Author Archives: SHG

The Polls are Closed!

The response has been overwhelming.  Defense lawyers everywhere are sitting on the edge of their seat.  Brother pitted against brother.  Sister against sister.  Who will win?  Do Texans really dress funny? 

Before revealing the outcome, please bear in mind that this has all been tongue in cheek and should not be taken seriously by anyone.  Some defense lawyers take themselves way too seriously, and have some inexplicable difficulty with a little tongue in cheek pretend competition.  So enjoy the results, and if you can’t, have beer and some Texas barbeque this weekend and chill out.  I want to add that I would be honored to sit at the defense table with Mark Bennett, any time and anywhere.  (Of course, I’d be the lawyer…)

And now, the results:


Where would you rather practice criminal defense?













































Selection 
Votes
New York 38%32
Texas 25%21
Anywhere but Texas 12%10
Could I practice in Texas but live in NY? 1%1
Would I have to dress funny if I practiced in Texas? 24%20
84 votes total
Conclusively proving…absolutely nothing.  Thanks to all for participating and I hope that you will take a few minutes to read the real stuff on this blog. 

The Penalty is The Problem

Last night, the New York Legislature created, with the endorsement of Gov. Eliot Spitzer, a new crime, Aggravated Vehicular Homicide.  The law will be known as “Katie’s Law,” named after the horrible tragedy that took the life of a young girl in a limo returning from a wedding where she was the flower girl.  The word horrible does not begin to capture the depth of this tragedy.

And so we have a new crime to allow for a sentence of 25 years to life, the same as intentional murder, for drunk driving that results in death. The aggravating factors include a suspended license, BAC over .18, more than one person killed or injured, a prior DWI.  And what is the compelling need for this new law?

“For Heidgen, there was a law in place to allow the family to get a semblance of justice. But for 99 percent of people whose loved ones are lost at the hands of drunk driver, there is no justice,” said Nassau District Attorney Kathleen Rice. “This is step one in making New York one of the most effective states in prosecuting this epidemic.”

Sen. Charles Fuschillo (R-Merrick) said the bill will “give prosecutors the tools they need” to go after deadly drunken drivers. Under current state law, prosecutors are usually only able to charge second-degree manslaughter in fatal drunken driving accidents. That carries a maximum of 5 to 15 years.


Will an increase in the maximum penalty reduce drunk driving?  Will it give families “justice”?  Will it give prosecutors “the tools they need?”  Or will it give politicians and prosecutors a chance to put on a show to prove their “tough on crime” bona fides? 

It’s hard to cobble together a credible argument that somebody drives drunk because, “hey, it only carries a max of 15 years.  If it was 25, I wouldn’t do it.”  More importantly, drunk driving is a very dangerous thing and it should be taken seriously.  But it is not the outcome that makes it bad, it is the potential outcome that makes the act egregiously wrong. 

Is the drunk driver blowing .25, but lucky enough not to kill someone or get caught, less morally culpable than the same drunk driver who causes death?   There but for the grace of god…  One goes home and sleeps it off, only to go to work, or school, or wherever, as if nothing happened.  The other spends the rest of his life in prison.  They both engaged in the exact same conduct, but the consequences are a world apart.  The only difference between the two is pure kismet, as the drunk who made it home has put every man, woman and child on the road at risk of their lives.  He is every bit as wrong.  And the drunk who didn’t make it home?  Well, he lost to the combination of his crime and the odds.

And while the tragedy that befell Katie scares the daylights out of me, I hate that names are married to laws to invoke a visceral response intended to overcome reason.  How can anyone be against a law for Katie?  But we know that using Katie’s name is the hook, nothing more, to garner political capital from a human being’s tragedy.  Poor little Katie is gone to all, except politicians who care more about her now than before.

Good Questions Coming From The Avvo Debate

While the debate about Avvo ratings continues, a very good question was posed at Mark Bennett’s (with 2 “t”s) blog, Defending People.

Interestingly, you also suggest that whether a defendant is found guilty or not guilty depends pretty much wholly on who the defender is. Doesn’t the available evidence in the case have anything to do with the outcome? Doesn’t this part speak for the whole at all?

Mark’s answer was spot on:

You can’t change your facts or your luck; the only factor under your control is who you hire.

This raises the issue of lawyer fungibility.  For those of you who prefer to speak English, whether one lawyer is the same as another, and therefore interchangeable.  While lawyers recognize vast differences in skill level and experience, clients lack the tools to either appreciate these differences or assess them.  How would a client know a good lawyer from a bad one?  How would a client even begin to find out.

The knee-jerk answer is through referral.  Defendant asks someone, a friend, relative or the woman on the street corner (as is more often the case than we would like to admit) for the name of a “good” lawyer.  But as experience shows, clients’ perception of “good” lawyers is generally outcome driven.  If a lawyer beat a case, or got a defendant a good deal, he is “good” lawyer.  Conversely, if the lawyer lost the trial, he is not a “good ” lawyer.  Again, as lawyers we immediately recognize the fallacy of the outcome drive endorsement.

Next is the personal appointment.  Potential client meets with lawyer.  While common sense tells us this is the best method, experience tells us that it too has its flaws.  Clients look down two paths to determine whether the lawyer is “right” for them.  Path 1 is the “nice” lawyer.  They meet and client likes the lawyer.  While likability is certainly a good trait, it bears no connection to the lawyer’s skillset.  Think about the second defense lawyer in the movie My Cousin Vinny, and the flaw of this approach becomes painfully clear.

Path 2 is the lawyer who tells the client what he/she wants to hear.  This is a dangerous lawyer, but one who is very appealing to the potential client.  Whether it is the ethically challenged tact of guaranteeing an outcome, or the merely deceptive tact of making the amorphous suggestion that everything will be okay, it is a play on the client’s vulnerability at a time when honesty and truthfulness can be quite scary.  Nobody wants to scare the client away, but in the same vein, flat out lying to clients should be frowned upon (if you get my drift).

My thoughts have always been that the best source of determining the right lawyer is lawyer to lawyer referral.  We tend to be capable of assessing each other much better than non-lawyers, right?  But this too is an imperfect plan.  First, if the lawyers are in the same practice area, why would one refer to another (unless it was an extra defendant or conflict situation)?  On the other hand, if the potential client goes to his real estate lawyer for a referral, the real estate lawyer is unlikely to have a firm idea about the quality of the criminal defense bar and will default to a referral to a criminal defense attorney he knows.  And, of course, the one he is certain will kick back the referral fee.  With shocking frequency, the attorney to whom the case is referred is not really a criminal defense lawyer, but rather a former ADA who pretends that criminal defense is in his repertoire.

And finally, there is the price shopper, which comes full circle to the lawyer fungibility problem.  Client’s first question is “how much?”  The assumption is an ad hoc cost/benefit analysis, except that it doesn’t include the benefit in the calculus.  Since there are lawyers, unfortunately many lawyers, who will take felony cases for the cost of a traffic ticket, competent lawyers are invariably priced out of this market and the generally fee structure for the proper representation of a criminal case is impacted down the line.  But the argument from the attorneys, usually young and desperate, for taking cases at such ridiculously low fees is that they either grab the money or starve.  It’s a compelling argument, as long as you don’t think too hard about the interests of the client, since these lawyers can’t afford to try cases or do research when they are doing felonies at $1000 a pop.

So we return to the Avvo rationale.  Clients, the consumers of legal services, need a better way.  That’s for sure, but unfortunately it begs the question.  Is Avvo a better way?  Stay tuned.

Dancing with the Cops: The Miranda Two-Step

So you think you can dance?  While not a new dance craze, the Miranda Two-Step should be on everyone’s radar and is worthy of discussion.  Thanks to Second Circuit Blog for bringing it up.

Here’s the deal.  Cops engage in a deliberately unconstitutional interrogation of a defendant.  No Miranda warnings, coercive, whatever.  They induce the defendant to give a statement.   A little later, they give Miranda warnings and then get the defendant to repeat the statement by using the fact that it’s nothing new, he’s already told them and it’s too late to take it back.  Boom.  Good confession.

Sound familiar?  Missouri v. Seibert, 542 U.S. 600 (2004).  Justice Souter’s opinion for the Court explains that this doesn’t happen by chance.  It’s another instance of an intentional law enforcement strategy calculated to circumvent a constitutional right. 

The technique of interrogating in successive, unwarned and warned phases raises a new challenge to Miranda. Although we have no statistics on the frequency of this practice, it is not confined to Rolla, Missouri. An officer of that police department testified that the strategy of withholding Miranda warnings until after interrogating and drawing out a confession was promoted not only by his own department, but by a national police training organization and other departments in which he had worked. Consistently with the officer’s testimony, the Police Law Institute, for example, instructs that “officers may conduct a two-stage interrogation… . At any point during the pre-Miranda interrogation, usually after arrestees have confessed, officers may then read the Miranda warnings and ask for a waiver. If the arrestees waive their Miranda rights, officers will be able to repeat any subsequent incriminating statements later in court.”

While Seibert recognizes not only the problem, but the Machiavellian scheme by law enforcement, many courts refuse to admit or acknowledge that this is for real.  Cops, ever vigilant, have figured out that they shouldn’t openly admit that this is what they are intentionally doing, and hence lie thought their teeth (but with the best of intentions) about it. 

Also, variations on a theme have developed, such as the manipulative interrogation followed by the tape-recorded confirmatory statement.  While Seibert and its progeny tend to be highly fact specific, with some courts doing cartwheels to explain why the obvious application of this technique does not fall within the rule, the rationale offers some decent argument to be made to the jury as to why they should not buy the step 2 interrogation as reflecting a true admission, after the police manipulated the step 1, especially where the stop 2 is recorded and the step 1 is left to the officer’s fertile imagination.

Poll: New York or That Other State

Since it has become apparent that so many of our readers are too shy to express their views on whether they would prefer to practice in New York or Texas, I’ve decided to make it a bit easier.

Below is a scientifically devised poll to ascertain your true feelings. No one will know who you are, so feel free to express yourself without reservation. And don’t feel bad for Texas lawyers; Most of them are busy sleeping through trial anyway.

























Where would you rather practice criminal defense?
New York
Texas
Anywhere but Texas
Could I practice in Texas but live in NY?
Would I have to dress funny if I practiced in Texas?

  
pollcode.com free polls

The Choice To Remain Silent

Not about the clients this time, but the lawyers.  Most attorneys feel an unnatural compulsion to have sound emit from their mouths.  It’s just what they do.  Sometimes, it’s what they should do, but not always.

Clients love to watch as their lawyers stand up and seize control of the courtroom.  With a calm stateliness, the lawyer speaks and the din of the room suddenly quiets to the point where you can hear a pin drop.  All eyes turn to the lawyer and no one, not even the judge, would dare to interrupt.  The lawyer’s oratory captivates the room.  The jury wakes up and every eye is on the lawyer.  The client feels very, very good.  And the lawyer feels that he has fulfilled his promise. 

But this dreamy scenario, while satisfying, may prove to be the absolutely wrong tact to take.  There are times when the lawyer best serves his client by remaining silent.  This is a hard lesson for some lawyers.  In my experience, it tends to come with maturity, though many older, more experienced lawyers fail to recognize those moments when the best thing they can do is…nothing.

For example, good times to remain are silent are:

1.  When the judge is ripping your adversaries head off for some error, whether real or perceived
2.  When your adversary has apparently forgotten to do/say something, and is about to walk off a cliff
3.  When your adversary has made an argument that is so patently frivolous that it is destined to undermine his position
4.  When the judge is about to address a situation in your favor, even though she’s absolutely wrong
5.  When a prosecution witness has just lied through his teeth about some significant fact, but the lie works in your favor

Every trial lawyer is familiar with the last example.  It’s the one where your client grips your arm with such force that you wonder if circulation will ever return, and whispers in your ear. “He’s LYING!”  And you calmly turn toward your client and respond, “Yes, but he’s lying FOR you.”  It’s uncanny how some clients have a sudden hankering for the truth.

Similarly, there are times when the use of silence is your best friend prior to coming anywhere near trial.  For example, I represented a young woman who should have been charged with a felony assault, but the arresting officer took pity on her and wrote the initial charge as a misdemeanor assault so he could give her a desk appearance ticket and avoid putting her through system.  The young woman was having a psychotic episode at the time, and would have had a great deal of difficulty in a holding cell.  The officer was very kind.

When we appeared for arraignment on the appearance ticket, the prosecution had neglected to file an accusatory instrument, and so our appearance was noted and we went home.  The parents of the young woman were distraught, and wanted (perhaps better described as demanded) forward motion so that this matter would reach closure.  The apple never falls far from the tree, if you get my drift.

After calming down the parents, I told them that they would have to leave strategy to me and bear with the situation.  After a period of quiet time, I received a call from the assistant who told me that she was going to present the case to the Grand Jury.  I asked her to give it some time to see if we could work out a disposition, as the young woman was receiving treatment and there was no need to saddle her with a felony.  We spoke nicely to each other, and the assistant agreed. 

I promised to call her in two weeks with an update, and I did.  She wasn’t around, so I left a message.  No call back.  This was the critical moment.  Do I pursue the assistant, or leave it alone.  I knew she had a case, but the only benefit to another call would be to remind her of that fact.  I also knew that, in the meantime, other cases would come across her desk.  Other defendants.  Other cops.  Other parents.  Other lawyers.  So I opted to lay low.  If she ever called me, I was in the clear as I had called her as promised.

And so I went silent.  Six months later, not a word.  And so the case died, a slow, lingering, quiet death, and was never heard about again.  The defendant had neither case nor record.  It never happened.  The parents were dissatisfied by the absence of closure.  They wanted a piece of paper that said their baby was innocent, and were unhappy that there is no disposition when there is no case.  But there was no such animal to give.  At the end, there was a black hole of nothingness, but that nothingness included no charge and no conviction, a very successful outcome.  Silence can be golden.

The Consumerist: Very Interesting Indeed

One of my pet peeves is how we, as consumers, are subjected to petty theft and abuse on a daily basis.  Of course, it’s generally too small to be worth our time and effort, as attorneys, to deal with.  But it pisses me off, and I just don’t like being a pin cushion.

And so I stumbled upon The Consumerist.  Though not a law blog, it’s quite interesting and certainly holds no punches.  Frankly, I believe that the reason so many businesses get away with it is that we refuse to demand better and continue to patronize businesses that fail to fulfill their claims.  I can’t speak for anyone else, but when I promise something, I deliver.  There are no excuses. 

Consider this:  Have you ever noticed that when someone you pay for a product or service actually delivers, you’re so thrilled that you heap lavish praise upon them, swearing that you will never go elsewhere and coming dangerously close to promising your youngest daughter’s hand in marriage?  Why are we so thrilled by the mere fact that someone actually does exactly what we have paid them to do?  Because it is that rare.  What kind of sick world is that?

And as long as I’m on a run here, let me tell you how I stumbled across The Consumerist.  I was googling my VOiP provider, Sunrocket, to find out if there was anything out there about a consumer scam I came across today.  I signed up with a promotion for 3 additional months if the year was paid in advance.  When I questions the customer service rep as to why my invoice did not show the 3 additional months, I was told (by a very nice official young woman) that I would get the 3 free months after I paid for the second year, at which time I would receive a credit. 

This comes on top of voluminous service problems, constant “I’m sorry for the inconvenience” excuses and a bottom line failure to provide the service for which I paid.  Just another ordinary day for the American consumer.  Kinda ironic that the nice kids who work as customer service reps don’t perceive their role as cogs in the big wheel.  Oh yeah, I forgot to mention that I called an old friend in the New York State Attorney General’s office to see what they could do about ol’ Sunrocket.  He was not amused.

The Avvo Controversy Continues

New York Legal Update, not ordinarily inclined toward editorials, has come out in support of the new and controversial Avvo lawyer ratings.  While I can’t argue with many of the points made, particularly the absurdity of the class action against Avvo which is just plain embarrassing, its ultimate conclusion misses the mark.

Before I explain why, I should say that Paul Bloom, one of the co-founders of Avvo, posted a comment here about the qualitative vs. quantitative issue I raised when Avvo first came online.  Afterward, I invited Paul to be interviewed about Avvo, thus giving him an opportunity to address the comments and criticism leveled at Avvo.  No response to my invitation.  To the extent that I was initially impressed by his willingness to expose himself to the scrutiny of the bar and defend Avvo’s system, it appears that the heat is too much for Avvo and they’re hiding under the kitchen table.  At least for now.

So Tom Schwartz, honcho of New York Legal Update, takes the position that anything that helps clients find the right lawyer is a good thing, and that we need more, not less, mechanisms to rate lawyers.  While I can’t argue with either point, it begs the question of whether Avvo ratings help or mislead.  I agree whole-heartedly that connecting clients with the right lawyer is a great thing.  I agree completely that many (most?) clients, particularly in my field of criminal defense, have no clue how to identify the right lawyer, or how to vet lawyers for competency, and find themselves making a horrible mistake in perhaps the most important matter in their lives by retaining the wrong lawyer.  A mistake they will be forced to live with for many years. 

But does Avvo solve anything?  Avvo, by relying on a mathematical calculus for its ratings, inherently ignored the qualitative aspect of lawyering.  I suppose that in non-litigation areas, that may work.  But when you need a litigator, it omits the critical elements necessary to make an informed choice.  Still, it rates the lawyers on what is arguably irrelevant bases and provides a rating.  Hooray, I’m a 10!  But what if a lawyer, rated a 10, has never tried a serious felony to verdict?  Suddenly that 10 rings hollow.  Worse yet, it may steer a client away from a lawyer with an 8.7 rating, but who has tried 50 murder cases to verdict, in favor of a lawyer with a 10 rating who has never tried a case to verdict but has written a few law review articles.

So the problem is that a client, the consumer of legal services, can be mislead by the rating, and pushed to retain an attorney who has a higher number but lacks the skills needed to serve the client.  Nowhere in the Avvo ratings is this accommodated.  To say, as Avvo does, that “no client should rely solely on Avvo ratings” is disingenuous.  Either the ratings serve a purpose or they don’t.  If Avvo ratings are intended to be but one factor in the retention decision, where’s the big disclaimer, in bold red type, that says “IN MAKING YOUR DECISION TO RETAIN A LAWYER, DO NOT RELY ON THESE RATINGS AS THEY PROVIDE NO INFORMATION ABOUT A LAWYER’S ACTUAL SKILLS!”  Of course, if they had such a disclaimer, why would anybody look?

And that’s the point.  Either the rating means something or it doesn’t.  If it can’t account for the qualitative distinctions between lawyers, then is presumes lawyers to be fungible.  That may be true for lawyers in some areas of practice, but not mine.  For clients who retain happy, smiling, glad-handing criminal defense lawyers because they are “nice”, only to find themselves in prison for the rest of their natural lives, this is a hard lesson.  For clients who pick a lawyer based on their Avvo rating, the lesson may be no different.

So I agree with Tom Schwartz completely that clients need a better way to decide which lawyer to retain.  I just don’t buy Avvo ratings as being the answer.  Unless Paul Bloom convinces me otherwise.  I’m still waiting.

The Snitch Corroboration Rule

Mark Bennett (with 2 “T”s), at Defending People, writes that one of the blessings of Texas criminal law is the snitch corroboration rule.  The fact that they need a  rule about snitches is itself a very sad commentary.  So, let’s take a look and use the opportunity to make fun of Texas at the same time.

In the early days of the Clinton administration, the idea of flipping your client (for non-criminal defense lawyers, that means urging your client to become to cooperate with the government and become a confidential information) was unthinkable.  Snitches, or rats as they are known in polite society, were the lowest of the low.  These were criminals who were not man enough to face the consequences, and hence went crying like little girls at the very thought of paying the consequences for their conduct and were willing to put their brothers and mothers in jail rather than take the weight.

I’m sure everyone remembers Berretta, the TV show with Robert Blake (who never killed anyone. Really!) saying those famous words, “If you can’t do the time, don’t do the crime.”  Well, that was about as effective as Nancy Reagan saying, “Just say no”. 

One day, there was a rush to the courthouse door, with snitches and their snitch lawyers pushing and shoving to be the first one to get to the US Attorney to flip.  Bear in mind, there was no god-given right to be accepted as a rat.  Last man there was the one to get screwed, because he had nobody left to snitch on.  There would be a room full of snitches and snitch lawyers, all with there hands raised, yelling “I was here first” and “I’m the biggest rat” and “Me! Me! Let me rat first!” 

It was a train moving full speed, wiping out any chance of beating an indictment.  It was the domino theory of snitches.  But most importantly, it was drive by the defense lawyers.  A coterie of criminal defense lawyers would take their fees and then run over to the US Attorney’s office like good little errand boys to serve up their clients on a silver platter.  Ah, those were heady days, when a lawyer could grab a decent fee, do little to no work and give their client (and everyone their client ever knew) up without breaking a sweat. 

Soon, the very idea of going to trial was almost an anachronism.  For some older lawyers, including yours truly, for whom flipping was neither a panacea nor a means to a quick buck, we were disgusted.  We watched this shameful conduct, trying desperately to hold conspiracy cases together so that we had a chance to win.  Only to watch the weak link lawyer go behind our backs to the government and beg to do their bidding. 

On those rare occasions when we could keep the group together, we won some stunning victories.  It always depended on one factor:  who the other lawyers on the case were.  If we had real trial lawyers, we had a chance.  But real trial lawyers became fewer and farther between.  Mind you, they never told their clients when they were retained that the plan was never to win. Oh no, they would talk a good case to get the retainer, but as soon as the wad of cash found its way to their pockets, they would be on line to take a number, just like at the deli counter, to flip their client. 

Return to the present:  And so today we have rules about snitch corroboration.  Snitches have become such an integral and accepted part of criminal law that legislatures have made rules about them.  For younger lawyers, they can’t conceive of a time when every conspiracy didn’t have a rat.  They similarly can’t conceive of a time when a conspiracy case, the “darling of the prosecution,” was tried and won.  Caselaw requires criminal defense lawyers to advise clients that flipping may be the only way to ameliorate the draconian sentences under the federal sentencing guidelines, lest they be guilty of ineffective assistance of counsel. 

A good friend and exceptional appellate lawyer, Diarmuid White, used to give a CLE lecture about the ethics of turning a client into a rat.  He contended that by doing so, the defense lawyer becomes the government’s enabling butt boy, violating his oath of zealous representation in favor of counseling his client how to be as compliant to the government’s will as possible.  He had a point.  But then again, he’s an old time lawyer like me, the kind who actually tried to defend their client and win the case.  And he’s not from Texas.