Author Archives: SHG

New Crime, But No Perp

It’s long been a rule of thumb that any law named after someone is destined to be a bad law.  The reason is simple: Politicians react to the public outcry of a tragic anomaly by putting on their “tough on crime” hat and passing a law, much the way the Lil’ Rascals put on a play.  In fact, exactly the same way. 

These laws are enacted without anyone considering the unintended consequences, or even the need, so that their sponsors can engage in hyperbolic rhetoric about how they’ve saved society from some plague of atrocities that never existed until this one particular circumstance.  No politician can vote against the law, since that would mean that Sean, Bill or Rush will tell their fans that the politician is in favor of atrocities, which is never good for re-election purposes.

And so the case was made for Laci and Conner’s Law.  You remember, there was a television show all about them, called the Scott Peterson Trial, starring Mark Geragos as Bozo the Lawyer.

Via Bashman, Micheal Doyle at the McClatchy Newspapers decided to follow up to see how effective this law has been in curbing the federal plague of murdering the unborn.  The demand for such a law was clear:

Congress commemorated the slain California woman by passing the controversial Laci and Conner’s Law and creating a new federal crime of killing an unborn child.

Supporters said the measure would fill a law enforcement loophole.

“Police and prosecutors . . . have shared the grief of families, but have so often been unable to seek justice for the full offense,” President Bush said at the time.

While some might question whether enactment of criminal laws are the right way to “commemorate” people, no matter how tragic the circumstances of their death, politicians are more finely attuned to the needs of the People than someone like me, and certainly the President of the United States would know from whence he speaks.  When President Bush says that justice has “so often” been thwarted, then it must be so.

So let’s consider how effective this law has been.


So far, Bureau of Justice Statistics databases don’t show any federal prosecutions under the law, also known as the Unborn Victims of Violence Act. Supporters of the law say they haven’t heard of any.

None?  Not one?  Maybe the mere threat of prosecution posed by this law put a stop to this plague?


But counting prosecutions isn’t necessarily the only measure of legislative impact.

“We think there are several types of value to this law,” said Douglas Johnson, the legislative director of the National Right to Life Committee, an anti-abortion advocacy group. “One is deterrence. Hopefully, people will take this into account when they beat up on a woman.”

There we go.  After all, most impassioned criminals hesitate just long enough to consider whether their act of violence toward a pregnant woman will cause the Laci and Connor Law to be invoked, then withdraw in their moment of calm reflection.

Note that there are two rather large problems standing in the way of the effective use of this law.  First, murders are almost invariably state crimes, not federal.  Second, when the perp murders the pregnant woman, that’s usually cause enough to prosecute hard.  These are how it should be, and there was never a need for yet another law, except as a promotional tool for those national politicians who feel sad and lonely that they don’t get to create enough crimes to make them heroes to their constituents.

But just in case we ever need it, we have a law on the books.  Who does it harm if it’s never actually used?

Sheriff Fletcher’s Day in the Sun

No one was more upset with the reduced role of the Republican National Convention than Ramsey County Sheriff Bob Fletcher.  After all, there isn’t much happening in the Twin Cities that offers national attention to fine police work normally, and this was his moment to shine.

Bob Fletcher, Ramsey County Sheriff, shows some of the confiscated materials during a news conference in at the Republican National Convention in St. Paul, Minn., Saturday, Aug. 30, 2008. Police raided several homes in Minneapolis and St. Paul on Friday and Saturday and four people were arrested and booked on probable cause of conspiracy to commit a riot. Associated Press. In the photograph at right, Sheriff Fletcher shows how he has honed his skills in directing traffic.  Note the casual attitude, yet firm command he exudes as he demonstrates his aptitude to a room full of reporters.  Also on display in the background are both maps the department maintains, so that they know where they are at all times.  Fletcher runs a very professional department.  Most of the time.

Unfortunately, a crack appeared yesterday in the smooth control over incoming riff-raff when Fletcher’s men mistook the crew of Democracy Now! for violent anarchists.  Producers Sharif Abdel Kouddous and Nicole Salazar were seized and roughed up by St. Paul police.  According to the Democracy Now! website :


Ramsey County Sheriff Bob Fletcher told Democracy Now! that Kouddous and Salazar were arrested on suspicion of rioting, a felony.

It’s easy to understand the confusion when one takes a look at the videotape.  Fletcher’s men were decked out in their finest black riot gear, looking quite macho and forceful.  It’s not surprising that the riot gear looked absolutely pristine, as this was likely their first opportunity to put it on, other than certain non-sectarian holidays and parades.



This is why the two producers were arrested for “suspicion” of rioting.  None of the black-dressed officers were entirely sure what an actual riot looked like, never having seen one in person before, but they assumed that if Sheriff Fletcher ordered them to get all dressed up in their finest black riot gear, then there had to be a darn good reason for it.  Sheriff Fletcher is not a whimsical sort of fellow, you see.

Then, the situation took a turn for the worst when Democracy Now! host, journalist Amy Goodman, viciously assaulted the ears of the protectors of riotous-freedom by asking why they were arresting her producers.  Rather than react in the best tradition of the mainstream media, and running in the other direction while dialing her cellphone for the corporate attorneys, Goodman resisted the police efforts to restore tranquility by employing her deceptively stentorian soprano to push their law and order button with the single most offensive word to police officers everywhere:  why?

Little did Amy Goodman know of Sheriff Fletcher’s standing order to violently seize and gag anyone using the anarchist codeword “why” to undermine the police efforts to return the area to complete and unchallenged subjugation.  Doesn’t Goodman get the idea that this is America, and you do whatever the cop tells you to do (and do it NOW!).

While not yet reported by any credible outlet anywhere, rumor has it that Sheriff Fletcher, upon seeing the videotape, chuckled and said, “And those Denver yahoos think they had something on me when they grabbed the ABC producer by the throat.  Hah!”

Every four years, our children get an excellent lesson in the practice of democracy in America, watching and learning how those fine platitudes they learn in civics class are played out in the streets of one of America’s cities.  This year, Sheriff Bob Fletcher has his turn to teach our kids a lesson.  Don’t those police officers look handsome in their black riot gear?

And my appreciation to Jon Katz at Underdog and Jeralyn Merritt at TalkLeft for keeping a keen eye on the story on the streets while the glorious stage show of American politics is played out in large amphitheaters with dubiously attired delegates to the official political parties of the United States of America. 

Wearing the American Hat

This New York Times article discusses how John McCain declared to his party that, in the face of Hurricane Gustav, this was the time to “take off our Republican hats and put on our American hats.”   Both McCain and Obama have chosen to focus on how they can contribute to helping the areas expected to be hurt.  Cynics will argue that this is all part of the show, and perhaps there is some of that involved.  But if the candidates can put aside attacks, it will be one of the few positive steps forward we’ve seen in a long time.

Of course, John McCain has far more to lose, since this means that the Republican National Convention stage show will suffer.  This was the show where they would attack Obama unmercifully, and create the persona for Sarah Palin that they need to energize the evangelical base that remain displeased by McCain’s moderate politics, his real beliefs that he’s hidden under his hat until he gets elected.

On Sunday afternoon, Mr. McCain declared on television that this was a time for members of his party to “take off our Republican hats and put on our American hats.” He made similar remarks at a campaign rally in St. Louis, even as some of his allies there, like former Gov. Mitt Romney of Massachusetts and Senator Christopher S. Bond of Missouri, publicly criticized Democrats and their nominee, Senator Barack Obama of Illinois, at the same event.

“This is a time when we have to do away with our party politics, and we have to act as Americans,” Mr. McCain said in St. Louis after a brief tour with Ms. Palin of a federal disaster relief center in Jackson, Miss.

While it seems impossible to wholly divorce politics from current events, I choose to believe that both John McCain and Barack Obama are genuinely concerned and would stand side-by-side to fortify the levies protecting New Orleans. 

While others in their respective parties will use anything and everything to capture a vote, this election offers two candidates at the top of their tickets who (despite the expected pandering, position shifting, vagaries and manipulation of reality to gain transitory advantage), will ultimately prove themselves to be sincere in their concern for the country.  What a wonderful change of pace.

If America could only chose a president for the good reasons, we could have avoided so many of the problems that have plagued this country in recent years.  Perhaps Hurricane Gustav will be the counterpoint to Karl Rove, who destroyed John McCain in the 2000 Republican primary.

I know, the rest of you love/hate the candidates for varying reasons, and can name a dozen reasons why each is lying, pandering, unqualified fraud.  After all, it couldn’t be possible that these are a couple of guys who need to get elected but want to do the right thing, in which case it’s really just a matter of which one is more your cup of tea.

And just in case you’re wondering, this week’s posts will be seen by the fewest readers of any during the year, such that I’m writing purely for my own amusement.  For the three of you who will read this, I trust that my pollyanna-ish views won’t ruin your holiday.

Thoughts on the Return to the Bench

The back end of August has traditionally been a down time for the courts.  This was the time when judges went off to seminars about how to be a better judge, amongst other things that sometimes involved libations with tiny umbrellas in them.  But things heat up again on the Tuesday after Labor Day, when all those cases neglected during the month of August are suddenly back on the front burner.

Since no one invited me to speak to large assemblages of judges to aid them in their difficult duty (again), I feel as if I’ve contributed nothing to the betterment of the third branch of government this summer.  To remedy this, I offer the thoughtful  words of the Honorable Bernard Boland from the October, 2002 edition of Bench & Bar , the official publication of the Minnesota State Bar Association.



Everyday, on the bench I learn something new and, probably, forget something I already know, but here is a list of some of the things I haven’t forgotten as of today. Some may sound sanctimonious, because judges, and admonitions, very often are. And most apply not just to judging, but also to other jobs and to other things in life, and like the Golden Rule and the Ten Commandments, just knowing them doesn’t mean you can keep them — they are aspirations more than they are rules and commandments. And they are in the order in which they came to mind, not of their importance. You may rank them if you can, but it’s probably not necessary. Here they are:


1. The case is not about you. The case you are hearing is about a dispute between the parties that is presented to you by their lawyers because they couldn’t resolve it themselves. It is not an opportunity to demonstrate that you’re tough on crime, or the champion of the underdog, or anything else that you would like people to think about you. Do not make rulings because you want to be regarded in a certain way. When a judge wants to be known for ruling in a certain way, he or she is likely to rule that way whether or not the case warrants it. That can be a disservice to the parties and in the long run won’t do you any good either. Be careful even of the reputation you wish for.


2. Rule. Rule. Rule. It is to judging what location is to real estate. Remember that old saw about “perfect being the enemy of good.” The parties want a decision; they don’t care if your citations conform to the Blue Book, or even if you have them. Get it out, give reasons for it, and don’t complain or explain.

3. The parties should be given a reason for your decision. (Number two to the contrary notwithstanding!) The parties have a right to know why you decided the case the way you did. If, in a few sentences, you can’t explain why you’re ruling the way you are, then maybe you ought to reconsider your ruling.


4. Don’t compete with the lawyers. There’s an old story about a lawyer who, after the judge had questioned a witness, pleaded with the judge that if he (the judge) was going to try his case for him, not to lose it. The lawyers can see that you have a black robe and they don’t. There’s no need to demonstrate that you’re smarter, or that you can try their case better. You aren’t and you can’t, and you’re likely to make a fool of yourself if you try.


5. Don’t be a deal breaker (inseparable from number four above). The last thing anyone needs or wants is for you to screw up the deal the lawyers have made for their clients. You do not know either their cases or their clients better than they do. Refusing plea agreements and stipulations is arrogant. Tread very lightly here. You need not abandon your responsibility, but remember when reviewing plea agreements and stipulations that your responsibility is to the law and to the standards of the community; it is not about your likes, dislikes, politics or preferences. (Also, see number one)


6. Never forget you’re a lawyer and always remember you’re not a lawyer. This is to say, though not simply, that you will always be a lawyer, even though you are no longer an advocate, and that you can no longer be “one of the guys” or “one or the girls.” There is a boundary here that isn’t precisely defined. You have the same education, experience, friends and identity. Lawyers expect you to understand where they come from and to help them out when you can do so without doing harm to the other side. Your livelihood and theirs are interdependent — you can’t be reelected without them; they can’t make a living without you. On the other hand, you are not one of them, can never be one of them again, and shouldn’t try. If you are unable to draw that boundary, at best, you will not be respected and at worst the Board of Judicial Standards will be in touch with you.


7. Don’t be afraid to cut lawyers some slack — they’re in a tough business. You get a check every two weeks; they may or may not get paid. Every day, they have to be two or more places at once; you have the luxury of one courtroom, one case at a time. They have the toughest job in the courtroom; you have the easiest. You get six weeks of paid vacation every year; they’re lucky to get two weeks, they pay double for it, and still have to worry about a judge scheduling a case in the middle of it. When the case is over, more often than not they face a client or a partner who is unhappy about something. You get to go home.


8. Never reach into a lawyer’s pocket. Do not handle contested cases where lawyers who practice in front of you are a party, and don’t handle their divorces even if they’re stipulated. Every day you rule against their clients, and they recognize (usually) that it’s not about them. If you get involved in their personal business, especially their fees and livelihood, expect never to be forgiven if you injure them. Never make a disparaging remark in front of a client about the manner in which a lawyer has handled a case; never handle a suit for fees, even in conciliation court; and except in the most egregious circumstances, stay away from awarding costs against them or fining them.


9. This isn’t a popularity contest. You’ve heard this before, but it bears repeating. Don’t expect to be liked and don’t expect to be thanked for doing your job. When your mother told you that you don’t get thanked for doing what you’re supposed to do, you should have remembered it, and you can apply it to being a judge. You’re not responsible for the facts or for anyone winning or losing a case. No matter how hard you try to “temper the wind to the shorn lamb,” nobody likes losing. The parties and their lawyers will often blame you — get used to it. If they thought they were wrong, they wouldn’t have sued or taken the case. Nor is it valid to make a tough call based on what you think an appellate court might do. As tempting as it may be to guess about the Court of Appeals, your obligation is to make the fairest ruling you can on the law and facts before you. The worst thing you can do is “throw people bones,” or try to make every case come out exactly even. If you do that, lawyers with good cases will avoid you and lawyers with bad cases will seek you out. The former because they know their good case will be cut in half, and the latter because they know they’ll be rewarded no matter how bad their case. Either way, they won’t respect you or your office.


10. Remember, what you don’t do someone else must. Think of your colleagues when you’re tempted to recuse yourself from that gut-wrenching family case, or a case brought by a pain in the neck lawyer, or the case involving your cousin’s babysitter’s brother. Try to remember that you’re not well-paid because you have more wisdom than the tens of thousands of lawyers who aren’t judges. You’re well-paid because your job is often uncomfortable — not because it’s complex and nobody else can do it. Also, think of your colleagues when you’re tempted to rip on a lawyer and cause that lawyer to remove you. Most excuses are really choices, and someone else will eventually have to handle that case. Neither the lawyer nor the case will go away. This is one of the few jobs where being a jerk is richly rewarded. If you’re angry and churlish, lawyers will duck you and remove you. You will hear the easy cases and draw the inexperienced lawyers; you will have more time to hunt, fish, and play golf. You won’t be the first to figure this out; legions have gone before you; that’s one of the reasons why an independent judiciary is always in grave danger. You will reap what you sow. So will your colleagues. So will the public. So will the judicial branch of government.


H/T to a  judge named Paul who commented at Gerry Spence’s blog.

Labor Day 2008, (Surf’s Up?)

Like most good Americans, I went to the beach yesterday, and then a barbecue with friends.  It was no more, nor less, in honor of organized labor in America than what most people do.  My thoughts on the state of unionization were spelled out in my labor day post last year, and they haven’t changed any.  There’s no point in repeating them here.

But the beach serves as a pretty good metaphor for where we are this labor day, as does Dan Hull’s discussion of why he prefers to eat at Gray’s Inn rather than Lincoln Inn, much to Geeklawyer’s consternation.  Since before my time, Mrs. Simple Justice has preferred to sun at the beach at Robert Moses on Fire Island, field 5 to be specific.  I would enjoy the beach far more if it wasn’t for all that sand they have there.  It gets into everything.

Years ago, the beach was a broad expanse, sporadically broken up by a pair of bathers or a family building a sand castle.  We would go early, when it was still cool, with bagels, coffee and the Sunday New York Times.  It seemed as if we had the whole world to ourselves, viewing the earth’s curvature over the water.

The beach is largely gone now, missing the last 150 feet and dropping off precipitously toward the water.  The water looked clean, far cleaner than it used to, but it was impossible to tell from where we found a small patch of sand to place our antique chairs.  We still use the same beach chairs we bought when we were courting, and even beach chair technology has changed since then.

But there were people everywhere.  Thousands of them.  It was like Jones Beach, where the rabble from the City went to bathe.  People were arguing over who saw the small bare area first, or over whose umbrella was encroaching on whose turf.  It was angry, loud and coarse.  And there were sand flies everywhere, no doubt drawn by the litter that our predecessors left behind.

Labor day marks the official end of summer.  People yield to the obligation to spend one last day at the beach, even though it was miserable.  This was why we went, but had I known that it was going to be so unpleasant, I would have stayed home.

Labor day is a dead holiday.  It serves no other purpose than to mark the return to school.  While a few union officials and an occasional politician make remarks intended to endear themselves to the few remaining labor unionists, no one else notices. 

But the beach at Robert Moses reflects the true state of things.  People still want to enjoy what little is left of the beach, but there isn’t enough to go around.  They have grown nasty and possessive about it, willing to fight over each grain of sand.  At the same time, they have no regard for anyone else, between the racket they make without the slightest thought that it might disturb their surrounding loungers, and the garbage they toss aside to foul what little beach remains.

I was surprised to learn that one fixture from the old days remained, the “fudgy-wudgy” man.  This was an enterprising fellow who walked up and down the beach with a cooler filled with dry ice and ice cream.  Back when, he would yell out “fudgy-wudgy bars” to let everyone know he was near.  This time, it was “ice-cream” spoken in a stage whisper.  But he still carried a heavy cooler filled with various delights, up and down the beach, in the hot sun.

As he closed in, he suddenly dove toward two older women with an umbrella between them, and threw a towel over his cooler.  He stuck his head between the two women and appeared to engage in animated conversation with them.  Two Park Police officers passed by on quads. 

Once they were past, the fudgy-wudgy man apologized to all around, explaining that they were scouring the beach in search of him in order to seize his fudgy-wudgy bars.  He sold them for a dollar less than the outrageous $4 charged by the state run concession, plus he delivered, and they were not pleased with him. 

So my thoughts of labor today are of the fudgy-wudgy man, still trying to make a buck by selling his bars for a dollar less than our government.  And having to dodge the government’s armed wing to do so. 

Here’s to the fudgy-wudgy man.

Where are they now?

I can’t help but wonder what’s become of some of my favorite voices in the blawgosphere.  I expect that  Jamie Spencer is busily preparing for Blawg Review #175, though he’s been awfully quiet lately.

But what of Anne Reed?  Deliberations was one of the finest, most thoughtful and interesting blawgs that ever graced the practical blawgosphere.  It’s been more than a month since Anne has put fingers to keyboard, and her absence has not gone unnoticed.

Then there’s Norm (background: entire bar yells “Norm!”) Pattis.  After retiring (again) from the daily grind of expressing errant thoughts, what does he do to fill those empty, lonely hours?  I picture Norm in a saffron robe, one long pony tail down his back, sitting cross-legged in the last remaining ashram in Greenwich, Connecticut, fastidiously painting the ancient Mandarin character for lo mein on rice paper will carefully sipping his vodka martini so as not to soil his work.

After a while in the practical blawgosphere, a certain camaraderie develops.  When someone inexplicably fades from view, they don’t necessarily fade from memory.  Where have you gone, Joe DiMaggio?  At the very least, say hello and let us know that you’re doing well.

Obama Saved by the Palin Debate

Having just read David Bernstein’s disgraceful polemic over at the Volokh Conspiracy, a gutter argument that would make Sean Hannity blush (assuming anything would make Sean Hannity blush), it occurs to me that the nomination of Sarah Palin has caused a seismic shift in the focus of the campaign away from Barak Obama.

The gut reaction is that this is a bad thing for the Democrats, particularly since it takes the wind out of their sails after the Big Tent Show in Denver.  But this may not be the case at all.

The constant attention leveled at Obama has made him, well, less exciting.  He doesn’t have much new to say, and seeing and hearing the same old stump speeches has become tiresome.  He needed a break, out of the limelight.  Perhaps this will give him an opportunity to think about developing a plan to effectuate some of the changes he speaks so eloquently about?

By taking the lights away from Obama, the Republicans have done him a favor.  Let’s argue whether Palin is qualified to be a heartbeat away from the presidency.  Let’s debate whether she was a “brigadier” in Pat Buchanan’s army, or just wearing a button out of courtesy.  Ultimately, the only people who care about this fly-spec scrutiny are the arch-partisans, who will argue to the death over the most absurd nuance while having absolutely no impact on the undecided voters.

In the meantime, Barak Obama can enjoy some quiet time to regroup, to focus his thoughts and to rejoin the campaign after the others grow bored with Sarah Palin.  By then, the Obama over-exposure will have faded and we will be ready for some new inspirational talk, and maybe even some substantive clue as to what he intends to do.

It’s hard, if not impossible, to stand the harsh glare of the spotlights for too long.  The Republicans could not haven given Barak Obama a better gift than some time in the shade while their own exposed wound gets a healthy dose of sunlight. 

Aside:  Jeralyn at TalkLeft has posted about Sarah Palin’s one Alaska Supreme Court appointment, Daniel Winfree.  He sounds like a terrific choice.

In the meantime, wouldn’t it be nice if we could have a discussion about the candidates on the sidewalk rather than the gutter?  With so many thoughtful conspirators over at Volokh, it’s a shame that David Bernstein chose to take the low road.  

Rumors of the Death of the Exclusionary Rule

When the Supreme Court granted cert in U.S. v. Herring last February, the product of a Stanford Law School litigation clinic student project, it raised some deep concerns.  For background, these are the facts via this New York Times article :

In this instance, officers in Coffee County, Ala., arrested a man, Bennie Dean Herring, in 2004 after being informed by the Sheriff’s Department in neighboring Dale County that he was the subject of an outstanding warrant. But the warrant, although still in Dale County’s computerized database, had in fact been withdrawn five months earlier. In the 10 or 15 minutes it took for the Dale County officers to realize their error, the Coffee County officers had already stopped Mr. Herring, handcuffed him, and searched him and his truck, finding methamphetamine and an unloaded pistol.

As the first Monday in October looms nearer, attention is beginning to focus on this case again, and where it might be heading.

In an article at Findlaw, courtesy of Bashman, Cal Davis Lawprof Vikram David Amar suggests that Herring might be the opportunity Justice Scalia has been looking for to finally put an end to the exclusionary rule.

Why, then, did the Court take the case? Perhaps because there appears to be some lower court confusion over the meaning of Evans and other exclusionary rule precedents. Or perhaps because the Court is interested in moving beyond those precedents, to forge new doctrine in this area. Since the Court (unlike lower courts) has the power to revisit and modify or overrule its own precedent, the question here is whether the arguments in favor of stare decisis – the presumption in favor of past rulings – have much force in this area.

In some contexts, we might stick with doctrines and rulings that don’t square with our deepest understanding of what the Constitution itself means and requires on the ground people have relied upon past rulings, and we don’t want people to be worse off for that reasonable reliance. But what reliance exists in the exclusionary rule setting? It seems incredibly unlikely that any criminal decides to break the law in part because he factors into his risk/reward calculus the possibility that evidence of his crime will be suppressed under the exclusionary rule.

Rarely will one find a lawprof’s writing that so fundamentally misses the point than here.  The reliance Amar questions isn’t limited to that of the criminal, but to all of us.  The public, as a whole, has a reasonable reliance that the police won’t violate our rights by searching and seizing people without a warrant. 

But aside from Amar’s antagonistic misunderstanding of the exclusionary rule, his point that it’s hard to understand why the court granted cert if not to do some greater harm to the rule has merit.  While the 11th Circuit’s approval of a search based upon an error by a court clerk could well be reversed based upon the fact that its all governmental action, and the rights of the people to be free from unreasonable searches should not be reduced by governmental incompetence, whether negligent or intentional, no one seems to think that the Supremes granted cert to reach that result.

The question then becomes, are the American people ready for a country without the exclusionary rule? 

The alternative method of vindicating the rights of a person subject to improper search is to sue the sheriff.  I don’t think this needs much discussion to say that no one believes that suing the cops every time they perform a bad search is going to provide an effective deterrent.  In fact, I don’t think anyone believes that this would likely happen.  What would you get as an award, $100 and a heartfelt apology for your 5 year long federal lawsuit?

Moreover, as the government sets its sights on white collar defendants, who face lengthy prison sentences under the advisory guidelines, the nature of concern for the criminal justice system as a whole shifts.  After all, a conservative is a liberal with a mortgage, and a liberal is a conservative under indictment.  As more conservatives face indictment, rules such as this become applicable to them, and they suddenly gain a sensitivity to the effectiveness of remedies to government overreaching. 

In the past, conservatives saw the exclusionary rule as a technicality exploited by criminals to go free because of some trivial error by police.  In response, it was argued that the 4th Amendment to the Constitution is no “technicality”, but this fell on deaf ears.  Today, however, the expansion of federal criminal attention and liability makes this “technicality” far more consequential to a far more powerful group than it once was. As major corporations, and their CEOs, stare down federal agents raiding their headquarters, the idea that they could do so at will rather than with a search warrant might be more than they could stand.  And these are the folks who finance election campaigns.

And what of the ordinary folks, the ones who haven’t done anything wrong and see no reason why police shouldn’t be able to search at will, since the only people they would possibly seize are the bad criminals, “those people,” who are of no concern to them?  As our many videos and posts have made incredibly clear, no one is immune from the kindly attention of the police.  You need not be one of “those people” to have your door knocked down, your children traumatized and your head bashed in, all in a misguided effort to get the bad guys.

With the exclusionary rule, the police still trample the 4th Amendment with regularity.  Without it, there will be nothing to slow them down, no less stop them, from riding roughshod.  The notion that civil damages is the route to go is laughable.  If anything, the more we learn about police efforts and errors, it appears that the exclusionary rule doesn’t nearly far enough to compel the police to think first.

But lawprofs don’t deal with the harsh reality of good citizens on the street harmed by a government that’s lost all sight of who it is here to protect.  Theory is the coin of the academic realm, and theory usually fails to account for its practical application to real world situations.  While Amar’s flip suggestion that the Supreme Court toss stare decisis out the window, as it has the power to do, and revisit the theoretical underpinnings of the exclusionary rule to the end of ridding constitutional jurisprudence of this judicially manufactured doctrine, may satisfy ideological purity, it will leave American society utterly exposed.

We have come to reasonably expect that there is a mechanism available in the course of a criminal prosecution to penalize the police for violations of our constitutional rights.  Without an exclusionary rule, there is no incentive for police not to violate the 4th Amendment.  The alternative, suing the cops (from your prison cell?) will give no officer pause from searching your car, home or body.  I cannot believe that society, no matter how conservative the majority may be, is prepared for cops without limits.

But then, if not to do harm to the exclusionary rule, why did the Supreme Court grant cert in Herring?

Trust Me, I’m from the Government (Part 2)

After posting about the blogversation on whether to disclose exculpatory evidence to the prosecutor before trial, or wait for that “Perry Mason Moment” when you spring it on them, WindyPundit alerted me to a prosecutor blog that also commented. 

The blog is called Seeking Justice by a prosecutor named Tom McKenna.  He is obviously a thoughtful and deliberate lawyer, as demonstrated by the fact that he doesn’t even acknowledge Simple Justice’s existence.  On the bright side, he also ignores Western Justice, whose post gave rise to the blogversation.  This suggests that Tom McKenna doesn’t dabble with either the lower echelon of the blawgosphere, or his unworthy prosecutorial competition.  But that doesn’t mean that I can’t aspire to address Tom’s perspective, in my own lower echelon kind of way.

Initially, Tom takes issue with the positions taken by Blonde Justice, the Texas Tornado and to some extent, Gideon.  To the extent that Bennett and Blonde argue that holding their cards close to the vest so that they can sandbag the prosecution at trial, Tom says “no dice.”


First, it usually doesn’t work: on even a mediocre defense cross, she’ll likely reveal her uncertainty anyway. And if a defense investigator has her saying she is really uncertain, that prior statement will come out. Either way, it’s a fair bet that a recanting witness is not going to be “threatened” into being a credible witness.

It strikes me that Tom’s perspective might be a bit narrow, which clouds his view of what a defense lawyer can do given the right material.  Since I don’t know where Tom prosecutes, or what types of cases he handles, I’m limited in my discussion.  But a recanting witness is not the only “bombshell” in town.  In fact, as bombshells go, a recanting witness barely makes the list.

My guess (and it’s only a guess) is that Tom probably hasn’t had too much experience with more complex prosecutions, where top defense lawyers can rip the heart out of a prosecution with a video or tape recording that shows their main witness to be a lying, scheming mutt.  Or documents proving that the thrust of the prosecution is manufactured out of whole cloth by malicious cops and naive prosecutors.  Bombshells don’t come along every day, but when they do, it can be huge.

But then comes the heart of Tom’s disapproval.


Of course, it remains that a defense attorney can save the “bombshell” for trial and get lots of jollies making the prosecution look foolish by bushwhacking the prosecutor with surprise information. Heck, it happens often enough, though it’s rare that the surprise evidence is of sufficient quality to gain an acquittal.

It seems that the bottom line here is that Tom doesn’t want to be embarrassed.  Tom expects the defense to put his feeling first, and thus place their trust in Tom’s good judgment.  Trust me, Tom says.  I’m a good guy.  I’m fair.  I will decide whether your bombshell “moves me” sufficiently.  And because I’m good and fair, and most importantly, because I’m the prosecutor, it’s my decision that matters.

But the kicker is on the back end.  Not only does Tom assert that he expects to be trusted, and for the defense attorney to accept his prosecutorial judgment as the final word, but then there’s the fist in Tom’s velvet glove.


But as Mark Bennett alluded to, I’m going to remember if you’re the kind of lawyer that would rather go for the public “gotcha” than work with me to find out the truth about the case. And if that attorney practices regularly in my jurisdiction, every attorney in my office is going to be told about it.

Payback, baby.  Make Tom look bad and he’s going to make sure that you, and all your future clients, get burned for it.  Forget about that concern for “justice” and not putting the innocent in prison.  Petty self-interest trumps all when it comes to making a prosecutor look “foolish”. 

It’s hard to imagine how someone could fail to recognize his own massive internal contradiction, by simultaneously arguing that he’s fair and “idealistic”, but that if you make him look bad he will do everything he can to harm innocent defendants going forward as payback to the lawyer. 

And, of course, Tom neglects to recognize that little detail that formed the basis of Bennett’s and Blonde’s position, that the sufficiency of the exculpatory evidence isn’t left to the prosecutor’s discretion, but to the jury’s.  This egocentricity is precisely the problem; prosecutor’s truly believe that it’s entirely their decision and they (and they alone) know the “truth” about guilt and innocence.

And that’s an awfully good reason why you can’t trust the prosecutor.



Lesbians, The Latest Threat to Homeland Security? (Update)

Since this has gotten Marc Randazza  (and the Satyricnistas?) all worked up, it’s got to be big.


In 2008, Lapriss Gilbert was ejected from the Social Security office in Los Angeles for wearing a t-shirt that said “lesbian.com”. Apparently the flunkie dipshit who worked for Paragon Security Company has never read that particular Supreme Court decision. He “cited the document, The Rules and Regulations Governing Conduct on Federal Property, as proof of his jurisdiction over Gilbert’s attire” (source) and told her to leave the building or she would be subject to arrest.

Randazza, of course, refers to Cohen v. California, 403 U.S. 15 (1971) (”one man’s vulgarity is another’s lyric”).  And yes, our erudite Randazza knows full well that the “FD” in the employ of Paragon Security at the behest of our very own Department of Homeland Security likely hasn’t read much of anything in many years, no less Supreme Court decisions. 

But should he really be held to such high, no impossible, standards?  After all, the law is for elitists and lesbian-lovers of all stripes, but a fine American working as a security guard for Paragon has something the law will never have:  common sense.  He knows a t-shirt that offends him when he sees it. 

More importantly, this was an American just trying to do his job.  Sure, he could have slacked off and let people with just any t-shirt into the Social Security office, but that would have resulted in anarchy.  He was vigilant.  He was decisive.  He saw a problem and dealt with it.  Isn’t that what Homeland Security is all about?  Protect us first and let the mortician sort out the details.

While northeasterners (such as myself) may be inured to the disgusting and pervasive threat of lesbian attacks upon Social Security, which will surely undermine the very fabric of our social security system and thereby threaten the welfare of millions of unemployed evangelicals, it’s time to stop lambasting the hard-working regular folk who do the dirty work of protecting our nation from moral carnage.

And be happy that Paragon Security didn’t arm its highly-trained personnel with tasers.

And if this isn’t enough of a reason to scrutinize the thought processes of those who believe that their personal view of morality present a hard basis for action to protect America from moral decay, consider this:  This fellow is allowed to vote.

Update:  I’ve just noticed that Randazza is no longer the solo Satyricon, but is now joined by the “Satyriconistas”.

Bonus Question:  The Satyriconistas are:

A.  A kick line of adult pin-up stars, all with the surname “Barbi”.
B.  The latest incarnation of Students for a Democratic Society.
C.  A hermaphroditic dance troupe of varying ages out of Boca Raton.
D.  Law students beguiled by the wonders of editorial comment and dirty talk.