It usually takes more than 24 hours for a point to be proven. Not today. As noted yesterday in my analysis of the SCOTUS Scott v. Harris decision, giving cops carte blanche in high speed chases was tantamount to a license to kill. That very same day, a high speed chase in Queens to stop a car thief (let’s assume guilt for the sake of argument) resulted in a bus full of children to overturn as reported in Newsday.
Thankfully, no child died. Was it worth it to catch a car thief? In the big trade-off, how many children’s lives are worth the arrest of one car thief? Hey SCOTUS, are you listening?
Author Archives: SHG
Beer with a Cop Chaser
As has been widely reported, the US Supreme Court has ruled in Scott v. Harris. As stated in the SCOTUS Blog, the decision held:
Here is how the Court phrases the rule it established: “A police officer’s attempt to terminate a dangerous high-speed car chase that threatens the lives of innocent bystanders does not violate the Fourth Amendment, even when it places the fleeing motorist at risk of serious injury or death.”
The Court’s decision, issued by Justice Antonin Scalia, has been called a “flat rule,” and castigated in a concurring (Justices Breyer and Ginsburg, separately) and dissenting (Justice Stevens) opinion as too absolute. From the solid 6 vote majority opinion, the answer is one of total deference to the judgment of a police officer to use vehicular deadly force to stop a high speed car chase without it being held unreasonable under the Fourth Amendment.
This is insanity. These justices, though clearly supportive of police, have demonstrated their total lack of connection to reality and, more significantly, that their support exceeds their realization that this is a license to kill. Not the bad guys. Us.
Let’s take this from the top. This decision was justified based on a videotape of a chase (the first to be published by the Court so all could see, bringing the Court into the YouTube generation. From this single scenario, the Court has established a per se rule, engaging in the dreaded inductive reasoning that invariably fails in the harsh light of experience. But they must have known that, because these aren’t a bunch of dopes.
A cop decides that he wants to stop a motor vehicle, so he turns on his lights. The car doesn’t pull over, but insteads speeds up and drives away. First question: What was the reason for stopping the car in the first place. Did the cop have probable cause to believe that the driver committed murder? Was a tail light out? Was the driver black? These questions used to matter.
By his action in trying to stop the car, the cop initiates the confrontation that results in a high speed chase. Granted, it’s not the cops fault that the driver doesn’t pull over, but then society can’t control the driver, but we can control the cop. Or we used to be able to.
Next step is the cop making the decision to pursue the driver. At this point, the cop makes a judgment call as to whether it is a better idea to escalate the situation into a high speed chase or not. But if he doesn’t chase, you ask, what is he supposed to do? Well, there’s always taking down the license plate and finding the driver later. Or radio other cars to find the car at a more propitious point where he can be stopped without need for a high speed chase. Yes, Virginia. There are alternatives.
But then the cop decides to pursue. At high speeds. And the chase is on. So what? This is one of the two things a police officer can do that presents the greatest risk of death to the miscreant, the cop and the public. The other is discharge his weapon, but we will leave that for another per se rule day. While police officers are trained in high speed driving, that doesn’t guarantee that they are very good at it. Further, stuff seems to happen that interferes with your basis high speed chase, like mommies in SUVs with kids in the back entering intersections with the light just when Officer Parnelli Jones needs to go through.
The driver of the vehicle being chased, however, has no such high speed training. He’s just full of adrenaline, ego or crack. Maybe he’s just brain dead. But even stupidity in the first degree doesn’t carry a death sentence. At least it didn’t used to.
So there are two players on the road, driving very fast and uninclined to stop at traffic control devices, while the rest of us merrily go about our daily lives. Our children carefully look both ways for the car traveling 30 miles per hour. Our spouses are tired and irritable (okay, at least mine is) driving home. And without warning, a car hurtles forward at an incredible velocity and then…BOOM!
For what? A broken tail light? A observation buy of a nickle bag of marijuana? Is that all your life is worth? Is that all anyone’s life is worth?
It is not that I have no faith in the good judgment of cops. I don’t imagine that every cop on the job is going to engage in high speed chases for the fun of it following Scott v. Harris. But some will. And someone will die because of it. And our Supreme Court does not need to encourage this. Indeed, put its seal of approval on it. Maybe in the ivory tower of black robed punditry these unintended consequences never happen, but on the stretch of road that real people drive they do. This is sheer insanity. And this time, we will all pay the price.
Could You Use Smaller Words?
Following the trio of death penalty decisions by the United States Supreme Court, which can be found on the SCOTUS blog, Anne Reed at Deliberations opines about the “high confusion” of death penalty juries in following instruction to reach their decisions. The piece is called Give Me Clarity or Give Me Death. What a great title.
While I completely support both the issue and the commentary as to the lack of clarity based upon the Supreme Court’s own inability to present a cogent approach, it also provides another opportunity to remind everyone that the rest of the instructions given to jurors continue to fail miserably to serve their sole intended function of providing a framework for a jury to reach a verdict.
I’m reminded of the efforts over the years to reform the instructions on “beyond a reasonable doubt” so that a typical juror can understand and appreciate its meaning. No one has every been able to do so. This is a problem, dontcha think?
We lawyers love our words. So precise. So clear. So filled with inherent content developed over centuries of squabbling. But jurors, most of the time, are not lawyers. So these wonderous words that we hold so dear, and take for granted, have disasterously different meanings to jurors (and a few lawyers, who aren’t always the sharpest knife in the drawer). We speak these words on summation, to tie in the judge’s instructions to our arguments so that the jurors believe that we (and not the other guy) fit into the sounds eminating from the court’s lips. Why do we strain so hard to match our rhetoric with the court? Because those of us with any experience at all know that the instructions are going to fly over the heads of some, perhaps most, jurors. We will take every potential tool available to seize the advantage. Can you blame us?
It’s not that jurors are stupid or ignorant. It’s that we use a strange foreign language, and everyone knows it except us. The legalese that clogs jury instructions does not, contrary to many lawyers’ belief, make for dazzling cocktail party chatter. Regular people just don’t have much call to say the phrase “malum in se.” Go figure. And they generally aren’t impressed with lawyers who slip it in when trying to get a date.
As courts struggle to find a way to express the legal concepts they are required to convey to the jury right before the jury is sent to the back room to eat deli sandwiches, we fall into the abyss of yet another legal fiction where we must presume that the jury not only heard and understood the instructions given, but followed them in reaching their verdict.
So yes, the confusion of SCOTUS in providing clear instructions for the death penalty is a problem, particuarly if you happen to be on the receiving end of the indictment. But we should never forget that the matter of jury instructions at all levels and in all respects is a bit of a weak link in our criminal justice system. I was going to insert one of our beloved platitudes here about the best system available, but I’ve decided to make today platitude-free and will resume my scandalous sarcastic approach to platitudes some other day.
And If You Felt Bad for Judges…
Consider the next trend, BigLaw clerks are getting $50,000 bonuses this year! According to Above the Law, four of the major New York law firms have decided to jump in so far.
Now let me be clear: I’m no commie. I am a capitalist, through and through. But, this is just getting goofy, and one has to wonder what is going through the minds of the nice folks who make decisions about how much they need to pay kids who have yet to finish law school, can’t argue their way out of paper bag and wouldn’t know what to do with a case if it hit them between the eyes. Do they really need to shove even more money down their throats lest these “best and brightest” be poached by some competing BigLaw firm?
Put aside the shear insanity of the endless money pit in absolute terms for a minute, and consider what this means for real lawyers, judges and clients.
Dear Mr. Client, ever wonder why that legal fee is higher than the gross national product of a small third world nation? Do you really think it’s worth it to pay some kid with less legal experience than a gnat to hold the bag of some associate who tails behind some junior partner whose claim to fame is logging 3874 billable hours?
And dear brother solo practitioner, as you struggle to get quality clients into your office, and as your experience of 50 jury trials, hundreds of litigated motions and developing winning strategies in thousands of cases, you find yourself straggling behind library bench-warmers who are spoon-fed the belief that they have the midas touch to bolster their budding arrogance.
So Your Honor, as the years go by without the Legislature believing that your services are worthy of the price for a first year BigLaw association, you now have to worry about wage compression with law clerks! The new career path has a fork in the road: Judge or Law Clerk. Which has the promise of assuring your children will get those braces they need?
Guys and gals, get real. This is a system that has shed all reason in the never-ending competition for the biggest of the big bucks. Twenty-five years ago, we thought that this could never continue. One BigLaw firm would up the ante and all the others would chant “me too, me too” so that they wouldn’t look like schnurrers in the club house. But we were wrong. Very wrong. It has continued, and the ante gets upped and upped. Worse yet, the clients, in mindless oblivion, continue to pay the tab for this insanity, as BigLaw profits challenge those of businesses that actually produce something with societal utility.
But a word of caution for you law clerks, flush with your bonus checks. You will get your associates position, together with a pay check that will make your father’s head explode with pride. But BigLaw will suck you dry, using up every waking hour and then some in the most miserable exploitation possible, until you awake one day and scream “I can’t take it anymore!” And then you will move out to some firm or practice in the real world, where the receptionists desk isn’t gold-plated. And at the end of the week, there will be a bunch of zeros missing from the paycheck, and you will struggle to keep up the lease payments on your Mercedes.
“Struggle” is a word that was never included in your personal financial lexicon. Law can be a tough world. The promises made during clerkship do not necessarily follow you throughout your career. And you will look back one day and wonder why you were a million dollar baby at BigLaw, but are now just a lawyer. You haven’t changed, except that you now have skills and experience. The shock of reality can be quite difficult. Enjoy your clerkship, as it can go downhill quickly from there.
But I Used to be a Prosecutor…
Yesterday, at a meeting of some of the finest legal minds in New York, the proposition was put forth by
Eric Turkewitz of The New York Personal Injury Law Blog
that former prosecutors are per se competent to be criminal defense lawyer. Turkewitz, better known as Turkey, has never been so wrong. Now I am not saying that former prosecutors cannot be competent, if not excellent, defense lawyers. Indeed, many of our best were once on the dark side. But Turkey’s position is that they are inherently competent by virtue (if you can use that word) of their service to the State. Turkey, you ignorant slut…
Why Should It Matter?
Earlier this morning, I read an interview by Dirk Olin of Judicial Reports fame with the Honorable Jonathan Lippman, Chief Administrative Judge of the New York State Courts, on the burning issue of judicial salaries. I was going to write something about it, but then I was overwhelmed by a sense of sound judgment. Why?
Why does it matter to me, or you, whether judges get a salary increase? When is the last time a judge asked you what he or she could do to help your business? How many judges do you know who show the slightest concern about how they’re actions affect you? Never, you say? Me too.
As a younger lawyer, I remember sitting in a courtroom for hour after hour waiting to have my case called, at which time I would spend 12 seconds before the judge. I would think to myself, does this guy have a clue what it means to me to sit here? I do not know whether he did (though I would bet money he didn’t), but I was very clear that he didn’t care.
And what about the times that I was there at 9:30 in the morning, signed up my case first, and then had to wait a few hours for the prosecutor to leisurely stroll in. We all know that court starts at 9:30 am, so why am I here, cooling my heals, and the judge is more than happy to let me stew half the day rather than call the case and make the prosecutor pay the price.
But then there’s the dreaded second call, where your case is called at 9:30 or so, but the prosecutor isn’t sure if his cops are available (like this was a big surprise), and will get back to the judge with whether he is ready for trial. After 2:00. After lunch. And so the judge says, come back at 2. At 2? To first find out if anything is going to happen. A whole friggin day lost? Because the prosecutor is either lazy or full of it? Give me a break. I have other cases. I have other things to do. I have to make a living. But the judge doesn’t care.
So they really don’t spend a lot of time considering how their choices affect my practice, my life or my income. And so why should I spend any more time or bandwidth thinking about theirs?
ADDENDUM: I was asked by another blawger if I feared that judges might get wind of this and retaliate. Not at all. I am not against raises for judges, as stated previously. But is this a priority for me? The answer is that we are all parts of the same system, and it’s time that we all give a little thought and concern to how we treat each other in the system. If one cog in the wheel wants the other cogs to worry about their plight, then they should demonstrate some concern about the other cogs as well. This may not be a hard concept to understand, but few judges think about how their actions impact the others in the well. It wouldn’t kill them to do dos.
I will add one additional point, however. I have made a gross generalization, and as has been pointed out to me, there are some (not many, but some) judges who do show concern for lawyers as a matter of simple courtesy and respect. It is not a universale plague. Merely pervasive and systemic. Little comfort, but better than nothing.
The Merit Selection Panacea
Gov. Eliot Spitzer, having had a good night’s rest, has moved forward in his agenda to the issue of merit selection of judges. For a long time now, merit selection has been the mantra for ending the dirty little backroom deals and paper bags full of money that characterized the ascension to the bench. The New York State Bar Association has been banging this drum unmercifully, using every platitude known to man, and more than a few mixed metaphors. Ah, you say. Finally. It’s about time.
Slow down a second. Hold yer horses. While I don’t understand why every sitting judge isn’t furious with the implication that they would be on the corner selling hotdogs but for this corrupt electoral system, the concept of “merit” as a basis for selecting judges seems unassailable. How can anyone be against merit? Except public employee unions, of course, but that’s a different discussion.
To accomplish this seismic shakeup in a very old system, New York will require a constitutional amendment. A lot of effort, but certainly worth it if the improvement to the system will be as vast as suggested. But I have this nagging concern that it’s a lot of hyperbole without a lot of change. It’s not that I’m against a better way, but that I seriously question whether anyone really has a better way. Maybe we are changing one dubious method for another with a better name but little substance.
The argument, at least to the public, is that judges will no longer be selected by party leaders in back rooms (they used to be smoke filled back rooms before the ban on indoor smoking). So far, fine. After all, this makes it sound really bad, suggesting that party leaders are cynical, nefarious manipulators whose purpose in life is to thrust incompetent party-faithful lawyers on the public in positions of extreme power who will do their bidding. Okay, a bit hyperbolic, but that is the intended impression.
So how does this merit selection thing work? I can’t say. Do we envision a bunch of guys walking the darkened streets of Oswego with a lamp searching for an honest man? Will there be a contest for the best and brightest? Or, as appears more likely, will it be the lawyer old boy club trying to earnestly choose from among their peers.
These good government things tend to begin with a blue ribbon panel of unimpeachable important folks. Who could complain about these mandarins of the bar? But these are the big guys. Biglaw. Important. White shoe. Noteworthy. The sort of guys and gals who you read about in headlines that include law firms with ten names on the letterhead. They do not tend to chat up a lot of small town, small time, solo practitioner-type lawyers at their cocktail parties. That’s because the little guys don’t get invited to the same cocktail parties.
So, who becomes the universe of potential judges from which the merit gets selected? My guess is it’s not going to be Atticus Finch. More than likely, the pool of potential judges is going to be the types of lawyers that these blue-ribbon panelists hang around with and know. Of course, the vast majority of lawyers in New York are not pulling down six figure salaries at Jones, Jones, Jones, Jones and Jones. Especially in Tonawanda.
So, is the point to change the potential pool of judges from those licking envelopes in party headquarters to those billing 3297 hours at Biglaw (but not going to make partner)? If that’s it, then this is a charade. I’m all for merit selection, as opposed to lack of merit selection, but if we are going to make a monumental change in how judges are selected, then it has to be both a real improvement and a significant one.
It’s not enough that the shift be from one group of favored lawyers to another. It’s not enough that decisions are made in the conference room rather than the backroom. And it’s not enough to spout platitudes to mask a change from one side of the mole hill to the other. Merit Selection! Yeah! Now let’s see whether it’s for real.
Class Assignment 101
Read Chapter 1 of The Irony of American History by Reinhold Niebuhr, 1952. Though written under the threat of communism and the atomic bomb, it is every bit as applicable today as it was when written. And that, gentle readers, is yet another irony.
For those of you who do not complete your homework (and yes, you get a gentlemen’s “C”), you will suffer the consequence of life without a philosophical understanding and appreciation of why the polemics that guide our existence continues to fail to satisfy our idealistic dream of virtuous hegemony. Okay, okay. So the language is a tad stiff and perhaps too precise given current common usage. Still, struggle a little because we are living today as Neibuhr explained more than 50 years ago because we have no yet gained an adequate understanding of who we are, why we do things and why we cannot overcome human nature by banging on the table.
Just change a few words and Neibuhr could be talking about Iraq and weapons of mass destruction. And when the next conflagration happens (and it will), the book will again predict the obvious. Yet another irony is that his purpose in writing is to give us the opportunity to view the world in a way that would allow us to break free of the chains that, he similarly tells us, cannot be broken. Too obtuse? Do you get your philosophy from Archie Comics? Give it a try. You certainly won’t be any the worse for it, and it may just clarify that gnawing sense that there really is intelligent life on earth.
My Brain Made Me Do It!
At the crossroads of science and law, Vanderbilt University Professer Owen Jones of law and biology (yes, another Law/Bio Prof) has published an article contending that violence and anti-social behavior is a result of brain dysfunction. Researching prisoners, he contends that things such as brain damage cause people to engage in criminal conduct. If the brain damage is repaired, the criminal conduct disappears.
As with all peer reviewed medical journal type essays, the title tells you the theory and the rest of the article tries to prove it. If you’re any good a statistical analysis, you can judge for yourself the validity of the theory, but let’s assume the theory is correct. Then what?
In law, we attribute violene and anti-social behavior to people being evil. We punish them because they are malevolent, bad people deserving punishment. What if they’re just sick? What if some damage to their brain, or some chemistry screw up, causes some wierd action to come out that breaks the law, but they would never engage in this behavior if their brain was not damaged. The answer, then, would seem that the sentence should be medical treatment, since that’s the cause of the problem and, once cured, they would present no danger or threat to society. Being sick is not being morally culpable. We don’t imprison people who have the flu, do we?
Or is this just another try at saying that people bear no responsibility for their conduct? They appear to appreciate the consequences of their actions. They know right from wrong. They are witty at a cocktail party, so why should they get a free ride at committing a crime?
My anecdotal researh has recently made me believe that Prof. Owen may be on to something. Neither he (nor I) say that all violent or anti-social activities are brain related. Indeed, in my opinion, many are decidedly related to the lack of use of the brain. But I’ve found in the past couple of years that a number of my clients suffered from various psychological disorders. Undiagnosed when they came to me, I’ve used forensic and neuro psychs to evaluate these clients only to find that they are severely screwed up people. This is a medical term, so do not use this term at home without an expert standing by.
For instance, I recently represented a 62 year old man, very successful in legitimate business, who just happened to have done a couple of 15 year bits in prison for drug dealing along the way. Very intelligent in an idiot savant kinda way, he presented (another medical term) with a bizarre grandiosity and a remarkable ability to shift focus without notice when confronted with unpleasant reality. He had never been evaluated for mental illness, so I had him seen by some really good people. Suprise! They tell me he’s a raging bipolar. He doesn’t meet any definition of insanity, as he fully understands and appreciates the consequences of his acts. He just lapses into this state of twisted judgment when confronted with criminal opportunity where he punishes himself by making bad decisions.
So we realize his condition after I got him an exceptionally good plea agreement in federal court following a lengthy suppression hearing where he testified. When it comes time for sentence, we present this to the judge. She looks at me cross-eyes, asking, “Are you saying that the defendant is not guilty by reason of mental disease or defect?” Noooooooo, I’m saying that the defendant is quite guilty, but that he is not the evil, morally culpable miscreant that his horrendous criminal history suggests. I’m saying he is a sick man, and was never diagnosed in all those years in prison, and came out as sick as he went in. I’m saying that he needs treatment, not a prison cell.
I have never seen an argument fall upon deaf ears as this one. Not only was the judge unpersuaded, but she so totally missed the boat as to suggest that the entire psychiatric discipline, organic and otherwise, should suck eggs. To this judge, there was only two choices: You’re either totally drooling nuts or just plain evil. No shades of grey here, thank you very much.
So what can we expect from solid research by folks like Prof. Owen? A legal system with a history going back to the M’Naghten case of 1843 that can’t quite figure out how to fit mental illness into its paradigm. The problem for society is that this refusal to understand the problem means that we won’t fix the problem, putting people in jail who don’t need it and cutting them loose to commit new crimes that could have been prevented. It’s an expensive, wasteful and dangerous way to deal with a problem by denying it. It makes no one safer and helps no one. We have a name for this sort of failure: the criminal justice system.
Lawyer Under Attack – Again
In the New York, a former Mets minor leaguer cum actor was accused of the brutal killing of a helpless cat. Joe Petcka has been castigated in the media for an act which, if committed, is disgusting and disgraceful. So much for the media learning anything from the Duke case.
But I do not write about the defendant, but rather his lawyer, Charles Hochbaum. For the offense of representing Petcka, Chuck Hochbaum has received a flurry of threatening emails attacking him for representing Petcka. Some of the emails come from people who claim to be attorneys. The gist of these emails are clear: By representing this defendant, the lawyer is as sick and horrible a human being as the perpetrator of this horrific crime. And deserving of attack as much, if not more so, than the defendant.
I can appreciate that some laypeople have some difficulty distinguishing between the attorney and client, and attribute to the attorney the evil they perceive in the client. As if, by representation, the lawyer endorses the criminal. Or perhaps worse, the lawyer becomes a party to the crime, like a co-conspirator, by serving the cause of freeing the miscreant. Wrong, but understandable in a twisted yet ignorant way.
But lawyers attacking other lawyers for being lawyers? That’s just pathetic. They should — no, must — know better. True, as argued to Chuck, he could have turned down the case and stood proud of his refusal to represent an accused cat killer. But the representation of the despised is the highest order of criminal defense. I am not saying that criminal defense lawyers are under obligation to take any case that walks in their door, or that they have no right to turn away a defendant whom they simply cannot stomach. But they are similarly entitled to do their sworn duty and defend those who are accused and hated. Someone has to, and that’s our role in our system of criminal justice.
Chuck Hochbaum deserves our praise, not threats, for doing his job in the face of such public outrage. Not because he supports cat killing, which I’m sure he does not, but because he fulfilled his role in our system despite being subject to attack. I wonder how long it will take before some psycho threatens the life of his family. It isn’t always fun and exciting to be a lawyer.
