Author Archives: SHG

Maybe Judges Are Paid Too Much?

Adam Liptak, whose output at the New York Times has dropped precipitously in recent months, probably as a result of the time require to polish up his resume, questions again the claim that Federal judges are underpaid.

“I couldn’t find any evidence to support his claim,” Scott Baker, a law professor at the University of North Carolina, said of the chief justice. Professor Baker published a study last year in the Boston University Law Review that considered whether society would be better off were judges paid more as a matter of labor economics.

Its conclusion: “Pretty much nothing would happen if Congress decided to raise judicial salaries.” Money appears to have almost no impact on the quantity and quality of the work judges produce, Professor Baker found, and lots of capable people are eager to take the jobs at the current salary.

It gets uglier from there:


A second study to be published in The Journal of Legal Analysis, a peer-reviewed publication at Harvard Law School, goes even further. Its title seems calculated to provoke the people who wear black robes at work: “Are Judges Overpaid?”

The problem begins, of course, with deciding on a metric to use to determine the question.


The professors collected data and analyzed it using the tools of economics. They measured things like productivity (number of published opinions), quality (how often other courts cite those opinions), speed (how quickly opinions are produced) and independence (how often judges disagree with colleagues with similar political views).

While such criteria fit well within the Church of Empirical Studies, they fail to address anything relevant to the work judges do.  The pay to quantity relationship is meaningless on its face, as judges aren’t support to produce more work for higher pay as if they worked the assembly line.  By employing such criteria, the studies appear facially pointless.

On the basic facts, there is little issue that judicial pay has decline in real terms:


Federal district judges make $169,300; federal appeals court judges, $179,500; Supreme Court justices, $208,100; and the chief justice, $217,400. There is no question that those salaries, which increased 2.5 percent last year, have dropped significantly in real terms in recent decades or that they represent a small fraction of what partners in big city law firms make.

This year, federal judges, alone among federal employees, did not even receive a cost-of-living adjustment.

However, that doesn’t preclude the argument that they were overpaid before and are not underpaid now.


On the other hand, being a judge is pretty sweet work and the job is in high demand. It comes with status, power, good working conditions, no clients, the ability to affect policy and the satisfaction of doing justice. Federal judges get very good health care, exceptionally generous pensions and the ultimate in job security — life tenure.

The fact remains that there is a large pool of well-qualified candidates for the federal judiciary, happy to take the job at its current rate of pay, which suggests that the salaries aren’t too low.  While Chief Justice Roberts claims that “38 judges left the federal bench from 2000 to 2005,” Judge Posner counters that “[o]nly 12 federal judges had resigned out of a total of 1,200 active and senior judges in the years in question, a small number in absolute terms and a smaller percentage than in the six years ending in 1974,” following a 30% salary increase in 1968.

The problem is exacerbated by the arguments frequently made in support of a judicial pay raise.  Chief Justice Roberts claimed that the problem ““has now reached the level of a constitutional crisis.” 


Many judges say the entire enterprise is absurd and insulting. “The country wants and deserves the strongest possible judiciary, and we should be willing to pay for that,” said David F. Levi, the dean of Duke Law School and a former federal judge. (He said he did not step down for financial reasons.)

By tying pay to quality and judicial independence, these arguments create the basis for their own failure.  While it’s no doubt hoped that cries of judicial suffering will resonate with the masses, it suggests that the public will suffer for wont of a judicial salary increase, when there is essentially no chance of that happening.  And demonstrating how out of touch the judiciary can be, crying over a $169,300 paycheck with great benefits really won’t evoke much sympathy from the single mom with 3 kids. 

Still, this fails to address the stagnancy of salaries, the decline of real income over the years, or the expectation of those who wear the robes to avoid having to beg at the legislative trough.  Liptak ultimately arrives at a curious calculus,


What is most interesting about the basic argument made for a judicial pay raise is that it appeals to a value that many judges resist in other contexts. It is an argument about fairness and respect. It is the sort of argument liberals make for raising the minimum wage or for laws that guarantee equal pay for equal work.

This certainly smacks of an opportunity.  So many federal judges land on the bench following a lifelong career with the government or a comfy corner office in Biglaw that they have no concept of what life is like for real people.  The same hard-hearted hanging judge is suddenly whining about the unfairness of it all when it’s his ox being gored.  It’s completely understandable given his peer group; Going from Gucci loafers to silken robes doesn’t lend itself to hearing the vox populus in ones sleep.

While the salaries of federal judges do not meld easily with economic theory, lacking easy empirical justification for an increase, I remain of the view that, at minimum, federal judges should not lose real earning power on their salaries, and in more concrete terms, should enjoy an increase in real terms over time, just as everyone else in the country wants. 

How much of an increase is a different matter, but one metric I’ve always believe appropriate is that they must be ahead of first year Biglaw associates.  To do otherwise is fundamentally demeaning to the role of the judiciary, from whom we expect slightly more than Biglaw does of its new kids. 

While judges should not, and I believe do not, take the job because it pays well, the oath of office is not an oath of poverty as well.  They have lives, wives and children, and are accomplished individuals for whom it is not unreasonable to expect a comfortable life.  They really shouldn’t have to brown-bag it to make ends meet, and as much as their salary seems pretty generous to most Americans, in the scheme of the upper-middle class, it’s really quite marginal. 

Still, it would be awfully nice if federal judges were able to realize this from some personal experience.  Maybe the metric that needs further development is how closely the federal judges can relate to the real people of this country, who struggle daily, makes mistake, try their best and hope that someday their children will be federal judges (and make a decent living with life tenure).

Silent Death in the Blawgosphere (Critical Update)

When a new blawg or legal website comes online, there’s often a bit of a splash.  Emails go out announcing its existence, perhaps even “requesting” a link exchange or at least a look-see.  A new link in a blogroll appears on technorati, albeit three date late and partially obscured.  Something to let us know it exists.

But death happens silently.

Yesterday, I received an email from Turk, asking what happened to Judicial Reports.  The URL was dead.  Gone. Disappeared.  As I’ve written some editorials for Judicial Reports, maybe I knew something about this gaping hole in the blawgosphere.  I didn’t.  It came as a shock to me as well.

I sent an email to Dirk Olin, honcho of Judicial Reports, to find out what happened.  He has a couple of email addresses, and I sent my query to both.  One came back undeliverable, a bad sign.  I have no yet received a response to the other, and I don’t know if I will.  My hope is that he’s started some new, great, monster project and I just don’t know about it yet.  But the fact that there’s no Judicial Reports page anymore, with some announcement of impending greatness, makes that seem unlikely.

In the nearly two years that Simple Justice has existed, I’ve seen a good number of blawgs come and go.  Some deserved to.  Others didn’t.  Some blawgers burn out quickly, when they realize that keeping this going isn’t nearly as easy as it looks.  They wake up one morning and just can’t bring themselves to write another post.  They unceremoniously shut the doors and disappear from view.

Some blawgers learn that all the hyperbolic claims of new media, networking, business development, all the marketing lingo that those who have hitched their financial wagon to the internet like to use to make inchoate blawgers believe that the next million dollar fee is right around the digital corner, are whisps of smoke. 

Judicial Reports was a business venture.  It had a paid staff to cover the New York courts.  As with all business ventures with paid employees, it had to earn sufficient revenues to maintain its existence.  I can only surmise that it did not do well enough to continue, absent any additional information that would change the equation. 

Does this foretell anything about the future of the blawgosphere?  Up to now, its “profitability” has largely proven to work far better for those marketing marketing than those who consume the marketers’ product.  But as the relative mix of supply and demand changes, as it invariably will, even the marketers will see diminishing returns.  Lawyers are invariably late to the new technology party, being stuck in our love of stare decisis, but we eventually figure it out.  The cheerleaders can keep us enthused for a while, but the money and effort put into the blawgosphere will do to us what it’s done to Judicial Reports.  Eventually, we will realize that the ROI isn’t there and move on.

What this means for the blawgosphere in the long run is unclear.  Perhaps it’s a fad that’s beginning to run its course.  That twitter, for better or worse, has captured the imagination of many of the blawgospheric cheerleaders may signal another shift in the paradigm, where the smart new “thought leaders” (a term I despise) are shifting their focus to the latest and greatest.  The masses will follow, until they get bored.

I see that many of the people who used to write comments here are now commenting about posts on twitter, and no longer bothering to comment on the blawg itself.  That strikes me as a consequential shift.  Twitter may be the new toy for many, but its has no depth. Has our attention span run the gamut from books to articles to blawg posts and now to 140 characters or less?  Maybe.  It’s much easier to post something on twitter than a blawg.  And twitter links to blog posts remind me of blog post links to newspaper stories.  See the trend?

I’m very sorry to see Judicial Reports disappear.  Not only did I enjoy reading it, but I liked receiving the checks for my editorials.  Is the day coming that no one reads Simple Justice anymore because it’s old new media?  Probably.  If so, I’ll be back in the position I was on day 1, when I wrote for my own amusement and was alone in the room.  For others, perhaps the ultimate resolution will be the next-generation of “twit” limited to two characters:  Hi

Update: For anyone who doubts that things change, this is the most painful example I’ve ever seen.  Watch at your own risk.



H/T Diane Levin.

Another Magic Bullet Misses Its Mark

From Radley “The Agitator” Balko, this Washington Post story of police from Prince George’s County, Maryland who stopped and ordered a TV reporter, Andrea McCarren, out of her car at gun point.  She was award $5,000 for her troubles, .

 

In her lawsuit, McCarren alleged that police manhandled her in an attempt to intimidate her into dropping a probe into the possible misuse of county government resources. McCarren and her attorneys said she suffered tendon damage to a shoulder when an officer grabbed her right wrist and yanked it behind her back.

 

Aside from the absurd award, the really interesting aspect of this story can be found in the last paragraph:

 

In all, nine police cars from Prince George’s and Cheverly responded. Although most of the squad cars were equipped with video cameras, police said none of them were working that day, Pavsner said.

 

No need for the apologists to provide “reasons” why this could happen, or the conspiracy theorists to offer the obvious reasons why the police concealed the evidence of their wrongdoing.  As much as I enjoy baseless speculation as much as the next blawger, this isn’t about the cameras per se.  This is about how another magic bullet solution, cameras in cruisers, somehow manages to fulfill its promise.  It doesn’t matter if the cops deep-sixed the tapes, or the cameras all failed for lack of simple maintenance under rough conditions.  It matters that another of the brilliant solutions to “all our problems” never seems to work out quite the way we hope.

Hope.  Whether it’s because we are idealists, optimists or just refuse to give up, we continue to have hope that we can improve our systems to the point where human error, hatred, prejudice and rage will no longer trump right and wrong.  No matter how many times our hope is dashed, it is renewed with the next great idea.  We never learn.

Whether it’s videotaped confessions, or double-blind sequential line-ups, we insist that this will “fix” the system.  They may well improve things, at least until law enforcement figures out a way to use it against us.  But our expectations in magic bullets has no better chance of being the fix than did those 9 squad car cameras have of showing the reporter being subjected to excess force.

It’s not the procedures or the equipment that makes things go terribly wrong.  It’s the people, the judges, prosecutors and police.  It’s the criminal defense lawyers as well, who lack the nerve to fight the good fight.  No one has come up with a magic bullet that will change the people.

As much as I hate to be the wet blanket of the criminal defense bar, when everyone else is jumping on the bandwagon of these new procedures and technologies, someone has to harp on the fact that none of this will ever overcome the law and order culture of the courts, the us against them culture of the police, the self-righteousness of the young prosecutors and the gutlessness and greed of the criminal defense bar.  The rest is bells and whistles.

MLK: It’s Over But It’s Not (Update)

As the first black man to be elected President of the United States of America is about to take the oath of office, some argue that we have now achieved The Dream.  Yet the same day that Barack Obama swears to God to uphold the Constitution, police officers will hassle, and ultimately beat down, some young black man wearing saggy pants.  Some store anti-theft security agent will follow a couple of teenage black women through the store to make sure they don’t steal.  And white lawyers, like me, will continue to note the skin color of clients.

I can’t adequately explain how these two worlds can co-exist, but I know that they do.  I believe that things have improved, though slowly and often as a result of accomplishments that are collateral to race.  Aside from his slightly darker skin color, Barack Obama could have been any well-educated, successful, boomer yuppie.  Whites saw more in common than different.  But this does little to aid the blacks who never made it out of their traditional ghettos.  Without the education, family support and great expectations, their status remains little different than it did in 1964, when the Civil Rights Act was enacted.

The saddest commentary is that criminal defense lawyers remains in a position bridging the gap between one segment of black society and the mainstream.  It’s sad because of what we do, and why it connects with so many black people.  They are still the disproportionate focus of our criminal justice system. 

Some argue that the reason for this is “simple”.  It’s because they commit a disproportionate amount of crime,  Whether that claim is true, since it ignores the reality that they are under disproportionate police scrutiny, is immaterial.  Put a young man of any color into a good school, with a strong family, with expectations of achieving success by hard work and following societal norms, and he will succeed.  Leave him the ghetto with farcical education, drugs, broken families and the expectation of death by 27, and he will meet those expectations as well.  And as long as our police spend their energies enforcing laws with much greater vigor in certain neighborhoods than others, we will have prisons filled disproportionately with young black men.

But not every black kid from the ghetto becomes a criminal, the deniers retort.  True, but neither would all the nice, warm, happy white kids in suburbia end up in law school if they lived under those conditions.  Indeed, they don’t now. Can you imagine how bad they would be if they lost all their advantages.

Whites are tired of black rage and black excuses, as if they get to choose how someone else is should feel about their lives.  Of course, they don’t live the life of a person with black skin, and merely project their own glaring misunderstanding of life as a black person on others.  Some of us try to understand, but we still go home as a white person at the end of the day.  The best we can hope to do is admit our prejudice and try our best to control it.

Now that Barack Hussein Obama will assume the highest office in America, will that end the drought of expectation for other blacks?  I can’t begin to know.  I would guess that it brings faith to the ever-increasing black middle and upper class.  Yes, they exist.  They are as educated, well-off, kind and knowledgeable as anyone else.  But it’s still not a hop, skip and jump for those who remain behind in the ghetto.  They may feel proud of Obama’s election, but it’s unlikely to have much to do with their lives.

Martin Luther King, Jr. tried to make his point before his life was cut short by the hatred born of white ignorance.  There has been progress.  There is still a long way to go.  That we have elected a black man president is an important step in the process, but it’s only a step.  There is so much more to go.  Why it has taken so long is a testament to the depth of the problem, and the size of the mountain Martin Luther King, Jr., tried to climb.

Update:  This week’s Blawg Review is hosted at On Being a Black Lawyer, rather than A Public Defender as had been the traditional locus of the Martin Luther King Day Blawg Review.  Sadly, no post by Gideon can be found in this blawg review, though some of the usual suspects are in there.

Twitter Update: I Care Deeply About Your Lunch Meat

Warning: For those who have had enough of my running commentary on twitter, you’ll probably hate this post.

Claims vary about the utility of twitter to get business, but some are certainly working their broad butts off trying.  Kevin O’Keefe, who is rumored to secretly hold a majority of twitter stock, noted perhaps the most shameful effort.  But such overt efforts are poorly received and likely entirely ineffective.



Edit addition: In response Kevin’s admonition, @ottawalawyers asks,


Isn’t @ vancouverlawyer just doing directly what most Tweeters are trying to do indirectly? Is it shameful to be upfront?

Point well taken.  It may be inartful, but is it any more shameful? Now back to the original post.


Rather, it is the love shown by one twit to another that will best serve the end of ingratiation.  And there are no shortage of twits happy to show the love.

Lextweet, one of Kevin’s better looking brainchildren, is enormously helpful in peeking into the world of the inane and its sycophants.  There are those who twit their every movement, There are those who then respond with fascination, bordering on adoration.  As Dale Carnegie, whose ideals have been revived in the quest for twitter supremacy, said, “become genuinely interested in other people.”  If lunch meat is what they twit about, then become genuinely interested in their choice of lunch meat.

While the advice is sound for the purpose of ingratiating oneself with others, it presents a problem for the purpose of being a lawyer.  The hope, of course, is that by expressing deep, genuine interest in the lunch meat of others, others will return the favor by sending back paying clients.  After all, the twit from Miami now knows a twit from New York who practices criminal defense, so when he has a criminal defendant to refer, where else would she go?  The logic seems sound.

But the fact that one twit expresses a deep, genuine concern for the other’s lunch meat offers little basis to determine whether the twit is a competent lawyer, no less a really good lawyer.  One might support that those who find it necessary to express deep, genuine concern for lunch meat are even a little desperate for work, indicating that they have some trouble obtaining clients, which may be a reflection on their skills. 

For years, people have asked me for referrals to divorce lawyers.  I have generally demurred.  In my early days, I gave people the names of lawyers I knew.  Things invariably turned ugly, and these same people would call me to inform me how unhappy they were with my referral, and how poorly they thought things were going.  They blamed me for sending them to this horrible lawyer.  I blamed myself as well, for being foolish enough to get involved.  I really did want to help, but it went straight into the “no good deed goes unpunished” folder.

Joel Rosenberg, who leads a small but exceptionally well-armed band of renegade renaissance theorists, pointed out to me that it “seems that it’s very hard to be intelligent in 140 characters, but very easy to be stupid.”  Perhaps this is why so much effort is placed in lunch meat appreciation rather than a demonstration of competency in the hope of attracting business.  The former presents many problems, and is likely impossible. 

But if a deep and genuine appreciation of lunch meat becomes the mechanism by which lawyer to lawyer referrals are based, acknowledging the difficulty of ascertaining degrees of competency via twits and instead relying on the kind words of others about salami or even liverwurst, then what does this say about us as lawyers? Is our personal pecuniary interest that overwhelming that we care nothing about the quality and competency of the lawyers to whom we refer clients?

In all likelihood, I am preaching to the choir.  Unfortunately, it’s the choir of the church down the street.  The church of self-promotion and marketing at the expense of honesty, integrity and professionalism.  I know, that would make a lousy name for a church, but bear with me.  I don’t challenge the mechanics of using twitter to find a lawyer for a referral.  I don’t challenge the mechanics of using twitter to seek out referrals.  I suppose any information delivery system with the right crowd will serve the purpose.  I challenge referring clients based upon people ingratiating themselves with others based upon their deep, genuine appreciation of lunch meat.

As Monty Python made clear, “strange women lyin’ in ponds distributin’ swords is no basis for a system of government.” 

Ingratiating twits are no basis for a legal referral system.

The Wittiest Inaugrual Address Ever

George Washington’s inaugural speech was 135 words, a record that has yet to be broken. 

William Henry Harrison’s inaugural speech lasted 105 minutes.  He died a month later from pneumonia caught while giving the speech.

Is there a lesson to be learned in these facts? 

Barack Hussein Obama, whose middle name is back on the table for use now that he’s the President-Elect, much to Congressman Peter Steve King’s consternation, will take the oath of office by 12 noon on January 20th, as commanded by the 20th Amendment, lest the United States be without a President for even an instant.  After that, he will speak.  It will be outdoors.  It will be cold.

Obama will no doubt seek to inspire us.  We are nation with problems, and he was elected because of his ability to inspire hope, even if he lacks solutions to our problems.  Hope is better than no solutions and no hope.  Solutions would be better than either, but we are undeserving of solutions, which is nature’s way of paying us back for our poor choices.  Bear in mind that I’m a Malthusian.

William Shakespeare wrote that “brevity is the soul of wit.”  Of course, the words were uttered by Polonius, the most witless and long-winded of Shakespeare’s characters.  Will our incoming President recognize this irony?  Will he emulate Polonius, or will he realize that people are standing out in the cold, both physical and metaphorical?

Many of the rituals of government were taken from the choices made by our first president (under the Constitution, as opposed to our other first president, John Hanson of Maryland, who is long forgotten).  Inspiration does not require great length, but great depth. 

Whether Barack Hussein Obama has the discretion to recognize the opportunity to truly inspire a nation will become apparent on January 20th.  It’s not about fabulous balls, or cute expressions from children, or even the historic inclusiveness of a black man leading a country that once enslaved black men and women.  That bridge has now been crossed.  Even party politics took a hit when a majority of House Republicans refused to adhere to the commands of its leadership, showing that ranks can be broken under the right circumstances.

David Post at Volokh Conspiracy has kindly offered the first inaugural address of Thomas Jefferson, It’s impossible to read them without feeling inspired, Jefferson perhaps best reflecting what our nation aspired to be.  While it was 1,723 words, it was capable of delivery in about ten minutes by my estimation.  I do not know what the temperature in Washington was on March 4, 1801, but suspect it was warmer than it will be this January 20th.

Follow in the footsteps of our greatest presidents, President-Elect Obama.  Inspire us, but do so with brevity.  It can be done if you select your words carefully.

As If Legal Fees Aren’t High Enough

As state budgets are being worked out with red pencils, an idea floated in Connecticut to help spread the pain is a tax on legal fees.  Not surprisingly, Norm Pattis is less than ecstatic, according to his Connecticut Law Tribune editorial.


I suppose the new tax will work something like this: A client pays a retainer of $10,000 for representation in a felony case. You take the money and assess the new tax. Let’s say it is a 2 percent tax. My fee for that same case will now rise by at least $200.

But is that enough? Not really. I will need to train staff to fill out forms. My accountant will need to audit compliance and, perhaps, prepare quarterly reports. New paper trails will need to be blazed and groomed.

So rather than raise rates by 2 percent, I’d better raise them some to account for additional time and expense of compliance. Add another 2 percent, or make it now $10,400. But that’s an awkward number, so $10,500 it is.

The point is a simple one. A tax on services will be transferred to clients, thus driving up the cost of legal services. 

While certainly true, I suspect there will be some other issues as well.  We all know how happy criminal defendants are to pay legal fees, and how they are inclined to make payments subsequent to the initial retainer.  Certainly adding a few points to this will have no consequence.

We all know that defendants feel that retaining private defense counsel is so much more effective than being represented by a public defender or indigent defender, so by increasing the cost of doing so, there will be no impact on the number of defendants who elect to forgo a private lawyer and enjoy the largess of the state.  Certainly, public defenders have plenty of room on their plate for yet another round of defendants in need of their services.

We all know that defendants have nothing to hide from the government, and are happy to have their lawyer affirmatively disclose to the government the amount of money paid for their legal defense.  After all, look how well Form 8300 has been received.  Certainly, defendants are proud of their earning power and tax compliance, and would enjoy nothing better than the state knowing as much about them as possible.

And criminal defense lawyers, already on the cusp of being perceived as a little too tight with the system, would gain the trust of their clients by acting as the collection agent of the tax man.

While legislators may wonder why lawyers, as opposed to those who make women’s dresses, should be immune from the pleasures of tax collection, there are some sound reasons to distinguish between the two.  It won’t work.  It will end up costing the state more money than it collects.  It will deny people the ability to retain counsel by increasing the cost of legal services.  It will compromise the attorney’s single-minded devotion to her client and make her part of the state evidence-gathering apparatus.

For most criminal defense lawyers, the cost of operating a law practice has increased, as has almost every cost for everyone else, while the ability to earn and collect legal fees has remained stagnant at best, and decline at worst.  Competition is rampant, and often turns on cost, since clients are frequently incapable of distinguishing lawyers on competence or service.

Lawyers aren’t unique in this regard.  Many, like health care providers, have watched their costs rise while earnings fall, for decades.  Or hedge fund managers, over the last month.  But facially appealing solutions aren’t always viable solutions, and this one will backfire big time.

Norm offers a radical solution to all of these issues for lawyers:


Of course, the real solution to the problem of legal services is one we don’t have the courage to enact. I say every person charged with a crime should have a right to a public defender. There is no reason why lower-middle class and middle-class families should be ruined by legal expenses. And if lawmakers had to fund defense as well as prosecution, they might be a whole lot less trigger happy when it comes to enacting new laws. The well-heeled can always opt out and hire private counsel.

His point, that even a well-heeled middle class family can be ruined by the cost of a criminal defense, especially galling when the defendant is innocent and spending his children’s college funds to fight spurious charges, is very well taken.  It’s not without problems, when criminal defense becomes dependent on state-love for its living (and hence existence), but neither is watching a nice family destroyed by the criminal justice system.



Bigger Than the Constitution

Jackson, Mississippi Mayor Frank Melton has already become the joke of the blawgosphere for uttering these immortal words:


“I certainly respect the Constitution, but we have some issues that are much bigger than the Constitution.”

So says, Radley Balko, Boing Boing and Reason.  Melton’s big issue?  Saggy pants. But neither the ridiculous quote nor the inane issue makes Melton the worst mayor in America.  Indeed, it strikes me that he’s right in the middle of the pack, being painfully average.

Having spent some time around those who would climb the pedestal to local prominence, both before and after the ascension, I can attest to an affliction that seems epidemic: They suddenly confuse themselves with the law.  Overnight, literally, they believe that they ARE the law.  They believe that whatever idea pops into their minds is, by definition, important.  And they believe that whatever solution came to them in a dream is, inherently, the right solution.

The very day before the weight of office was laid upon their shoulders, they sought advice and counsel, doubted that they alone held all the answers, and expressed their desire to transcend the limitations of a single individual’s thoughts.  But the next day, the pressure was too much to bear, the crown too tight, and an omniscient monster emerged.

This affliction isn’t limited to mayors of towns large and small.  Richard Nixon suffered from it.  Dick Cheney still does.  It doesn’t afflict every mayor, but most.  Some hide it while others flaunt it. 

Most suffer this affliction in silence.  Not because they fear telling anyone of it, but because no one asks the right questions.  Indeed, they don’t see it as an affliction at all, but rather as their raison d’être, to be the Messiah and save their charges from whatever terrible evil they see through their foggy vision.  In Melton’s case, it was the dreaded saggy pants. 

There is no cure for this affliction.  Worse still, it cannot be treated through the election of another as mayor, for the likelihood is strong that the next mayor will suffer from the affliction as well. 

As lawyers, there is a strong chance that we know these people, perhaps even advise these people, who suffer from this affliction. Often we seek to serve these people, as they require lawyers to aid them in accomplishing tasks and solving problems bigger than the Constitution.  It’s important that we never forget it exists, as it is contagious. 

Lawyers and Drugs; We’re Not Special

Substance abuse is a subject close at hand to most criminal defense lawyers.  Some even more than others.  When Charles Alan Ramsay went to court to represent accused killer Jack Nissalke, he didn’t anticipate that he would end up the person in need of legal counsel.  From the Star Tribune :


Deputy Winona Police Chief Paul Bostrack said an investigator preparing to testify at the hearing had noticed Ramsay was acting suspiciously after he left a bathroom. In addition, white powder was found at a conference table where Ramsay had been working, Bostrack said.

Sheriff Dave Brand told KAGE-AM that a drug sniffing police dog was brought to the scene, and it indicated one of Ramsay’s brief cases contained a controlled substance that prosecutors allege was cocaine.

The sheriff waiting until Nassalke took his plea and the spectators left before arresting Ramsay in the courtroom.  This may have been simple courtesy, or a tip of the hat to Ramsay’s brother, Duluth Chief of Police Gordon Ramsay.

Sheriffs deputies claim that Ramsay went into the bathroom, but they heard no flush.  He came out sniffing repeatedly and pinching his nose.  For those who think that police have no interest in hygiene, let this be a warning. 

Chuck Ramsay was not exactly a slouch as a lawyer, apparently, but that didn’t save him from turning himself into a defendant.


Ramsay runs his own practice, Charles A. Ramsay & Associates PLLC, based in Roseville. He has held the title ” BLOCKQUOTE cases.< DWI in specifically defense, criminal of areas all work his touts bio His site. Web firm?s the on biography a to according Army, lieutenant currently is and 2000 January since magazine Politics & Law Minnesota from Lawyer? Super>

No one is immune.  Whether it’s alcohol, drugs, gambling, lawyers are as susceptible as anyone else.  But we are different in two significant respects.  First, we are responsible for the lives of others.  When our skills and judgment are impaired, it’s not merely our lives that we’re playing with, but the lives of our clients.  It doesn’t matter what your excuse is, you have no right to put someone else’s life in jeopardy.

The second difference is that we spend an awful lot of time around cops and courthouses.  While lawyer may think they are hiding their indulgence well, as do most people using drugs who tend to significantly overestimate how well they’re handling things, we are particularly at risk of detection.  Don’t think no one will notice.  Don’t think that you’ve brilliantly hidden your little secret.  Chances are that it’s more obvious than you think.

For Duluth Police Chief Gordon Ramsay, this bust was both personally and professionally devastating.   Brother Gordon gave this statement :


“Our family is devastated by this. No one is immune from problems associated with drugs, whether it’s a family member in trouble or a victim of a crime perpetrated by a drug user. I am passionate about the role police play in making our society a better place, and this is a good example why. No one is immune. Drugs devastate families.”

Of course, Chuck Ramsay’s problem is not a criminal one, but a medical one.  Joining the hundreds of thousands of drug users currently warehoused in prisons as prisoners of the war on drugs serves no beneficial purpose and exacts a ridiculously high cost.  So naturally, Chuck was charged with two felony counts for his drug possession, and stands to lose his license, because that’s how we deal with drug abuse in America.

As for Nassalke, he’s weighing his options.  While getting out from under the plea taken the day of Ramsay’s arrest seems relatively easy, it’s unlikely to improve his defense sufficiently to make it a wise choice.  He’s “waiting to speak with Ramsay” before making any decisions.

The Drug War, Summed Up

Via Doug Berman, Culture II has put together three posts that seek to present both sides of the never-ending war on drugs, together with an analysis of the cost this misbegotten war has on our society.











War on Drugs: The Collateral Damage


by Radley Balko
Prohibition militarizes police, enriches our enemies, undermines our laws, and condemns our sick to suffering.


Keep Drugs Illegal!


by David Freddoso
Legalization won’t end the violence, but it will fry plenty of brains.


War on Drugs: The Price Tag


by Anita Bartholomew
America can’t afford marijuana prohibition – it’s a matter of dollars and sense.

While these may not present exhaustive arguments on the subjects, and are certainly sufficiently value-laden to get the blood pumping in anyone who disagrees, they nonetheless provide an excellent presentation of the issues and arguments involved.

Having spent the better part of my legal career dealing with people who use and sell drugs, as well as those who don’t but are prosecuted nonetheless, I have long suffered from serious ambivalence on the subject of legalization.  I see “truth” in all the arguments, and cannot conclude as easily as many others that mind-altering amd addictive drugs are sufficiently similar to alcohol that we can rely upon the comparison to predict the impact legalization will have on society, in general, and its members. 

Marijuana, on the other hand, presents a markedly different issue than narcotics, and one that our government has resisted with inexplicably force.  Not only has the government steadfastly denied its clear and conclusive medicinal use, to the detriment of so many who suffer, but its effort to villify it as the gateway to heroin, since that cult gem of propaganda, Reefer Madness, has been laughable to any but the most ignorant Luddite. 

But this is not merely an issue of anti-drug religious ferver.  As Anita Bartholomew posts:


The price of deploying an army of local, state and federal cops, prosecutors and guards to arrest, try and imprison the perpetrators of this non-scourge? Using data from 2000, Harvard economist Jeffrey Miron estimated it as $7.7 billion4 per year while a 2007 study, by public policy expert Jon Gettman, figured it closer to $10.7 billion 5 per year.

Most of that money is eaten up by law enforcement according to Miron, with $2.94 billion going to prosecution costs in 2000, and less than half a billion toward incarceration.

Add in the revenue we’d eventually gain if marijuana were regulated and taxed like alcohol and tobacco (from $6.2 billion to as much as $31.1 billion per year), and you’re talking real money.

The cost of this fool’s battle is crushing.  It was bad before and, in the throes of our current economic status, is now ruinous.  This is money that might otherwise buy food, education or housing (or bombs or bailouts of major corporatations), but is now flushed down the toilet, along with the hundreds of thousands of young people whose lives are destroyed by marijuana convictions.

Whether this will be the right time to revisit our government’s knee-jerk approach toward drugs on the whole, or at least marijuana as a subset, has yet to be seen.  But it’s most assuredly an awfully good time to pursue the discussion and push hard for a rational approach.

With that in mind, perhaps this would be a good time to pull the popcorn out of the microwave and enjoy a movie.