Author Archives: SHG

Bad Thing to Say During Summation #3

From J-dog, the Minneapolis version of “NYPD Blue,” where two police officers were tried and convicted for having sticky fingers, this piece from the Minneapolis Post :


St. Paul Police Officer Timothy Rehak and another defendant, Mark Naylon, were found guilty this afternoon of the theft of $6,000 from a hotel room in November 2004. The money was taken in a sting operation set up by the FBI to test their integrity.

Now that the formalities are out of the way, let’s cut to the good stuff.  It’s time for closings.  The AUSA does a yeoman’s job, arguing that the “it was just a joke” defense was “ludircous”.  Paul Rogosheske, the attorney for Mark Nylon, “the man shown in the video tape putting the fingered $6,000 in his right pocket,” argues that every dollar was accounted for.  So far, all fairly pedestrian.

Finally, the second defense attorney, gets his turn at bat:



After the jury has had breaks between Marty and Rogosheske’s closing statements, all are seated and ready to hear the words of the loquacious Mr. Short.


His closing argument is dramatic, his voice rising to a shout at some points, and dropping to a whisper at others. The government has tried to put “round pegs in square holes and left splinters all over the courtroom,” he says. Flapping his long arms like a seagull headed out to sea, Short tells the jury that the defense lawyers could have “come in here and played cribbage for two weeks and the result would have been the same.” The government’s case doesn’t “make a lick of sense,” he says.


After an hour, Judge Patrick Schiltz cautions Short that it’s time to wrap it up. Short goes on for another 20 minutes until he gets to his grand finale:


“There is only one verdict you can return,” he tells the jury in a booming voice. “And that is GUILTY.”


“You mean ‘not guilty,’” Schiltz whispers to Short.


Oops. 

Initial Reactions to Sarah Palin (Update)

Like most people, I knew nothing about Sarah Palin until yesterday, beyond a slight familiarity with the sound of the name.  In the past day, the Governor of Alaska has become the focus of national scrutiny.  Republican strategists have pounded the talking points across the airways, while hosts and analysts have been cautious. 

Within minutes of John McCain’s announcement of his running mate, everything was abuzz.  His strategy was apparent: Bring in a hard right-wing woman and capture the hearts of disaffected Hillary supporters and evangelicals who see McCain as far too liberal for their tastes.

Since I’ve questioned Joe Biden’s bona fides within the niche of this blawg’s focus, it seems fair and appropriate to do the same for Ms. Palin.  Unfortunately, this is not to be, since Ms. Palin has no track record from which to discern her position on law, order and punishment. 

We know, thanks to Jonathon Adler at Volohk, that she wrote a New York Times Op-Ed opposing the listing of polar bears on the endangered species list.  I hear that she’s anti-abortion, a PTA mom and a lifetime NRA member.  Is this enough to speculate that she will follow the basic “tough on crime” agenda?  According to OntheIssues, this is Palin’s views on crime:




If legislature passed death penalty law, I would sign it


I support adequate funding for a strong public safety presence in Alaska. Feeling safe in our communities is something we cannot accept any compromise on. This includes policing in all its forms, the court system, prosecutors and corrections. If the legislature passed a death penalty law, I would sign it. We have a right to know that someone who rapes and murders a child or kills an innocent person in a drive by shooting will never be able to do that again.


Source: Campaign website, www.palinforgovernor.com, “Issues” Nov 7, 2006

A white-bread Republican position, strong on order based on fear of crime.  The only aspect that’s curious at all is her statement that “we have a right” to execute people.  Clearly, she is deeply concerned with rights.  Just not those of the people she would execute.



Since it’s only been a day since Sarah Palin’s name has been on the wagging tongues of so many, it’s premature to claim much of anything about her.  My suspicion is that the novelty of McCain having a woman on the ticket will wear off relatively soon, as it did when Geraldine Ferraro ran for VP.

The only question will turn out to be whether Sarah Palin, “a heartbeat away from the presidency,” is someone we would want with her finger on the button (note: this is an old cold war reference, with which the slackoisie may be unfamiliar), regardless of her sex.  Being deeply concerned with issues of latent sexism, this is how it should be.  Only when we remove sexist concerns can we see people as people.

In the case of John McCain, the qualifications of his number 2 may be more significant than for Obama, since odds are greater that he won’t make it through the full term.  He may be in robust health now, but he is old and there’s no way to ignore this fact. 

What is curious is that the primary thrust of McCain’s arguments against electing Barak Obama is that Obama lacks the experience to be President.  It would seem that he’s now blown that argument completely by taking in a governor of 18 months longevity in one of our more peculiar states.  Since people ultimately vote for the top of the ticket, not the bottom, this would seem an incredibly poor trade-off, giving away his best argument against Obama for a VP who will only bring in the staunchest of die-hard feminists, willing to sacrifice every iota of principle to put a woman into the Naval Observatory.  There may be some, but hardly enough to make it a good trade.

So while one should have deep concerns about Joe Biden’s somewhat schizophrenic views of criminal justice, at least he’s demonstrated a basic understanding of the issues and may be subject to thoughtful persuasion.  Sarah Palin, not so much. 

One thing that presents a very interesting question:  How does Joe Biden debate Sarah Palin?  No matter what he does, will it look like a bully beating up on a child?  Will he come off as a pedantic old man lecturing a recalcitrant schoolgirl?  

But the Presidency of the United States is bigger than just criminal justice issues, or even polar bears.  At the moment, there’s nothing to suggest that Sarah Palin has any thoughts and competencies at all.  But Laura Ingraham likes her a lot, and since she is one of the most nasty, despicable ignoramuses around, that tells me a lot.



Update:  Check out David Frum’s Diary from The National Review.  Therein lies the difference between honest, intelligent conservatism and the neocon crap that masquerades as thought to those who think twinkies are “darn tootin’ good.”

Brooklyn Lawyer Marina Tylo Deserves a Good Spanking

From the annals of the truly stupid comes this latest attempt to shut down a blawger.  Andrew Lavoott Bluestone at New York Attorney malpractice Blog posts about legal malpractice cases.  Andy’s approach is quite straight forward, providing salient facts without much by way of commentary.  Certainly nothing as snarky as here.

And what does he get for his efforts?  Sued! 

Last September, Andy posted about a malpractice case, Khlevner v. Tylo, in which the attorney, Marina Tylo, served a summons before purchasing the index number, which renders it defective.  So Tylo ends up the defendant in a legal malpractice suit.  The case was ultimately dismissed, not because Tylo didn’t screw up but because there was opportunity to undo the damage, thus leaving the plaintiff client without the necessary causation.

But Brooklyn lawyer Tylo apparently doesn’t like the fact that her name showed up in Andy’s blawg, letting anyone with access to Google know that she’s slightly less than perfect.  So the  case  in which plaintiff’s attorney served a summons before buying the index number. Khlevner v. Tylo, 10733/07 

I kid you not.  This is the entirety of her claimed defamation.

Now it’s one thing to get a passing mention in an attorney malpractice blawg for having screwed up on the purchase of an index number, but it’s another entirely to think she’s going to scare off another lawyer with lunacy like this.  If Tylo was worried before about her reputation, she should have given that some far deeper thought before pulling such a ridiculous, bone-headed move like this. 

For those non-lawyer bloggers who harbor fears that someone is going to go after them no matter how frivolous the claim, and thus put them to the expense and aggravation of having to defend some piece of utter idiocy like Tylo’s, the good news is that Tylo has left her flank wide open for a good spanking on the counterclaim for this, and Andrew Lavoott Bluestone is just the lawyer to give it to her.

While our legal system allows any moron with a word processor and the price of an index number (or maybe not, if you happen to be like Tylo) to start a lawsuit, that doesn’t mean that they’re going to have their way. 

And if the rest of the blawgosphere feels similarly, then let’s make sure that those inclined to try to use the courts to shut blawgers down and keep lawyers’ screw-up as their dirty little secret, learn that such vapid efforts to undermine speech in the blawgosphere is going to backfire on them.  Perhaps Tylo will regret her decision to try to silence Bluestone as her misbegotten effort spreads across the internet.

The Hidden Purpose Behind Law Enforcement Advertising

Shawn Matlock has been busy while the rest of the legal nation spent its time staring at the TV screen hoping to see a wardrobe malfunction at the Democratic National Convention.


We have all seen the billboards around that read “Drink. Drive. Go to jail.”  For the longest time, I just assumed this was standard scare-tactic propaganda used to frighten people away from ever drinking and driving.

I thought these billboards were aimed simply at scaring the uninformed populace to change their “law-breaking” ways. If someone saw the enormous billboard and read that, maybe they would think twice about hitting the road after having that beer with their Mexican food. That’s the point, isn’t it? Well, I’m not sure it really is.

But as the bow-tied blawger formerly known as Young Shawn recognized, there is a latent, and far more insidious affect.


Not too long ago, I had a conversation with my father about some federal case I had where there were some complex search and seizure issues. I tried to explain to my twenty-ninth generation Texan, former rodeo cowboy, straight-talking father that the government can’t actually just walk into your house and seize everything on a hunch. To my dismay, he apparently assumed the government could.

During the middle of the conversation, my father interrupted me to state very matter-of-factly that “If you drink and drive, you go to jail. End of story.”

Shawn was shocked that his father would have swallowed this hype, lock, stock and barrel.  After wiping the drool from his mouth, Shawn tried to explain to his father that this was a cute little advertising slogan, but it wasn’t the law.  Dad wasn’t buying.

It was in the midst of defining intoxication that Shawn had the epiphany that while these slogans and billboards might have no impact on people inclined to have a few for the road, they had a great impact on everyone else.  This advertising served not merely to put offenders on notice, but to firmly plant the idea in the minds of the public (also known as potential jurors) of what the law is, even though it isn’t the law.  But they don’t know that.

If Shawn’s right, then it’s a brilliant plan.  Try undoing this brainwashing with some quick instructions at trial, when the public has spent years seeing, and believing, that the law is simple and clear. 

Maybe we need to come up with some cute slogans of our own to counteract these advertising campaigns?  Like, “No more than three and you get home Scot-free?”   I hate the that phrase. 

Dismissal for Government Interference with Right to Counsel Affirmed by Second Circuit

Via Berman, the 2d Circuit has affirmed Judge Lewis Kaplan’s dismissal in U.S. v. Stein, better known as the KPMG case.  This was the case where the government threatened KPMG to stop funding the legal defense of its employees in a case that involved 22 million documents.  Naturally, the defendants couldn’t possibly mount a meaningful defense on their own without the assistance of KPMG, and you know how much the government hates a fair fight.


Defendants were indicted based on a fairly novel theory of criminal liability; they faced substantial penalties; the relevant facts are scattered throughout over 22 million documents regarding the doings of scores of people,; the subject matter is “extremely complex,”; technical expertise is needed to figure out and explain what happened; and trial was expected to last between six and eight months, As Judge Kaplan found, these defendants “have been forced to limit their defenses . . . for economic reasons and . . . they would not have been so constrained if KPMG paid their expenses.” We therefore hold that these defendants were also deprived of their right to counsel under the Sixth Amendment.

While one might think that this affirmance was a given under the egregious circumstances of this case and the heavy-handed government action to deny the defendants the ability to fight, Judge Kaplan’s dismissal at the District Court level was a huge step forward in the protection of the defendants and a major smack in the government’s kisser.  This was by no means a slam-dunk.

It’s hardly unusual in the Southern District of New York to have white collar prosecutions that involve voluminous paper, require a great deal of technical expertise and involve many witnesses.  Even defendants possessed of some wealth find themselves unable to afford an attorney for these cases, the cost of which can be quite high.  And not everyone has a corporation willing to front the fees, as here.

The government figured they had these guys by the throat, despite its novel theory, by attrition alone.  If they can’t afford to defend, then there’s nothing left but a plea.  When KPMG stepped into the breach, however, it ruined the government’s plans, since KPMG had the wherewithal to finance a vigorous defense. 

Since the kids down at 1 St. Andrews Plaza aren’t used to not getting their way, the next step was to take the fight to KPMG and let them know that financing the defendants legal fees was tantamount to mass murder as far as they were concerned.  This is where they cross the line for Judge Kaplan.

What’s interesting about this case is that it stands in stark contrast to the Circuit’s decisions on right to counsel otherwise, where the 2d Circuit has carved out more exceptions than anywhere else.  For example, the Circuit has approved the government’s pre-trial seizure of funds for forfeiture, which serves to deny the defendant the ability to retain counsel, creating a self-fulfilling prophesy.  Similarly, a defendant can be denied counsel of choice, even when he has the ability to retain him, based upon claims of conflict by the government, “for the protection of the defendant.”  Both of these rules allow the government to take affirmative steps to impair the defendant’s right to counsel, despite the fact that the defendant has yet to be convicted of anything (and hence is presumed innocent) and defendant’s choice of counsel.

So the affirmance here is a significant shift.  In this instance, Judge Kaplan’s dismissal, and the Circuit’s affirmance, are directed toward the government’s abuse of power to strip the defendant’s of a chance to fight.  It’s good to see the court concern itself with the government’s abuse, since it could just as easily have been rationalized away as it has 100 times before.

Master Conspirator Eugene over at Volokh has done a thoughtful analysis of the decision, and believes that the court arrived at the right conclusion.  He states:


Constitutional rights generally (with some exceptions not applicable here) include the rights to pay for what it takes to exercise the right — to pay for counsel, advertising space, private schooling, contraceptives, abortion, and the like.

While I agree wholeheartedly, it simply hasn’t been the case in the Second Circuit previously, where some rhetorical gymnastics are usually more than sufficient to tout the right while allowing the government to emasculate its exercise.  It doesn’t take much slight of hand to justify the legitimacy of the government’s interference, and the Circuit hasn’t been particularly reluctant to do so.

But there is one notable difference between US v. Stein and the prior cases:  These white collar defendants were with KPMG, a renown accounting firm.  Anybody want to guess the nature of the cases, and the defendants, in the Second Circuit’s prior decisions?  Sniff.

Trust Me, I’m from the Government

I tried my best not to get sucked into this blogversation, but I’m weak.  So here it goes.

Mark Bennett, the Texas Tornado, prodded by a query by prosecutorial blog Western Justice, contrasted with an old post by PD turned private turned PD again, Blonde Justice, has decided to address the WJ’s question,  “why would someone wait until trial to show the prosecutor exculpatory information like that?” 



Tactically, the criminal defense lawyer has to decide whether, and when, to reveal his NLSes [Nasty Little Surprises] to maximum effect. Some NLSes might be bombshells that will change the outcome of a trial (like the “complainant” swearing that the crime didn’t happen), and some might be less earthshaking revelations that might affect the outcome of a trial. The former might, if revealed before trial, convince the trustworthy prosecutor to dismiss outright even what he believed to be a whale. The latter might shift the tone of negotiations and convince him to offer a more favorable plea agreement, or dismiss the case that he had doubts about before.


The Defense should (as The Blonde illustrates) not reveal either kind of NLS to an untrustworthy prosecutor.


But this would have been too simple had my other brother Gideon not decided to join in.  But he did, in a well-titled post called “Do you gamble?”  And while Bennett and Blonde prefer the surprise attack, Gideon is more cautious:


When a jury of six or twelve is sitting in that box, watching every move, evaluating every word that comes out of every witnesses mouth (and the lawyers’ too), then it’s always a gamble. Do you have the perfect factual defense? Maybe, but who the hell knows what juries do. Do you want to take that risk?

I think, for the most part, if you have the exculpatory information that should result in a dismissal, you should try and utilize it pre-trial. After all, that too is part of our jobs as criminal defense attorneys.

Everyone agrees that these generalizations are subject to the particular circumstances of the case, ranging from the trustworthiness of the prosecutor to the strength of the exculpatory evidence.  But that said, ceteris parabus, what to do?

Gideon’s point, that if something goes awry in the execution of the “Perry Mason Moment,” the whole thing blows up in the defense’s face, is well taken.  I’ve seen far too many trials where lawyers thought they had things under control, only to have some unanticipated intervening event blow what they thought was a sweet gig.  If things go south, and somehow the big bang evidence loses some of its big bang, the result could be disaster for the defense.

On the other hand, Bennett’s and Blonde’s point that some prosecutors can’t be trusted to do the right thing, and if you show them your hand, will do whatever they can to undermine or circumvent your evidence, is similarly true.  In deference to Westy’s point, since it’s up to the prosecutor to make the call whether to toss the case in light of new evidence, it puts an awful lot of power and trust in the hands of someone with adverse interests and a significantly different perspective.  Most defense lawyers have been burned by prosecutors who are trustworthy, but in their own eyes only.

Addressing Bennett’s dichotomy of big bang exculpatory evidence from little bang stuff, the former being the sort that will blow the case out of the water, and the latter being helpful but not quite overwhelming, it seems clear that giving the prosecution a heads-up on little bang stuff is tantamount to malpractice.  If it’s not of the sort that will convince a prosecutor to toss a case, then there is no choice but to keep it to yourself.  Anything else would be foolish.

As to the big bang stuff, my reaction depends on whether the defense has it completely locked up or whether the prosecution can find a way to spoil your moment if it knows about it ahead of time.  I agree with Gideon that if it can effectively used before trial, without risking the defendant’s case at trial, then there is an obligation to try and avoid the trial.  After all, even when you think you’ve got the big bang locked up, trials are still trials, and nobody ever knows how they play out.

Key to all of this is a real assessment of the strength of your evidence, even more so than your trust of the prosecutor.  A trustworthy prosecutor still has an obligation to his job to circumvent your proof if he believes it susceptible to challenge.  He may be trustworthy, but don’t assume that he won’t do his job if he still believes the defendant guilty.  Remember, the prosecutor sees the glass half empty, no matter how you see the glass.

On the other hand, if the big bang evidence is as strong as you believe it to be, and of the sort that will compel a dismissal, then there should be little risk to revealing it to even the most untrustworthy prosecutor.  He may refuse to dismiss, and may try to circumvent the evidence at trial, but that’s where your honest assessment of its strength comes in.  If its that strong, it should be immune from prosecutorial shenanigans.  If it isn’t immune, it may not be nearly as big a bombshell as you think.

All in all, it’s a balancing act, taking into account all of the factors that have already been discussed.  But no matter how tempting the “Perry Mason Moment,” and no matter how cool it is to watch the prosecutor fall on the floor, sobbing and writhing, as his case crumbles, our duty is to the defendant first, and we must put our desire to cause prosecutorial paroxysms aside in the best interests of the defense.






Three Ponies is Enough for Anybody

Michael Strahan, one of the stars of the New York Football Giants (who won the Superbowl last year, I might add), is on a streak.  From law.com,

Former New York Giants defensive end Michael Strahan on Tuesday won his appeal from an $18,000-a-month child support obligation imposed in his 2006 divorce, which a New Jersey appellate court found both exorbitant and unfairly apportioned against him.

The decision focused on two issues.  The Court held that the award below improperly ignored the fact that Jean Strahan was a college-educated woman who was capable of working but chose not to, thus shifting the support burden to Michael while Jean got a free ride.

The panel also agreed that income should be imputed to Jean Strahan, who decided not to work even though she held two college degrees, a previous career and “employment opportunities [that] were, in all likelihood, enhanced by her celebrity marriage.”

“There is no question that as a healthy, educated, forty-one year-old, defendant is capable of earning her own income,” added Parker, directing that on remand, the trial court should consider all possible sources of Jean Strahan’s income — earned and unearned — as well as her assets in determining her share of support.

As noted by Mike at C&F, this holding is quite extraordinary, as being a man in a child support proceeding is the only position in the law worse than a defendant in a criminal prosecution.

But New Jersey Appellate Division Judge Lorraine Parker, writing for the panel, went on to raise a rule that was new to me.  Judge Parker referred to

the Kansas “Three Pony Rule,” which states that “‘no child, no matter how wealthy the parents, needs to be provided [with] more than three ponies.'” (quoting In re Patterson, 920 P.2d 450, 455 (Kan. App. 1996)).

Though applied to the needs of a child, this should be a life rule for all of us, along the lines of not eating anything bigger than your head.  To appreciate its application here, consider what was claimed as necessary to support the Strahan children:

Those “needs,” wrote Appellate Division Judge Lorraine Parker, included the children giving their nanny a 10-day vacation in Jamaica; diamond jewelry for their grandmother; $30,000 yearly for landscaping expenses; $36,000 a year for “equipment and furnishings”; and $3,000 yearly for audio visual equipment. Jean set their clothing needs at $27,000 a year, since the children needed new outfits every time they saw their father and one of them demanded a new purse every time she left the house.

“[T]he court made no distinction between what needs were reasonable, given the age of the children, and what simply amounted to a ‘fourth pony,'” wrote Parker, who was joined by Judges Rudy Coleman and Thomas Lyons.

Frankly, I’ve seen far worse, perhaps best described as the tenth or twentieth ponies.  Perhaps the expectations of Manhattan power children are greater than those of New Jersey kids.  After all, you can’t get much haute couture for the kiddies at $27,000 a year.  That would barely keep them in Manolos for Children .

But the notion that three ponies are enough for any child is quite fascinating.  Why only children?  One of the questions asked over and over is when does someone have “enough”?  We look at top level corporate, Wall Street and Biglaw salaries and perks, and wonder what was so special that they warranted a multi-multi-million=dollar bonus.  Why so much?  When is it enough?

I’m not questioning the capitalist right to make as much money as possible, but rather why anyone would need to pay out that much to anyone.  How much does it take to motivate top talent?

What’s fascinating about this rule is that no person can ride more than one pony at a time, meaning that the second and third ponies are excessive from the outset.  The rule gives latitude to excess, with the second pony reflecting a degree of wealth and privilege, and third distinguishing significant wealth from more ordinary wealth.  But at the point where the child can flaunt the third pony, leaving no doubt as to the great wealth he enjoys, enough is enough.

As applied to child support, the point is that the parent’s wealth reaches a point where a simple percentage provides support that is so excessive to the child’s needs and lifestyle that it can no longer be justified.  Certainly this is true, as the needs of a child of a wealthy parent do not increase simply because the parent’s income does.

But this also has meaning to the wealthy parent.  Does anyone need more than three ponies?

Controlling the Rabble Outside (Update)

Major party conventions are a wonderful staged affair, where all surprise is removed by the release of scheduled spontaneous actions to the media.  It would be awful if the media failed to cover a well-choreographed spontaneous moment.  No one would get to see it and be filled with the majesty of American politics.

But as this paean to politics proceeds with precision, there is messy business going on outside.  While the official game of politics is played inside, the unofficial show of Americans disappointed with the game happens in the streets, blocks away within an area delineated by fences, barricades and polices officers charged with not letting unofficial voices disrupt the wonderful staged affair.

Jon Katz of Underdog raised this issue in a comment, and offers a great post about it.  Jon explains the reasons why some people are disenchanted with the official system, which covers the full spectrum of political thought, provided one has a very narrow perspective.  I’m not sure that it’s something that requires much explanation. 

Major political parties are far more similar than different, and never stray from the mainstream of political ideology.  Regardless of whether one agrees with the party platform, Americans have both the right, and the historical duty, to raise their disagreements with those in power.  It is our birthright to question and challenge politicians and parties when we believe that they are failing to serve our Country.

And so it happens in Denver.



The difference is that those Americans who lack a tag around their neck issued by the official party are relegated to being treated like cattle, with armed police keeping them in check lest they disturb the official celebration. 

There are few scenarios more ironic than this juxtaposition of the officially sanctioned political dog and pony show and the gulag-like treatment of Americans who think outside the official parameters.  This is not a phenomenon of the Republicans or the Democrats, but one of those in power and those whose voices annoy those in power.

Most Americans will view the rabble in the cattle pens as malcontents, unworthy of being taken seriously and just a perpetual disruption to the steady grinding of normal politics.  Of course, most Americans are lemmings, carefully drawing within the lines lest their picture appear messy and the teacher be upset with them.  Not only are they incapable of connecting the actions of outside protesters to our American ideals of free speech and political activism, but they find the chaos that follows abhorrent.  They claim to love this Country, while loving order more.

When these malcontents stray too far, they are brought to protester court, according to Anne Skove at Court-o-Rama.  The host city to a convention is as clear that the malcontents will show as they about the delegates, and Denver has prepared well for those who won’t comply with their official directives.  This is why the outsiders are surrounded by police in riot gear while the official stage show relies primarily on colorful balloons to keep people happy. 

But the irony is not complete until the official delegates get the opportunity to sneak outside the “big tent” and enjoy the host city a bit.  No, they don’t wander over to the rabble to listen to their views and ask themselves why the major political parties prefer milquetoast to beef, why they all want so desperately to be as close to the middle of the road as they can be.  They go to parties.

Michelle Chen at Viewsday posts about the wonderful shindigs designed to educate the official party delegates.  Major corporations throw major bashes for major party delegates.  Their “voices” are heard, amid the caviar and champagne.  In fact, even some delegates and media are deems unworthy of entrance to these very exclusive parties.  This largess is only intended for the ears (and stomaches) of most important delegates.

While the official machines of American politics plays out its well orchestrated stage show for the adoring fans back home, and while the important delegates stray long enough to listen to the concerns of major corporations, the rabble remains penned like cattle, under armed police control, with a special court all their own should they exercise their rights with too much vigor.

Regardless of whether you prefer the orderly show put on by the major political party to the chaos of the rabble, the convention presents a great opportunity to see American politics play out.  But before you condemn the rabble as mere malcontents, unworthy of having their voices heard and properly herded behind distant barricades by armed police, ask yourselves where Thomas Jefferson and James Madison would have stood had the convention been called by George III.

You don’t have to agree with anything the rabble has to say, but their voices are every bit as worthy as those of the delegates in the official stage show.  Maybe the convention would have greater relevance if there was more disruption and fewer well-planned spontaneous moments.  Maybe we’ve missed the whole boat on the meaning of democracy.  But man, those political parties sure know how to put on a show.

Update:  It appears that a clash of “parties” resulted in ABC News Producer Asa Eslocker being arrested while trying to film Dem Biggies and their donors at one of those special educational parties at the Brown Palace Hotel. 


A cigar-smoking Denver police sergeant, accompanied by a team of five other officers, first put his hands on Eslocker’s neck, then twisted the producer’s arm behind him to put on handcuffs.

A police official later told lawyers for ABC News that Eslocker is being charged with trespass, interference, and failure to follow a lawful order. He also said the arrest followed a signed complaint from the Brown Palace Hotel.


Eslocker was on the public sidewalk outside the hotel when he was forced into the street by a cop, who later has this public menace by the throat.  Naturally, he was charged with disobeying a lawful order.  But the situation was caught on video.

Clearly, if the Denver cops have so little fear for manhandling a network news producer, the rabble better watch their butts.

H/T Turley

Attack of the Killer Breasts (Updated)

Following a discussion last evening with a friend, who is of the view that any action taken by the government to facilitate his personal safety is justified, comes this story via Boing Boing.



A large-breasted woman flying from Oakland to Boston was accosted by the TSA when the underwire in her bra set off the magnetometer. She was given a choice: allow her breasts to be fondled or give up on flying. Instead, she raised a stink:



Kates asked to see a supervisor and then the supervisor’s supervisor. He told her that underwire bras were the leading item that set off the metal detectors, Kates said.

If that’s the case, Kates said, the equipment must be overly sensitive. And if the TSA is engaging in extra brassiere scrutiny, then other women are suffering similar humiliation, Kates thought.

The Constitution bars unreasonable searches and seizures, Kates reminded the TSA supervisor, and scrutinizing a woman’s brassiere is surely unreasonable, she said.

The supervisor told her she had the choice of submitting to a pat-down in a private room or not flying. Kates offered a third alternative, to take off her bra and try again, which the TSA accepted.


To proclaim this ridiculous is far too easy.  Like folks with metal pins in their legs, or plates in their skull, we now add large-breasted women to the list of people who are placed in an untenable position at the airport security checkpoint.  But it’s people like my friend who are happy to argue that it’s the “price of freedom.”  Only people like my friend are never the people who have to pay the price.  Funny how that happens.

One reaction was to suggest that women who wear underwire bas go braless to avoid the problem.  I’m unclear whether this falls under capitulation or appeasement, but either way this strikes me as the wrong answer.  The idea of always taking the path of least resistance rather than buck the system stinks.  This whole airport security scam is out of control, but targeting large-breasted women with the choice of allowing themselves to be subject to a physical search or forced out of their underwear is just too bizarre.  Where are the family values crowd when it comes to TSA workers copping a feel?

At what point does this stop?  Full body cavity search, perhaps?  Maybe then my friend will feel differently about things. 

Update:  Anne Skove, taking a break from promoting judicial economy over at Court-o-rama, sent over this Washington Post piece, dated December 10, 2004.  As time goes by…


Many passengers think it is worth the effort to find shoes and clothing that will help them avoid added scrutiny at the airport checkpoint. Travelers who set off the walk-through magnetometer are automatically pulled aside, and a screener waves a hand-held metal detector over their body. Then, the screener conducts a physical pat-down search to check for hidden explosives or other prohibited items. The pat-downs have become more common since September, when two Russian planes exploded after two women allegedly brought explosives on board.

Is it still worth it?

“Just Trying to Help” May Cost 15 Years

From Above the Law, this story from the Salt Lake Tribune about the homicide prosecution of a Candice Collard for the death of 14 year old Jess “Micade” Horrocks, who died of alcohol poisoning:


On April 12, Horrocks and some other teenagers were drinking hard liquor in a Vernal parking lot, said Uintah County Deputy Attorney Greg Lamb. Horrocks chugged so much booze he became unresponsive and someone called Collard, 24, for help, Lamb said. 

Lamb said people had to lift Horrocks into a car. But instead of taking Horrocks to a hospital or to his parents, Lamb said, Collard drove him to her home in Jensen, 13 miles away. 

Another adult found Horrocks to be unresponsive in the house at about midnight, Lamb said, and the adult called 911. The next day, Horrocks was ruled to be brain dead, disconnected from life support and died.

According to the prosecution, who admittedly have taken a “novel approach” to this case, Collard’s “inaction” was the cause of Horrocks’ death.

I’m not suggesting that Collard handled the situation well, but there was nothing about her effort that demonstrated anything beyond simple negligence.  For her efforts, she now faces homicide charges.  This is the latest in the trend toward the compulsion to create a crime whenever a bad outcome occurs. 

The death of Horrocks, by any measure, is a tragedy.  No 14 years old should die, and especially not this way.  But a tragic death doesn’t mean that someone has to pay.  Tragedy can happen without any crime being committed.  Whether there is civil liability is another matter, but Collard is facing 15 years for having tried to help, even if her choice was poor.


The charge seems especially harsh given that Utah has a criminal statute for failure to render aid. Uintah [sic] County Deputy Attorney Greg Lamb said that the homicide charge was warranted because Collard “failed miserably in several areas that could have prevented [Horrocks’s] death.”

So the lesson here is to refuse to help, lest a bad decision puts someone at risk of homicide?  That’s certainly not going to provide an incentive to do the right thing.   Most jurisdictions have “good samaritan” laws designed to encourage people to help, and protecting them from liability for their decisions. 

No doubt this tragic story brought cries from the public that someone’s head must roll when a 14 year old dies.  And obviously the Utah County prosecutor heard the pleas.  It would be nice to think that a judge will toss this case as quickly as possible, but it would take an awfully secure judge to do so.