Author Archives: SHG

Discarded DNA: Fair Game For Cops?

The  New York Times reports on the police tactic of “surreptitious sampling” of suspect’s DNA in their effort to investigate crimes.  What this means is taking the cigarette butt, the water glass, whatever the suspect once used in a way that would leave a sample of DNA behind, for testing.  The problem is that the suspects leave their DNA behind unwittingly, providing evidence for law enforcement to scoop up and use at will.

Critics argue that by covertly collecting DNA contained in the minute amounts of saliva, sweat and skin that everyone sheds in the course of daily life, police officers are exploiting an unforeseen loophole in the requirement to show “probable cause” that a suspect has committed a crime before conducting a search.

“The law cannot tolerate such back-door methods, which seize something that any reasonable person expects to remain private,” Mr. Gallego’s lawyer, David Lynch, wrote in a motion to suppress the DNA evidence extracted from the cigarette butt.

Normally, cops would be required to get a warrant to obtain a sample of DNA from a suspect.  This “back door” method allows them to circumvent that need, and allows them to do so without a showing of probable cause or alerting the suspect to the nature of their interest.

In its favor, the argument is that the suspect has abandoned the property from which the DNA sample is collected, and therefore has no reasonable expectation of privacy left.  While it might be disingenuous to say that the suspect intentionally abandoned his DNA, it would be accurate to argue that he abandoned his cigarette that happened to contain a sample of his DNA.  Are the cops to blame if the suspect doesn’t put 2 and 2 together?

There are external policy considerations that are implicated in the collection of DNA samples, however, that are quite disturbing:


The privacy implications of surreptitious DNA sampling may extend beyond individual investigations. The police, critics say, could collect DNA deemed “abandoned” from targeted individuals and monitor their movements even if they are not suspected of committing a serious crime. Innocent people whose DNA turns up unexpectedly may find themselves identified by a database file that they did not know existed.

Imagine hearing your name on the evening news as being identified as a person of interest in a horrific crime based on some preliminary DNA testing, because your DNA just happened to be in a law enforcement databased somewhere.  That would be decidedly unpleasant.

This problem, of course, could be addressed by controls over government databases by deleting DNA from suspects who have not been shown to have been involved in any crime.  But few of us trust the government to do so, or do so satisfactorily even if they tried.  The abuse potential is high, and for the innocent party who gets caught up in police interest, there would be no remedy to undo the damage.

But as for using the surreptitious sampling, aside from the potential for abuse, the argument that it violates the constitutional prohibition against unlawful searches is hard to make stick.  As long as police aren’t actively engaged in creating the abandonment scenario, or faking it as has happened as well, it’s hard to understand what privacy interest a suspect maintains in his discarded cigarette butt.  It seems to fit perfectly into the paradigm of abandonment, which makes it fair game for police.

Another approach that has been suggested is to carve out a separate rule to apply to DNA sampling, aside from the reasonable expectation of privacy.


Some legal experts advocate curbs on surreptitious sampling. Albert E. Scherr, a professor at Franklin Pierce Law Center in Concord, N.H., who has a grant from the National Institutes of Health to study the practice, suggests that the police be required to meet the “reasonable suspicion” standard before secretly collecting DNA. “You’re not asking them to let criminals go free,” he said. “You’re just asking them to investigate a little more.”

While this would certainly help to protect the integrity of DNA collection of innocent people, it’s hard to imagine that the courts or legislatures would be inclined to create such a requirement.  Such a Utopian approach would fly in the face of the get-criminals-at-all-costs attitude that the public loves so dearly.  And it would mean more work for judges, and that won’t win any popularity awards.

Perhaps the only good answer to this problem for the time being is for suspects, and their attorneys, to be aware of the risk of surreptitious DNA sampling and take steps to avoid it.  Don’t leave the butt behind.  Don’t drink the water.  Knowing that DNA samples happen, do what’s necessary to not leave behind the evidence that the police desire, and force them instead to obtain an order on probable cause.

Old Lawyer in the Hallway

I had little to do, sitting in a courtroom the other day waiting for the judge to take the bench.  It was about 9:15 when I got there, and it was almost 11 am now.  The court officers read the Daily News and the Post, ignoring the lawyers sitting in the front row.

A few feet away from me was a young lawyer.  He was very well groomed, almost to the point of looking like an ADA.  Even his tie was regimental, an affectation that most defense lawyers lose after a few years.  Some revolt as they get older, choosing ties that assault the eye as a branding thing.  My good buddy “Don’t Worry” Murray does that, as if he needed more branding.

After a while, an older lawyer walked up to this young man, studiously reviewing the file and reading, or more likely rereading, the opposition papers.  The older lawyer wore the trappings of a hallway lawyer.  A suit that hadn’t seen anything hot and steamy in a very long time, baggy at the knees and elbows, droopy around the back.  He wore the black sneakers that referees wear, like someone who thinks that no one notices that they are wearing sneakers instead of shoes.  He needed a haircut and had a 5 o’clock shadow.  On his wrist was a Rolex, though it was impossible to tell if it was real.

Then the old lawyer started talking to the young lawyer.  It was a conversation I’d heard about a thousand times.  In the vague vernacular of the New York streets, he started telling the young lawyer about his experiences, peppered with war stories of great glory and brilliance.  The “th” sound was replaced by “d”, making all of it sound so strained.  The hallway lawyer was trying to convince the young lawyer that he was still a man to be reckoned with.  He still knew his way around the courthouse, including the back hallways to the judges’ chambers.

I don’t know if this happens in courthouses around the country.  But in New York City courthouses, there are always old lawyers to be found in the hallways.  They can always be found there.  They have a handful of cases every day.  Rarely retained, except for the odd arraignment by the scared wife whose husband was arrested the day before and without a clue where to turn.  He’s the guy who will pocket the $200 in the hallway outside the arraignment part and deftly handle the misdemeanor plea.  He’s done it a thousand times.  He could do it blindfolded.

The young lawyer listened diligently.  He looked the older lawyer in the eyes, and sat silently as the old man spoke.  He nodded occasionally, but mostly sat there rapt as the old-timer told pedestrian tales of his many successes and dear, close friends in power.  When the old timer finished, the young lawyer thanked him and told him that he appreciated his thoughts.  He told the old man that he had not yet made a decision as to the best tact to take in the case, but that he would certainly give a great deal of thought to what the older man had to say.  The young lawyer turned back to his file and continued to read.

The older lawyer stood there, as if he had nowhere else to go.  He seemed like he wanted to tell more stories to his attentive listener, but the young lawyer was back to work and the old lawyer didn’t want to be told to get lost or ignored.  After fiddling with his clothing, looking around the room and seeing no one he could chat up, he walked out of the courtroom and into the hallway.

The judge finally took the bench.  He was an old friend, a former United States Attorney for a brief period, and made a production about seeing me.  He told the clerk to call my case first, and then he called me to the bench to tell me a few jokes, and I gave him a few of mine.  We laughed, and then he moved on to other cases. 

After I finished up, I walked out into the hallway.  There, sitting on the bench, was the old lawyer.  He was talking to a young lawyer, his hands gesticulating wildly as he was re-enacting some courtroom scene of apparent importance.  The young lawyer appeared to be listening intently, though he was nervously fondling his file, as if he had work to do and really preferred to get back to it.  But he wouldn’t be rude to the old-timer, and listened without interruption.

I’ve walked along those hallways for 25 years, and there have always been old lawyers in the hallways.  I remember when I was the young lawyer listening intently. I had work to do, but it would have been rude to interrupt.  The only lesson I learned was that I never wanted to be an old hallway lawyer.

Congestion Pricing and The Cost of Life

New York City’s latest and greatest idea to reduce the overwhelming crush of midtown traffic is congestion pricing.  As argued in this New York Times editorial, it would hopefully result in “cleaner air, less gridlock and billions of dollars for mass transportation.”  The idea is that people driving into midtown would have to pay an additional $8 for the pleasure.

The basic idea is sound in many respect.  There are a ton of yuppies who have no need to drive into the city, spend $38 a day on parking, but for the fact that they can.  Too important to wait for the train, they insist on their right to guide their Porsche or Beemer at 3 miles per hour through bumper to bumper traffic because the commuters trains aren’t frequent enough for these very important people.  I know. A lot of them are dear friends of mine.

But this is happening at a time when real people are suffering a net decline in income, costs are skyrocketing for all the normal accoutrements of city employment and the fares on everything else are rising in multiples of the cost of living increase.  And then there’s that whole subprime mortgage thing.

The use of financial incentives to manipulate behavior is an American tradition. It’s the foundation of our tax code.  It’s the basis for sin taxes.  It’s government’s way of making us do what they think we should.  If you happen to be on the right side of these machinations, you are likely to support them.  If you’re on the wrong side, you pay the price.

But it’s reaching a point where going to work in Manhattan is no longer economically feasible.  The costs just keep piling on, and they have to come from somewhere.

At the same time, we realize that the fees charged for legal services are beyond the reach of normal people already.  Where is it supposed to go?  The judges are ready to take up arms to get a raise, and the lawyers want to earn a decent living too.  But private lawyers have no one to go to when we want a raise.  Our fees are paid by our clients.

The costs imposed by these various taxes apply to us, our employees and our clients.  When the cost of going to work every day  increases, net income declines.  We need to make it up somewhere, and there’s only one place to go. 

I have no personal beef with the purposes behind Bloomberg’s congestion pricing scheme, and in the long run hope it does the anticipated good.  But when fees go up to pay for each politicians little slice of heaven, bear in mind that it wasn’t my choice.  I appreciate that you work for a living.  So do I.  And I pay the same bills that you do, so I do understand.  So do I eat the increase or do I spread it around?  Either way, it’s unpleasant for someone.

As for my buddies in their Porches and Beemers, they will pay the extra $8 without blinking.  It’s a small price for their personal convenience.

Defying Gravity: Supreme Decline to Hear Acquitted Conduct

The  Los Angeles Times reports that the Supreme Court has declined cert in the case of Mark Hum, who was sentenced to 18 years rather than 3 based upon a crack count.  The only problem is that he beat the crack count, as if that mattered.


WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court declined Monday to reconsider a legal rule that might surprise most Americans: Judges can punish defendants for certain crimes even after a jury has acquitted them of those charges.

In recent years, the justices have described the right to jury trial as one of the bedrock principles of American law. At the same time, they have been unwilling to say that a jury’s not-guilty verdict on some charges means the defendant cannot be punished. Instead, the court has said judges may take into account “acquitted conduct” when they decide on a prison term.

Sentencing based upon acquitted conduct is one of the most insidious and unjustified mechanisms in federal court.  There is simply no legitimate justification, no rational explanation, for it.  The public is astounded by it.  So are criminal defense lawyers, though likely more outraged than surprised.  It’s patently offensive and flagrantly wrong.

And it’s the law.

Doug Berman, with whom I’ve had occasional disagreements on policy, is  right on target on this one.  Read Doug’s post for his additional background on the subject and other cases where the issue arose.

The question remains, why did SCOTUS refuse to hear this case?  While it could be for technical reasons, such as an inadequate record, it doesn’t appear likely.  I hate to be cynical (I really do), but it’s impossible in this instance.   Particularly in a case where the issue presents so clearly and distinctly:  3 to 18 years is a huge gap.  What point is there in a trial, a verdict, all the varied protections that we write about, ponder, research, and argue, if at the end of the trial, the court sentences the defendant no differently than had he been convicted.  It renders the entirety of what we do a farce.

Due to my limited imagination, I can think of only one reason why the Supreme Court refused to hear this case.  They were unable to must the votes to change this atrocity and are unable to think of any potential argument to justify it.

Harlan Protass of  Second Circuit Sentencing Blog  expressed the problem well:


Acquitted conduct sentencing … goes against virtually everything we know and respect about the American criminal justice system.  We understand that the government cannot lock people up unless and until guilt has been proven to a jury beyond a reasonable doubt.  We also understand that the American criminal justice system would rather free a guilty person than imprison an innocent one.  Sentences based on acquitted conduct erode these principles and, with them, our respect for the law….

We’ve been taught from a young age that juries are the bedrock of the judicial system, and that we should take pride in the system’s inherent fairness.  But acquitted conduct sentencing effectively nullifies jury verdicts and allows judges to usurp the jury’s fact-finding role — no need for juries at all if a sentence can be based on conduct of which a defendant was found not guilty. This upsets the delicate balance that the founding fathers struck when framing the U.S. Constitution. As Alexander Hamilton put it, “arbitrary punishments upon arbitrary convictions” are the “great engines of judicial despotism.”…

It’s bad that such a thing as acquitted conduct sentencing exists.  It’s worse that the Supreme Court won’t even consider it.  When that happens, it falls into the netherworld of hopelessness, and undermines the integrity of the criminal justice system and our efforts to protect and defend the Constitution and our clients. 

So this blight on the system continues, without the hope of review.  For now.

How Dangerous Can One Man Be? (Updated)

While the public is often aghast at the harm one particularly evil defendant can perpetrate, it ends up smelling trivial compared to what John Yoo had up his sleeve.  Yoo, a minor league Deputy Assistant Attorney General, is the fellow who prepared a memo to the Department of Defense telling them that torture was as American as apple pie.

Marty Liederman at  Balkinization, via the Washington Post, provides access to the 81 page memo,  Part One and  Part Two.  Mind you, it was just declassified, having been subject to our need for secrecy lest the terrorists know what Yoo had in mind for them.  Or to protect the government from the sheer embarrassment of its content, whichever comes first.

In fairness, not everyone in our government lost their senses:


[T]he March 14th Yoo memorandum, and the April 2, 2003 DOD Working Group Report that incorporated its outrageous arguments about justifications for ignoring statutory limits on interrogation, was secretly briefed to Geoffrey Miller before he was assigned to Iraq, and became the source of all the abuse that occurred there in 2003 and early 2004. (In late 2004, new OLC head Jack Goldsmith reviewed the March 2003 memo, was stunned by what he later called the “unusual lack of care and sobriety in [its] legal analysis” — it “seemed more an exercise of sheer power than reasoned analysis” — and immediately called the Pentagon to implore them not to rely upon it. Later, the next head of OLC, Dan Levin, wrote the Pentagon to confirm that they rescind any policies that had been based on the Yoo memo.

While an 81 page memo is likely more than most people will care to read,  Orin Kerr’s post drew some comments directing attention to footnote 10, “…our Office has recently concluded that the Fourth Amendment has no application no domestic military operations….”  No doubt Orin will be back to offer his analysis of Yoo’s venture into policy-directed revisionism.

Also, a great analysis by David Tarrell at In the Moment, which compares it to the Downing Street Memo and sheds light on its impact on Specialist Sabrina Harman, who took the photographs of prisoners being abused at Abu Ghraib prison, through her letters home.

And how was John Yoo rewarded for the harm this one person caused so many, and a nation, in his quest to appease his “client” and become an important player in the United States Department of Justice, Office of Legal Counsel?  John Yoo is  now a lawprof at the University of California, Berkeley, (a/k/a Boalt Hall) as well as Visiting Scholar at the American Enterprise Institute.  From his faculty bio:


Professor Yoo has published articles about foreign affairs, international law and constitutional law in a number of the nation’s leading law journals. He is the author of The Powers of War and Peace: The Constitution and Foreign Affairs after 9/11 (University of Chicago Press, 2005), and War by Other Means: An Insider’s Account of the War on Terrorism (Grove/Atlantic 2006).

Some dangerous people go to prison.  Others go to Boalt Hall and write books about it. 

Update:   Orin opines that he’s struck by how “lawyerly” it is.  Emily Bazelon responds, “lawyerly can mean trussing up bad and thin arguments with questionable analogies from other cases and a horde of citations.”  Jack Balkin chimes in,


This observation points to an important fact about legal discourse: Lawyers can make really bad legal arguments that argue for very unjust things in perfectly legal-sounding language. I hope nobody is surprised by this fact. It is very commonplace.

They don’t really disagree about it, but still manage to find something to argue about.

The Best April Fool’s Post Ever

Eric Turkewitz is a master.  No, a genius.  When it comes to fools, there’s none better.  Over at New York Personal Injury Law, Eric led yesterday with

Supreme Court Grants Cert in “Fantasy Baseball” Case; Three Justices Recuse Themselves Due To Participation in High Court League


The U.S. Supreme Court granted certiorari today in the “Fantasy Baseball” case of CBC Distribution v. Major League Baseball Advanced Media. The suit is remarkable not only for the First Amendment and right to publicity issues that form the basis of the dispute, but because Justices John Paul Stevens, Samuel Alito and Stephen Breyer recused themselves due to their participation in a fantasy baseball league comprised of current and past court personnel. Justices Antonin Scalia and Ruth Bader Ginsburg, who also participate in the league, declined to disqualify themselves, exposing a non-ideological split in the court on the issue of when justices should step aside when conflicts appear.

Absolute nonsense, of course, but so well done, so very believable, that the news flew around the internet. 

Who got taken in?   New York Magazine,  San Diego Tribune, Eugene Volokh,  David Lat and a host of others, including the Baseball Think Factory.   Then there’s PrawfsBlawg, which took down it’s post after finding out it was a goof, as did Sports Law Blog.  Seriously, how cool is this?

Naturally, I was not fooled by Eric’s post.  But then, he gave me a heads-up a few days earlier when he asked me to vet his post for credibility.  It was picture perfect until Eric disclosed the “source” of the story:

While obviously not wanting to be identified here, s/he told me of a trip to Florida two weeks back for an annual spring training vacation with friends and to watch a cousin, Siddhartha Finch, at the New York Mets’ spring camp in Port St. Lucie. Over twenty years ago Finch gave up a promising baseball opportunity to pursue a career with the French horn. He is trying to become the first rookie over the age of 50 to break into the big league as part of a book project.

Sidd Finch?  Didn’t anybody notice that one?  Unfortunately, when New York Magazine picked up the story, Lat, apparently letting the ex-prosecutor get the better of him, felt compelled to snitch on Eric and let them know it was a joke.  Maybe he was hoping for a 5K1.1?

Runner-up for best April Fool’s post was  Gideon’s announcement that he was leaving indigent defense to serve new masters. 


I’ve taken a position with the general practice firm of Houlihan and Horowitz, where I will be dabbling in various fields, such as real estate, civil litigation, med mal and insurance defense.

So long, then, and thanks for all the fish.

My pathetic attempt at an April fool’s post was an embarrassment next to Eric’s and Gid’s.  I’m not worthy.

While many people here aren’t all that interested in personal injury law, Eric’s blawg is terrific and he really does a great job, both in breaking new stories and in analyzing the state of affairs.  It’s great stuff, and he’s got unbelievable tolerance in dealing with those who believe the tort and med mal system is the end of American civilization. 

The Price of a Public Trial

Newsday reports on our government servants from ICE making certain that society is safe.  Today it’s ICE’s safety in the courtroom version, where our observant and ever-faithful avengers of America kept a close on eye on anyone who might appear to be a defendant-lover, exploiting that constitutional loophole, a public trial.


A normally mild-mannered Brooklyn federal judge hit the roof and hinted at further action against federal authorities after learning that government agents aggressively questioned a courtroom spectator in a Middle Eastern currency transaction case.

The blow-up by Judge Eric Vitaliano came during the closing phase of the trial of five men last week. They are charged with being part of an illegal remitting business, which prosecutors say funneled cash to Yemen from 2003 to 2006 without proper government authorization. The case is scheduled for closing arguments today.

Vitaliano became angered after he learned from defense attorneys that two agents with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement confronted a friend of one of the defendants and asked to see his passport, according to a transcript of an impromptu hearing held before the judge later Wednesday.

As the story states, Judge Vitaliano was way past “not amused” by the conduct of the ICE agents.  The idea that a person, exercising the constitutional right to observe a trial, would be subject to interrogation by government agents is quite an outrage.

But that’s only part of the problem here.


Assistant U.S. Attorney Michael Warren explained to Vitaliano that the ICE agents were acting out of caution because there had been some witness intimidation in the case. Warren apologized to the court.

But Vitaliano wasn’t happy with the government’s action and let everyone know.

“The United States attorney’s office does not run my courtroom, Mr. Warren. Anybody in the public is entitled to come in here, unless I close the courtroom, not you,” said Vitaliano. “No one is to be interrogated in my courtroom. … That is outrageous, the record will so reflect it. I am flabbergasted about it. We’ll address it after this case is over.”

As is virtually guaranteed, the AUSA sought to rationalize the impropriety rather than consider how it might relate to that oath about defending the Constitution.  On the other hand, the judge expressed his outrage at the conduct, stating that it would be “address[ed] after this case is over.”

So here’s my question.  What is he going to do about it?  Will he give the AUSA, or perhaps the ICE agents, a very strong tongue-lashing?  Will he draw an inference to be applied to all future proceedings that ICE agents are disinclined to feel any strong compulsion to respect constitutional rights?  Will he hold the agents in contempt?

The problem, you see, is that there are many unaffiliated violations of constitutional rights that are wrong, harmful, and defy remedy.  While the judge may be outraged, it begs the question:  What can he do to the agents of the government of the United States of America when they behave this way?  And if he can do nothing other than a harsh harangue, then there’s nothing that can be done to stop these agents.

OT: First Show of the Season

The end of March was fairly cold in New York, but a slight chill isn’t enough to stop classic car people from revving up the engine and pushing the tach needle almost to the red.  It was a brisk Sunday and time for the first car show of the season.

The show was run by Long Island Car Shows, a decidedly for-profit enterprise that operates a series of car shows around Long Island.  I use the term “car shows” loosely, as these are basically beauty pageants, where they give trophies to cars that a shiny rather than significant or authentic.  This is a group that will take a fee from anyone with a car, and draws an array of vehicles that are monumentally pedestrian.  As the weather improves, better cars come out just to kill a day, but in late March the pickings are thin.

My son and I entered this show at Belmont Racetrack the year before, and took first place in the foreign category.  There are something like 62 categories, including about 10 for Corvettes alone.  There is one category to cover all foreign marques, and they let in any car that pays, whether it’s 50 years old or last month’s model.  When you operate for profit, cash is king.

But few people come to see a Nissan Sentra with some extra chrome.  Muscle cars and T-Buckets are always a draw, but classic British cars like my Healey always draw a crowd.  And without a crowd, the Long Island Car Show folks have nothing to offer.  Car owners pay to get in so these guys can sell tickets to people to look at the cars.  Without interesting cars, they have nothing to sell.

We decided to come again this year because my son and I were both itching to get back in the Healey and go for a ride.  It didn’t hurt for him that we won first place, as he got a monster size trophy, though it was made of cheap plastic, a perfect reflection of the show itself.  For me, it meant a day with my son, which is the best reason there is to go.

Packed up the Healey and took off for the show, my very excited son as navigator and I as the obligatory driver.  We arrived about 10:30 in the morning, about a half hour earlier than we had arrived the year before.  At the gate, we were told that we were too late.  Too late?  The woman told us that cars to be judged had to be there by 10.  She said they had kept it open until 10:15, but then closed the judging.  I could go in as a “display only” car, but not to be judged. 



We went into the show and stopped at the judges’ van, to see if we could get them to let us into the judging.  The boss, whose name is unknown since he didn’t bother to introduce himself, gave me a broad smile when I asked.  He then explained how if he let us in, he would have to let everyone who came late in.  I told him we had come a long way.  He didn’t care. 

I reminded him that when he needed more cars in the show to make more money, he was quite happy to let people come in and late, as long as they paid.  He told me how it was people like me who make his life un pleasant.  Actually, he used somewhat rougher language than that.

Since we were already inside as a display car, we decided to park and look around.  The show was less than overwhelming.  There weren’t too many cars, and the ones there were notably inconsequential.  Within the foreign class, there was a 1996 BMW Z3 and a Volkswagon Beetle with some extra chrome purchased in the Bronx.  One would have thought that he would want a car like ours in the show.  Apparently, he just wanted the fee. 

The Healey immediately drew a substantial crowd.  It was clearly the most interesting foreign there, and one of the few true classics at the show.  Now my Healey is a driver, not a concours-level trailer queen.  But it is a beautiful car, in original condition and treated with respect by my chief mechanic.  We’re quite proud of it, even though it won’t win a gold medal at a big time event.  And others seem to enjoy checking it out, talking to us about it and taking photos of it. 



My son was extremely disappointed to have been shut out of the show.  He likes the big, flashy trophy.  But Long Island Car Shows has rules. It breaks those rules when it’s good for business, but for some reason it decided not to let us in that day.

After a brief walk around, seeing little of interest, we jumped back in the Healey to leave.  On the way out, the show’s owner yelled at me, “And I see you leave early too!”  He missed the point, of course.  No reason to hang around for his benefit if we weren’t going to be judged.

My son left without a trophy and said to me that from now on, we should only go to real car shows, where cars were judged by knowledgeable people based on real criteria, and where a first place win meant something.  Real car shows don’t worry about when you arrive, only that you bring a car that adds to the richness of the show.  They tend to focus more on the cars and less on the cash.

And I’ll still get to spend the day with my son.

Ignorance of the Law

While directed primarily at civil litigators, particularly personal injury lawyers, two posts,  here and  here, have generated a small mountain of comment that all lawyers should read.  No, not simply because they show the anger and hostility toward lawyers and the law in general.  That’s old news.

The significance is in how little non-lawyers know or understand about the law.  Sure, we’ve got one flavor or another of Law & Order on TV every night, not to mention another half dozen lawyers shows that come and go, but people aren’t buying. 

There are two primary problems raised by the content of the comments:  All lawyers are painted with the same brush, and the law and its practitioners is some vague and fuzzy evil thing.  To address, post by post, the factual errors would have been overwhelming and pointless.  People are angry at lawyers and believe that they know something about the law based upon their water cooler discussions with others whose knowledge of the law equals their own.

Perhaps the most obvious irony of this steam vent is the failure to recognize that there are two sides in every dispute, and that both sides often adamantly believe that they are absolutely right and the other side is absolutely wrong.  They refuse to accept the premise that being a litigation loser might have something to do with being on the wrong side of the law.  Instead, the only possible answer is that lawyers are evil and the law is a scam, since it couldn’t possible have anything to do with their conduct.

This problem isn’t limited to the ignorant.  Many of the comments are intelligently written, but fundamentally ignorant of the facts.  A great example of this can be found in this post, via the Turk,  The writer, Dr. Sam, goes on at great length about what is wrong with the legal system, summed up neatly here:

First, what is the root of the problem? I think at it’s heart it is basically a matter of myopic self-centered greed on the part of a significant portion of the legal profession, supported by the willing participants who make up a small but significant part of our population.

It is about folks willing to say, “To hell with justice. To hell with right and wrong. To hell with society and tough crap for any damage done to society as a whole. I see an opportunity to get some cash and I’m gonna pursue it, no matter who gets hurt in the process.”

If we assume that Dr. Sam is indeed a physician, which appears to be the case, then we must similarly assume that he’s a well-educated man, capable of rational thought, deliberation and fact-based analysis.  Yet when it comes to the law, he goes on a tear that’s sheer, ignorant emotion.  He don’t need no stink in’ facts.  He’s not gonna take it anymore!

The PI guys will attribute this pervasive hatred to years of promotion by the insurance industry to undermine the purpose of their efforts.  Others may be inclined to look to Dickie Scruggs, Mel Weiss and other scandals that have brought the legal profession into disrepute, whether deserved or not.  But this misses the point.

We are way past the point where there can be a rational discussion of why these visceral attacks on the law are wrong, and the countervailing reasons for the rules that apply to our society but seem foolish without further explanation.  Nobody wants to  hear it.  Nobody cares anymore.

Nor can we take comfort in the fact that our clients “love” us, and that we didn’t do anything to cause all these contentious lawyer-haters to feel as they do.  There are two themes that appear throughout the comments.  First, that regular people can’t afford lawyers.  Second, that they are far less than impressed with our services than we think.  The latter is somewhat obvious: In litigation, there’s almost always a loser.  The loser doesn’t believe that it’s a product of his conduct, but of his lawyer’s failure to win. 

We have a lot to do with this attitude.  The self-promoting lawyers try to sell the notion that they are so brilliant and wonderful that by merely paying them money, a client is guaranteed a good outcome.  When that doesn’t happen, we have another very angry person.

Of course, there are people who come by their hatred of lawyers honestly, meaning that they are taken advantage of, they are abused, they are lied to, they are mistreated.  We all know these lawyers, and rarely do we do anything about it.  Yes, the law is the only professional to sue its own.  Yes, our disciplinary boards take their job seriously and lawyers are regularly disciplined and even disbarred.  But for some reason, the public isn’t getting the message and thinks that we cover-up for our brethren.  Unfortunately, this is largely true.  While the most overt legal malpractice and ethical violations are addressed, the garden-variety incompetence is almost always ignored.  Even by judges, who have come to expect no more than garden-variety incompetence from the bar. 

I have posited that this is a by-product of supply and demand.  We churn out way too many lawyers, far more than our society needs or can handle, and these excess lawyers find imaginative ways to earn a living at the expense of the public.  The old joke, that it’s the 99% of incompetent lawyers that make the 1% look bad, really isn’t that funny anymore.  The bar association cheerleaders will react with platitudes about the majesty of the law and dignity of the profession, but this is meaningless rhetoric to the public.

One commenter stated that the lawyers can either clean up their act or the public is going to do it for us.  I believe he is right.  And it doesn’t matter that criminal defense lawyers don’t have anything to do with the problems that have caused all this anger; The public sees lawyers as one, big, ugly cancer on society, and criminal defense lawyers are just part of that amorphous mass. 

So they don’t understand.  They don’t want to understand.  And they aren’t going to understand. They are wrong about everything. So what?  This ignorance of how the law works, what the law is, why we do what we do, is pervasive.  It has become an article of faith, and no TV show is going to educate the public. 

The maxim, “ignorance of the law is no excuse,” no longer applies.  We may disagree about the root cause of the mess, but we can no longer justify sticking our heads in the sand and pretending that this problem is just going to go away on its own.  We can, and should, have a dignified profession of truly competent lawyer serving the public.  It’s up to us to make it so.

Done Deal: NY Judges Get 67% Raise

After intense negotiations lasting until the early morning hours, according to this  New York Times report, Senate Majority Leader Bruno, Assembly Majority Leader Silver and Governor Paterson emerged with their arms intertwined singing the Joni Mitchell song “Twisted” in a three part harmony, much to the shock of the waiting media throng.

“We’ve done the impossible,” Paterson announced, with a beaming Shelly Silver at his right hand side, wearing a powder blue suit.  “We have hammered out an agreement on a deal to increase the salary of New York’s judiciary that will not cost the taxpayers of New York one dime.”

Senator Joseph Bruno broke in that it was about time the Albany logjam was broken, and the third branch of government was shown the respect it deserved. 


This is a momentous occasion, not just because we’ve fixed the long-festering blight on the State, but because we’ve come up with a solution that will save New York’s judges from ever suffering like this again.

The deal includes an immediate payment of 52.5% to all judges who have served for more than five years to compensate for their having suffered so long without an increase and to help them over the “hump” caused by the increase in the cost of living over that period.  In addition, the base pay will increase by 67% to $232,950, with an annual automatic cost-of-living increase and an opportunity to purchase bespoke black robes at deep discount.

Governor Paterson stated that “it was only right,” and both Bruno and Silver added in unison “uh huh!”  They noted that the recent flight of 259 elected Supreme Court judges from the bench, leaving a backlog of nearly 27,000 cases across the state in less than one month, really caused them to focus on the problem.  “It was like an epiphany,” Bruno said.  “I felt just awful about the tsuris I caused,” Silver added. 

Paterson added that the near-death experience at the highly-publicized kiln explosion in the Governor’s Mansion made him appreciate the urgency of the situation. 


There was nothing that I needed to do as Governor more than straighten out this mess, Realizing that I could go at any minute made me understand that we needed to put the entire weight of the State behind increasing judicial salaries.  The future of New York depended on it.

Chief Judge Judith Kaye, when informed of the plan, exhorted, “Nice that those guys finally came to their senses.  I was just about to write another scathing editorial about the independence of the judiciary, and they would not have been happy, let me tell you!” 

Also announced, the Legislature has terminated all funding for indigent defense in order to fund the salary increase for the judiciary.  Governor Paterson explained, “And what are they gonna do about it?”