Author Archives: SHG

Naked Co-Ed Lawprof Mud-Wrestling

Fortunately, no pictures.

The other day,  Orin asked why nobody reads Slate’s new blog, Convictions.  He used other words, but that’s what he meant.

So I took a look around Convictions today, just for kicks.  Man, those lawprofs are going after each other in that collegial way that only lawprofs can.  They’re smacking each other around like crazy.  Name calling, b-slapping, jello wrestling, you name it.

I’m serious.  Check this out,  Marty Lederman’s smackdown at Eric Posner :


With all respect, I think that post really is beyond the pale.

And that’s just the first line!  It’s like wild animal at the zoo day over there.

So what did Posner do to deserve this vicious attack?

Few pleasures are more intense than that of contemplating one’s ideological opponents being punished for their errors, an activity that we law professors have so far been able to indulge only in our fantasies. 

Indulge in their FANTASIES!!!!!  Gag me.  This is what gets lawprofs all hot and bothered?  Ewwww.

Check it out.  But remember, it doesn’t get any grittier than this.

John Stossel, American Patriot

So he’s no intellectual, but John Stossel has his finger on the pulse of America.  In this  Wall Street Journal Op-Ed (courtesy of Overlawyered), Stossel explains why lawyers are parasites:


Foes of lawsuit abuse have been writing gleefully about the fall of Dickie Scruggs, Bill Lerach and Melvyn Weiss. All three lawyers are likely to spend time in jail for plotting to bribe a judge (Scruggs) or paying kickbacks (Lerach and Weiss).

Good riddance.


Locking them up will stop them from further damaging America – at least for a few years. But it’s a small victory for reformers.


New members of the parasite circus will just step forward to take their place. And what these aggressive class-action and securities lawyers do legally is more damaging to America than the crimes that Scruggs, Lerach and Weiss committed. They broke laws to cheat other lawyers out of some loot, but at least that barely hurt the public.


It’s not entirely clear at this point whether Stossel knows that none of this has anything to do with lawsuit abuse, but the guy’s on a roll and there’s no stopping him now.

But at least paying off plaintiffs honestly reflects how such lawyers get rich. Often, they are less “officers of the court seeking justice” than businessmen colluding with plaintiffs in a lucrative extortion business. Legal extortion. But still extortion. Companies pay the lawyers to go away even when it’s unclear that they did anything wrong.

Once companies pay, it’s logical that the plaintiff/partner who helped the lawyers enrich themselves should get a cut of that loot. That’s a fairer deal than what typical plaintiffs in class actions get: coupons or a check for perhaps $1.26.

So now he’s got Mel Weiss and Lerach on the ropes.  Here it comes…


A federal judge will soon decide whether to award Lerach his cut of what may be the biggest class-action legal fee ever. Lerach extorted – I mean persuaded – J.P. Morgan, Citigroup and a Canadian bank to give $695 million to him and other lawyers who claimed the banks were culpable in the Enron debacle. On March 19, 2007 an appellate court ruled that the banks were not culpable. But so what? Fairness doesn’t necessarily govern this game. The game is more about rounding up lots of complainants and using America’s one-sided legal system to terrorize businesses into settling

Companies could fight and win, but that distracts managers from what they ought to be doing. And they might get a bad jury and lose the entire company. It’s safer to settle.

We’re a nation of distracted managers?  That explains a lot, now doesn’t it.  Maybe if we gave those managers Ritalin, they could focus better and then companies could fight and win these frivolous lawsuits.  Did anybody think of that?


Our legal system invites lawyers to act like bullies. For “20/20” tonight, I report on a class-action lawyer who’s suing his neighbor for smoking in her own apartment. Toxins are “being breathed every day by our 4-year-old,” says Jonathan Selbin of Lieff, Cabraser, Heimann & Bernstein. His frightened neighbor had the apartment manager seal off air ducts between the two apartments, but Mr. Selbin sued anyway, claiming smoke was in the hallway. Mr. Selbin’s neighbor was unusually feisty in going to the media to fight back, at least for a while. But last night, she decided to settle. After all, Mr. Selbin had written her that he had a legal advantage, because he and his wife “are both lawyers, and both litigators, for whom the usual barriers to litigation are minimal.” Right. Mr. Selbin wrote ABC, “I have recovered more than $2 billion in cash for consumers defrauded by companies. I am proud of what I do.” He wouldn’t tell us how much of the $2 billion he kept.

What’s the $2 billion got to do with suing his neighbor?  Wait, I know. This is about the outrage of using the courts, a bludgeon in the hands of a lawyer, to resolve a dispute.  Outrageous!


What do we get from this kind of “private law enforcement”? Very little. James Copland of the Manhattan Institute points out, “The small, diversified investor is as likely to be a buyer as a seller and thus a payer in a class action settlement. The ‘little guy’ pays money to himself.” Actually, it’s worse than that: Little guys come out behind because the lawyers pocket so much.

But John, you were talking about the outrage of Selbin suing his neighbor for smoking.  What’s that got to do with class action settlements?


If securities class actions really deterred fraud, their high cost might be justified. But research from St. John’s Law School Prof. Michael Perino shows that most of these lawsuits follow SEC investigations. The lawyers don’t unearth frauds. They come in like vultures after the problem is already revealed. We pay for that.

Didn’t you just say that the investor pays himself for the lawsuit?  Now I’m confused.  And I don’t think that’s exactly what lawprof Perino concluded, though it’s hard to say since you could be looking at a different study than this one.  So let’s wrap it up already, John.


Onerous as the legal fees are, the nastier cost is the loss of so many good things. Weiss’s former firm got companies to pay $45 billion in damages. That’s $45 billion that will not create new jobs or life-saving drugs. 

The fear also reduces options. After Dickie Scruggs filed his post-Katrina class action against insurance companies, State Farm, citing an “untenable legal environment,” stopped insuring homes in Mississippi. 

America needs judges willing to say “no” to legal bullies. America also needs the legal standard that works in most of the world: “loser pays.” Without reform, the parasites will take away your money and your choices.

Thank God we have heroes like corporate America to protect us from the evils of lawyer-bullies.  And thank you, John, for clearing all this up.  I know it was a lot of work, and I sure hope you didn’t sprain anything.

Bad Business Is A Crime

As Enron CEO  Jeffrey Skilling’s appeal comes under scrutiny, and the flames of passion have died down, a different view is emerging toward “corporate criminals.” Maybe, just maybe, they aren’t exactly criminals, but businesspeople who did a lousy job and made some bad decisions.

In a great article, Criminalizing Capitalism, Nicole Gelinas dissects why the efforts to prevent these corporate criminals from ever taking over again has resulted in the next great failure, the subprime mortgage crisis, and will continue to fail.

It wasn’t supposed to be this way. After Enron imploded six years ago, Congress and President Bush enacted the Sarbanes-Oxley law, which aimed to reform corporate practices and prevent future market surprises. The law imposed new regulations on corporations and their executives, as well as new criminal sanctions for corporate wrongdoing under both the new law and existing ones. “How can you measure the value of knowing that company books are sounder than they were before?” asked sponsor Michael Oxley, defending the law. “Of no more overnight bankruptcies with the employees and retirees left holding the bag? No more disruption to entire sectors of the economy?”

But in the end, Sarbanes-Oxley has just made it easier for ambitious government attorneys to criminalize bad business judgment and complex accounting in hindsight. Further, in their focus on strengthening legal enforcement, the feds have passed up opportunities to create commonsense protections for investors. Worse still, the government has instilled investors with false confidence by implying that they can rely on prosecutors, not prudence, to protect their market holdings. Now the housing and mortgage meltdown—which could hurt the economy far more than Enron did—is reminding investors that no law or regulation can protect them from economic disruption.

According to common wisdom, Enron’s crash had to reflect criminal conduct.  It was impossible for so much harm to be cause otherwise.  Or so it seemed. 


Enron was actually an example of how markets work—messily, sometimes tardily, but in the end with ruthless efficiency.

In the year before the crash, Enron stock lost half its value on Wall Street.


When Enron declared bankruptcy in December 2001, the regulators were left only to certify the market’s verdict. Those investors and lenders who hadn’t scrutinized the company lost money, as they should have

In other words, it was a business failure, available for all to see if they cared to look.


Though Enron didn’t signal a market failure, it was a business failure, of course. The company overvalued its assets while undervaluing its liabilities—the oldest trick in the fraud book but also sometimes an honest mistake. In the 1930s, Samuel Insult, a utility entrepreneur who created the modern power grid, did the same thing; so did savings and loan banks in the 1980s. Enron’s chief financial officer, Andy Fastow, did it by vastly overstating the company’s assets and hiding liabilities, such as off-the-books sums owed to outside “investment partnerships” (he stole cash on the side, too). It was easy for Enron to perform accounting hocus-pocus because many of its assets, such as a one-of-a-kind power plant in India and speculative broadband ventures, were difficult to value. Enron’s assets were worth what Enron said they were—until the market decided otherwise. 

Young prosecutors, armed with laws like SOX that criminalize bad calls unless outsiders are equally inept in approving the bad calls, view big business as an exact science.  It’s not entirely their fault, since business likes to pretend that it has a clue what it’s doing, rather than the very overpriced mom and pop shop run by the fortunate son who thinks his every whim is a stroke of capitalist brilliance.  This is bolstered by a cadre of Wall Street jargoneers, who similarly pretend that they have a clue.


Wall Street prosecutions weren’t born with Sarbanes-Oxley. As prominent white-collar defense attorney Stan Arkin says, prestigious law firms regarded criminal-defense practices as unsavory 40 years ago, but the increased threat of white-collar prosecutions eventually led almost all of them to offer such services. Many in the financial world first understood the acute risks in the 1980s, when Rudy Giuliani—then the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of New York, which includes Wall Street—ordered three investment bankers arrested in their offices or homes, one of them in handcuffs, on suspicion of insider trading, though two of the three cases against them were later dropped

And so, under the ever-watchful eye of our savior, St. Rudy of the TV Cameras (and now an important criminal defense lawyer), the spectacle of white collar crime became the solution to the vagaries of business.

After discussing the advantages that the law and courts have given prosecutors in “white collar prosecutions,” because of the perceived complexities of unearthing evidence and understanding how businesses engage in their “conspiracies” (better known as board meetings), Gelinas writes:


Contrary to popular perception and despite millions of documents, the feds had no smoking-gun evidence against Enron chiefs Jeff Skilling and Ken Lay. The two men, each of whom served as CEO at times during the company’s final two years, faced charges that included conspiring to conceal Enron’s true financial state before it collapsed and, in Skilling’s case, selling company shares using information about that conspiracy.

But in court, any complex accounting is suspect. “They were accountants,” said juror Freddy Delgado of some witnesses. “They mumbled, and I didn’t know anything about what they talked about.” Further, prosecutors pressed companies and people to cooperate who might otherwise have cleared up what Skilling and Lay knew about that accounting. Banks like CIBC and Merrill Lynch, which participated in Enron’s financing, reached deals with the government that kept employees from testifying for the defense.

And so, a new field of crime was born and came to maturity.  The crime, of course, was pretending that these men at the top of the corporate food chain knew what they were doing, when the truth was that they were treading water as hard as they could to make it seem that they had everything under control.  They did this to satisfy the Wall Street analysts, who were similarly pretending that they understood what was going on with the company, to pretend that they could offer some intelligent assessment when they got a spot on the morning cable business report with the Money Honey.

But the truth could be found in the jury room:

After the trial, it became clear that some jurors didn’t even understand what they had convicted the two defendants of doing. Describing how he had reached the guilty verdict, Delgado said: “To say you didn’t know what was going on in your own company was not the right thing.” Another juror, Dana Fernandez, said that if Lay and Skilling “didn’t know, they should have found out somehow what was going on.” But the burden of the government’s case was to prove beyond reasonable doubt that Lay and Skilling had engineered a conspiratorial fraud. If they didn’t know about the conspiracy—regardless of whether they should have known about it—the jury should have found them not guilty.

A guilty verdict, but the truth is that no one in the courtroom really had any understanding of what was done and why it was criminal.  They understood that it didn’t work, and that seemed to be a bad thing, even something that made the defendants prison-worthy, but they couldn’t tell you why.  That, in a nutshell, is the sad secret of white collar crime.


The worst thing about criminalizing what should often be civil regulatory matters is that it creates a false sense of security for investors, who may think that aggressive prosecutions protect them from losses. Disclosure—even if it’s slow and imperfect—is still their best protection. “We find little evidence that public enforcement benefits stock markets, but strong evidence that laws mandating disclosure and facilitating private enforcement through liability rules benefit stock markets,” observed Dartmouth business professor Rafael La Porta, University of Amsterdam professor Florencio Lopez-de-Silanes, and Harvard professor Andrei Shleifer in a recent Journal of Finance study.

And this is what it’s all about, from SOX to prosecutions.  Giving the investing public a sense of false security that when things go horribly wrong, it’s because of criminals and not just lousy business people making bad decisions with other people’s money.

Every time our economy faces another disaster, heads will necessarily roll and prosecutors profiles will rise as the heroes of the great unwashed.  We want so badly to believe that business really knows what it’s doing, that Wall Street isn’t a total scam, that we can invest our money in the American economy and still sleep at night, unless those mean criminals take hold of it.

There are people in business who commit crimes.  Who lie and defraud.  But there are far more who just aren’t anywhere near as good at what they do as they claim, and they go down foolish roads and make bad decisions and stand there at the helm of their corporation as it crashes against the rocks.  There isn’t always a criminal to blame.  Some of our most celebrated business minds are just a bunch of lucky folks who managed to skirt disaster by making a zig rather than a zag at the right moment.  If you catch them with a few martinis in them, they might even tell you that they didn’t have a clue why they picked that path.  It just seemed like a good idea at the time.

Work-Life Balance or Professionalism: Who Wins?

Two of my favorite blawgers, Niki Black at her new blawg, Women Lawyers–Back on Track, and Dan Hull at What About Clients?, are unwittingly going to head to head.  It smells like a good fight.

Niki, quoting from Denise Howell’s piece, On Life Support, argues that lack of work-life balance is causing massive disenchantment with the law:



It costs firms somewhere between $200,000 and $500,000 to replace attorneys who don’t work out, according to Joan Williams, director of the Center for WorkLife Law at Hastings College of Law.


And the replacements are becoming scarce. In a recent ABA member survey, only 44 percent of respondents said they’d recommend the profession to others. The animosity doesn’t stop at passive nonendorsement. Disenchanted lawyers are busy warning off the uninitiated via every channel available-chronicling the pitfalls of large firms and the profession in general.


On the other side, Dan says


Like work-life balance, lawyer “professionalism” as touted and practiced in the U.S. is an anti-client, lawyer-centric ruse which needs to die before it can be re-born. It is disingenuous and a crock. It’s a license for mediocrity, cooked up and maintained by lawyers who think law is a special club for special people.

Like two freight trains traveling full speed at each other on the same track.

While Dan’s approach reminds me of the movie Moonstruck, where Cher smacks the guy across the face and says, “Snap out of it,” he doesn’t address the flip side.  In fact, he dismisses it completely.  That’s fine for those of us who are willing to dedicate every second of our lives to our work and clients.  But I’m not clear that it’s necessary to go to that extreme in order to put the client’s interest first.

Being available to do everything necessary to represent a client is what I think Dan is talking about.  But that may mean that when a client can’t sleep at night, he’s welcome to call to chat and the “professional” lawyer should be happy to hand-hold at 3:37 a.m. if it makes the client feel better.  Not in my practice, pal.

Dan is right, of course, that the entire work-life balance theme is predicated upon the lawyer’s needs rather than the client’s.  But most businesses close at some point, and the staff goes home and leaves work behind.  Lawyers aren’t particularly special in that regard.  If anything, we’re unique in our dedication to our clients beyond the 9 to 5 construct.  When an arraignment comes in during the lobster shift, it has to be done.  No judge sitting on the bench at 3:37 a.m. wants to hear that you’re sleeping and hold the case until the morning.

But Niki brings up a point that’s important to recognize:


If firms are to get serious about fostering environments of “reasonable balance,” they may need to look back before they can move ahead. In the 1970s, my dad, who was a partner at a respected California firm, made sure that our family spent most of each August river rafting, and that we took some fishing trips during the rest of the year. In 1963, the ABA considered 1,300 billable hours full-time. This Kennedy-era approach and my dad’s insistence on being a dad seem far more suited to the mind-set of the twenty-first century legal workforce than today’s firms have yet to recognize.

There’s a degree of client-centrism that’s not really about the client, but about the money.  Law firms just can’t seem to suck enough hours out of lawyers these days to cover the cost of the new gold-plated faucets in the partners’ bathroom.  How many criminal defense lawyers have had the pleasure of strolling leisurely through the offices of Biglaw in Manhattan?  The cost of maintaining these Taj Mahals would blow you away; the cost of keeping these big boys in redwells would sustain most criminal defense practices in hitherto unknown luxury.

I am particularly dedicated to my clients, far more so than most of them realize since they don’t see the hours spent working on their cases when not in court, or pondering how to get them out of their jams when they’ve done everything possible to guarantee that the prison door is going slam shut on them.  That’s not just my job, but my quest.  It’s a matter of personal pride.

But not at the risk of my family.  My solution is to limit my caseload to those I can address properly while still having a life.  I’ve spent a career letting cases walk out of my office, each representing a loss of revenue that pains me when things get quiet, because taking them would make it impossible to eat dinner with my kids.  But then, it’s my firm and I get to make my own balance.

Niki, I think, has the better part of the argument, since lawyers working for firms have no option to call it a day when they’ve reached the melting point.  This isn’t the clergy, where we’ve taken an oath of obsequiousness to our masters to serve clients night and day and sustain the big boys in the lifestyle to which they’re accustomed.  It’s not about clients, then, but about being a profit center.  The expectation that lawyers should give a thousand hours more per year than their fathers pushes the envelope too far.

Serve your clients.  Serve them well.  But there has to be an end of the day, when even lawyers can take their uniform off and pretend that they’re human beings.

Federal Restitution Changes Could Be A Disaster

Turley provides a  lengthy commentary on proposed changes to federal restitution that must be read by all criminal defense lawyers.  His commentary comes from the testimony he gave to the House Judiciary Committee.  You can skip over the opening rhetoric and cut to the substance.

The highlights of the proposed changes are:



  • Mandatory restitution for all federal crimes, eliminating all judicial discretion.

  • Pre-Indictment asset seizures to cover potential post-conviction restitution.

  • Pre-Appeal payment of restitution.

  • Expansion of the definition of “Victim” due restitution.

  • Inclusion of victims’ attorneys fees for the representation of victims in the investigation and prosecution of an offense (go figure that one out).

  • Extension of probation and supervisory release until restitution is paid.

Bearing in mind that this was his testimony to the committee, and therefore presents far more by way of rhetoric than would otherwise be the case, Jonathon explains in detail why each of these changes has substantial harmful collateral consequences for the system.

But then, as one wag commented, the public wants victims to receive restitution, so who cares what happens to the criminals.  While lacking in depth, this comment captures much of the sentiment that could propel these changes forward regardless of how much havoc they could cause.

One interesting anecdote from Turley’s post worth repeating:


Many years ago during the height of federal sentencing reform, a federal judge complained to me that he spent his career distinguishing himself as an attorney and, in recognition of this experience, he was made a federal judge – but he was then told not to use that lifetime of experience in sentencing criminals.

While I have some doubts that this was ever said, it’s point is well taken.  Just when you thought that one-size-fits-all justice might be on the wane, Congress comes up with a new brainstorm like these restitution proposals.  Read the full post.  It’s quite disheartening.

How To Explain Why the Lawyers Were So Wrong

I’ve previously posted about the Long Island school district  scandal surrounding lawyerswho were carried as full time employees on various district’s books in order to receive state pensions.  The mess continued yesterday and has exploded with Attorney General Cuomo’s announcement that this was fraud.  State Comptroller Tom DiNapoli has  announced rules to stop this from happening in the future.

I had a long chat with an elected official friend of mine about this.  We both agreed that some of the lawyers involved simply took advantage of a long-standing perk of the job.  They weren’t malevolent about it.  In fact, it’s unlikely that they gave it any thought at all.  It was just what school district attorneys did.  And they were wrong, and what they did was to enjoy perks to which they were never entitled, at the expense of the taxpayer.

Of course, some of the lawyers may have known full well that what they were doing was wrong. 

Albany’s response, like Newsday’s sensationalism, is naturally directed at the symptom rather than the disease.  My friend and I agreed that while the focus was on the surface of the problem, it misdirected attention away from the cause.  This means that the problem will continue in other areas unabated, until a decade from now another scandal erupts and everyone points fingers again. 

I’m not so arrogant as to believe that no one in Albany has figured this out.  They just realize that more play is gained by putting out fires then disrupting the machinery of government by fixing what’s broken. 

This brought my friend and I to the point of questioning what these attorneys, the ones who practiced “municipal government” law, actually brought to the table.  If this was there specialty, why didn’t they know that what “everybody did” was wrong?  What else were they wrong about?  Why have them if they can’t be trusted?

My elected official friend is one of the good guys.  He wants nothing for himself, and truly believes in trying to help make things better for everyone.  He’s such a Pollyanna.  But he’s not a lawyer, and realizes that local governments depend heavily on their legal counsel for advice.  This scandal reflects a fundamental failure of legal counsel to fulfill their function, and simultaneously a fundamental failure of elected officials to be capable of performing their function because of their need to rely on their legal counsel.

In other words, this is a system that is doomed to sanction fraud, abuse, corruption and error, because it lacks any mechanism to know when it’s happening.  The non-lawyers desperately want to be able to rely 100% on their legal counsel, so that they can press forward in reliance on their advice.  They are incapable of challenging or questioning the legal advice, and are thus captives to the word of a single lawyer.

This is hardly a new problem.  In fact, State Comptroller DiNapoli, who started his political career at 18 on the Mineola School Board, approved putting the lawyer on as full-time employee back in the 1970s.


“It was a school board vote taken 32 years ago, based on information the members had before them,” said Dennis Tompkins. “You can’t cast a blanket over every school attorney — that every one is guilty of fraud or trying to game the system. Each one has to be looked at on a case-by-case basis. At the time he took the vote, he thought it was proper.”

“Mr. DiNapoli moved that the board appoint Henry Weinstein as school district attorney for the school year 1976-77 at an annual salary of $7,000 for all legal services to be rendered, with N.Y.S. Employees Retirement and Social Security benefits and with an expense allowance not to exceed $500,” the minutes read.

Tom DiNapoli was taken in like they still are today.  No one would attribute criminal intent to his vote, and yet it might have landed him on the front page of Newsday with the word “fraud” across his face. 

Municipal attorneys make a million decisions, small and large, that guide a public authority in its conduct.  These ultimately dictate major policy decisions, and impact on the lives of residents and taxpayers in ways they will never know.  In school districts, it toys with the lives of students and teachers.  In every municipality, it is a critical factor for taxpayers, who pay the price of decisions, good and bad. 

In many districts, the attorneys wield far more power than any elected official.  By the mere shake of a head, they can “authorize” conduct that is flagrantly illegal, and the elected officials will then happily engage in a corrupt practice because the attorney said they could.  These practices then become embedded in the institutional history of the municipality, and are perpetuated until the day comes when a scandal breaks out.  If that day ever comes.  In the meantime, everyone suffers for the corruption. 

The problem has long been clear to me.  One attorney, hired by a municipality to be the legal pontiff whose mere word makes everything right or wrong, is an invitation to abuse and corruption.  Sure, there is always an Article 78 proceeding to challenge the municipality’s action, but rarely does this happen as the impact is broad-based and no one is individually harmed sufficiently to be worth the price of a lawsuit.  Also, rarely does anyone know what happens in this mini-enclaves until long afterward, if ever.  Outsiders aren’t often watching, as they are home with their families trying to enjoy what little free time they have left.

So my elected official friend asked me, “Okay, so assuming that’s the problem, what’s the answer?”  Discussing the limitations of lawyers was a frustrating experience.  Not because he didn’t get it.  He did.  But because it was all so very vague and generally unhelpful. 

There are some things that most lawyers agree upon, and other things that are merely educated guesses, and other things that are simply wrong coming out of the lawyer’s mouth.  The lawyer’s loyalty is inherently divided: He wants to keep the gig, so he’s compelled to help the municipality achieve its goals, even when they may be questionable.  Many elected officials have their own corruption issues, believing that they are above the law, and want their lawyer to be mini-John Yoos, approving torture if they want to keep their job.

My friend inquired, how is he, a non-lawyer, supposed to distinguish the things lawyers know from the guesses?  How is he, a non-lawyer, supposed to know when the lawyer is lying through his teeth to appease his master by approving corrupt practices?  How is he, a non-lawyer, supposed to move forward to fulfill his duty when he can no longer rely on legal counsel?

Aside from the routine explanations that law is more art than science; that lawyers whose opinions are unchallenged are often inclined to give unreliable advice. This problem is pervasive and inherent in the single-lawyer reliance of municipalities.  But small governmental units can’t afford a groups of lawyers to keep an eye on each other, to challenge each other, to provide all sides of a position.  Nor would these units ever accomplish anything if the lawyers were left to argue amongst themselves forever.

And so Albany will pretend that the problem is with a handful of school district lawyers who have defrauded the public.  And will turn a blind eye to a system that breeds corruption and abuse at a huge cost to taxpayers, both in the actual dollars spent as well as the failure to deliver the quality and nature of services that justifies their existence.  This is a huge mess, and disease remains virulent. 

Lawyer Fashionista: What Not to Wear Shopping

While my sartorial focus is generally on the courtroom, today we venture outside to that most American of venues, the mall food court.  “What?” you exclaim!  Am I not allowed to dress as I please at the food court?  Well, no.  And while this applies to all people, it’s particularly important for lawyers, since this fashion faux pas has dire consequences.

As told by Newsday,  


An 80-year-old church deacon was removed from the Smith Haven Mall yesterday in a wheelchair and arrested by police for refusing to remove a T-shirt protesting the Iraq War.

Police said that Don Zirkel, of Bethpage, was disturbing shoppers at the Lake Grove mall with his T-shirt, which had what they described as “graphic anti-war images.” Zirkel, a deacon at Our Lady of the Miraculous Medal in Wyandanch, said his shirt had the death tolls of American military personnel and Iraqis – 4,000 and 1 million – and the words “Dead” and “Enough.” The shirt also has three blotches resembling blood splatters.

Tacky, tacky.  The owner of the Smith Haven Mall, Simon, is all about happiness.  Happy people buy stuff.  And Simon wants happy people at its malls.  When Zirkel, together with a small group of geriatrics, stopped at the food court for a hot cup of joe and a nosh, their shirts did not make people happy.  Their shirts made people unhappy.  Simon was not pleased.


But Zirkel said he was sitting in the food court drinking coffee with his wife Marie, 77, and several others when police and mall security officers approached and demanded they remove their anti-war T-shirts.

Remove their shirts?  That could have causes some serious unhappiness too.  I wonder if the security people thought that one through.

Today, the respective sides have  letters to the editor published in Newsday.  The manager of the mall had this to say:


The mall’s corporate parent, Simon, has a policy — and right as private property owner — not to allow protests or demonstrations of any kind to take place on mall property regardless of the topic. In keeping with our code of conduct, mall management notified the indoor protesters that their behavior was in violation of mall policy. For the most part, they complied and left the property.

Unfortunately, Zirkel insisted on continuing to rally inside Smith Haven Mall by handing out pamphlets and interacting with patrons in the mall’s food court, despite being asked repeatedly to stop. He refused to leave the property when requested. At that point, Suffolk County Police arrested him.

Sounds like Deacon Zirkel was asking for it, bucking those nice requests to keep his protests out of their happy food court.

But then Nancy Dwyer, one of the people who was actually present (Note to Simon: People with actual knowledge know more than people who have powerful mall positions), describes the incident differently:


I was one of the four Pax Christi Long Island members in the Smith Haven Mall food court Saturday when Deacon Don Zirkel was dragged away by officers.

The T-shirt he was wearing had no obscenities, issued no threats, railed against no elected official, endorsed no candidate. It simply stated a tragic fact on the front: “4,000 U.S. Troops. One Million Iraqis. Dead.” And on the back, it said, “Enough!” and had three blood-colored splotches.

The four of us, senior citizens all, wore these T-shirts as part of a demonstration we had been in on Route 25. We’d gotten cold; we went inside to get some coffee. A hot dog and french fries were afterthoughts.

Eight mall security officers surrounded our table and ordered us to take off our T-shirts or leave. Why? Because they can. By law, the mall owner has all the rights. You have none, only those the mall owner wishes to grant you.

Dwyer goes on to note:


It used to be that every town had a town square where people would gather, stroll, meet friends, discuss important issues of the day. Now people gather, stroll, meet friends – and discuss shopping.

Is it any wonder Americans’ attention is so focused on shopping and so out of touch with the war?

And there’s your problem in a nutshell.  This woman is old, old, old.  She doesn’t have to look good.  Is it any wonder that mall security was incensed?  The mall should be a place of beauty, within the limitations of whatever goods are currently for sale by its tenants.  And let’s face facts, senior citizens just don’t do enough shopping to count.

And so, I implore you to think carefully about your attire before venturing out to the mall food court for a fine dining experience.  The dignity of our profession is counting on you.



Shamelessly stolen pic from David Tarrell shows that even the Marines recognize the importance of shopping.  That’s what they’re fighting for, so if you love our country and respect our fighting men and women, then show your patriotism where is counts! And dress appropriately!




Giuliani, For the Defense

Every few days lately, there’s been  an announcement by a particular law firm of their acquisition of a new partner.  This would be nothing notable, but for one small detail.  The firm is Bracewell & Giuliani.  That’s right, the same Rudy who loves women too much and thought that a few decent speeches after 9/11 would make everybody forget what how hated he was as United States Attorney in the Southern District of New York.

With Rudy off the campaign trail, he naturally needs to make tons of money by capitalizing on his name and fame.  Within minutes after stepping down as Mayor of New York, he opened a string of businesses, one of which was his law firm.  The Giuliani Taco Suprema biz hasn’t fared nearly as well.

Bracewell & Giuliani have been buying up lawyers right and left lately, and some of the names are familiar.  So I wondered, has Rudy turned over a new leaf?  Has the Angel of Death become the savior of the Constitution?  This could really spoil his chances of world hegemony, but he could drown his sorrow in some significant partner profits.  And so I took a spin around the  B&G website to see how my competition was doing.

Imagine my surprise to find that B&G is indeed in the criminal defense business.  White collar, natch.


In the past several years, this country has witnessed a dramatic increase in the investigation and prosecution of business institutions and their executives and employees. Federal and state prosecutors and regulators, armed with new statutes and increased penalties, have placed institutions and individuals under great scrutiny in virtually every industry from Wall Street to Main Street.

Well, Rudy would sure know about that!  Why he didn’t take personal credit is beyond me.


The lawyers in Bracewell & Giuliani’s White Collar Criminal Defense practice possess the skill and experience critical to defend a client in the face of a criminal, quasi-criminal or regulatory investigation or prosecution conducted by the Department of Justice, a U.S. Attorney’s Office, the Securities and Exchange Commission, or a state District Attorney or Attorney General.

Really?  Why tell me, Rudy, how that “skill and experience critical to defend a client” was obtained.


Prior to making their mark in the defense bar, many of our lawyers served in leadership positions at the Department of Justice, the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York, the SEC, and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission.  They offer an insider’s view of how best to defend a case.  We have found that a lawyer who is prepared to put prosecutors and regulators to their proof can often achieve a superior result for the client.  For that reason, every member of the White Collar Criminal Defense section is a seasoned trial lawyer.

That’s right.  Every member is a “seasoned trial lawyer.”  Not “seasoned defense lawyer.”  Nope.  Very artfully said.  After all, they offer an “insider’s view of how best to defend a case.”  What do you suppose they are suggesting?  Not about them, but about the rest of us.

Some might be inclined to spurn Rudy’s rhetoric, perhaps even falling back on his failures, overreaching and the massive harm he did to the innocent while pursuing his quest for world domination.  Not me.  Frankly, I admire the fact that Rudy is just as willing to put self-interest above all else now as he was while cashing the public pay check.  This man is a rock, consistent to the end.


Bracewell & Giuliani LLP is a prominent international law firm with more than 400 lawyers in Texas, New York, Washington, DC, Connecticut, Dubai, Kazakhstan and London.

If you’re interested, I hear they’re looking for some new blood in the Kazakhstan office.  Any former Soviet prosecutors interested?

What Do Doctors Think About Guns?

While lawyers have wasted untold millions of words on the potentially earth-shattering case of D.C. v. Heller, it has largely been an internal discussion.  Sure, there are specific interest groups who cling on every word, but what about the larger world, those people who (gasp) didn’t make Heller their primary focus in life.  Yes, Virginia, such people exist.

One such group is physicians.  While many docs have a certain fascination with law, it tends to be a bit myopic and focus on their enlightened self-interest.  It’s hard to blame them.  They’re busy and malpractice insurance is money out of their pocket.  But they are not necessarily disinterested, as they will be the folks who have to patch the holes in people who appear at the ER with a “GSW” or two.

The  New England Journal of Medicine has finally taken an interest in Heller, and includes a piece by “Mark Tushnet, J.D.” a Harvard lawprof.  This rather short explanation of Heller is fascinating in its effort to reduce a matter of great complexity to its simplest terms.  This is a sort of Heller for Idiots article.

My first reading of Tushnet’s explanation left me scratching my head, wondering how it was possible to cover a case that has been subject to such great scrutiny and yet totally avoid any nuance whatsoever.  This was the New England Journal of Medicine, after all, and it’s readership wasn’t that incapable of understanding the complexity of the issues.  Even the New York Times had produced far superior articles and op-eds.  But then, they have more space then NEJM.

After further contemplation, I realized that Tushnet was in a quandary.  How does he explain the basic issue within the confines of a brief article to a bunch of docs whose interest was likely tested by the second paragraph?  His answer was KISS, apparently.  A dissatisfying answer for me, and likely for him as well, but an answer that made some degree of sense. 

Unfortunately, Tushnet’s efforts fail to impart much of anything in the end, aside from his personal opinion of how the case will turn out.  The vague and imprecise language used to explain the arguments of both sides, ignoring that there are about 32 sides to this particular issue, and then jumping into the level of scrutiny with an explanation that offers no discernible clue what it means because of his purely subjective language, does a disservice to anyone reading that far into the piece.  If the reader has put in enough effort to read to the end, the least the writer can do is offer something meaningful rather than vague gobbledygook.

But the worst part of the article was the unexplained jump to conclude that there is some inherent basis to conclude that an individual right to bear arms exists, but that the right is inherently subject to regulation.


So what can we expect from the Supreme Court? Early in the Bush administration, the Department of Justice issued an extensive legal analysis supporting the gun-rights view of the Second Amendment. It has adhered to that position in the D.C. case but with an important twist. Suppose the Second Amendment does protect an individual right. Still, like all rights, that right can be regulated by the government for good reasons — as the Amendment’s reference to a “well regulated” militia itself suggests. In the First Amendment setting, we let the government regulate speech only if it has extremely good reasons for the regulation.

So next time you’re at a cocktail party and chatting with your friendly local surgeon, and she explains to you that Heller’s no big deal since the government can regulate it as long as it has “good reasons,” you know where that comes from. 

And if you wonder who’s to blame for the fact that physicians’ understanding of the law is so vague, don’t blame the New England Journal of Medicine.  Think Harvard lawprof.

Buying Talent Around the Ivy League

Jim Chen at  MoneyLaw has a series of posts,  here and here, discussing how changes in the availability and use of financial aid have manipulated the landscape for poor students to attend the nation’s most prestigious universities.


One of the things that we can look at is how colleges and universities use their own financial resources either to broaden access or to serve other purposes. And what we’ve seen is a huge shift away from providing institutional financial aid to the financially neediest students and more towards giving larger financial rewards to students who could afford to go to college whether they got a financial award or not. But these public universities, in order to move up in the ratings and the rankings systems, are actually buying up students who have done better previously.

Schools are using financial aid, in the guise of merit scholarships, to buy perceived talent.  Where once we thought that financial aid was there to help the needy student who would be shut out of college because his family lacked the resources to pay the tab, the scenario has changed.  In order to play the U.S. News and World Reports ranking game, this money is used to entice students that the school wants and needs to up its numbers.


Luke Gilman’s assessment of this trend is extremely perceptive. I quote him in full:


There is a clear incentive to “buy” high performing students in order to increase the illusion of selectivity. This incentive in turn puts pressure on admissions offices to make choices based on numbers that it might otherwise make on less quantifiable grounds and also applies pressure to increase tuition to fund the arms race. In this context, the recent moves by wealthier universities to reach into their endowments looks less like philanthropy and more like the erection of barriers to entry.

When the rankings start to reflect not the value the institution can impart on a student by virtue of its education but rather the status the school can achieve by leveraging its endowment to pad its LSAT stats, then it’s time for a MoneyLaw revolution.

Having a daughter in her senior year of high school on her way to college, I’ve stared this beast in the eyes personally. In fact, during the myriad of lectures one sits through during campus visits, the admissions people have been fairly straight forward about it.  If they really want you child, they will pay for him or her. 

Admissions was once about whether your kid had the intelligence and drive to successfully complete the program.  Later, it was about whether you could pay the freight, so the school could use its cash on the needy while others shouldered the financial burden on their own.  But as Jim and Luke make clear, those days are gone.

Today, it’s a bidding war for the kid with good numbers, the one who will help the school to up its ranking.  If a lesser school can buy the kid, then it won’t be a lesser school for long.  This is the skewed nature of the rankings, based not upon their output but their input.  If smart kids with high scores go there, it must be good.

In the second part of the series, Jim notes that the benefit of the Ivy League education diminishes with the amount of effort the student puts in.  While those who didn’t go Ivy think that it’s a free pass to success, Jim accurately notes that a kid in the middle (or bottom) at an Ivy is viewed as an also-ran by potential employers and graduate schools.  It’s not a substitute for academic achievement, despite common belief to the contrary. 

The central finding of the Dale-Krueger study is that the academic prestige of the college attended by a student, generally speaking, has no bearing on future earnings. Greater selectivity in the admissions office simply sinks a student, ceteris paribus, deeper in the class by graduation. Employers are not wholly irrational: they discount class rank by the academic reputation of a job applicant’s alma mater, and they discount the reputation of an alma mater by the applicant’s class rank. And just as smart, motivated students can find suitable study partners at a less selective school, lazy students at an elite school can find plenty of counterparts with whom to loaf.

So this tends to show that the smart, motivated student who excels will achieve greater success at a lesser school than the lazy wealthy kid at the elite school.   So an Ivy diploma alone is no guarantee.

I’m troubled, however, by basing the definition of “success” on future earnings rather than the quality of education.  One thing that remains true is that the depth of education depends upon the level of thinking and discussion developed during classes, and that depends on the intelligence and thoughtfulness of the other kids in the room, as well as other factors.  Future earnings, on the other hand, don’t necessarily depend upon brilliance, which is often more of an inhibiting factor in a future career than an aid.

Jim goes on to note that:

Of course, to the extent elite education does make a difference, there is one class that appears to benefit most: “students from more disadvantaged family backgrounds.” Poor students seem to benefit because elite schools give them connections they would otherwise never acquire. These are the very students being iced out of elite universities by emerging trends in admissions and financial aid.

Ironic, isn’t it?  This trend is not only a danger to the fabric of higher education, particularly in light of the efforts over the past 50 years to provide opportunity for the disadvantaged, but it reflects how one magazine’s list, one ranking, has so badly screwed up the model for American education.  You’ve got to give U.S. News and World Reports credit.  Our institutions of higher education may hate the rankings, but they still play the game.