The Senate has passed the Second Chance Act, already approved by the House, intended to provide the crucial assistance for prisoners to re-enter society and move on to a productive life. It is described in a synopsis of the law from a press release by the Council of State Governments:
The Second Chance Act includes key elements of President Bush’s Prisoner Reentry Initiative, announced in the 2004 State of the Union address, which provides for community and faith-based organizations to deliver mentoring and transitional services. The bill will also help connect people released from prison and jail to mental health and substance abuse treatment, expand job training and placement services, and facilitate transitional housing and case management services.
There is little question that this law is long overdue, given the desperate need for services to reduce recidivism, educate, train, integrate and provide health and addiction services for those leaving prison. Yes, it’s unfortunate that prison doesn’t do more, a lot more, to prepare inmates for their release, but nobody likes to pay much attention to what happens inside prisons since they hate those people anyway.
But when they come out, people care a little because their recidivism impacts others. It’s not to be fair or nice to prisoners, but to keep those mutts from committing crimes against good people. There will be those who complain that “those people” get better services than they do, which is always a great argument for guaranteeing massive failure of the criminal justice system. If you don’t like recidivism, then something has to be done to give former prisoners a means to reintegrate. Pick your poison.
[Side Note: The bill was held up by that paragon of virtue, Alabama Republican Senator Jeff Sessions who put a block on the bill , perhaps waiting to see who would provide the largest contribution to his re-election war chest. This would be the same Jeff Sessions who sold himself to commercial banks in the DataTreasury amendment scandal.]
So this is a good start. The problem with good starts, however, is that everybody tends to pat themselves on the back for doing such a great thing and walk away from the grave. It’s a start, but only a start.
“The Second Chance Act will provide an opportunity for realistic rehabilitation for the more than 650,000 inmates who return to their communities each year,” said Senator Specter. “The bill’s focus on education, job training, and substance abuse treatment is essential to decreasing the nationwide recidivism rate of 66 percent.”
That’s a lot of people. It’s going to require a lot of resources to provide meaningful help “more than 650,000” re-entering inmates, and this comes at a time when the economy has turned south, “good, law-abiding” people are struggling and nobody wants to spend their hard-earned tax dollars on criminals.
A February 2007 report from The Pew Charitable Trusts stated that if federal, state, and local policies and practices do not change, taxpayers are expected to pay as much as $27.5 billion on prisons alone from 2007 to 2011 on top of current corrections spending.
That’s the catch. The cost of crime, the cost of investigation, arrest and prosecution, the cost of punishment, will far exceed the cost of reintegration. Will Congress have the will to do the job right? Will the public have the foresight to spend today to save tomorrow? We have a long history of being short-sighted when it comes to criminal issues.
There’s one additional facet worthy of mention, and that is the involvement and reliance on “faith-based” organizations for the delivery of these services. Grits posted about his support for the Second Chance Act, and I wondered how he felt about the faith-based component. In particular, I was curious whether concerns about religious involvement changed from region to region, since Grits is down in Texas, which seems to have some unusual views on non-Christian religions. It’s not that are biased, but that it is viewed as benign because there’s nothing about “faith-based” organizations that seem problematic when you’re in the religious majority.
Not surprisingly, this facet of the law raised no cackles. Perhaps this would be different if, say, the Nation of Islam become the primary provider of services rather than, say, the Salvation Army. While I raised the distinction between a “faith-based” organization’s religious versus secular function, nobody seemed particularly concerned about this either. It’s been my experience that people have a hard time distinguishing the secular from the religious function when it’s their own religion. This is a distinction that can best be seen with outside eyes.
But Grits brought up a second, overarching point: Faith-based organizations are the ones doing this critical work, offering services to help former prisoners re-enter society. It is not a matter of favoring the religious over the secular. They are the only game in town in many places, and without them (and in the absence of secular organizations willing and capable of providing these services), we’re left with no one.
Do you argue against throwing a life-saver to a drowning man because it says “Love Jesus” on it? No. And I while it may be unfortunate the secular organizations either do not exist, or are not sufficiently prevalent, to handle this need, I appreciate the fact that faith-based organizations exist to fill this critical need. Filling in the need is far more important that than the nature of the organization’s core mission. In the hierarchy of needs, survival comes first. We should appreciate the fact that these faith-based organizations exist, for without them many prisoners would have no one who cared enough to help.
My hope is that this initiative will produce a sufficient drop in recidivism to make it clear to the public and politicians that putting resources toward the goals underlying this law is a far better allocation of resources than building more prisons. As long as the program produces positive results, it will provide the foundation to push for more resources, more providers and fewer human beings in prison to prove how tough Americans can be on each other. We can sort out the details later, but this is a good start and an important positive step.