Author Archives: SHG

It’s the Defense Lawyers, Stupid

Randy E. Barnett, in an April 17th Wall Street Journal editorial, Three Cheers for the Lawyers, figured it all out:

The point I decided to make was simple: For better or worse, we have an adversary legal system that relies for its proper operation on having competent lawyers on both sides. In every case I knew about where an innocent person had been convicted, there had been an incompetent defense lawyer at the pretrial and trial stages.

No, his point wasn’t to castigate incompetent lawyers.  In fact, he goes on to praise the defense lawyers in the Duke rape case and use this opportunity to admonish the readers of the Journal that they too should bear in mind that lawyers serve a purpose other than as a pin cushion.

While he is undoubtedly correct that competent counsel is crucial to success in criminal defense (as opposed to the lawyers are fungible crowd who prefer to pretend that any lawyer will do when one’s life is on the line), his statement above is either shockingly naive or disturbingly disingenuous.

So it’s all about defense lawyer incompetence?  It has absolutely nothing to do with deceptive and deceitful law enforcement practices?  It has nothing to do with concealment of exculpatory evidence by the prosecution?  There is no impact of a court system largely inclined to pay lip service to the presumption of innocence while firmly assuming the opposite?  On what planet?

Never will I excuse inadequate representation by a defense lawyer.  But I will similarly not pretend that they alone bear the blame for wrongful convictions.  The prosecution side has weapons that the defense side will never have:  They have cops with guns and shields.  We are lucky to have clients who can afford a basic investigator.  They can pressure witnesses into saying, or not saying, what they want.  We get doors slammed in our face at every turn.  They can obtain information.  We are denied anything beyond the most cursory information.  It’s not a fair fight, which is why the defense has to be a whole lot better than the prosecution if we are to have a fighting chance.

So thanks for the complement Randy.  And thank you, Mr. Wall Street Journal, for remembering that defense lawyers have a role to play in the system.  But let us not rest easy knowing that we have solved the problem of prosecuting, and convicting, the innocent by laying all blame at the feet of the incompetent defense lawyer.  The prosecution has a duty, a very meaningful duty, to make sure that the poor fellow they put through the wringer is not an innocent man (or guilty, but of a lesser crime than alleged).  Some prosecutors take this obligation very seriously; many do not.  Many more are too immature or blind to understand what this means, seeing their cops as perfect heros incapable of doing or being wrong.  There’s plenty of blame to go around.

It’s Tough To Be The Big Guy

Andrew Lavoott Bluestone of New York Attorney Malpractice Blog brings us this juicy little tidbit about that bon vivant of the Manhattan legal set, Raoul Lionel Felder.  Inexplicably, Raoul was tapped to replace an exceptionally competent and well-respected lawyer, Lawrence Goldman, as chair of the New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct. Larry had been unceremoniously dropped as chair, not to mention member, of the commission without so much as thanks.  And now the ten commissioners have unanimously issued a vote of “no confidence” against Raoul, a Pataki-appointee. 

On Friday, Raoul responded, “I wrote a book. This is America — I thought I had a right to write a book.” And the people who have work with you have a right to vote that they have no confidence in you.  It’s a two-way street.  Like Probity Road.  Or Integrity Highway.  Well, you get the point.

Lawyers who try to be taken both seriously and as a “character”, as does Felder, often find themselves caught in a bind.  There are few things a lawyer can do that are as serious and significant than to sit in judgment of judges.  It’s a very risky business, and integrity means more than anything else.  So now, Raoul’s relationship with comedian Jackie Mason comes back to bite him in the butt. 

Raoul was one of those larger than life lawyers, who apparently never missed an opportunity at self-promotion and was always ready for his close-up.  bad guy.  However, he’s a matrimonial lawyer, and yet I would see him on TV opining about matters criminal, civil and otherwise.  It would seem that discretion, and substance, would not stand in the way of a TV opportunity.

Still, I don’t begrudge someone who so obviously desires the limelight his right to show his face whenever he’s asked to do so.  And I don’t even begrudge him some of the silly things I’ve heard him say, since they are hardly much worse than the silly things other people have to say on TV.  Granted, when he puts himself out as a criminal defense lawyer, it makes me wince.  But that’s just a personal pecadillo, and not a reason to castigate ol’ Raoul.

But when he was made the chair of something as important, and serious, as the Judicial Conduct Commission, that made me take a very deep breath.  This is not a show pony position.  This is very serious, and is the final safeguard between a judge (whose word in court can destroy lives in a flash) and everyone else.  When judges can’t be trusted to sit on the bench, it is left to this Commission to throw him or her off.

The last thing the Commission needed was a show pony, whose written words raised significant issues as to what was “allegedly” going on in his head.  This Commission, from chair to the newest member, needs people of unimpeachable integrity and the strength of will to do the right thing no matter how powerful the target.  Thankfully, Raoul imploded.  Let’s hope that the next chair will better reflect the type of lawyer that the people of the State of New York expect and need.

Court TV: Why Bother?

A dear friend in the media implored me to watch Court TV to see another friend, defense lawyer Joe Tacopina, in the Melanie McGuire murder case in New Jersey.  So I had some time last Friday to tune in.  Naturally, the trial was put over to Monday for closings, so I didn’t get to see Joe do his magic.  But there were the talking heads, as always, discussing the case.  And that’s where this rant begins.

First, the anchors.  I don’t blame people whose career path is television for doing their thing on whatever channel will pay them.  But I’m watching Jack Ford, Rikki Klieman and Ashleigh Banfield and, to be blunt, they’re just blathering.  Words are just coming out of their mouths to fill air time, ranging from the banal to the silly.  I tried listening carefully.  I really did.  But the words offered absolutely nothing.  They were not informative.  They were not interesting.  They were not accurate.  They were just, plain pointles.

Attorneys have an ethical obligation to assist the public to better understand the legal system.  But Court TV treats the system like a little league baseball game, turning witnesses into innings and offering such elucidating comments as “the prosecution scored a big point with that one.”  Where’s the little box score in the corner?

Second, the guests.  There are always attorneys who appear as the “expert” commentary.  They don’t pay these lawyers, but know that there are always going to be plenty of lawyers who want to get their puss on TV, even if they have nothing to add and can’t get three words out without tripping.

Why?  Why do they put some guy whose sole purported reason for appearing is that he was “once a prosecutor and now a criminal defense lawyer” on the air to discuss what’s going on in the real defense lawyer’s mind.  He doesn’t have a clue.  He can’t have a clue.  If the expert has half a brain, he KNOWS he doesn’t have a clue. Yet, he will happily appear, waste hours of his day, with the absolute knowledge that he has nothing to say.  Why?

But the anchors are pros.  They know that their expert brings nothing to the table, and is just another excuse to fill up empty air.  So, they ask the expert a 3,742 word question that includes the answer to their own question, not to mention a half dozen presumptions of dubious validity, leavin the expert to bob his head like a blithering idiot until the anchor says, “Well Joe, we’re out of time.  Thanks again for that insight. And now…”

Third, Nancy Grace.  Nancy Graces gets a category all her own.  Unlike the others, Nancy has an ax to grind.  She claimed to be the fiance of a murder victim, on top of being a former prosecutor.  Of course, it is now well known that she is accuracy challenged, but somehow nobody seems to mind.  Instead, she brings insight such as “where there’s smoke, there’s fire” to the legal table.  She has single handedly done more to undermine the standard of proof, concept of reliable evidence  and rationally connected thought than any other blond in America. 

But unlike the others, at least she says something, stupid though it may be. Shockingly flawed reasoning?  Grotesquely biased views?  Cynically deceptive manipulation of facts?  So what.  Nancy’s going after the bad guys, and she don’t need no stinkin’ facts to tell her who’s guilty. 

In the interest of full disclosure, I’ve spent many a happy hour waiting in the green room (or on the cold street in front of a courthouse) doing the stand-up expert thing.  In fact, we used to mess with some of the anchors (like Ashleigh Banfield when she was over at MSNBC in Secaucus, New Jersey, before she put on her glasses to look more serious) when we did 6 hours bits of debate before they changed the format.  They would have a defense lawyer and former prosecutor to create a debate-type set up.  Sometimes, it would be so boring and obvious that we would switch sides without telling the anchors just for fun.  Six hours is a long time to spend in Secausus.

In my own defense, I refused to accept the anchors’ presumptive questioning when asked foolish, misleading or truly banal questions, and instead freely corrected or challenged the anchor.  This was particularly true when I was asked if I could “get inside the judge’s head.”  NO, I would exclaim, I’m a lawyer, not a psychic.  But I’d be happy to talk about what the judge’s ruling means to the defense.  I seriously tried to illuminate rather than fill empty air time.  But I was still there, talking as if one piece of evidence was the equivalent of a triple with a man on second.  So mea culpa.

There is so much that Court TV, and all the other networks and new magazines could do, to enhance the publics understanding of the criminal justice system while enjoying the free content that trials offer.  It could be fascinating.  At times titillating.  Even sensational enough to grab an audience by the throat and pull them in, while being accurate, informative and educational.  Most of these anchor types are lawyers, and had their share of time in the well sufficient to demonstrate a real knowledge of what’s happening.  It’s a shame that this opportunity is being squandered. 

Why Imus?

I avoided any comment on the Imus fiasco for the past week because it was so, well, tacky.  We all know what was said.  It is universally agreed that it was mind-bogglingly stupid.  What’s left to say?

Just one question:  Why?  So Imus popped off a shockingly inappropriate comment.  Certainly not the first time, but then again, this was blatantly racist and sexist from a former shock jock who now plays host to important public figures, and is supposed to know better.

But why care?  Obviously, he wasn’t referring to any meaningful assesment of any woman on the Rutgers basketball team.  While the young women responded that the characterization did not fit them, no one ever thought otherwise.  This really had nothing to do with them.  They were just the lunchmeat in the Imus sandwich, and it could just as easily been any other group that became the inadvertant subject of abject stupidity.  It had to do with Imus’ mouth, disengaged from his (or anyone else’s) brain.  So Imus is a jerk.  A moron.  An idiot.  So what?

Based upon Imus’ career, no one thinks Imus is really racist or sexist.  Stupid?  Sure.  But he’s done some good things too.  So much for fair and balanced.  But the real question is this dopey comment generated this much interest.  This is Imus, for god’s sake.  He’s a radio talk show host.  He is not a Washington decision maker.  He has never been elected to any position anywhere.  He is the conduit by which information is provided over the free airwaves to listeners.  It is the guests, the people who are important, that matter.  They have the power to make decisions that impact our lives.  Imus is the comic relief of his show, not the substance.

Granted, as the host of the program, Imus gets to exert a degree of influence over people’s thinking because his words reach so many, just like those other geniuses of the airwaves, Hannity and O’Reilly, whose random venom has allowed so many to believe that they are not alone in their hatred of any concept that requires more than 10 seconds of thought.  But even so, no one has ever thought, or believed, that Don Imus’ opinion on any subject matters.

To put this in perspective, take a look at the very important regulars who fill in the voids when Imus can’t get a real person to appear on his morning drive show.  Bo Dietl, a former NYC cop who can barely speak English and whose only topic of conversation is his own self-aggrandizing buffoonary?  If it wasn’t for his appearances on Imus, Bo would be hanging around the laundrymat hoping someone would toss him a quarter. Imus is not hanging around with movers and shakers, kids.

I fully support meaningful discussion on the subject of racism and sexism.  It matters.  But Don Imus doesn’t, and unfortunately we have allowed a real subject to be dictated by the half-baked comment of a radio host.  Who cares how this impacts on Imus.  Think instead how this impacts on the rest of us.  Let’s talk about how rap music lyrics have made the denigration of blacks and women fashionable.  Let’s talk about how suburban kids take comfort emulating the prison culture that has been glorified by celebrities.  But let’s not waste our time on Imus. 

Compensatory Damage

One of my blawging heros, Nicole Black of Sui Generis fame, does this Friday feature called the New York Minute (wisecracks about sibilant “esses” will not be tolerated!).  I look forward to Nicole’s videos with great anticipation, as she is always fascinating.

This week, however, I find that I must take strong issue with her.  Discussing the hot-button issue of judicial raises, Nicole has chosen to stand shoulder to shoulder with the black-robed wobblies, adding her support to their quest for the first raise in 8 years.  So far, I’m with her on the picket line.  Nicole notes the absurdity of judges being paid less than first year associates at BigLaw.  I’m at your side, waving the banner.  Nicole then tells of judges who are forced to leave the bench to earn enough money to provide a college education to their kids. 

HUH!  Nicole?  What happened to ya?  Did one o’ them Pinkertons bean ya on the noggin during the lockout?

Who put a gun to their heads and forced them on the bench:  “Adjudicate or I’ll shoot!”  They can’t afford public service?  Then go get a job.  That’s not the issue, and should never be the issue when it comes to assuming the bench.  What about senior trial attorneys in the various DAs or public defenders offices?  Are they driving around in Ferrarris?  Indigent defense under 18b went a generation without an increase, and now has finally risen to poverty levels.  Have you heard any judges crying about the plight of the 18b lawyers?  They have kids too.

The inability of some judges to make ends meet on a judges salary reflects a serious problem, but not a justification for raising salaries.  This problems relates to who is being chosen by political leaders for the bench.  If they have to worry about saving up some loot to send junior to Harvard, maybe it’s because they aren’t ripe for the job yet.  Maybe they should have spent some time working for a living before they ran for judge.  Maybe they should have worked in the trenches before becoming yer honor.

I reject the argument that judges need a raise because they can’t afford to live as they want while wearing the robes.  If they want to live like Willie Gary, they’re going to have to produce like Willie Gary.  It remains unseemly and inappropriate that judges are paid worse than first year BigLaw associates.  It remains inappropriate that legislators want to free-ride on judges to get an increase rather than withstand the heat of their own fiscal desires.  But it is not right for judges to complain that they can’t afford the life they want on the salary paid.  They knew what they were getting into when they chose to run for judge instead of going for the gold, and it is disingenuous to complain about it now. 

A Penny for your Thoughts

I’m all in favor of lawyers making a living.  Better lawyers should make a better living.  Great lawyers should make a great living.  But there is a point where it becomes absurd, and it looks like we’ve reached that point.  Courtesy of law.com, we hear of Broward County, Florida, attorney Willie Gary seeking $11,000 an hour. 

Some of you may remember ol’ Humble Willie, the lawyer with the flashy mansion,  Rolls Royces and private 747. Willie comes from the “if you got it, flaunt it” school of self-promotion.  Willie and I have sooo much in common.  I just choose not to be quite as showy.

Now Willie may be one of the nation’s top litigators.  He may be brilliant.  He may be the brightest shining star in the constellation of lawyers.  But asking for $11,000 an hour is just plain piggish.  My apologies to all my pig readers for the slur.

So why does this bother me?  Because it feeds the belief that lawyers are over-compensated sluts, and that litigation is just an excuse for lawyers to find a way to stuff their pockets at the expense of the public.  As with megasuits, and shareholder derivative actions and class-action suits, where the individuals who suffer receive pennies while the lawyers receive millions, the impression is that the legal system is out of control and serves no one’s interest but the lawyers.  This sense, which is pervasive, harms all of us and diminshes our professionalism in the eyes of the public.  It becomes the fodder for those bashers who want to take the bizarre case and make it appear to be the norm.

My feelings are not limited to lawyers, or doctors, or even corporate executives who parachute out of their failures with a few hundred million to keep them warm at night.  Some may say that you can’t blame people for preferring more money over less, but I can’t help but wonder how many millions are really necessary to fill that empty hole in their self-esteem?  Once you can afford the insurance on your Bugatti Veyron, don’t you have enough?

So in the interest of public service, I make an offer.  I will gladly take up arms on the retrial in place of Willie and promise to do an exceptional job.  And I’ll only charge $10,500 per hour.  Think of the savings!

Lessons from Duke

So the rape charges against three Duke students have been dropped and all is well in the world, right?  Well certainly, this is a vindication of our criminal justice system, having ultimately arrived at the right conclusion so that innocent young men are not sent to prison, right?  Okay, at least we can take comfort in the fact that these three student athletes can now emerge from the dark cloud to pursue their future unencumbered by false charges, right?

No.  Not right.  Not right at all.  Way down yonder in Chapel Hill, there are three young men, and their families, whose lives are forever changed.  No matter what they do now, they will never have their lives back as they were 396 days ago.  Their dreams for their futures are permanently altered.  Their families have spent untold sums to reach this conclusion, but it’s a conclusion that should have never been. 

Lesson Number 1:  The harm is done the moment they were arrested.  Nothing will ever change this fact, and there is absolutely nothing anyone can do about.  The notoriety is manifest.  These boys were attacked with a knee jerk ferocity that is only shocking in retrospect.  Of course their names will forever be connected with a rape, but more than that there will be people who will never be able to get it out of their heads that they did something wrong.  Perhaps not the rape as alleged, but something.  They are forever tainted.

Then, of course, there is the impact of this past year on the lives of ordinary and extraordinary kids.  What happened to their year of school?  What happened to their prespective of the world?  What happened to their efforts to establish a normal, productive and satisfying future?  Over the next week, I would expect to see them hounded by Oprah and GMA so they can be the tear-jerker du jour.  The media is relentless in pursing young meat, and human beings seem to be fundamentally weak when it comes to resisting a chance to be on TV. 

But expect these boys to be different.  They have had far more than their 15 minutes, and they have learned too well that it isn’t all it’s cracked up to be.  Once the glow wears off, one finds it to be an enormous burden fraught with innumerable burdens.  The media is not your friend, and given half a chance will elevate to a pedestal, then rip to shreds, anyone it can.  It makes for good TV.  I would imagine that these kids have already learned this lesson well, and will not fall into this trap.  But their lawyers were on TV early this morning.

Lesson Number 2:  People with 5 second attention spans must rush to judgment.  Let’s face facts, we are bombarded with information.  There’s no time to ponder and wait; we must decide this instant right or wrong, guilt or innocence.  The default position is that alleged rape victims, police and district attorneys are right, and accused rapists are wrong.  Ergo, the boys are guilty and we can now change the channel and watch Scooby Doo.  Had the media not followed up on this story because of its sensationalistic potential, these boys would have been forever guilty no matter what happened at trial. 

Lesson Number 3:  District Attorneys sit at the right hand of God.  They do God’s work.  Their only purpose in life is to pursue justice and protect us regular folk.  Or maybe they’re just people who can be good, bad or both on any given day.

Lesson Number 4:  All’s well that ends well.  So the white Duke lacrosse players will walk away from the false accusation of the rape of a black woman.  Change just about any word in that sentence and no one would have ever heard of this incident.  No media interviews of witnesses, who would then recant their stories.  No investigations into their backgrounds.  No network anchors pondering important questions like, “How did it feel to be the viciously raped by three athletic boys from wealthy and powerful families?” 

But, you say, these boys were vindicated!  Get over it!  Yeah.  It never happened to anybody except these three young men.  We cannot extrapolate from the myriad of systemic disasters that were exposed to public scrutiny that there are any other men or women sitting in prisons for the rest of their lives because some purported victim lied, some elected DA abused his power and some cop decided his time was better spent proving the guilt of the person he decided was guilty rather than investigating to find out who was guilty, or even whether a crime was committed.  Those things never happen.

So what grade do we get from this course? 

Media:  B (they did ferret out the recanted witness statements)
Boys:  A (they conducted themselves with exceptional dignity in the face of unbearable scrutiny)
Defense Lawyers:   A- (they were doing great until they succumbed to the allure of early morning TV and sounded only slightly less vapid than the victim)
Society:   D (these kids would have been lynched on day 1 if the Duke professors and administration knew how to tie a knot)
Nifong:  F (no explanation needed)

Bless the little children

In the New York Times, Bob Herbert writes of 6 year old Desre’e Watson, Florida’s newest li’l felon.  There are two options available when a young child throws a tantrum.  You can hold them in your arms, soothe them and show them that someone cares about whatever issues fill their world with anxiety.  Or you can cuff them and rationalize how society needs to be protected from 6 year olds.  One Florida school district chose the latter.  This seems to be an epidemic in Florida.

For a society that claims to have concern and compassion for its children, we seem to struggle when their issues manifest themselves in any way that suggests aggression.  What is striking about Herbert’s op-ed is how the police, through the facile use of rhetoric, take a relatively benign childish tantrum and turn it into a threat to the life and limb of a teacher.  During the course of the tantrum, the child pulled the hair (whether deliberately or not is unknown) of a school employees.  “At least one woman reported ‘some redness’.”  My heart bleeds.

The part of the tale that is most troubling is the description of the police placing the felon in custody.  The handcuffs were too large to put on her wrists.  She would just escape!  So, they had to cuff young Desre’e by her bicepts.  My god, they cuffed a 6 year old!  Did they fear she was a serial hair puller?  And they had the audacity to complain that the cuffs were too small?  That’s because no one should EVER cuff a 6 year old. 

Few stories should evoke the insanity of our times like this one.  Our compulsion for security, and knee-jerk reaction to any threat, no matter how trivial and reflective it may be of a child’s need to love and compassion, results in the sort of treatment that would spark protests in totalitarian regimes.  Yet here we are, enlightened America, cuffing 6 year old alleged hair pullers. 

Do you ever wonder how and why children grow up to have no respect for authority or the law?  You can spin this story any way you want, much as the very important Police Chief Frank Mercuio did in lauding is capture of this young threat to our way of life, but Desre’e Watson is still a 6 year old.  This conduct shames all of us.

DNA, A little dab will do ya!

The Second Circuit has answered the age old question, is it constitutional to collect DNA samples from non-violent probationers?  No, the answer is not dependent on which orifice is used for collection.  The answer, as quoted by Second Circuit Sentencing Blog, from United States v. Amerson , is

Taking and storing samples of DNA under the restrictions of the DNA Act fulfills many important governmental interests, only some of which are limited to the criminal history of the subjects of the DNA testing.  The invasion of privacy, both immediate, and long term, from DNA testing of convicted felons — even those convicted of non-violent crimes and sentenced only to probation — is, given the safeguards of the 2004 DNA Act, relatively small.  Accordingly we conclude that the 2004 DNA Act, as applied to appellants, does not constitute an unreasonable search or seizure and hence does not violate the Fourth Amendment. 

Fulfills many important governmental interests?  I gather this means that the court is weighing the “many governmental interests,” so important that they need not be named, against that petty little individual freedom called privacy.  Privacy, shmivacy.  What’s freedom when compared with many important governmental interests?  It’s not like it’s just important governmental interests.  It’s MANY important governmental interests. 

Seriously, DNA keeps rearing its ocassionally unattractive head as being the solution to society’s ills.  As noted in a previous post, it’s both a blessing and a curse, but notably it’s the silver bullet to government ID, both now and going forward.  So the next question is why?  Why does the government want to collect a teeny weeny bit of each of us, starting with the convicted and ending with the Pope?  Because it will impart secret knowledge that we cannot later avoid or ignore.  It will tell us who dunnit if we get enough uvit.

So the more erudite reader is now asking, “then why are you wasting our time writing this?”  Because I, and perhaps I alone, fear DNA.  The moment the letters are uttered, all thought stops abruptly and absolutism absolves us from any further responsibility.  If the DNA says Joe Smith killed her, then bygummit, Joe Smith killed her.  Let’s all go have a beer! 

Why does this bother me?  Because the foregoing sentencing was neither sarcasm nor hyperbole.  People love a magic bullet.  Fingerprints with 5 points was once the answer to all ID.  Until it was shown to be failure.  Today it’s DNA, though few understand or appreciate its potential flaws via collection, storage, comingling, degradation, and just plain crappy lab work.  Many lawyers and experts have harped for years over the flaws and failures of eyewitness identifications.  DNA is just the new kid on the block.  Everybody loves the new kid.  Even the Second Circuit.

Some Housekeeping Stuff

Having wandered off the continent for a brief period, I apologize to my friends for having provided no content in the last week.  Consider it time off for good behavior.

Further, I received a request today to teach a CLE on cross-examining eyewitnesses, always a thorny matter, on behalf of the NYSACDL.  The CLE will be given on May 18th at St. Francis College in Brooklyn Heights.  Contact the NYSACDL for more information.  It should be fun and worthwhile.