Having received the 32nd email from the State Bar Association asking for my help in supporting the increase in judicial salaries, it seems like a fine time to have a frank discussion. For most lawyers, this is a no-brainer. And indeed, there can be no rational person who disagrees with the notion that even judges deserve a salary increase once every 17 years. But…
There are some issues that need to be discussed. So let’s give it a go, shall we?
In the “pro” column, judicial salaries have stagnated for way over a decade because of political shenanigans: Legislators trying to tie their salaries to judges’ salaries so that they can enjoy the backdoor largesse while shifting the blame on the judiciary.
Also in the “pro” column, first year associates at “biglaw” are paid more than judges. This juxtaposition points out the absurdity of the current situation. First year associates, the legal equivalent of bell hops, are paid more than judges, our virtual King Solomon’s. Under the compensation theory of relative worth, this is a travesty.
But then, we have some issues. First, becoming a judge was once considered the crowning glory of a legal career. It was what one did after many years of experience, honed in the well of the court. A judge brought the accumulated experience of the lawyer, the appreciation of the plight of the common man, the astute recognition of the beauty of the law to serve society. A judge (picture Judge Wapner) possessed the understanding and temperament that can only come from a breadth of experience as an attorney that spanned the full spectrum of human interaction and experience. Sigh. Dontcha miss those days?
Today, the judiciary is a separate parallel career path. Youngsters are being appointed and elected to judgeships, often straight out of the District Attorney’s office, who have never had the experience of dealing with clients, understanding their needs and concerns, appreciating their misconceptions about the law and the process, suffering for the actions (or inactions) of judges. I’m not suggesting that they are not good judges, but they often lack any appreciation of how their decisions and conduct impact on attorneys and, more importantly, the human beings they swear to serve. Even the best of them have monumental gaps in their background that give rise to unintended misery for the very people who depend upon them most. This is a problem.
Further, should someone become a judge for the money? To serve in the judiciary was an honor. This was public service, something one could afford to do because one saved one’s pennies while practicing law and could now live off the accumulated wealth. It was never for the money. It should never be for the money (apologies to former Judge Garson).
Unfortunately, this changes when a young judge has young children who need braces, or college tuition bills are looming in the future. Or the dreaded “ice sculpture” nuptuals. Having always sucked up the public weal, and never having suffered the indignities of paying office rent, they lack the accumulated savings that enable a judge to serve in Plato’s Republic without any concern for personal needs. These judges need to make a buck. Why should they have to live like paupers, with only one black robe in their closets?
Of course, the answer is fairly clear. If they can’t afford to be judges, perhaps they would do better to work for a living in the halls of justice like the rest of us until they have accumulated the necessary wealth, not to mention experience, that would enable them to sit comfortably on the bench. There is no god-given right to sit on the bench AND make a decent living at the same time.
A large part of this problem stems from the fact that these youngsters serving the public as prosecutors (and sometimes legal aid lawyers) and law secretaries make for easy judicial fodder. They gain some decent political connections within the system, and enjoy the pristine life-style that many lawyers in the trenches can barely remember from the youth. They don’t bring all the ugly baggage that comes with practicing law with real clients who have real problems. They don’t leave behind a messy string of decisions where they represented people with whom they don’t necessarily agree or support.
So where is the proper tipping point for judicial salaries? What’s a judge worth to society? Clearly, more than a first year Biglaw associate. But not necessarily enough to support a young family. Perhaps if we took a big step back and looked at the people being appointed and elected to sit on the bench from a more functional perspective, we would find that this is less a matter of finances and more a matter of propriety. Higher paid, but still devoid of real world experience, will not give us a better judiciary. Just a more expensive one. Let’s pay judges a lot more, but lets make sure we have the right people sitting as judges. There will be time for these youngsters to earn their bones and then, and only then, sit high on the bench. And they will be better judges for it.
Author Archives: SHG
The Unloved Lawyer
This is a little off topic, but I couldn’t resist. Eric Turkowitz, of New York Personal Injury Law Blog fame, was picked up by some doctor blog because of his advice on dealing with good looking physician witnesses. Now I know Eric, and he’s one handsome devil himself, so you would think he hangs in the attractive professionals club with those nip and tuck guys and they would lay off their buddy. Not so.
Check out how the docs respond to Eric. Between refusing to treat lawyers who sue doctors, and using the pediatricians to poison the minds of their children, it would appear that our beloved physicians are displeased with lawyers. Frankly, I offer them (free of charge) the solution to all their legal woes. Stop killing your patients! Care a little more about whether you’re doing the right thing than whether medicaid will only pay $12 for the 30 second treatment so you have to back up 29 patients to make your Mercedes payment. Stop blaming lawyers because you keep killing your patients. We have enough of our own problems. Nuff said.
Seeing is Convicting
Brought to my attention by one of my favorite, and one of the finest, blawgs around, Sui Generis, is this slip opinion from the Court of Appeals in People v. LeGrand. The Court reversed the defendant’s murder conviction because the trial court precluded the defense from calling an expert witness to testify as to the reliability of eyewitness identification.
This is huge. Eyewitness IDs provide the deadliest of evidence against a defendant. Picture if you will the sobbing witness, pristine and pure in their honesty, being asked, “Do you see the person who murdered your father in this room?” The witness, looks up, tears in her eyes, and fixes her gaze on the one black person in the well, points her delicate finger toward the defense table and proclaims in a loud, clear voice: “I will NEVER forget that face. He murdered my father.” It is one of the most devasting moments in a trial. There is nothing, absolutely nothing, that has the impact of this moment.
But what if the witness is well-meaning, but wrong? We know from long experience and many, many studies that people misidentify the alleged perpetrators of crimes with alarming frequency. The witness often has a mere split second to observe, under unbearably stressful circumstances. Cross-racial identifications are, despite society’s wish to the contrary, particularly problematic and wrong. The initial ID is usually based on an article of clothing, and later the mind plays games to reach an absolutely firm conclusion that attaches a face to the clothing, which then becomes the witness’ reality. All in all, eyewitness identification is one of the worst possible pieces of evidence because it is so devastating and, often, so wrong.
Up to now, however, the defendant was precluded from calling a witness to testify to the jury about the frailties of eyewitness ID. Some courts precluded it on the basis that it was junk science. Others on the basis that it was argument, and the jury had no need for an expert to tell them what the attorney could argue in summation. These bases were, frankly, excuses for denying the defendant an opportunity to mount a real challenge to this dubious evidence. Eyewitness IDs were historically the lynchpin of prosecutions, and to allow an expert to explain to the jury why there were of such limited evidentiary value was to admit that 200+ years of convictions were based on flimsy evidence. This undermined the very fabric of criminal convictions, and diminished our respect for a process that took away the liberty, and sometimes the life, of human beings.
Will this fundamental change cause a seizmic shift in the balance of power at trial for criminal defendants? That has yet to be seen. Bear in mind that there will likely be a sudden appearance of “experts” in eyewitness IDs who become available to trial testimony despite their lack of credentials and credibility. This may well result in this important testimony being trivialized and becoming a hackneyed trap for the defense rather than its savior. But for the moment at least, a door has been opened to allow critical, and crucial, testimony to come before the jury. What we do with this opportunity has yet to be seen. We can only hope that it serves to bring greater integrity to the process, and doesn’t devolve into yet another marketing opportunity. Stay tuned.
What’s Good for the Goose…
As every criminal defense lawyer knows (only too well), deception by police is a “necessary law enforcement tactic” in the war on crime. We’ve heard this over and over, as police lie to people to get them to confess, to agree to commit crimes, to nail some poor miscreant’s butt to the wall. We’ve become so inured to the fact of law enforcement deceptive tactics that we don’t even blink when a defendant tells us the story of how he was manipulated into saying something that never happened. A travesty perhaps, but an everyday travesty that rarely rises to the level of being significant.
So what happened when a criminal defense lawyer uses a bit of slight of hand to gain access to the truth in order to level the playing field? Check out this AP story about the hoopla it caused. It really isn’t about the particulars of what the lawyer, a fellow named Stephen Hurley, did on behalf of his client. Or about the client, yet another in the long line of upstanding Americans accused of sexual misconduct with a young boy (I know, but as I’ve said before, there has been an explosion in child molestation/porn prosecutions courtesy of the internet).
What this IS about is whether the tactic of deception that is fundamental for one side is unethical and improper for the other. Why? If it gets to the truth of the matter, doesn’t that count for anything? More to the point, it’s a double standard that puts the defendant at a clear disadvantage in attempting to show that he is not guilty when the cops can lie and deceive and manipulate, all with the smiling approval of the court, but the defense lawyer is precluded from fighting fire with fire.
The whole thing “emits an unpleasant odor?” I think so. I never accepted the premise that police, our public servants sworn to uphold the law and the Constitution, must necessary climb into the gutter to seek out, if not create, criminals to arrest and prosecute. What is wrong with expecting our police to tell the truth? How did honesty and integrity on the part of law enforcement fall out of fashion? Once you’re on the slippery slope of deception for the greater good, a variant of “the ends justify the means,” the integrity of the system becomes secondary to the end result of getting the bad guy. This is a recipe for disaster.
Thus, it would be far better for society if our law enforcement and legal system encouraged truth and honesty and discouraged deceit and manipulation. But to limit this focus to the defense is insane. The answer is not the demand that the defense lawyer hold to a higher standard than the police, but just the opposite. All players in the system, from the cops to the judge, should be held to a standard of honesty and integrity in the performance of their duties that will give rise to renewed public faith in the criminal justice system, both as to the process as well as the result. Either we all live in the gutter or we expect better of everyone. What’s good for the goose is good for the gander. This is the discussion that Mr. Hurley’s conduct should have generated. Unfortunately, it did not.
Reversal Report #2
More interesting stuff from Judicial Reports excellent reversal roundup. This time, it’s about a 1993 Queens murder prosecution of Eric Jenkins, secured with the concealment of a cooperation deal with a critical prosecution witness. This is one of those systemic fiascos that makes one wonder what kind of joke the criminal justice system has become, more for the fact that almost 15 years later, it still hasn’t reached its conclusion.
But aside from the obvious castigation of the prosecutors for their deceit and misconduct in their zeal to convict, the report raises two nagging questions. Check out this statement by current appellate counsel:
“I’m obviously terribly disappointed, but it’s not over. We are going to appeal,” said Powell. “Unfortunately,” she added, the misconduct by Landa and Lendino in sweeping their deal with the witness under the rug was not preserved for appellate review, so that issue has been put to rest.”
Huh? How is this possible? Before the defense lawyers knew there was a concealed cooperation deal with a witness, obviously they could not raise the issue and thus preserve it. But after it became known, how could they not? Have they never heard of a post trial motion? Does their copy of the Criminal Procedure Law lack the page where section 440.10 is printed?
There may well be plenty of cause to go after the nefarious prosecutors, but what of the ineffective assistance of counsel? It’s not enough to point the finger at the prosecution for being evil. The next step is to look to the defense and ask, “so what did you do about it?”
And the other question? What the hell is going on at the Appellate Division, Second Department? Why should it be necessary to go to the United States District Court on a writ to get a little justice around there? Albany, are you listening?
Don’t Worrry, We’re Alone
Brought to my attention by Daniel Arshack, President of the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, is this astounding development reported by cnetnews.
The FBI appears to have begun using a novel form of electronic surveillance in criminal investigations: remotely activating a mobile phone’s microphone and using it to eavesdrop on nearby conversations.
How does this work? Beats me. Apparently, your cellphone is off, and yet susceptible to being remotely activated such that its microphone works and transmits whatever sound is within its range to our good buddies in the government. We have the technology, thanks to cellphone manufacturers who want to continually add functions designed to thrill any 12 year old to cellphones used by us, well, grownups. Just try getting a cellphone without all the bells and whistles that limit their function to, well, cellphones.
Consider this development in light of two others: First, under the Patriot Act, our good buddies in the government no longer need frivolous stuff like eavesdropping warrants. Their need to protect us far exceeds our need for privacy. And then there’s the shockingly forgotten detail that the government has been engaged in rampant abuse of this ill-conceived power. Inexplicably, this minor detail has gotten lost in all the news coverage of the firing of US Attorneys. Frankly, I’m surprised the FBI can’t take surrepticious pictures with the cellphones as well. We’ll get those techies working on that right away.
I’m Ready for my Close-up, Justice DeMille
Yet again, the issue of cameras in the courtroom is burning in the New York Legislature. It’s deja vu all over again, except this time the cameras are going to win. Make no mistake about it. Andy Warhol was absolutely right.
I don’t want cameras in my courtroom. I find trials as much of a bore to watch as the next guy, unless I’m the one trying the case. But having the experience of trying high profile cases, and realizing the impact the media has on the judge, the witnesses and the jury, I believe that cameras are a very good thing for those TV stations that feast off free content, but a very bad thing for justice.
No doubt that poor Florida judge who was castigated nationally for his show of emotion during the Anna Nicole Smith hearing will be used by both sides to demonstrate how compelling/evil television can be. But he’s not the point. The point is that media attention changes everyone in the courtroom, and everyone in the courtroom plays to the camera. There is no way that it can be unobtrusive. It’s there. We all know it, and nobody wants to look foolish on TV. Or admit they lied. Or make a ruling that laypeople will perceive to be wrong.
If there is anyone in the courtroom most likely to be changed, it will be the judge. Will a judge be inclined to make an unpopular but legally correct decision when the whole world is watching? And when ignorant commentators, meaning those media pundits who hold themselves out as experts on all things legal, start pandering to an angry mob about the horrible judge, with full video of the court’s egregious ruling, will the judge hold firm, secure in the knowledge that he or she will be well respected by that small group of inside folk who appreciate the bold gesture?
No, no, a thousand times no. It’s hard enough to get a fair trial. With cameras in the courtroom, we can kiss that possibilty good-bye. And what’s the downside for the media? They have to come up with their own content for 12 hours of Court TV? Bummer. Let’s pick justice first once in a while.
What Decisions Really Say
On behalf of a dear friend who wrote the brief, I argued a Murder appeal last month before the Appellate Division, Second Department. It was a tough case to argue, as the trial attorney had used a “scorched earth” defense that the defendant had committed no crime whatsoever. Given the evidence in the case, this was a major stretch.
This was a fairly notorious case, with a fairly high profile, about a murder for hire that had gone wrong, and the wrong person was killed. It was ugly. Ugly people involved, doing ugly things for ugly reasons. It was the kind of case that made you want to shower afterwards. But there was one solid theory to pursue: The defendant had not intended that the hired gun (with whom she became lovers during the course of this scheme, just to make matters worse) murder her husband, but merely beat him into submission. Had I tried the case, I would have given up the assault to beat the murder. Alas, the trial attorney did not, and the defendant went down on Murder 1 and 2.
But I’m not writing this to castigate the theory of the defense. In fact, I’m willing to bet that the defendant and her family demanded that he concede nothing, leaving him no choice but to go for broke. I’m writing this to comment on the decision. It reflects a very sad and difficult trend in the Second Department in particular, and courts in general.
The affirming decision was one page. It was generic. It was utterly routine. The fact that it was an affirmance was no shock. This was a tough case. What was a shock that in a case of such high profile, with a person spending the rest of their life in prison, the court could not find it in their collective hearts to write a serious decision. What happened to specifically addressing the argument with a minimum level of detail to show that the court actually took the case seriously? In fact, one line, stating that the trial attorney had failed to preserve an objection to hearsay evidence, was simply wrong. He objected. He jumped up and down. He objected again. And yet the decision says it wasn’t preserved.
In trying to decipher this decision, it says to me that the appellant raised some very disturbing points. Too disturbing, perhaps, to be easily dismissed in a real, thoughtful decision. And the honorable court had no intention of reversing the conviction in a case of this magnitude. So they punted, with a brief, cursory decision that dismissed the arguments in an off-hand fashion that was designed to trivialize the appeal and foreclose further discussion or review. In this regard, the decision was quite successful, using the time honored language of “meritless” to ignore what they preferred not to address.
The thrust of the appellant’s position was that the evidence of assault was overwhelming, but the evidence of intent to commit murder was non-existent. What did the decision say? The evidence of guilt of murder was overwhelming. It was many things, but overwhelming it was not. Thus, with judicial slight of hand, the argument disappeared into thin air.
As I said, affirmance did not surprise me. It’s the lack of intellectual honesty that makes the practice of criminal defense law so hard to explain. Whether it is best described as a lack of respect, or simply taking the easy way out, it is unacceptable that courts are so cavalier with people’s lives. I found the decision deeply disturbing. My dear friend, who wrote the brief, was crushed. Not because he lost, but because his efforts were deemed unworthy of being taken seriously. And then, of course, there’s the woman who will spend the rest of her life in prison.
Even Lawyers Have Their Moments
Allow me this indulgence. On Friday, I hear from an ABC TV reporter about the Sean Bell indictments. It seems that the Queens courthouse is abuzz with news that the Grand Jury returned indictments against 3 of the 5 police officers involved in the killing of Sean Bell, but no word on what charges were voted.
The reporter is left to speculate on the grand jury action, what it means and what the 3 officers are facing, and my job (if I decide to accept it) is to divine an answer that will accurately predict the future. So, I repond that I bet they are indicted for Manslaughter 2 and Reckless Endangerment 1, a “C” and “D” felony in NY, with top sentences of 5-15 and 2a-7. A few hours later, I hear back from the reporter that the word is out. I nailed it.
“So how’d you do it?” he asks. Easy. They’re cops. We give them every benefit of the doubt, as does the DAs office. We look for explanations, rationalizations, excuses. Gestalt kicks in and even without a defense presentation, the grand jurors feel compelled to view the outcome in the light most favorable to the police.
To be fair, it would be unreasonable for the grand jury to assume malevolent intent by the cops. It’s not like they had some personal beef with Sean Bell, or that they were out on the street that night itching to shoot and kill some poor mutt. But could this have just as easily been Murder 2 under a depraved indifference theory? Let’s be frank, if it was anyone but a cop who had killed Sean Bell, you could bet the farm that the charge would have been Murder 2.
So why is it different when it’s a cop? Society gives them a gun and shield, and we expect them to be used. Is this too much to expect of any human being, or is this the job and they are responsible for performing it without killing innocent people in the process?
Learned Hand Was Wrong
The Second Circuit Court of Appeals, in McKithen v. Brown (opinion by Judge Calabresi), addresses the best/worst thing to happen to criminal defendants since the advent of the jury: DNA. This can free the innocent man, or convict the guilty, and puts a quick end to the tedium of reasonable doubt.
The question before the court, when one removes the procedural legalisms of the Rooker-Feldman doctrine, was the extent to the United States Constitution gives a convict the right to post-conviction DNA testing to prove his onnocence. Frank McKithen has lost in the New York State courts, and sought to vindicate his right in federal courts by way of a writ of habeas corpus. The Circuit, in an extraordinary decision, remanded the case to Eastern District Judge John Gleeson (who’s worthy of a discussion given the exceptional fortitude and intellectual integrity he has shown as a judge) to decide.
First, a brief interlude. The opening sentence of Judge Calabresi’s decision is really worth reading.
“Eighty-four years ago, Judge Learned Hand observed that ‘[o]ur procedure has been always haunted by the ghost of the innocent man convicted,’ but posited, optimistically, that ‘[i]t is an unreal dream.’ United States v. Garrison, 291 F. 646, 649 (S.D.N.Y. 1923). Today, with the advance of forensic DNA technology, our desire to join Learned Hand’s optimism has given way to the reality of wrongful convictions — a reality which challenges us to reaffirm our commitment to the principle that the innocent should be freed.”
Now, go back and read that opening again. I’ll wait.
There has been a horrific trend in the federal courts to disavow any interest in actual innocence in favor of the stability of a system that functions quite efficiently, though not always effectively. In other words, they don’t care about no stinkin’ innocence. Keep them defendants moving. To this end, the right of habeas corpus, notoriously suspended by President Lincoln during the Civil War, has been quietly curtailed to make sure that convicted defendants stay convicted, no matter whether they are guilty or innocent.
Then suddenly, out of nowhere, Judge Calabresi reminds of why we have a criminal justice system in the first place. To distinguish the innocent from the guilty. To curb the police power of the state from just tossing people in jail whenever they feel like it. Innocence matters! This is huge. INNOCENCE MATTERS!
For those defendants with a DNA element to their cases, this could wreak havoc on the sacred cow of the jury system. The efficacy of such ridiculously poor methods of proof, like eyewitness identification, are shown for the travesty they really are. The tailored testimony of cops, hellbent on lying about the guilty, exposed for all to see. Hah!
So here’s the next problem. If DNA has proven Learned Hand’s naive support of the adequacy of the criminal justice system to protect the innocent from conviction to be vapid and wrong, what happens to all those men and women who are convicted in cases where DNA evidence is unavailable or plays no role?
If the system is wrong, and wrong a lot, when there is DNA to be had, how can we ignore the fact that the same proof that failed in the DNA case, like eyewitness ID, is suddenly irrefutable in the non-DNA case? If 28% of death row inmates with DNA evidence available are ultimately proven to be innocent, would it not be reasonable to assume that 28% of all defendants are in fact wrongfully convicted?
Why do we ignore the logic of this dilemma? Because if we faced the harsh reality that our system is rife with flaws, we could not sleep at night. Like children, we believe that the system works because we need to believe.
A good buddy (and astute philosopher) of mine from my morning commute to Manhattan has explained this to me in very simple terms. He says, “It’s fine to sacrifice a few innocent people to make sure I’m safe at night, as long as it’s someone else doing the sacrificing.” That about covers it.
