Author Archives: SHG

Stuff You Ought to Know

From the front page of today’s Wall Street Journal:


The federal deficit swelled 62% to $263.3 billion in the first five months of the buget year.  February’s deficit was a reord $175.6 billion.

Only 28% of Americans know that hearly 4,000 U.S. troops have died since the Iraq war began, a survey found.

Crude Rose $1,17 to a record close of $109.92 a barrel despite a larger-than-expected increase in inventories.

And from the online edition:

Bush vowed to veto a House bill that fails to give immunity to telephone companies that may have cooperated with the administration’s warrantless wiretapping program.

Just thought you might want to know.

When Candy Goes Underground

When New Haven honors student Michael Sheridan needed a fix, he never thought he’d be caught and suspended.  Nobody ever does.  So what was this 8th grader trying to get his hands on?  Skittles.  No, that’s not some new name for a dangerous narcotic mixed in bathtubs.  I mean skittles, the candy.  That’s right.

According to this AP report, courtesy of Overlawyered, poor Michael’s sweet tooth put him right between the cross-hairs of  those who demand that our schools micromanage every nuance of our children’s lives (since there is no aspect that can be trusted to parents anymore), including what goes into their stomachs.


The most recent reauthorization was in 2004 and added a new piece: Any school using federal money to provide food on campus (such as lunch) was required to create and implement a “wellness policy” no later than fall 2006. It’s been driven at least in part by concerns about childhood obesity; the National Center for Health Statistics reports that in 2003-04, 19 percent of children ages 6-11 and 17 percent of adolescents ages 12-19 were considered overweight or obese.

It’s intention was good, but did they really want to criminalize skittles?  Will there be a schedule coming out with the varying degrees of punishment for “dangerous candy?”


The New Haven school system banned candy sales in 2003 as part of a districtwide school wellness policy, school spokeswoman Catherine Sullivan-DeCarlo said.

There is a vast difference between a school encouraging good eating habits to combat obesity and criminalizing candy.  Teach, encourage, control what you serve in your cafeteria, all appropriate ways to address the problem.  But call out the swat team to take down a nefarious hallway candy buyer?  A little overkill, perhaps?

Notably, this is yet another example of the failure of prohibition.  Make candy illegal, and only criminals will sell candy.  Yes, even on this level it happens. 

As for young Mr. Sheridan, the school relented, recognized the abject stupidity of its actions. 


I am sorry this has happened,” [Principal] Turner said in a statement. “My hope is that we can get back to the normal school routine, especially since we are in the middle of taking the Connecticut mastery test.”

Mastery of what?  You mean they have to teach that too in Connecticut?

Forgotten, But Not Gone

Like the fear of waking up to find yourself buried in a coffin, 6 feet under, defendants in custody fear that they will be forgotten as their family and lawyers walk from the courtroom.  In Little Rock, they have good reason to be afraid.


According to reports by  the Chicago Tribune and  the AP, one bailiff in Arkansas had finished locking away Adriana Torres-Flores, charged with selling pirated CDs, but held because she was an illegal immigrant, when his attention was diverted.  He went about his work and then went home.  But he forgot one thing: Ms. Torres.

Torres-Flores, 38, appeared in court last Thursday on charges of selling pirated CDs. While others pleaded guilty she pleaded not guilty, but Circuit Judge William Storey ordered her held because she is an illegal immigrant from Mexico, deputies said.

Hankins locked Torres-Flores in the temporary cell and meant to have other deputies drive her back to the county jail. That never happened. No one heard Torres-Flores pounding on the cell’s steel door or looked through its peephole Friday, as snow blanketed Arkansas and Storey did not hear criminal cases.

However, the sheriff’s office said Hankins was on duty Friday.

The bailiff discovered Torres-Flores on Monday morning when he went to put another prisoner in the cell.

There is no one suggesting that anything about this was right, least of all bailiff Hankins, who feels awful (not to mention monumentally stupid) about all of this.  There’s no doubt that he didn’t mean to forget her in the jail cell.  There’s no doubt that this was a terrible accident. 

So, beyond the fact that poor Ms. Torres was subjected to this traumatic situation, why bother with this story?  While it’s not anywhere near as weird as the woman whose skin/fat grew around a toilet seat, it serves to make one important point: 

Human beings screw up.  It defines us.  We all make mistakes, and have the constant potential to be knuckleheads (I was reminded of this great word by  a commenter who used it to describe me, together with other choices words that are less colorful).  As we argue our way through people’s lives based upon the say-so of individual accusers, we need to keep this in mind. 

The Second Chance Act — A Good Start

The Senate  has passed the Second Chance Act, already approved by the House, intended to provide the crucial assistance for prisoners to re-enter society and move on to a productive life.  It is described in a synopsis of the law from a  press release by the Council of State Governments:


The Second Chance Act includes key elements of President Bush’s Prisoner Reentry Initiative, announced in the 2004 State of the Union address, which provides for community and faith-based organizations to deliver mentoring and transitional services. The bill will also help connect people released from prison and jail to mental health and substance abuse treatment, expand job training and placement services, and facilitate transitional housing and case management services.

There is little question that this law is long overdue, given the desperate need for services to reduce recidivism, educate, train, integrate and provide health and addiction services for those leaving prison.  Yes, it’s unfortunate that prison doesn’t do more, a lot more, to prepare inmates for their release, but nobody likes to pay much attention to what happens inside prisons since they hate those people anyway.

But when they come out, people care a little because their recidivism impacts others.  It’s not to be fair or nice to prisoners, but to keep those mutts from committing crimes against good people.  There will be those who complain that “those people” get better services than they do, which is always a great argument for guaranteeing massive failure of the criminal justice system.  If you don’t like recidivism, then something has to be done to give former prisoners a means to reintegrate.  Pick your poison.

[Side Note:  The bill was held up by that paragon of virtue, Alabama Republican Senator Jeff Sessions who put a block on the bill , perhaps waiting to see who would provide the largest contribution to his re-election war chest.  This would be the same Jeff Sessions who  sold himself to commercial banks in the DataTreasury amendment scandal.]

So this is a good start.  The problem with good starts, however, is that everybody tends to pat themselves on the back for doing such a great thing and walk away from the grave.  It’s a start, but only a start. 


“The Second Chance Act will provide an opportunity for realistic rehabilitation for the more than 650,000 inmates who return to their communities each year,” said Senator Specter. “The bill’s focus on education, job training, and substance abuse treatment is essential to decreasing the nationwide recidivism rate of 66 percent.”

That’s a lot of people.  It’s going to require a lot of resources to provide meaningful help “more than 650,000” re-entering inmates, and this comes at a time when the economy has turned south, “good, law-abiding” people are struggling and nobody wants to spend their hard-earned tax dollars on criminals.

A February 2007 report from The Pew Charitable Trusts stated that if federal, state, and local policies and practices do not change, taxpayers are expected to pay as much as $27.5 billion on prisons alone from 2007 to 2011 on top of current corrections spending.

That’s the catch.  The cost of crime, the cost of investigation, arrest and prosecution, the cost of punishment, will far exceed the cost of reintegration.  Will Congress have the will to do the job right?  Will the public have the foresight to spend today to save tomorrow?  We have a long history of being short-sighted when it comes to criminal issues.

There’s one additional facet worthy of mention, and that is the involvement and reliance on “faith-based” organizations for the delivery of these services.   Grits posted about his support for the Second Chance Act, and I wondered how he felt about the faith-based component.  In particular, I was curious whether concerns about religious involvement changed from region to region, since Grits is down in Texas, which seems to have some  unusual views on non-Christian religions.  It’s not that are biased, but that it is viewed as benign because there’s nothing about “faith-based” organizations that seem problematic when you’re in the religious majority.

Not surprisingly, this facet of the law raised no cackles.  Perhaps this would be different if, say, the Nation of Islam become the primary provider of services rather than, say, the Salvation Army.  While I raised the distinction between a “faith-based” organization’s religious versus secular function, nobody seemed particularly concerned about this either.  It’s been my experience that people have a hard time distinguishing the secular from the religious function when it’s their own religion.  This is a distinction that can best be seen with outside eyes.

But Grits brought up a second, overarching point:  Faith-based organizations are the ones doing this critical work, offering services to help former prisoners re-enter society.  It is not a matter of favoring the religious over the secular.  They are the only game in town in many places, and without them (and in the absence of secular organizations willing and capable of providing these services), we’re left with no one.

Do you argue against throwing a life-saver to a drowning man because it says “Love Jesus” on it?  No.  And I while it may be unfortunate the secular organizations either do not exist, or are not sufficiently prevalent, to handle this need, I appreciate the fact that faith-based organizations exist to fill this critical need.  Filling in the need is far more important that than the nature of the organization’s core mission.  In the hierarchy of needs, survival comes first.  We should appreciate the fact that these faith-based organizations exist, for without them many prisoners would have no one who cared enough to help. 

My hope is that this initiative will produce a sufficient drop in recidivism to make it clear to the public and politicians that putting resources toward the goals underlying this law is a far better allocation of resources than building more prisons.  As long as the program produces positive results, it will provide the foundation to push for more resources, more providers and fewer human beings in prison to prove how tough Americans can be on each other.  We can sort out the details later, but this is a good start and an important positive step.



Spitzer Aftermath; What to Expect

Eliot Spitzer has resigned, with the same aplomb as he demonstrated by going after legitimate businesspeople who did nothing more than their normal job.  It showed a man who didn’t grasp that his “private” conduct was a violation of a public trust.  It showed a man who was still tough and brazen.  He claimed he was “taking responsibility” for his conduct.  That has yet to be seen.

Spitzer’s resignation was not a symbol of “taking responsibility.”  It was a political necessity rammed down his throat.  Holding public office is not a right, but a privilege.  He lost that privilege when he, especially he, placed himself outside the law.  But taking responsibility for the commission of crime means something entirely different.  After any criminal defendant and they’ll tell you all about taking responsibility.

Even though Dan Hull (who it terrific) thought the Spitzer resignation was “pitch perfect” and he’ll be back (presumably after he’s zipped his fly up), what I saw was a horrific display of fear, self-absorption and disingenuity.  Politically, Eliot Spitzer no longer exists, except as a bad New York Joke.

But our departed Governor is not yet out of the woods. 


Immediately after New York Governor Eliot Spitzer announced his resignation yesterday, U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York Michael Garcia issued an unusual statement: “There is no agreement between this office and Gov. Eliot Spitzer, relating to his resignation or any other matter.”

This is obviously intended to dispel any speculation that he resigned as part of a deal.  This is revealing for another reason as well:  The general deterrence aspect of any high-profile criminal defendant is never far from the prosecution’s thoughts.  What they do, and how they do it, impacts both the defense and the prosecution.  The legitimacy of prosecutorial choices is at stake here.  Michael Garcia’s announcement made it clear the he is aware of his responsibility, and that his decisions will be made accordingly.

So what happens next?  The media has been awash with silly and vague speculation.  There have been a few astute comments, but they are drowned out by the chorus of “former prosecutors” with nothing to say.   Much of the speculation is based on the fairness approach (“ordinary johns aren’t prosecuted so why should Spitzer?”) and the paid-his-dues approach (“He resigned, isn’t that enough?”).  Neither approach, in my view, is appropriately applied in this situation.

The latest spin effort is that this is a Republican effort to smear Democratic politicians.  Maybe so, maybe not.  It doesn’t matter, since Spitzer’s commission of a crime, if the case, rises above (falls below?) political considerations.  If it was a matter of partisan attack, then he would have been safe had he not engaged in criminal conduct.  If he did, then it doesn’t matter what motivated his investigators to find out.

With the  complaint and the search warrant affidavit in hand, we are able to put aside some of the rank speculation and focus on what Spitzer is really facing.  This is not a case about arresting the “john”, but about the commission of two federal offenses, money laundering (structuring) and the Mann Act, together with conspiracy to commit both.

The talk about what would happen to ordinary people is off base.  Beyond the fact that “ordinary people” aren’t governors, or self-righteous avengers of morality, the hard fact is that the government regularly prosecutes “little people” for money laundering violations.  It happens all the time, and there’s no reason to think that Spitzer would or should get a pass.

The Mann Act violations are far more rare.  It’s a somewhat archaic law, from the days when the idea of crossing state lines to take advantage of more lenient laws in other locales was more offensive.  But as the warrant affidavit shows, it was in play with regard to the primary defendants, clearly implicated in the way that prostitutes were shipped around to meet the needs of the clients.  It’s not at all surprising that the Mann Act was resurrected, given the Department of Justice policy to charge the highest provable crime.  But since it has been raised with regard to the operators of the escort service, it should be anticipated that clients who sought to have their dates cross state lines will bear the consequences as well.

And of course, there will be the obligatory conspiracy counts relating to Spitzer’s agreement with the primary defendants to engage in the illegal conduct.

The United States Attorneys office will prosecute Eliot Spitzer because it has no choice to do otherwise.  Neither pauper nor Governor can ignore the law, as it should be if the law is to have any integrity.  Given the scrutiny that this case has  and will receive, there can be no other outcome.

Cries in the Dark: Decriminalization

Two of my most respected colleagues,  Mark Bennett and Jon Katz, have argued strenuously to end the war on drugs and prostitution, respectively.  Their arguments are persuasive and well-conceived.  Both know that they are crying in the dark.  It’s not going to happen.

Legalization of drugs was the most controversial stance of the National Review, Bill Buckley’s mouthpiece.  In 1996, he wrote:

Things being as they are, and people as they are, there is no way to prevent somebody, somewhere, from concluding that “NATIONAL REVIEW favors drugs.” We don’t; we deplore their use; we urge the stiffest feasible sentences against anyone convicted of selling a drug to a minor. But that said, it is our judgment that the war on drugs has failed, that it is diverting intelligent energy away from how to deal with the problem of addiction, that it is wasting our resources, and that it is encouraging civil, judicial, and penal procedures associated with police states. We all agree on movement toward legalization, even though we may differ on just how far.

There is nothing novel, nor truly controversial, in the rational for legalizing certain crimes.  The “War on …” cliché remains a vibrant part of the politicians’ lexicon, it remaining as effective today as it has always been.  Sure, it was a dishonest theft from the War on Poverty, to provide the sword to the shield of LBJ’s Great Society.  But a catchy phrase can’t be kept under raps.

For reasons unclear, people just refuse to connect the cost of programs based upon visceral disgust and self-righteousness to the benefits obtained.  Society (meaning the media and the politicians) ignore the former and harp on the latter.  Perhaps it’s our Puritan roots.  Perhaps it’s just easier not to think too hard.

As with our current economy enjoying devaluation of the dollars as massive deficits build to fight a war for some vague notion of unwanted “freedom” in Iraq, one might think this is an opportune point in time to revisit the cost/benefit analysis of our endless and costly wars.  Maybe it is, but someone has to champion the cause.  As much as I admire Mark and Jon for their bold positions, they are unlikely to have sufficiently high profiles to get this on the public agenda.  I suffer from the same problem.  Even though I think all presidential candidates should keep me in the loop at all times, they never seem to call.

I believe that our nation’s failure to have a thoughtful discussion about these issues goes back to the anti-intellectualism and elevation of “common sense” above all.  As we continue to promote mindless acceptance of commonly held beliefs because it is so much easier than thinking (“I hate thinking. It hurts.”), we are stymied in freeing up the tens of billions of dollars being flushed down the toilet of complacency and perhaps even making headway in dealing with some long-term societal problems.

There’s no need for me to restate the rationale behind decriminalizing/legalizing certain crimes, as others have already done so and I have nothing to add.  But as  Grits added by  a comment to  Doug Berman’s post about the things to consider when pondering the legalization of prostitution, even the academics are burdened by an intrinsic bias that starts the discussion with a straw man argument for the purpose of guaranteeing political correctness at the expense of meaningful debate.

We could turn around our economy, substantially reduce crime, provide help to those in need and reduce the massive “war-machine” surge to win the war du jour.  But that would require a massive paradigm shift led by a brilliant, charismatic leader.  Like I said, it’s not happening.

Crimes of the Times

Dan Quayle said, “What a waste it is to lose one’s mind. Or not to have a mind is being very wasteful.”  Amen Dan.  So what is the New York Times thinking, or wasting as our former Vice President so aptly puts it.

I am, at very best, a fair weather fan of Adam Liptak’s Sidebar column.  Granted, he’s demonstrated little grasp of criminal justice issues, and often shown a bias toward the facile as if he’s auditioning to take over Dunleavy’s desk at the New York Post.  But he writes for the New York Times!  This is no tabloid, but the great Gray Lady.

It’s not that he isn’t a good writer.  His words flow fairly well, though usually lacking much color or imagery to convey complex ideas to the reader in a cognizable fashion.  But then complex ideas rarely find their way into his columns.

It’s not that he isn’t a good lawyer.  Frankly, I haven’t a clue how good a lawyer he is (or was), but I have no reason to disparage his legal skills.

It’s that he is committing a crime, journalistic murder if you will, by taking up something that is enormously precious and wasting it:  Space in the New York Times.  It is dead space, and he killed it.

Gideon posted about the insipid  Sidebar column this week, asking the crucial question, which state’s court has been followed the most over since 1940.  While this may (arguably) pique the interest of some lawprof in the bowels of some left coast law school library, desperate for a subject to write about to pad his wad for tenure, it is utterly inconsequential.  No, that’s unfair.  It is monumentally, shockingly and utterly inconsequential.  That’s better.

The law is a never ending source of wonderment.  I have trouble keeping my postings down to a half dozen a day, there are just too many things that strike me as relevant and important, worthy of my time and yours.  Why is Liptak unaware of any of these?  Is his vision of the law so myopic that he found absolutely nothing worth writing about last week other than this inane study?  Lawyers don’t care about it.  Did he think the public would be fascinated by something so arcane and meaningless?

But now it’s time to address the Times editors.  Hello?  Anybody there? 

The New York Times has given Adam Liptak a bully pulpit, should he choose to use it.  Regardless, he has been given one of the most significant opportunities to educate and enlighten the public on matters crucial to society.  He has squandered this opportunity.  It is a crime.  It is an outrage.  How can anyone take such an opportunity and waste it this way?

I’ve asked a variety of the people I know in the media how certain choices are made, such as the pundits who opine on the variety shows that masquerade as news who demonstrate a total lack of understanding of the subject matter.  The answer for TV is generally that they look pretty.  Think Kimberly Guilfoyle.  Sometimes it’s because they are sufficiently outrageous that they draw an audience of the outraged or just regular people who show up to watch a car wreck.  Think Nancy Grace.

But the New York Times doesn’t cater to the sophomoric reader.  On topics political and economic, they offer some brilliant and provocative minds.  Why not law?  What caused them to pluck Liptak from their counsel’s office to their opinion page?  I’ve seen his picture.  He’s no matinée idol.  So why?

To paraphrase Dan Quayle, “Space in the New York Times is a terrible thing to waste.”  To do so is a crime.

Why Is Spitzer Silent? (Update)

Update 2:  Governor Eliot Spitzer announced that he will resign on Monday, March 17, at Lt. Governor David Patterson’s request.  In a speech lasting 2 minutes 41 second (WABC pegged it at 90 seconds, but I stick by my timer), that ranged from the self-serving to the insulting, somehow promoting the idea that he was resigning because he was living up to his own ideals of justice, as if this redeems his conduct and proves that he remains the avenging angel of morality, he barely managed to get out any inkling that this was all about him resigning.

It was a poor showing.  I was offended that the bulk of his speech remained self-promotional.  He claimed to be doing this to take responsibility for his failings.  If he wants to take responsibility, there’s a coutroom waiting for him downtown.

Additionally worthy of note was that Spitzer arrived late for the press conference, which was scheduled for 11:30, because his car was stuck in midtown traffic.  The news showed helicopter shots following the car through traffic to the State Office Building, like a O.J. low-speed chase, as if his car might take a surprise left and head for the West Side Highway.  Needless to say, watching his black SUV stuck in midtown traffic only served to heighten the ancitipation.  Well, not really.

Update:  Media outlets everywhere are announcing the Spitzer will resign this morning.  Word is that he is informing top officials first and then will make the public announcement. 

Eliot Spitzer learned that he was a target of a federal prosecution, Client-9 (the first good use for the Beatles’ White Album song ever) on Friday, and issued his public “apologia” on Monday.  He had the weekend to consider his options.  He chose an apology, with his poor wife Silda, looking like an advertisement for Thorazine, at his side.  It did not solve the problem.

Not only did it not solve the problem, but it has raised the problem to levels unseen since Hillary’s husband didn’t have sex with “that woman.”  One would think that the Governor would have a reason.  This is a very smart, if very foolish, man.  It is impossible to believe that he hadn’t given thought to where he was going after the apology, and he must have anticipated the groundswell of interest and abuse it would generate.  He MUST have.

So why is Eliot Spitzer silent?  Mike at  Crime and Federalism has posted about the speculation from CBS news that he is playing the governor card to cut a deal with the feds.

Eliot Spitzer is going to resign his post as governor. Sources tell CBS 2 HD he’s using the resignation as a bargaining chip with the feds. But after negotiating all day there was still no deal Tuesday night.

Spitzer doesn’t have the luxury of playing deal or no deal. Experts agree that his involvement in a prostitution ring makes him damaged goods.

If the strategy is to offer up his office in exchange for a deal, then Spitzer is a bonehead, his advisers are morons and he needs a new lawyer badly.  But I don’t believe this to the strategy, and I don’t believe any of them are as inept as to think that the governorship is a viable bargaining chip.  Even Michelle Hirshman, despite her  dubious qualifications to defend anyone, should know better, and I believe she does.

The unknown in this scenario was the depth and length of the public’s and media’s attention span.  This just isn’t an everyday type of problem, and it is unclear whether it would be a hanging offense or just the  Letterman joke of the week.  A day or two of waiting wasn’t going to change whatever clamor this situation would bring.  If he was dead, he would be dead a few days later.  If not, why commit suicide?

As it turned out, this is huge.  It would have been huge for any top level politicians, but it’s particularly huge for someone who’s career is built on the bodies of the indiscreet and has sold himself as the avenger of the righteous.  I can think of no time in Eliot Spitzer’s career that he showed any mercy, and despite  my suggestion to the contrary, no one is showing him any mercy in return.

Should it turn out that Spitzer’s relinquishment of office is tied to a plea deal for his conduct, whether it be structuring (breaking up sums of money to avoid reporting requirements or recognition that it would generate suspicious activity reports) or even the Mann Act (traveling across state lines for the purpose of prostitution), it would generate yet another outcry of impropriety, this time including the United States Attorney, political favoritism and abuse of his office.  It would be the only thing that could make this situation worse.

The problem for Spitzer right now is that his apology was insincere (or at least not nearly as sincere as it should have been), and his conduct egregious in light of his law-enforcer persona.  It was a tactical gambit that didn’t work, but has an impact on the availability of his subsequent options.  He can’t get a do-over.  He can’t trade-off his office for a sweet deal.  He can’t deny his involvement.  And he’s got nothing to give up.

Nor can Spitzer find comfort (as many have suggested) in the technicalities of federalism (what right does the federal government have to interfere in the service of a duly elected governor) or common practice (johns don’t get prosecuted, especially for structuring).  He is a governor.  He is not an ordinary target.  And sometimes johns do get arrested and prosecuted, even if it doesn’t happen every time.

We are nation of law, not men, or so the saying goes.  When situations like this are rubbed in our nose, the government has to put up or shut up.  What could be more cynical than to let a Governor get away with something like this?  It can’t happen, and it shouldn’t happen.

So what should New York Governor Eliot Spitzer do now?  I’m available for consultation, and I have a few ideas.  Operators are standing by.

Universal Legal Representation

Universal health care has been bandied for a long time as a cure for the plague of rising health care costs and the inability of the middleclass and poor to afford and obtain proper health care.  We have given a great deal of thought as to how this will impact doctors, their livelihood and the willingness of young men and women to assume the rigors of a medical education and career.

But what about us lawyers?  Kathryn Madigan, president of the New York State Bar Association,  has announced its support for the basic right to counsel in civil cases.


“If you are a poor person facing a fundamental forfeiture like the loss of health care or the loss of a home, there is no guaranteed right [to counsel],” she said. “It is a similar forfeiture to the loss of liberty when you lose your health and home and your safety. These are really basic human needs.”

She has a very good point, and one that all private counsel know all too well, whether they want to admit it or not.  As society has increasingly looked to the law to resolve its problems, and made every facet of life increasingly complex from a legal standpoint, the need for legal advice and representation to navigate life has increased significantly. 

Let’s face facts, one can’t deal with a broken vacuum cleaner without understanding the warranty terms, maintenance requirements, terms of sale, etc.  The cute TV commercials about how every company loves you may draw you in, but when you have a problem (as happens to all of us on a regular basis), you need a lawyer.  On a more significant scale, how many subprime borrowers now in default say that they had no lawyer when they closed a deal that any competent lawyer would have told them was insane.

Having created a need for lawyers, society now has a problem filling that need.  No, the problem isn’t the number of lawyers.  We’ve got far more than enough.  What we don’t have is a source of advice or representation that normal people can afford. 

Most people don’t have $25-50,000 lying around the château just in case a lawsuit erupts.  They can scream at each other on the phone, but the truth is that they can’t do anything to vindicate their rights when the person on the other side of the call says, “tough noogies, sue me!”  Sure, contingent fees work for personal injury, but they have no applicability to the vast array of non-PI cases, and certainly not to low-damages or (worse yet) equitable relief.

So we’ve constructed this fine-tuned legal machine, but at the cost of admission that leaves only the wealthy few able to enjoy it.  We’ve made it clear that the legal system, not self-help, not open-warfare, not vigilantism, is the way to redress our grievances, and then slammed the door shut in the face of ordinary people. 

The cost of legal fees would destroy the lives of many middleclass Americans.  They are shocked to find out what a lawyer’s time and advice will do to them.  They still have homes, cars and kids to feed, and are ill-equipped to give it all away to finance a lawyer.  Add the variable to the mix, that there is no guarantee that they will get what they want out of it at the end and thus may squander their family’s survival for a chance to roll the dice, and we have a failed system.

The other day,  Norm Pattis was on a rant about how we should extend the right to counsel in criminal cases beyond the indigent and just give everybody a free criminal defense.  Crazy talk for sure.  He was miffed because some lying lawyer stole a case by suggesting that he could win the unwinnable case, and the client went along because he wanted to know that his money was well spent.  Some clients just want to believe, no matter how ridiculous the claim.

I doubt that Norm was seriously suggesting that criminal representation be free for all under our existing paradigm, since that would present an awful problem for taxpayer and lawyer alike.  But the underlying point, that even a solidly middleclass defendant will find the cost of a criminal defense to be overwhelming and perhaps out of reach.  While he could do it if he refinances his home, sells his car, cancels cable, cellphone and wifi, this is a lot to expect of a person who didn’t ask to be in this position and receives no legitimate assurance that these sacrifices will suffice.  Worse yet, if he loses or pleads, he’s out of luck all around.  And if he wins, it’s not like he gets his money back. 

Criminal defense lawyers hear the recurring question from people who don’t qualify for free representation: “But why should I pay if I’m innocent?”  The facile answer is to keep from going to prison if you’re innocent.  This response, of course, is offensive to the person who did nothing wrong, but is still expected to watch his life destroyed by a system endorsed by people who reap the benefits of legal fees. 

It’s a problem for the vast majority of Americans.  Lawyers and legislators have made it a problem.  As we continually rely on the legal system as the answer to all problems, we leave too many people without access to the courthouse.  One day, they are going to figure this out and they are not going to be happy with lawyers.