Author Archives: SHG

Keep Your Distance

Turley posted about Chicago lawyer, Nathan Billmaier, who got himself into one heck of a jam. 

Billmaier was convicted of six such incidents. He was arrested with nine flattened tinfoil packages that contained 4 ounces of marijuana, 4 ounces of contraband tobacco, 6 Ecstasy tablets and 40 matches.

The girlfriend of prisoner Donald Jordan (who is in for murder, parole violation, and prison contraband) put together the packages for Billmaier who was given $500-$700 per delivery. He made only $3,600 in return for destroying his career and his life.

The two initial reactions to this story, that Billmaier is a moron and that he sold his life cheap, are no doubt true but likely miss the point.  I’ve known some lawyers over the years who have made the mistake Billmaier made, and they were neither morons nor cheap.  Rather, they made a fundamental error in the management of their relationship with their clients, which ultimately led to similar fates.

In criminal defense, the best and primary source of business is current and former clients.  Whether inside or out, a client who likes you refers business to you.  Contrary to what most people mistakenly assume, the best source of business referrals are criminals.  They know other criminals.  When a criminal gets arrested, they turn to other criminals for advice.  Who knows better than a criminal who to turn to when the going gets tough?  Non-criminals have many virtues, but knowing who the most effective criminal defense lawyers are is not amongst them.  We tend to deal with a specialized crowd.

Because of this, currying favor amongst criminals has long been a method used by criminal defense lawyers to gain their love.  It’s not because they like crime or criminals, but just business.  Keep the criminals happy and they send you business, and business means your kids eat for another day.

But as we all know, there are lines that lawyer never crosses in his quest to please his clients.  Represent them hard.  Treat them well.  Give them everything you’ve got.  But do not aid them in the things they do that are illegal.  Do not confuse your role as their lawyer with their role as the criminal. 

One would think this obvious, and the line clearly drawn.  And indeed it is, most of the time.  There are instances where the line gets fuzzy, but as a lawyer we must know better than to tread anywhere close to the line of engaging in criminal conduct.  The problem for some lawyers is that the pressure to go just one step too far is irresistible. 

Taking that extra step has two components: First, the pressure from the client for the lawyer, if he wants to maintain the client’s devotion, can be very strong.  Bear in mind that the client couldn’t care less about the lawyer’s legal and ethical duties, as they aren’t his problem at all.  And the client, who is a criminal, has little concern for the fact that he’s asking his lawyer to engage in criminal conduct.  After all, he does it, so what’s the big deal about the lawyer doing it?  It doesn’t bother the client at all.

Second, many clients are exceptionally good at being manipulative, and play upon the lawyer’s pride.  They inflate his ego by saying things like, “Hey, you can get away with it. You da lawyer, You know how to pull stuff like this off, no problem.”  Rather than admit to the client whose devotion the lawyer seeks to attract or maintain, the lawyer convinces himself that he can get away with it, that he is smarter than the average bear and can pull it off. 

Suddenly, the lawyer forgets about the line between right and wrong, and which side he’s supposed to be on, and thinks that he can make the client love forever him by performing a criminal act, and that there is no risk in doing so.  The lawyer may not be comfortable, and may even regret his agreement to do the deed mere moments after the client or the wife walks out of his office, but lacks the nerve to change his mind and say no.  The lawyer moves forward.  The lawyer ends up like Billmaier.

The simple solution to this problem is, just don’t do it.  You are a lawyer.  The client is the criminal.  You are not the criminal, and becoming a criminal to please the client is just completely wrong and misguided.  Aside from the fact that you are doing something illegal, the idea that you will win the client’s undying devotion reflects a misunderstanding of what the client really wants from you.  Defendants want a lawyer they respect more than they want a lawyer they can manipulate.  Defendants want a lawyer who flexes his mojo in court, not one who will join the criminal club to become one of the gang. 

And as Nathan Billmaier would likely tell you, just because we’re lawyers doesn’t mean we’re smart enough to get away with it.  If the idea that you should become embroiled in criminal conduct to please a client isn’t put to rest because it’s illegal and wrong, then bear in mind that people who do so get busted and convicted.  Even lawyers. 

After 25 years, I assure you that clients will respect you, admire you and refer their friends to you, if you provide excellent representation and service.  Never, but never, believe that you need to cross the line between lawyer and criminal to have a successful practice. 

Computer Law Arrives by Pony Express

The cutting edge of search and seizure law, computers and cyberspace, is a subject of great interest, particularly since the trailing edge is so darn depressing.  Orin Kerr had recently published a  series of posts arguing that the law should be “technology neutral” in its approach to the digital world,  As I’ve since learned, this is similar to the view espoused by 7th Circuit Judge Frank Easterbrook in his 1996 law review article,  Cyberspace and The Law of the Horse.

In another post on the collateral issue of computer data, Orin did something rarely seen in academia.  He conceded that he was wrong.  In a 2005 article in the Harvard Law Review, he reluctantly argued that the computer data could not, by definition, be the subject of a seizure unless it happened to come along with the whole computer. 


[T]his essay offers a correction of some of my prior work. In a 2005 article published in the Harvard Law Review, I concluded somewhat uncomfortably that copying should never be considered a Fourth Amendment seizure. At the time, I was influenced by the cases holding that photographing and writing down numbers were not a seizure, as well as by what seemed to be considerable practical problems with calling all copying a seizure. I now see I was wrong.

I remember the last time I was wrong in an article of mine for the Harvard Law Review.  Oh wait. I’ve never had an article in the Harvard Law Review.  I guess that means I was never wrong there, which is why Orin’s thoughts on the subject are so much more worthy of discussion than mine.

When I read Orin’s latest iteration of computer data seizure, from whence the above quote comes, I found myself so myopic that I could not grasp the problem.  What “considerable practical problems” could he possibly be talking about?  I couldn’t even begin to imagine what so troubled him that he was constrained to conclude the exact opposite of what was painfully obvious to me.  Fortunately, Orin was willing to connect the dots for me.

Pointing to pages 560-2 (and thus saving me the pain joy of reading the entire HLR article, I came to appreciate the issue.  It’s hardly complicated at all, but rather evinces a somewhat slavish literalism:  In “seizing” computer data, law enforcement doesn’t usually take physical custody of the hard drive, but rather makes a mirror image of the content for later perusal and reflection.  In other words, there is no literal seizure of a physical thing.  Just as taking a photograph (or capturing an image) cannot be a seizure, Orin analogized the imaging of data to fall outside the 4th Amendment sphere.

Judge Easterbrook’s explanation was that law, hopefully overarching, was conceptually sound enough to accommodate technological change, which in any event moved too fast to keep up with in any event.  Orin, however, realized that this issue outran the horse.


What does it mean to “seize” computer data for Fourth Amendment purposes? Does copying data amount to a seizure, and if so, when? This essay argues that copying data “seizes” it under the Fourth Amendment when copying occurs without human observation and interrupts the course of its possession or transmission. It offers this position by reaching back to the general purposes of regulating seizures in Fourth Amendment law and then applying that function to the new environment of computers.

While the precise parameters of Orin’s reasoning won’t be known until the Yale Law Review, where it will be published since Harvard Law Review contains so many erroneous articles, comes out, I’m going to take a leap of faith and speculate as to what turned Orin around.

The 4th Amendment was designed to protect the privacy of the individual from the intrusion of the government, so that we need not fear that they could look under our covers at will.  The fact that technology has eliminated the need to grab us, our covers and whatever else the government could get its hands on, from actual physical seizure doesn’t obviate the purpose of protecting our privacy, but alters merely the literal means required to do so.  While literalists demand slavish adherence to 18th Century understanding of the world, this one transcends the problem of physical seizure.

What makes computer data, and cyberspace if I can be so bold as to extend the argument, is that it is more akin to our diary than anything open to others to observe.  Within the four walls of our computers, we keep our thoughts, our images, and a deep view of the full panoply of interests that occupy that dark, dank place we call our mind.  Sometimes we send a tiny bit of its contents to other people, and sometimes we reveal a tiny bit to everyone, but rarely do we open it all up for others to see.  The data on our hard drive is our sanctum sanctorum, and to the extent we share its contents, it’s our choice.  If there is any analogy to be adequately made, it’s like talking to a friend and revealing only so much of our personal lives as we want them to know.  No matter how much we tell, there’s always something held back.  It’s ours alone, and no one can peer into our mind to learn it.

But they can peer into our computer and see whatever secrets we’ve hidden there.  Mind you, they may not have the slightest clue why we’ve chosen to force bits of data to reside on our secret drive, and may well draw ridiculously wrong conclusions from finding it and misapprehending (or conveniently apprehending, as the case may be) our purposes.  But that’s true of most everything that comes into the clutches of law enforcement.

None of this, of course, should be attributed to Orin Kerr.  I’m just making this stuff up as I go along, and I haven’t even used the word “normative” once, meaning that my views are clearly colored by my trench lawyer 4th Amendment bias.  Still, it’s important that criminal defense lawyers both recognize and do whatever they can to influence scholars in this cutting edge area for two very real reasons. 

First, chances are much better that Orin Kerr, his brethren or his acolytes will be getting sized for a black robe with velvet stripes long before me (or you), making his thoughts on the subject a lot more real than ours.

Second, even if Orin is never shown big bench love, he gets to have his thoughts published in journals bearing Ivy League names, while I only get to post on this stinky blawg because I know the password.  He’s influential.  I’m, at best, prolific.

And as we move deeper into the 21st Century and beyond, the application of our beloved Constitution to realms wholly unforeseen by our forefathers will mean the difference between constitutional vitality and cyber-erosion of freedom.  The old gray mare just ain’t what she used to be.

Learning, One Blog At A Time

Via Walter Olson at Overlawyered, I saw this blurb about Coyote Blog, started to talk life in a small business, posting about police misconduct.  Two matters out of Spokane made the list, one via a blog called dispatches from TJICistan (who lists his favorite book as Heinlein’s The Moon is a Harsh Mistress, TANSTAAFL, brother) and photojournalist Carlos Miller’s Photography is not a Crime.  Carlos gives a big tip of the hat to Packratt’s Injustice in Seattle, and most particularly his twitter feed on police misconduct.

It comes as no shock that criminal defense blawgs frequently raise and discuss issues of police misconduct, as well as its corollary, that criminal conduct perpetrated by police officers against outsiders is ignored, overlooked, treated as if it’s inconsequential or results in a disproportionate number of acquittals compared with the rest of the criminal defendant universe.  This is expected of us.  This is one part of our focus.

But the fact that blogs are popping up by people outside of our sphere, and posts are written by bloggers who have no connection to criminal law issues, creates a synergy that could probably exist in no other place than the blawgosphere.  Sure, the stories are reported in newspapers (as long as they exist), but they tend to be localized, isolated and so mixed with the supermarket advertisements as to suggest that it’s the product of the day. 

Imagine, a small business blogger so outraged by police misconduct that he’s moved to post about it.  So what if it doesn’t reflect the depth of the problem, or the intricacies of the issues.  It’s the fact that it’s noticed, repeated, spread around.  To readers of the usual suspect blogs, here and Bennett and Gideon and Tannebaum and Grits, this may offer nothing new.  In fact, some folks who email to tell us of some “outrage” become enraged that it may not make a post, unable to realize that while it may well be outrageous, it’s more of the same.  It can get tedious to post the same bodies day after day, with only the face different.  It’s not that it doesn’t matter or we don’t care, but there is just far too much of it to keep it front and center.

This is why the proliferation of stories, of interest, of epiphanies, outside the blawgosphere matters so much.  Each reflects a new person, and hopefully many new people, seeing with fresh eyes what’s happening in the world around them.  Even Eugene Volokh, who is as vested in the system as anyone can be, had some fun with the cops in his post, about “When Seconds Count, the Police Are Only Minutes Away.” 

Little by little, the facade that conceals a system badly gone astray comes to light to people who have supported it and believe in it.  They still need to get past the “isolated incident” frame of reference, but this is how it’s going to happen.  As the public becomes increasingly aware of the problems, the media and politicians will take notice.  As reports and speeches start to address the issues, perhaps even judges will start to consider their role in perpetuating the assumption that the cops are most likely to tell the truth, and thus default to cops win, defendants lose, whenever they are in doubt. 

Whenever I rail against the police culture of the Blue Wall of Silence, someone asks how we’re going to change it.  This is how.  Inch by inch, blog by blog, person by person.  It’s a long and painful process, and many will be the victims of police abuse, lies and beatings before we reach the point where equilibrium is reached.  But it behooves us, the criminal defense bar, to take note and support each of these efforts outside our sphere that contribute to a broader and fuller awareness of the reality we’ve long endured.

One blog at a time.  Keep it up.

Underdog Turns 3 Today

When I started Simple Justice, Jon Katz had already been blogging for almost a year.  He was bold and clear.  The strength of his belief in civil liberties was the hallmark of every post.  It was inspirational, if somewhat mystical, and Jon set the bar for those of us who came after him. 

Jon called his blawg Underdog,  It wasn’t a reference to the cartoon, but to where criminal defendants and their lawyers stood in the hierarchy of power in the legal system.  For a brief moment, Underdog disappeared from the title, but re-emerged quickly as Jon realized that it was the soul of his blawg. 

Always a daily read, and always enlightening, Underdog was a fixture in the practical blawgosphere.

Why do I blog? Through blogging , I keep a valuable diary that helps keep my written and oral pen sharpened, my self-awareness deepened, and my bully pulpit strong. Also, it can be more important to touch one person in the audience in a valuable way than for thousands to receive the message in a much less profound way. M y motivation for blogging goes far beyond having a web presence for our law firm, to a thirst to express critical and undiluted messages about justice, and to increase the number of people who will assert their rights with the police so as never to need our criminal defense services in the first place.. So many civil liberties need to be won and re-won worldwide. One of the most effective ways for a non-full-time writer or television/radio personality to get out the pro-civil liberties message is through blogging. 
Underdog turns three years old today.  Happy birthday, Underdog.  Thanks for all you’ve given the rest of us, Jon.

Paying Attention to Commercials

When I needed to book a flight to Dallas for the Summer National Fencing Championships, I used Expedia.com.  Today, I decided to check on the flights and found that they were substantially less expensive than what I booked, so I called up my dear friends at Expedia to ask about my refund.

No refund.  I was told that their policy was to price match 24 hours after booking.  After that, tough nuggies.  But I thought, I told the nice CSR, that they had some sort of price guarantee if the price went down.  Nope, I was informed.  That was some other website, not theirs. 

He was right.  I was wrong.  Nuts.  I knew I saw a commercial about it, and I could have sworn it was Expedia.

I used the wrong website. Had I used Orbitz, then I would have gotten a refund.  But not Expedia.  I asked my good buddy, the CSR, why Expedia wouldn’t do what the other guys did.  I can’t be sure, but I think he shrugged over the phone.  He had no answer, and it really wasn’t his job to have an answer.  He just explained the policies that somebody upstairs told him about, and he did a fine job of it.  I like him, but I still wasn’t happy that I was paying $350 more for the flight for 2 than I would have had I booked today.

It’s entirely my fault.  I used Expedia.  That won’t happen again.  I told my CSR friend as much.  I believe he rolled his eyes over the phone, but I can’t be sure.  Why would anybody use Expedia when the price are the same at Orbitz, and they will refund the difference when the price goes down?  And why would anybody make the same mistake twice?

And by the way, for all my friends in the Great Republic of Texas, I will be coming.  Please divert the attention of the police long enough that I can get away clean.

The Risk of Existing in Cyberspace

There have been numerous efforts, stories, suggestions and concerns posed over the past week alone about the preservation of reputation online.  Dan Solove wrote The Future of Reputation, a chilling book about it.  Teens who did the stupidest thing ever live with the consequences.  The CCR Symposium involved it.  A cyber-stalked lawyer is writing federal legislation to protect herself from it. Carolyn Elefant wrote about what to do about it.  And I received yet another request to delete a post that undermined a lawyer’s “carefully crafted online persona.”

To say that this is a matter of concern is an understatement.

As Dan Solove cautioned, we are not in control of our image on the internet.  Even if each of us is careful to a fault about what we post, what we reveal, the battles we pick, how we behave, we are not in control of what others post about us on the internet.  Over time, the chances are good that anyone with any connection to life online will find someone who disagrees with them, thinks ill of them, even posts misinformation about them.  There will be negative, unpleasant things to be found on the internet.

This should be distinguished from posting hard threats of harm, or malicious lies, which takes us into a different realm of concern.  As was contended in the CCR Symposium, the veil of anonymity disinhibits otherwise normal people from doing some very venal things online.  Of course, the likelihood that it will translate into real world action is small, as the veil is then lifted and the conduct subject to the same proscriptions are all other venal conduct. 

One pervasive question is where the line is drawn between acceptable and unacceptable comment.  This gets very difficult, since each of us has a line of our own and believes that our line is correct and others are absurdly wrong.  Our ideas of propriety differ, as does our sense of humor,  Some of us are tougher than others, and some are very sensitive.  Some are easily offended and others have thick skins.  Many have worked hard to craft a marketing image about themselves, and can’t stand anything that might impair their financial gain.

When Carolyn wrote about dealing with online negatives, I questioned her advice.  Not so much because it was per se wrong, or not methodologically viable, but because is assumed that negatives were unfair or wrong, and that there was a presumption that every lawyer should know how to shed their online personas of negative comments.  This struck me as equally problematic, since there are many lawyers who post things that are wrong, improper, questionable and sometimes even unethical, in their quest for self-promotion.  Should they be immune from challenge because they are lawyers obsessed with marketing themselves?  They think so.

If we put our ideas out there in cyberspace, regardless of reason, we need to accept the fact that not everyone will think as highly of our thoughts as we do.  We invite criticism, and some of it may be harsher than we would like.  We are not entitled to a pleasant internet.  We are not entitled to be like, respected and admired.  We take our chances.  Nobody forced us to jump in, and when we do, we need to be tough enough to take the heat.

While many promote the idea that the blawgosphere, for example, presents a grand opportunity to present a desirable persona to the world, they neglect to mention that there is a downside to exposure.  When the criticism comes, cyberdenizens get upset.  Some characterize this as attacks, which is one of the grave failings of Citron’s CCR claims.  There are true attacks, but this isn’t them.  This is the belief that people get to post what they want without threat of negative peer review.  The internet is not a free ride.

Given the extent of my thoughts that appear in the posts on Simple Justice and elsewhere, I believe that I can speak with some authority on this subject.  I’ve been criticized many times by people who disagree with what I’ve said, both here and elsewhere.  I’ve received threatening emails and comments.  I’ve been called names, sometimes by jerks and sometimes by law professors.  I’ve seen my work stolen by unwanted mercenaries and friends who didn’t think I would mind.  I’ve had my very own nutjob cyber-stalker.  And none of it has thrown me off my game.

When I decided to start posting my writings here, I understood that it was out there in a world over which I have no control.  I put it out there.  I’ve got no cause to complain.  If someone throws a punch at me that I believe to be unwarranted, I punch back. 

No one did any of this to me because of my race, sex, age, skin color, national origin or religion.  And since I provide virtually unfettered access to my background, they are all on display for anyone who cares to find.  I didn’t find it fun to be harassed or attacked, but I never lost sleep because of it.  No anonymous attacker ever showed up at my door with an ax.  Every morning, I sit back down at my computer and write whatever pops into my head, as if yesterday’s unpleasantness never happened.  In a very real sense, it never did. 

Many argue that my views trivialize “the very real harm” that others suffer.  Perhaps they do, as I have no doubt that some have had a knock on their door by some ax-wielding psychopath.  But we can’t craft out world around that most oddball fears coming to fruition, not to mention we already have legal mechanisms in place to deal with ax murderers.

Short of that, it’s all words and letters and ideas, floating in the mist.  So what?  If you want a guarantee that no one will ever disagree with you, dislike you, say mean things about you, this isn’t the place to be.  There is no guarantee.  And contrary to those who promote a Utopian view of a “safe haven” online, where one can enjoy all the positives and benefits without fear of negatives, I cannot agree.  The price of having a public place to air our ideas is disagreement. 

I have never been a fan of anonymous posting, though I understand why some prefer it and that good reasons exist to protect those who would suffer real life retaliation for it.  Bennett calls nasty anonymous commenter’s the car-k eyers of the internet.  They are easily ignored, if you chose to do so.  If you chose to take them to heart, then you empower them to hurt your feelings.  I posted a question on a website recently and received some idiotic and nasty replies.  I didn’t cower in the corner, feelings hurt and afraid of the attacks.  I clicked on the little “x” in the corner and they magically disappeared.  What happened after that is of absolutely no consequence to me.  Don’t tell me it isn’t that simple. It is exactly that simple.

Note that this does not extend to real life attacks and harms that begin online but manifest in reality.  Note that this does not apply to children, who act without thought of consequences.  Note that this does not apply to people who are engrafted into the cyberworld without their knowledge, consent or involvement. 

But for the rest of us, as competent adults who are fully capable of real
izing that we have made a decision to be part of the cyberworld, blawgosphere, whatever, for fun or profit, there will be no assurance that everyone who comes across us will love and admire us.  We can and will invite critics to take their best shot at us.  If this upsets you to the point that you demand criminalization, the end of anonymity, legislation and compensation, then you have no business being here. 

Frank Pasquale asked:


Is cyberspace a “wild west“? Should “anything go” online? Are statements and behavior sharply distinguishable? Are the former “only words” that change the world through the unforced force of persuasion, and the latter the kind of action we rightfully fear and regulate?

We could do far worse, if we let each interest group impose its will and delicate sensibilities on the rest of us, no matter how highly they think of their own value judgments.  When the desperados rode into town to make trouble, the townspeople formed a posse to go after them.  It wasn’t easy, and it had some risks.  But we survived.

Maybe the day will come when a guy with an ax appears at my door and changes my view of thing, but for now, I’ll keeping writing whatever I please and anyone else in the blawgosphere (or anywhere else in cyberspace) can write what they please, even if it is something nasty and false about me.  Just remember, I punch back.

The Wake of a Wake

Long time readers (do I have any of those?) will recall this post about a bunch of kids in Bushwick, Brooklyn, going to the wake of a friend.


Wearing white t-shirts with a picture of the deceased teen and the letters RIP on them, a group went to pay respect.  On the way, the cops swooped down on them.  They were hauled away to the 83 Precinct, searched and held.  It’s not entirely clear why, except “unlawful assembly” was mentioned.  The kids didn’t know what that was (a separate indictment of the NYC school system).

Bob Herbert wondered why things like this only seem to happen to black kids in Bushwick. I explained that it was because nice white suburban parents would never allow this to happen to our kids.


This is a big mountain to climb, and those of us who live in the cushy, protected and (dare I say it) white neighborhoods pretend not to see it or, more likely, just ignore it because it isn’t our fight.  It’s not our kids being hassled.  They better not do that to our kids.  If they do…Well, they’re gonna have to deal with me!  But they’re not our kids.  They are the children of the powerless, the uneducated, the poor.  And they have no champion to protect them.

In the two years that elapsed, there was one guy who decided that he could be bothered with a bunch of black kids from Bushwick, and as first reported by Eric Turkewitz at New York Personal Injury law, a settlement has been reached for 16 of the youths.


According to Michael Scolnick, a civil rights attorney that represented 16 settling plaintiffs, an agreement was reached recently in federal court to dispose of those cases. The settlements ranged from $9,000 to $20,000. Scolnick said:


The settlement was on two levels: the 6 boys and girls (under 16 years of age) who either were not charged or were given desk appearance tickets and later dismissed without appearing, but were in custody from two to six hours, cuffed to a pipe or a Snapple machine, each settled for $9,000. The older ones who had formal charges issued against them for unlawful assembly and disorderly conduct settled for $20K.

Whether these are the right numbers for the frivolous, baseless, obviously racist arrests of black kids on their way to a wake, I can’t say.  Frankly, it seems to be a little light if we want to make the city think twice before allowing its cops to engage in mass arrests to show how that they are more powerful than a bunch of kids on their way to a wake.  But I can’t second guess based on my limited knowledge.

On the other hand, that these kids came out of it without rap sheets is something of a victory as well.  The cases against all the kids were thankfully dismissed.  The kids got at least something in return for being harassed, arrested and/or held in custody.  As for Michael Scolnick, who fought for 16 settling plaintiffs, the fee will likely be scarcely worth the time and effort required by the case.  But he did a good thing for some kids from Bushwick who needed someone who cared enough to help.

The Risky Number 5

When New York Governor David Paterson threw caution to the wind by his vigorous support of legislative approval of same-sex marriage, it caused a bit of a storm.  Was Paterson being bold?  Were the opponents being bold?  Or is this just about the stupidest waste of time anyone could imagine?  I vote for stupid.

The deal is done.  It’s been done for a while already, just as I predicted here. 

Across the country (and across New York), politicians will put on a show of opposition to appease the moral outrage of their constituents at this assault of their religion’s commandments.  After the rhetoric, New York will legalize gay marriage.  There’s no choice.  There was no possibility that a marriage recognized as such in one state could not be recognized in all.

Consider, what if a gay couple married in Vermont and moved to Kansas?  The implications of unsorting the bundle of rights would be beyond imagination.  What a disaster it would be, for everyone.  Who owned the car they drove there in?  Who was the mommy (daddy?) of the dog?  Don’t even ponder the bank account.  The scenario is just ridiculous.  Gay marriage is here, it queer, get used to it.

When the Iowa Supreme Court broke the middle America ice, the only thing it changed was the timing.  Rather than the slow crawl from right to left, Iowa embarrassed the dustbowl refugees who settled in California and votes in accordance with Mormon advertising.  Seriously, if the good people of Iowa can figure this out, just how long is it going to take before the rest come along?

So David Paterson, unelected leader of the cutting edge State of New York, has finally found a cause worthy of strong support.  A cause that’s a forgone conclusion.  While the upstate dairy farmers, courted by his rifle-toting replacement Senator, will mutter some vague complaints, the largest swathe of New Yorkers will applaud his strength, foresight and boldness.  New York has its fair share of gay citizens, you know.  And a bunch of social liberals as well.

So New York might be the 5th State of the Union to legalize gay marriage (if Nebraska doesn’t jump our bones while the Times is composing its favorable editorial).  Big deal.  It’s not bold.  It’s not cutting edge,  It’s not risky.  It’s a given.  Can we move on already, and let all our gay fellow-citizens learn about the joys of marriage that us heteros have endured for years? 

And if Paterson wants to do something bold, he’ll have to do better than being number 5, long after the deal is done.

I Swear, Officer, That Wasn’t My Twit

It really shouldn’t come as any surprise at all that twitter, the techno flavor of the day for those with a taste for brevity and collecting vast numbers of pointless followers, would eventually find itself on the police blotter. And it has.

From Techdirt,


[N]ow we’re seeing stories about some police departments that are actively using Twitter either to send out emergency alerts to people, or to better connect with the community they’re supposed to be protecting. Of course, that story worries about “impostors,” but there are ways to deal with that issue. For police looking to make use of the technology, it can be quite useful, and it’s great to see some actually realizing that and embracing the technology.

That’s how it starts.  Twitter is obviously a great delivery mechanism for bursts of information, provided that anyone is following.  It’s not merely a benign use of twitter, but a positive one.  Imagine that we all follow our local gendarmes to learn of emergencies in our area, like the tickers crossing the bottom of the TV screen.  It really is a great use.

But it won’t take long for the police to figure out that this form of communication, like all others, is a two way street.  Just as they can talk to us, it will dawn on someone that we are talking to each other.  By we, I mean persons of interest, targets, suspects and ordinary people who may be twitting about stuff that may be of interest to them. 

This is an invitation to entirely new forms of mischief.  How long before we have “secret followers,” with police intercepting twits of identified individuals in whom they have a particular interest?  What about general monitoring, with key words or algorithms that make a light go off on some spaceship-like panel in the bowels of some government building? 

And the nature of twitter, which has now gone from the refuge of middle-aged, balding, overweight men to more general acceptance, lends itself to far greater problems.  Because twits are a mere 140 characters, users tend to abbreviate, making their twits often appear somewhat coded.  Twitterers often send messages that make perfect sense to their intended recipients, but can hold very different meanings to others.  That twits seem to hold hidden meanings means that they are subject to facile post hoc interpretation.  Uh oh.

To any lawyer who has enjoyed leisurely reading the transcripts of intercepted telephone calls, including the parenthetical interpretation by special agents of what the parties “really” mean, the potential for misinterpretation of wholly innocent twits is obvious.  I remember once being caught on a wire, calling my mother from a client’s cellphone because it was her birthday and I had forgotten to call earlier (sorry, Mom), and reading a year later that the call was interpreted as a coded request for narcotics.  Once the judge scoffed at the interpretation, I laughed and laughed about it.  The other interpretations of conversations on the same phone weren’t nearly as funny.

Since twits are essentially a shout out to anyone who cares to follow, with the limited proviso that the reader isn’t blocked, it seems doubtful that there is any reasonable expectation of privacy involved.  Thus, twits are fair game for law enforcement.  They are a ripe source of information.  They are there for the picking.

It’s not that I’m trying to throw cold water on the thrill of twitting, the freedom and joy of expressing your every short thought whenever you want.  But when we twit we tend to forget that there are eyes and ears that may be following us more closely than others, and reading our more fascinating twits with an eye toward a purpose that may not be consistent with all the fun and joy of the twittersphere.  Just be keep it in mind.

Membership in the Club Denied

Marc John Randazza teaches law school.  He is an adjunct professor at Barry University Law School in Florida, and knows his stuff when it comes to First Amendment, Trademark, Copyright, Entertainment and Sports Law.  He believes in law students.  He believes in teaching them to become first rate lawyers.  And yet the other lawprofs won’t play with him.

Randazza was one of the original participants in the discussion about Danielle Citron’s Cyber Civil Rights, the online symposium that brought about some great, and some less than great, discussion on her controversial proposition that by turning cyberbullying into a sexist thing, it would justify suppression of free speech and anonymity.  Yet Randazza was excluded as a “symposiast”.  Worse still, when a crack developed in the closed circle of “open-source academics” and Randazza had a chance to get a word in, he was either ignored or berated by other lawprofs. 

When Paul Caron at TaxProf Blog listed the top 35 law professor blogs, Randazza’s very popular blog, The Legal Satyricon, which would certainly have deserved a spot based on its visitors and page views, was nowhere to be found. 

What has Marc John Randazza done to deserve this treatment?  He refused to behave like a good member of the club.

It all spilled over yesterday in his scathing attack on legal academia, The Worthlessness of American Legal Education.  Every sacred cow, every inside secret, all the things that lawprofs are supposed to hold dear, came under scrutiny.  And Randazza told it exactly as he saw it, no holds barred.  This is academic blasphemy. 

The issue is not with Randazza’s qualifications, or thoughts, or scholarship, as far as I can tell.  It’s that he says what he means. He says it clearly and in bold language.  He uses colloquialisms, and truth be told, epithets.  He curses like a drunken sailor, and if he thinks someone is a liar or a idiot, he calls them a liar or an idiot.  What he does not do is employ the multisyllabic, obfuscating jargon of the academy to maintain the level of decorum and collegiality demanded of members of the club.  For this, he is shunned by the rest of the law professors. 

It’s not that scholars are forbidden to disagree, but that there is a rigid manner imposed on the language of disagreement, where it must begin with a statement of positive affirmation and then, coupled with a tenuous claim of potential error, the weak assertion of a counterpoint framed in nonthreatening jargon is marginally included.  Much of the time, one is left clueless as to the points, both for and against, and where and why disagreement exists. 

Indeed, the framework often fails to leave the reader with the notion that there is any disagreement at all, but merely some extraordinarily minor variation on a theme, even when the positions are polar.  It gets that obtuse because no one wants to speak ill of someone else’s idea, no matter how wrong or absurd.  That’s how club members are supposed to treat each other.

As a result of my time in the blawgosphere, I’ve come to gain great respect for many lawprofs. Not all, but many.  Not many respect me, I’m afraid.  Most hate it when I tread on their turf, because I do so in a way that causes them vapors.  Like Randazza, I speak like a lawyer, using course, occasionally vulgar, often snarky and sometimes even brutish language.  My thoughts aren’t wrapped up in pretty paper and tied in a pristine white ribbon.  When I write in disagreement, they attack me.  Ironically, it’s about the only time they find it acceptable to use clear language, but then I’m not a member of the club, so I’m fair game. 

It may be that members of the club have delicate sensibilities, though it’s hard to imagine that they were so soft when they worked for the Department of Justice for that year or two before joining up.  It may be that wrapping themselves in the trappings of academia, a warm cocoon where they are protected from the animals who inhabit the trenches, has insulated them from the harsh world where lawyers scrape and fight with each for intellectual crumbs and dirty fees.  They can be unbearably thin-skinned about disagreement, feeling that it’s unfair and unduly harsh because we don’t used the veiled jargon of the Academy to conceal our real meaning. 

For example, one of my favorite quotes, when Dan Markel at PrawfsBlawg chastised me for using the phrase “circle jerk” to describe the internal goals of law review articles: impress their tenure committee.

The other day, I shared some of Jeff Lipshaw’s advice for beginning law professors. It triggered this  conniption from Scott Greenfield at Simple Justice. Apparently Greenfield was so blinded by rage  over the fact that law profs don’t always care about whether their scholarship had practical utility to practicing lawyers that he couldn’t even accurately read that the advice actually came largely from Jeff (instead of me). In any event, I’d be happy to take credit for Jeff’s pearls [and Scott has since tried to clarify it with an update].

To my mind, Greenfield’s rant is misdirected.  Putting aside the juvenile tone —  is a description of academia as a big “circle-jerk” really all that illuminating? — let me just make a few quick points on the merits.

The phrase “circle-jerk” was not merely a great descriptor, but one that has often been used to describe the insularity of lawprofs agreeing amongst themselves and within themselves.  That may make us (me?) juvenile, but it really is a great illuminator because to clearly conveys the point, something anathema to the members of the club.

These issues have reared their ugly head again with the CCR symposium comments, Straightforward criticism is called “abusive” and “harsh” because it can be easily identified as disagreement.  No one, but no one, openly says that another member of the club is wrong.  Well, actually one person, but that’s only because she is such a bully that she can say whatever pops into her head and anyone who challenges her is immediately labeled sexist and tossed from the wood-paneled clubhouse.  There is no greater crime.  All the other members cower in fear of her. 

The lawprofs really hate the fact that a trench lawyer like me writes about their world.  They send me emails asking, imploring, demanding that I lay off and stay away from them.  Some tell me that they agree with me, but that they could never openly admit it and beg me to keep their emails private.  I respect their requests, because I know that they have to live amongst their own.  But they consider what I do here to be a threat to the carefully crafted image they’ve developed, especially the ones who have yet to obtain tenure.  I can shoot nasty, brutish arrows at them, and they feel that they can do nothing to defend themselves without getting down in the mud with a trench lawyer like me. 

My self-references here are used merely as a courtesy to Randazza.  It’s better to make the point by self-example than to bring the lawprof, Randazza, into the mud, mostly because he doesn’t belong there.  Whereas law schools would never touch a lawyer like me, not just because I have experience in the things that their lawprofs teach, but because I might cause “conniptions” in their faculty meeting when I neglect to use the word “pedagogical” and cause tenured professors to faint.  If I taught, my students might learn how to be lawyers, but could I possibly produce the scholarship that distinguishes a member of the club from the pedestrian lawyer-trainer?

But as easily as the lawprofs can blow off a fellow like me, it’s much harder for them to explain and justify their rejection of Randazza from the secret society.  After all, he’s already got the job, though the tenure track sneers at the lowly adjunct.  But Randazza isn’t some legal research and writing cog, the typical throwaway post, but teaches real courses.  He just won’t play their game.

Neither Randazza nor I think ill of the many lawprofs who post their ideas and thoughts on legal subjects across the blawgosphere.  Indeed, I believe that we both have great respect for them, and I know I’ve learned a great deal from reading their many posts.  But this fear of scrutiny, hiding behind big words to obfuscate their point, and the compulsion to reject clarity because it’s too vulgar for their delicate sensibilities, diminishes their worth. 

It’s fine to ridicule me as a dumb trench lawyer, unworthy of your scholarly attention, but you can only stand on your pedestal if there are trench lawyers like me to look up to you.  It seemed for a while that we were getting past this scholar/lawyer dichotomy, but the CCR symposium made clear that the division remains as deep as ever.  Despite some hearty dissenters, the knives were as dull as ever, except when it came to Randazza.  Suddenly, the soft grew firm and clear.  Like magic.

Marc John Randazza is a lawprof.  He just sounds like one of us trench lawyers.  If you think he’s wrong, stand up to his ideas rather than dismiss him because of his word choice.  If you’re half the scholars you think you are, this shouldn’t be a problem.  Toughen up and deal with the challenge.  Like it or not, he’s one of you as far as the rest of us are concerned, and we can see quite clearly that you’re trying to keep him out of the club.  If you want our respect, let Randazza be a member.