in achieving a positive outcome, though the path to achieving it may be different.  To the good lawyer, outcome is the product of hard work, strategy, perseverance and a healthy dose of luck.  To the client, it’s what he pays for.  For the lawyer, it is the difference between effectiveness and efficiency.  (I would explain this further, but I would be giving up one of my best secrets and so will save it for another day.)

Also posted today is Mark Bennett’s How to Choose a Criminal Defense Lawyer.  Mark takes issue with my view that a personal interview of a lawyer by a client has its problems, as clients tend to mistake “likability” for competence and pick the lawyer who tells the client what he wants to hear.  Mark contends that

I have great confidence in the ability of people working together to tell who is shooting straight with them. While one person (especially one frightened person facing criminal charges) may get snookered by a snake-oil selling businessman, two people working together are much less likely to make the same mistake.

I don’t, not because of a cynical view of people but because of experience.  It happens constantly.  Even after the client crashes and burns, the snake-oil lawyer can explain away the failure by adding new layers of deception, so that people sitting in prison for substantial chunks of their lives STILL think their lawyer was a good guy.  We find out about this when some other person, wife or mother for example, comes to a new lawyer only to learn that the snake-oil lawyer never made a suppression motion, or demonstrated flagrant neglect or incompetence in some other way.  How many of these defendants are sitting there thinking, “Well, at least I had a good lawyer do everything he could for me” when in reality he got sold out on day 1.

So now the second question, how do they get away with it?  This is a multi-part answer.  Part 1 is that clients who are susceptible to being lied to in the first place are just as susceptible to being lied to on the back end.  The lawyers make up excuses for their failure and the client buys it.  But this is only to be expected as the completion of the circle of deception.  The better question is why does the rest of the profession, including judges, sit there with their mouths shut and allow this to happen, day after day after day.

Perhaps other lawyers don’t know about this?  This may occasionally be true, but we absolutely know a great deal of it.  If a lawyer say he hasn’t seen incompetence and deception, you know which side of the fence he falls on.  The sad and pathetic truth is that we, like most professions, don’t police ourselves well enough.  We fear that we might become pariahs amongst our own if we start playing Torquemada.  And are we so pure that we can criticize others?  Isn’t it the responsibility of the courts and bar to weed out the incompetent and deceptive?

All good questions, but the plain old truth is that it hasn’t happened the way it should and our ranks are replete with lawyers who should not be.  It’s wrong for clients.  It’s wrong for honest and competent lawyers. It’s wrong for society.  And yet we cannot bring ourselves to do anything about it.  Except Gideon, who opened up this Pandora’s box.  Thanks, Gideon.

Fair and Impartial?

Anne Reed at Deliberations brings us Voir Dire Questions That Could Have Been Better, about a friendly trial judge who asks the jury two questions, but tells them NOT to raise their hand until both questions have been asked. 

Question 1:  Now, here is the first question. And, again, you don’t need to raise your hand. Listen carefully. This is a question about you personally, you personally as well as any close family member or close personal friend. Is there anyone in that group, either you personally, close family member or close personal friend, who is either presently or previously employed by any law enforcement agency?

Question 2:  Now, if the answer to that is yes, listen very carefully to this question. As a result of that experience that either you had personally or are having right now as an employee, as a result of that experience or as a result of the experience of a close family member or a close friend, . . . do you believe that you, that you personally would be unable to be fair and impartial to both sides if selected as a juror in this case?

Thankfully, the DC Circuit held that the “defect in that question is obvious,” U.S. v. Littlejohn.  For the handful of criminal defense lawyers who actually try cases, consider the implication of finding out after the verdict is rendered that, unbeknownst to you, you had a few agents sitting on the jury who never raised their hands since, either in their own minds decided they could be fair (“I would never convict the defendant until after he had a fair trial”).  Worse yet, what are the chances that they just decide not to raise their hands, and hence nobody has a clue that they’re having a good ol’ time sitting on that jury, getting paid, and just biding their time until they do a little justice by putting the defendant away.

There is no substitute for knowing who you’re potential jurors are, and their inherent bias is subject to scrutiny.  Most people will state with absolute conviction (pun intended) that they can be fair and impartial, even when they’re either in, or connected to, law enforcement.  Clearly, that self-assessment is utterly useless, even if sincere.  The point is to be able to probe, and assess, bias, not to let the juror tell you how pristine and honest he or she is.

In a recent trial, I ended up with two fellows on my panel who were worth a second look.  One was a well known criminal defense lawyer and the other was an FBI Special Agent.  We all knew the lawyer, and it didn’t help that he sat in the front row and was giving us the “hi sign” from the Little Rascals the whole time.

The agent, on the other hand, was unknown to any of us.  He looked like anyone else.  No sign on his forehead.  No telltale bulge in his waistband.  He could have been anyone.

The judge called us to the bench and asked if it was necessary to make this criminal defense lawyer waste his morning, since he obviously could not serve as a witness.  “Obvious?” I inquired.  Why couldn’t a criminal defense lawyer be fair and impartial?  Just because we defend the accused doesn’t mean that we favor crimes.  Hey, we’re law-abiding people who understand duty and obligation as well as the next guy.  Maybe even better.

Nope, the judge responded.  He’s out of here.  The prosecutor, naturally, chimed in with, “Oh, of course, Your Honor is absolutely right.”  What a suck up.  Over my strenuous objections, the defense lawyer was cut loose and sent packing.

But when the agent was put in the box, the world changed.  Of course he could be fair and impartial.  When I challenged for cause, the judge raising an eyebrow at the very suggestion, I was subject to a massive effort at proving how this FBI agent would never consider being anything less the absolutely fair.  He would never be inclined to believe a law enforcement officer over a defendant.  He would never consider a cop to be more trustworthy and honest than anyone else. 

Despite my arguments, the judge concluded that there was absolutely no basis for a cause challenge, forcing me to use a peremptory challenge to throw him off the jury.  And so it goes.

The point of voir dire is to get at the truth. But the truth is a relative thing when its comes to selecting a jury, and the final step of the process, the question that the judge in Littlejohn had yet to ask, is how a person whose career is dedicated to putting the bad guy away, to protecting his brother agent, to overlooking those little details that get fudged at trial with a wink so that “justice is done,” at least in their eyes, can be fair and impartial.  In the good old days when both cops and lawyers were out of the jury pool, these stupid problems didn’t exist. 

Today, they are very real, and we have two problems to deal with.  First, we have to unearth the people with inherent bias.  Second, we have to get the court to go along with the idea that those jurors with pro-police bias should be taken off the jury just like the ones who are anti-police.  The second will prove as much of a struggle, if not more, than the first. 

No Bong Hits Today

The Supreme Court has just issued its decision in Morse v. Frederick, the “Bong Hits 4 Jesus” student free speech case.  Thanks to I was the State for alerting everyone to this decision. 

Chief Justice Roberts, writing for the Court, says that while students don’t leave their constitutional rights at the school house gate, they just can say any old darn thing they want (paraphrasing).  So they can have all the free speech they want, as long as it school officials approve of it.  And so the circuit decision (which upheld the Frederick’s right to say stuff that the principal didn’t like) was reversed.

Finally, a bright line test!  The “big picture” rationale related the termination of free speech with a message that was “reasonably viewed as promoting illegal drug use.”  But if we focus in a little tighter, it becomes clear that the message sent by this decision relates to any speech which the school believes is contrary to the message it wants to promote.  Judge Robert’s attributes all evils of drug use to this banner, concluding that there is a compelling need to shut this kid up before every child in Juno, Alaska becomes a junkie. 

The Chief Justice concludes with the recognition of the tough job school principals have, and that the principal in this case had to make a snap decision.  This struck C.J Roberts as being overwhelmingly difficult. 

THIS JUST IN, via Abovethelaw from SCOTUSblog :

Morse is a very limited holding — essentially limited to the drug context. The Alito concurrence, joined by Kennedy, is controlling. He writes:

I join the opinion of the Court on the understanding that (a) it goes no further than hold that a public school may restrict speech that a reasonable observer would interpret as advocating illegal drug use and (b) it provides no support for any restriction of speech that can plausibly be interpreted as commenting on any political or social issue, including speech on issues such as ‘the wisdom of the war on drugs or of legalizing marijuana for medicinal use.’”

According to Above the Law, this proves that Justice Alito is a closet liberal after all.  According to Scotusblog, Justice Alito has aligned himself with C.J Roberts to chip away incrementally at the Constitution.  Ironically, in another free speech case today involving Wisconsin Right to Life, the C.J. wrote that “the court should give the benefit of the doubt to speech, not censorship.”  Unless, of course, it’s not about right to life, but about bongs. 

Watch the video for a better understanding of the issue:





I, Witness

Civil rights lawyer Michael Tarif Warren was driving down Vanderbilt Avenue with his wife, Evelyn.  They saw a bevy of cops stop and cuff a young black man.  Once the cops had him under control, they did what cops sometimes do.  The tune up.

We don’t know why the cops felt the need to give the kid the tune up.  Maybe he had hit one of them before running.  Maybe it was because he had the audacity to run.  Maybe it was because he made them run after him, leaving their donuts and coffee behind.  Who knows.  But they felt the need to show the kid who’s boss. Over and over.

Michael Warren was not an ordinary New Yorker, the type who let Kitty Genovese die and about whom Phil Ochs sang.  Michael Warrant was a human being, and did what a human being was compelled to do.  He got out of his car, told the police he was a lawyer, and that they should just arrest him and bring him in.  He told them to stop kicking and beating the kid.  And he paid the price for his humanity.

The news account tells the complete story.  But for those of you who refuse to believe that bad things can happen (and who are not likely to be New Yorkers), understand this.  Michael and Evelyn Warren took their lives into their hands when they went to help a young man they didn’t know.  I’m sure they realized the risk they were taking, but took it anyway.  Maybe their intervention made the difference between a young man alive today and a sidebar story in tomorrow’s New York Post.  I’m sure the police would tell the story about how the vicious perp’s face attacked the cops feet while he lay handcuffed on the ground.  “Six cops were injured and went to the hospital with sprained toes, out for 18 months on disability,” goes the typical press release.  “The evil interloper was believe to be drunk, high on drugs and dressed in peculiar clothing…” It’s much easier to smear the victim than stop the brutality.

I don’t know Michael Tarif Warren.  He apparently is quite political, which comes as no surprise.  I don’t know his politics, and I have no idea whether I agree with his politics.  But if I was the kid lying on the ground being beaten, I doubt that I would ask him about his politics before I would accept his aid. 

Lawyers have bar associations.  Bar associations give out “Best Lawyer” awards.  Usually, we pick attorneys to receive awards because they can bring in a few extra tables of paying guests.  I don’t know if Michael Warren can bring in any paying guests, but I nominate him for an award.  Not as a lawyer, but as a human being.  Maybe some bar association can find some room to honor someone who actually did something worthy of the honor.  Not about his politics, but because he risked his own safety for someone else.  It’s something worthy of admiration.

Strange But True

Lowering the Bar has a story about a fellow at the San Francisco DA’s office who got a job after claiming to have passed the bar exam.  He then lost the job when his ersatz new employer checked the bar results.  Most of us would take this for granted, that an employer like the District Attorney would verify passing the bar, but that’s not necessarily the case.

The story reminded me of the tale of Dan Penofsky.  Dan had 16 years in as an ADA at the Brooklyn DA’s office and the Special Narcotics Prosecutor’s office.  Special narcotics was a citywide superjurisdictional prosecutor in New York City that handled drug cases across county lines.  It’s head was Sterling Johnson, later to be a federal judge in Brooklyn and member of the US Sentencing Commission. 

Dan was a hard-nosed ADA.  Neither unpleasant nor unreasonable, he was no pushover.  He looked like an ADA.  He dressed like an ADA.  He was a go-to type of ADA who faced down some very tough drug dealers in the days when drug dealers meant what they said.  Not the girlie type of rat drug dealers we have today, but the Tony Montana type.

The only problem was that Dan Penofsky wasn’t a lawyer.  He was never a lawyer.  Sixteen years in the DA’s office, from 1973 to 1989, and nobody knew that he wasn’t a lawyer.

But he was one hell of an ADA.  He put a lot of people in jail.  A LOT.  He tried cases, and he tried them damn well. 

When the word came out about Dan, it was one of those rolling on the floor laughing moments.  Not at Dan, so much, but at the absurdity of it all.  For all the platitudes we spout about education and professionalism, about law and society, there was good old Dan putting bad guys behind bars year after year after year.  And he wasn’t a lawyer.

Epilogue:  Some defendant sought to challenge their convictions, arguing that they could not lawfully be convicted by an ADA who was unqualified (in the technical sense) to prosecute their case.  The theory is that the exercise of prosecutorial discretion by a person not qualified to prosecute, and his unauthorized presentation to the grand jury, denied them due process. The Court of Appeals disagreed.  It’s not like they were going to let every miscreant that Penofsky put away out of jail, no matter how embarrassing the decision might be.

In dissent, Judge Titone wrote the following:

It has been observed that a Grand Jury can indict anyone or anything — even a ham sandwich. [n 1] Now, under the majority’s holding, apparently anyone can present the People’s case to the Grand Jury — even an unadmitted layperson masquerading as an attorney. Because this position makes a mockery of both the rules prohibiting legal practice by laypersons and the Grand Jury system itself, I dissent.

Now if this doesn’t make you proud to be a lawyer, I don’t know what does.

The KISS Principle

It’s a Sunday morning, so naturally my thoughts turn to trial strategy.  Some recent questions I’ve read from criminal defense lawyers have caused me to think about flawed or misguided strategies that consume time and thought (neither of which the questioners had in abundance) that detract from winning the case. In response to those convoluted, complicated, prolix approaches, I offer this advice.

KISS.  Keep it simple, stupid.  This is a principle of monumental importance in criminal defense, and one that lawyers, particularly young lawyers, ignore with regularity to the great detriment of their clients.

The more explaining a defendant is forced to do to allow the jury to reach a verdict of not guilty, the more unlikely the jury will get there. 

The basic problem is that defendant’s want to challenge everything.  Every word of a cops’ (or victims’) testimony comes under intense scrutiny by the defendant, who often has a lot of time on his hands to obsess over the allegations against him.  He will parse every word, looking for a crack that he can somehow explain away or question. 

To the defendant, the more holes he can poke in the prosecution, the more satisfaction he feels and the more likely it will be, in his mind, that he can get the other side to break down in a fit of anguish and admit that he is an innocent man.  Whether he’s innocent or not, of course, since defendant’s have a tendency to forget that they were found standing there, bloody, holding the murder weapon.  “Oh yeah,” the defendant says sheepishly, “I forgot.”

But it is the job of the lawyer to determine the strategy, not the defendant.  While some lawyers will defer to the client, whether to take the onus off of them or to please the client (for the moment), the lawyer will push whatever buttons the client wants.  The problem is that the client is ill-prepared to devise strategy.  That’s why other defendants don’t go to the client for representation, they go to a lawyer.

Judges and juries are not likely to accept the premise that the cops have singled out this one particular defendant, of all the people in the world, who the cop never met until the day of arrest, to fabricate from whole cloth a crime and charge him with it.  They don’t buy that everyone is lying about everything.  It may be true, but it is the hardest sell there is in criminal defense. 

Strategically, there is almost always a lynch pin that ties the prosecution’s case together.  It may be ID, or a single act showing intent, but it is the tipping point between conduct that constitutes a crime and conduct that doesn’t.  In any particular case, there may be a number of lynch pins of varying strength and support.

The first thing the lawyer must do is identify the lynch pin that is vulnerable to attack.  Concentrate on that lynch pin.  Your trial theory is directed at that lynch pin.  You voir dire and open on that lynch pin.  You tell the judge and jury, that’s why your client is not guilty.  And as your client writhes in pain because you didn’t attack the other 43 points that he thinks are absolutely critical, you maintain focus on the issue with the best chance of winning.

Think of this as the surgical, rather than shotgun, approach.  If you can successfully excise just one specific necessary allegation from the prosecution’s case, it fails.  If you poke a bunch of unrelated holes in the prosecution, you may weaken some of their points but the prosecution maintains its inherent vitality and the jury convicts.  Never forget that trials are not like a baseball game; they are not scored in innings (witnesses), but a “winner takes all” at the end when the verdict is returned.

By conceding issues that are theoretically subject to challenge, but highly unlikely to be winnable or insufficient to turn the jury to acquit, you focus all of your capital on the lynch pin and ask the jury to do only one thing for you, put all of their attention on the lynch pin where you plan to levy your attack.  By asking less of the jury, you will greatly increase the likelihood that they will do it for you and, ultimately, give you this one concession. 

Bear in mind that you walk into the courtroom as the defendant, and hence with the jury inherently biased against you.  They are not inclined to do you many favors.  So the fewer favors you ask of them, the less you demand, the more likely it is that they will give your argument one good hard look.  If you’ve done your job and focused your strategy on the lynch pin, that one good hard look is all that you will need.