Author Archives: SHG

Hershman (Who?) For The Defense (Update: Mystery Solved)

Mark Britton, Avvo CEO and loyal Simple Justice reader, has solved the Michelle mystery.  It appears that the Times Union spelled the name wrong, and that this is the  Michelle Hirshman who represented Governor Spitzer.

From her Paul Weiss bio:

A partner in the Litigation Department, Michele Hirshman focuses her practice on internal investigations and white collar defense matters. Ms. Hirshman comes to Paul, Weiss from the New York Office of the Attorney General where she served as first deputy attorney general under then Attorney General Eliot Spitzer. Prior to joining the Attorney General’s Office, Ms. Hirshman served as an assistant United States attorney in the Southern District of New York for eleven years. In the course of her tenure, she served as chief of the Public Corruption Unit, where she led major investigations and prosecutions of government fraud and political and police corruption. Ms. Hirshman has significant jury trial experience, and has argued many appeals before appellate courts throughout her career. She is a recipient of the John Marshall Award for Outstanding Legal Achievement from the U.S. Department of Justice.

Ms. Hirshman was articles editor of the Yale Law Journal.

She probably has plenty of pros experience as Chief of the Public Corruption Unit.
____________________

The  Albany Times Union as well as 1010 Wins says that Eliot Spitzer is represented by an attorney named Michelle Hershman.

His lawyer, Michelle Hershman, did not take calls to her office. She formerly worked with Spitzer’s attorney general’s office when he garnered international attention for his prosecution of securities fraud on Wall Street.

I’ve googled, Avvo’d, M-H’d Michelle Hershman, with negative results. 

A little help here.  Can anyone provide any background on Ms. Hershman.  Odd that a former prosecutor has no readily available track record.  Or existence other than in these reports.

Rejecting Ruling, School Bars Student. Again (Updated)

The principal of the W. Tresper Clarke High School in East Meadow, New York, had a decision to make.  He could do what most people would have done, and accepted the ruling of the New York State Division of Human Rights, and allowed 15 year old John Cave, accompanied by his service dog “Simba”, to attend school, or not.

Timothy Voels, the principal, decided to block the door to the school, according to Newsday.


Despite a state order in his favor, a hearing-impaired Westbury teenager was barred Tuesday morning from bringing his service dog to school.

John Cave, 15, his mother, his twin sister and a family attorney were met at the entrance of W. Tresper Clarke High School in East Meadow by principal Timothy Voels, who refused to allow the dog inside the school. The Caves and attorney Paul Margiotta then left, and John Cave did not return to school.

There are two levels of concern raised by Voels action.  On the first level, there is a student who is being harmed by a public school.  The principal, I would expect, would argue that bringing a service dog to school will “disrupt” other students, and it is his responsibility to care for the majority over the individual.  It is hard to fathom that anyone could believe such tripe in this day and age.  Except a principal.

The second level is respect for the determination of the agency responsible for enforcing laws relating to non-discrimination in New York governmental subdivisions, such as school districts.  The message from East Meadow is that they answer to no one.  They will decide what will happen within the walls of their schools, and no outsider will tell them otherwise.

As usual, a young man is lost in the arrogance of overly important people trying to prove their pre-eminence.  This is a nice way of saying who has the bigger genitalia.  And there is always some poor kid, some poor family, caught in the middle.  But this time, Voels has gone too far.


The confrontation on Tuesday morning lasted less than a minute as reporters watched from a distance. Margiotta said Voels, who was accompanied by a sign language interpreter, told the family that the district would not abide by the state’s ruling.

There is a pervasive stench of petty dictatorship that emits from school districts.  They know better than anyone.  They listen to no one.  When the caught committing crimes, they always have a ready excuse, and smiling chorus of sycophants that will back them up no matter how vapid their rationalization.  It would be a brilliant set up, if only it wasn’t so damaging to students and families.  Even the ones to foolish to realize that they are played for fools.

So here’s a petty tyrant, whether it’s Principal Voels, the district superintendent Leon Campo, or the school board (which exists to rubber stamp the “professionals”), doing harm to students, one at a time.  It’s hegemony in a little pond.

John Cave, the 15 year old who only wants to go to school, deserves better:


With Simba lying at his feet, John Cave said he was nervous before going to school Tuesday morning.  “I didn’t get enough sleep last night, so I’m going to go home and rest,” he said.

If I was his father, I would hold him and rock him until he fell asleep.  He sounds like a fine young man.

Update:  If John Cave’s situation doesn’t bother you, perhaps you will enjoy two NYC 4 year olds hand-cuffed and told then will never see their parents again if they don’t take a nap, per the New York Post, courtesy of Turley.  Keep telling yourself that schools are good, teachers can be trusted, they know what they’re doing.  I know, maybe if we give them a raise, then . . .

Spitzer Aside: Money Laundering Considered

It now appears that my governor (a term that still applies for the moment) may have given rise to the initiation of federal attention because of his “unusual currency transactions.”  Thus, an opportunity arises to talk about the unintended consequences of the development of money laundering in America.  No, this will not be a law review article, so don’t ask for string cites.

There was a time when people reached in their pockets and pulled out something called “paper money” to pay for things.  This was considered normal.  It was not viewed as criminal conduct; Indeed, it was a rather prudent course because people didn’t spend more than they had in their pocket.

This presented a dilemma for the watchdogs of American morality.  How could they know where the money was coming from or going to?  Such archaic transactions precluded those who held themselves as our moral saviors from peeking into our wallets to make sure that you, me, Spitzer, weren’t being bad. 

The idea was sold publicly that this was needed to assure that criminal proceeds would be identified and that the taxes levied were collected.  A presumption was crafted we should all use our money in a fashion that the moral arbiters deemed appropriate.  This was the way they acted, and therefore was the only “right” way for the rest of us to behave.  Only criminals would do otherwise.

So a system developed that allowed our government to keep tabs on all its citizens and visitors to make sure that we weren’t spending our money in a way that displeased the morality police.  It was not enough that you earned your money lawfully.  It was not enough that you paid every penny of taxes due.  It became the manner in which money was spent, because money used in a way that displeased the moral arbiters could be indicative of unlawful conduct.

This notion was unacceptable.  It offended the sensibilities of those who needed to know what we did in private.  They could not bear to have us spend our money without their oversight.  They enlisted the banks in their cause, with the fist in the iron glove.  The IRS was only to happy to create forms to assure compliance.  Rules were set in place that presumed a free society to be a criminal society.  We were required, upon pain of imprisonment, to disclose our finances to border guards, bank tellers and grocery clerks.  We were presumed, by our very own government, to be criminals unless we proved otherwise.

This has been a very effective measure in the war against crime.  If there is any doubt, Governor Spitzer will disavow you of the notion.  But it has also been a very big step toward Big Brother.  I remember an America where people could travel from one side to the other without having to show identification to anyone.  I remember an America where people could spend their lawfully earned money in currency without having to fill out a form or explain it to a government employee’s satisfaction.

We have become a nation run by grocery clerks with checklists.  An elite cadre of moralists have taken paternal control, and we have happily handed our personal choices over to them because they have promised us safety and security in exchange.

New York Governor Eliot Spitzer has been caught and disgraced as a result of our government’s deep involvement in personal spending.  Do you feel safer knowing this?  Has the trade-off been worth it for you?

Why Eliot Spitzer Should Get Better Than He Gave (Update)

When the  Wall Street Journal calls for Spitzer’s head, you know it’s the end of the road.  But it’s times like this, after we enjoy the delicious irony, that we can put our detached beliefs on the table and prove whether we will give the same consideration that we ask for our clients to those who aren’t worthy.

Eliot “Ness” Spitzer would not have cut me a break.  Nor you.  Just ask Hank Greenberg or a dozen others who were ruined by this man as he climbed the ladder of prominence as the “Sheriff of Wall Street.”  Of course, this makes it all the more difficult to ponder why he would risk everything.  Norm Pattis explains that he was thinking with the wrong head, and he’s no doubt right. 

Like any man who assume a position of such prominence, there is hubris, which will prove to be his ultimate downfall should he prove incapable of controlling himself. 

Under a slightly different set of circumstances, I might well be in the Spitzer administration today.  Not because I was a fan or supporter of Eliot Spitzer, but because he was a Democrat elected governor by a huge margin, giving him a mandate to challenge certain practices in the state that I believed demanded reform.

A dear friend of mine was close to Eliot and his wife from their early days as lawyers.  My friend had been engaged in a number of important public service functions, and I admired the work he had been doing with non-profits to help others.  When he was given a top post in the Spitzer administration, we talked.

There were a number of areas that I was interested in helping, including criminal justice and education.  I’ve had an exceptionally good run as a private criminal defense lawyer, and felt strongly that I could contribute to the betterment of a system that I was swift to criticize.  I wanted to be part of the solution, not just another guy pointing out problems.

And so my friend shepherded my name to the group of people who were making decisions about who was worthy of involvement.  I waited a while.  No word.  Finally, I called my friend to ask what was happening.  He hemmed and hawed a bit, then came clean. 

The people who had been charged with putting together the team of criminal justice decision-makers were a bunch of ex-prosecutors.  These were the types of guys who were called the “white collar crime defense lawyers” at Biglaw, guys who shifted firms but never shifted allegiance.  They now had manicures, but there hands had never gotten dirty, like mine, by defending people in the trenches.

The decision-makers remembered me.  All too well.  I had been their adversary when they were “doing justice” in the United States Attorneys offices, the District Attorneys offices, the Attorney Generals office.  When they saw my name as someone who wanted to help, they chuckled.  Thanks, but no thanks.  I was told that the Spitzer administration had no place for a criminal defense lawyer.

Eliot Spitzer is in freefall now, by his own hand.  He will, eventually, hit the ground.  Hard.  I could take this opportunity to pay him back, to remind his cronies that they chuckled at the prospect that a criminal defense lawyer had anything to offer the people of the State of New York.  I was ready to give up a great deal to serve others, and they laughed at the prospect.

I will not seize this opportunity for payback, either personal or general.  Neither Eliot Spitzer, nor the smug coterie of prosecutors who he surrounded himself with, is of sufficient consequence to change my principles. 

Eliot Spitzer has proven himself to be a human being.  He has made ruinous choices in his personal life, like so many others before him.  The mighty fall, and they deserve to fall.  But I will not relish his fall and join in the chorus for his ouster.  I will demand that he learn from this experience, to appreciate how far from perfect he is and how much he has in common with his fellow man.  I will point out that he is not above others, that his lack of mercy and understanding toward others was terribly wrong, but that he can now be a better person if he recognizes his hubris.

It’s unlikely that Eliot Spitzer will call me this morning and ask me my thoughts.  It’s far more likely that he will sit in his majestic Fifth Avenue apartment with his pro-prosequi advisers, who will tell him in hushed tones that they, virile men all, understand his urges and needs, but that his sin is unforgivable.  These are men who have never forgiven another.  Only they are allowed their secret errors, and only as long as they remain secret. 

Eliot Spitzer will be counseled by to resign.  There is little doubt that this is the only outcome he will see as a viable end to the shame.  Lloyd Constantine will urge him to consider alternatives, but Spitzer will be broken and unable to face dishonor.  The die was cast yesterday.  Now, it’s just a death watch.

And the opportunity to learn and grow from this flagrant demonstration of hubris will be lost, and New York will be no better for this law-and-order Governor’s disgrace.

Update:  The New York Times editorial speaks to Spitzer’s arrogance and the harm he has done to the cause of reform in Albany.  Why did no one notice the arrogance when they were annointing him Emperor (pun and irony intended) in his run for governor?

Eliot Spitzer: I’m a Jester Too! UPDATE: Spitzer Does NOT Resign!

UPDATE 5:  From Talkleft,

CNN just reported Gov. Eliot Spitzer is under federal criminal investigation and that he is, indeed, customer “9” in the 55 page complaint in U.S. v. Mark Brener, et. al.

Spitzer was at a hotel in Washington, D.C. and allegedly asked Tameka “Rachelle” Lewis to send a specific woman, Kristin, from NY to D.C. to his room at the Mayflower.

Go to page 34. There’s a lot of detail. Paragraph 85 may be key.

It’s clear from the document that Customer #9 was a repeat customer and that he intended to use them again in the future. Read pages 34 to 39. They discuss his having a credit balance and whether he can leave more than he owes for future visits.

Spitzer’s statement today is here.
UPDATE 4:  Latest word from  ABC and BBC, Spitzer apologizes but no mention of resignation.  No word on global pardons for prostitutes and johns.

UPDATE 3:  After word was spread that Spitzer was resigning, effective immediately, it now appears that he has made a vague mea culpa and NOT resigned.  Stay tuned.  The situation is (as they say in politics) fluid.

UPDATE 2.1:  Spitzer to resign, effective immediately.  New York State to have first African American and Blind Governor, David Patterson.

UPDATE:  While awaiting the press conference, the rumor amongst press in attendance is that Spitzer will announce his resignation.  Unbelievable!

Aside:  From Overlawyered : Best line heard so far, adapted from comment at Reason “Hit and Run” : “Hooker admits Spitzer link, quits escort service in disgrace”.    Posted by: Walter Olson

The  New York Times and  Newsday have announced that New York Governor Eliot Spitzer, who made his bones as the tough-on-crime Attorney General, is embroiled in a prostitution scandal.  Details are scarce, but this is what the Times had to say:
Mr. Spitzer, who was huddled with his top aides inside his Fifth Avenue apartment early this afternoon, had hours earlier abruptly canceled his scheduled public events for the day. He scheduled an announcement for 2:15 after inquiries from the Times.

Mr. Spitzer, a first-term Democrat who pledged to bring ethics reform and end the often seamy ways of Albany, is married with three children.

Just last week, federal prosecutors arrested four people in connection with an expensive prostitution operation. Administration officials would not say that this was the ring with which the governor had become involved.

But a person with knowledge of the governor’s role said that the person believes the governor is one of the men identified as clients in court papers.

Now I don’t personally care who Spitzer is shtupping, provided it isn’t me, but this isn’t likely to turn out well.  Word from my friends in the media (awaiting his press conference at this moment) is that he is done.

Update:  Here’s the Southern District complaint.

Kentucky, Center of the Anonymous Universe

Many people make fun of Kentucky.  Sure, there’s a dearth of dental hygiene and a DNA distinction issue, but it really isn’t anywhere near as bad as people say, right?  Well, consider this bill proposed to the Kentucky legislature, picked by our hinterlands correspondent, Kathleen “Miz K” Casey, who is apparently hiding out from the revenuers in search of the wild and bizarre.

From the local ABC affiliate, WTVO 36 :


Kentucky Representative  Tim Couch filed a bill [House bill 775] this week to make anonymous posting online illegal.  The bill would require anyone who contributes to a website to register their real name, address and e-mail address with that site.   Their full name would be used anytime a comment is posted.

Full name?  You mean, like Timothy instead of Tim?  So tell me, Timmy, what exactly do you plan to do if somebody posts a comment and lies about their name (let’s make this as malevolent as possible, shall we?).


If the bill becomes law, the website operator would have to pay if someone was allowed to post anonymously on their site. The fine would be five-hundred dollars for a first offense and one-thousand dollars for each offense after that.

And that would be against who, me, the blawg owner, or Mr. Anon@Anon?  (Incidentally, I think you should give me your real names too, but just to satisfy my pathetic idle curiosity and let me track you down if need be.)

Just so we’re clear, when Representative Couch is not busy proposing new laws, he spends his time running the Hayden Grocery and Couch’s Shell station.  He pumps gas real good.

For those of you who so desperately want to attribute a semblance of intelligence to the otherwise pathologically silly things that politicos do, would you like the offer an explanation of how exactly Timmy thinks he’s going to make this happen?


Representative Couch says enforcing this bill if it became law would be a challenge.

You think?  Maybe the Kentucky Highway Patrol is going to make a road trip to New York and make me pay?  I certainly don’t want to trouble them, so anybody thinking about posting an anonymous comment on the inter net, please show Kentucky a little consideration and please register your full name, address and email with the State of Kentucky.  You can do so at [email protected]. 

Hey Jim Chen, is it something in the water down there that makes the fellas in Frankfort come up with this stuff?

What Does More of the Same Prove?

When the Pew Report announced that we have reached the pinnacle of prison success, a full 1% of our population in prison, former federal judge  Paul Cassell wrote that this proves that imprisonment reduces crime.  I was unpersuaded.

Undeterred, Judge Cassell  found an ally in his quest to show that the more people we put in prison, the better off the rest of us will be in Kent Scheidegger at Crime and Consequences, a blog sponsored by the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, whose motto is “Give ’em a darn good trial before you put ’em to death.”  For apparently good reason, Judge Cassell didn’t include a link to Kent’s post lest we note that he’s a shill for the prosecution.

Frankly, I’m hurt that Paul Cassell didn’t link to me.  As a Utah lawprof and victim’s rights advocate, his credibility is judged on his ability to address the challenges presented by those who disagree with him.  Instead, he pulls Kent out of the chorus to support his singing the lead.  The gist of this new-found claim is that the same statistical showing, that more people in prison means less crime, can be tracked back to the 1960s per Kent, when it was only tracked back through the 1990s in the Pew Report. 

The problem is that this wasn’t the challenge to Judge Cassell’s argument that locking people up en masse doesn’t have an impact on crime.  So, while he’s given us more of the same, he still has refused to recognize the failing of this statistical showing to prove his point in the first place.  Or address it.

Others, far better with stats than me, have shown how the statistical correlation between incarceration rates and crime rates fails.  There is no direct inverse relationship between the increase in incarceration and the decrease in crime.  The two lines operate independently, and the assumption that because they tended to trend in the same direction meant that there was a direct correlation doesn’t hold true.  Us non-statisticians tend to assume a lot about statistics because we just don’t understand them very well.

Even if we ignore the statistical failings of the argument, however, the issues of logic remain unresolved.  If we were to lock away 1000 people at random, we would have a reduction in the crime rate because some of our randomly selected prisoners would have committed a crime.  What about the rest of the randomly selected prisoners who would not have committed a crime?  Square that up with your victim’s rights position, Judge.  They would be victims too.  Victims of your philosophy.

It would be awfully nice if Judge Cassell would link to me from time to time, as I would really like to know why there are some victims that are worthy of his devotion and others that he will happily throw away.  How exactly do you chose which victims are worthy?  Just asking.

Shame On You

Shaming as an alternative punishment keeps cropping up, invariably raising controversy.  Doc Berman found an instance in Florida, and raises it as an example of a sound approach to punishment:


Photo_servlet As detailed in this local Florida story, headlined “Teen Forced To Carry ‘I Am Stupid’ Sign After Speeding Ticket,” a mother recently made headlines by imposing a shaming punishment on her reckless son.  Here are the basic details:



Adam Clark was pulled over going 107 mph in a 55-mph zone; neither the police nor his mother were pleased.  Adam’s mother, Heidi Wisniewski, not only took his car away, but also made him a sign to show outside of his school every morning and every afternoon.


He was forced to hold a sign reading, “I was stupid. I drove over 100 mph and got caught. Thank God!  I could have killed me and my friends.”  Adam said he got some strange looks and laughs from classmates at Orlando’s Merritt Island High School, but said he accepts his punishment. Despite the humiliation, he said he isn’t mad at his mother….


Wisniewski said her son would be in front of the school before and after school for a month, and added that she didn’t think the punishment is over the line.  “I love my son very much,” she said.  “I think more parents need to be tougher on their children.”…


Adam said the punishment worked. “I’ve learned my lesson,” Adam said.


Doug, who has some  curious theories about why alternatives to incarceration meet resistance, clearly favors shaming as a viable option.  Unlike forfeitures, shaming has greater merit as an alternative, though it is not without its problems in execution.

For example, one comment raised a proposed California brainstorm :

[P]proposed legislation by California State Senator (15th Dist.) Abel Maldonado to “require sex offenders to be identified on their vehicle license plates, like modern-day scarlet letters, pointing to statistics that show such criminals frequently use their cars to commit crimes.”

The commenter asked whether this would also be viewed as a fine option.  There was no response.

From my experience, I can think of plenty of defendants who would have happily accepted a shaming punishment in lieu of incarceration.  For the most part, these defendants couldn’t have cared less about the shaming aspect, and simply preferred not being taken off the streets to ply their trade or away from their families.  Would shaming have served to deter them?  There’s no general answer.  It’s a person by person determination.

Shaming is a psychological punishment; For those who care about being shamed, it should have an impact.  Others with more sociopathic tendencies may be harder to shame, since they don’t really care a great deal about what others think and, in a strange way, may even view the shaming as a badge of honor.

The problem with shaming is that it’s efficacy is based upon projected assumptions.  You and I may feel the harsh impact of public shaming, but then you and I aren’t out there committing crimes.  We assume that those who do will feel the same way that we do.  Whether this is true is up in the air.

But shaming also takes us further down the road of creating a permanent underclass of certain types of “criminals” that creates another set of problems with which we are ill-equipped to address.  For example, the sex offender registry is largely shame-based, allowing the general public to identify sex offenders so that they can make sure that they have no viable future in society.  The public, with torches and pitchforks, can march on their homes and jobs to assure that they will be perpetual social pariahs.  This leaves people on the registry to do what for the rest of their lives? 

Then there’s the problem of overbreadth, where there are people on the registry who are devoid of the moral culpability that is assumed, but are still there and will be there forever.  Consider the high school senior convicted of statutory rape of his girlfriend, who he later marries and with whom he has 4 kids.  He cops to probation and is a sex offender for life.  Who have we saved?

But between these extremes, there may well be plenty of room for shaming as an appropriate penalty, provided that it is indeed in lieu of incarceration (one of my constant problems with newfound punishments, which are too likely to be used to pile-on rather than as a substitute).  Yes, it is painfully paternalistic for government to treat citizens like children, but it may well be more effective, far less costly and, in the long run, more acceptable to defendants than a vacation at Club Fed.

The question remains, who’s to choose when shaming is a good idea or a disaster, and how much shaming serves its purpose and how much is creates improper harm?  The quick answer is the same judge that decides how may months or years one spends in the clink.  But prison covers certain legitimate sentencing functions that shaming does not.  For example, shaming does nothing for rehabilitation, a critically important function for many defendants who need education and substance-abuse rehab to function in society.

While shaming should not be dismissed out of hand as a potential substitute for incarceration, it is similarly no panacea and has significant limitations and problems that will have to be worked out before it can be accepted as a real substitute.  The problem is that it is unlikely to receive this vigorous scrutiny, as demonstrated by the knee-jerk SORA-type legislation, that makes great political headlines and works huge unintended harm.

Judges, Jesters and “Mirth is King”

From our hinterlands correspondent, Kathleen, comes another missive from Buffalo, where those long, cold winters seem to impair judicial discretion beyond repair.  Have you ever heard of the Royal Order of Jesters? It’s apparently some subset of the Masons (that secret association of leaders of American government and business) and Shriners (grown men in funny hats) dedicated to getting drunk and having sex with prostitutes.  No, I can’t tell you how to join.

But according to the Buffalo News, retired Supreme Court Justice Ronald H. Tills, a judicial hearing officer, found himself an application.  He, together with his law clerk, Michael Stebick and a retired police captain decided to pack up the Winnebago and go to a Jesters’ convention to make merry. 

FBI and U.S. Border Patrol agents are investigating allegations that retired Judge Ronald H. Tills, his former law clerk and a retired police captain took the female massage parlor employee in a motor home to a gathering of members of a nationwide group called the Royal Order of Jesters.

At the Jesters event, law enforcement officials said, the woman allegedly was paid to perform sexual favors. Police said the men who took her to the event could face federal criminal charges for transporting her over state lines for the purposes of prostitution.

When is the last time anybody heard of the Mann Act being used?  Now it could be devastating for an old time judge to hit the road and engage in risky business involving young women.  This isn’t the sort of thing that an old ticker can handle without practice and exercise.  I mean, he could kill himself.  But then, he’s a Jester.


The investigation is a spinoff of a case involving prostitution at local massage parlors. Court papers filed by federal prosecutors after a December crackdown on those local massage parlors referred to a “judge” and a “police captain” as being frequent customers of some of the parlors.

Six sources who are familiar with the investigation said Stebick, the owner of the motor home used on the trip, Tills and retired Lockport Police Capt. John Trowbridge went on the road trip, accompanied by the woman from the massage parlor and as many as nine other local men associated with the Jesters.

Now, I was always of the view that these Masons and Shriners (aren’t they the ones with the children’s hospitals?) were dedicated to good causes, religion, stuff like that.  Frankly, I’m beginning to think they need better marketing, because I certainly missed the boat on this club.


“Mirth is king” is the fun-loving group’s motto, according to its Web site. There are about 23,500 members in all, and each must already be a member of the Shrine of North America and the Masons, Rogers said. “Our purpose is to spread the gospel of mirth and merriment,” Rogers said.

That seems pretty clear.


To hear of the investigation from a reporter was “unnerving and shocking,” Rogers said.  “We certainly don’t stand for any of that stuff,” he said.

He was shocked.  Shocked!


However, allegations of prostitution activity at Jesters conventions have surfaced publicly at least once before — during a federal court case in Milwaukee, Wis., in February 1990, according to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. According to the newspaper’s account, a woman admitted to a federal judge that she ran an interstate prostitution business and was hired to provide prostitutes for Jesters conventions in New Orleans, Houston, Chicago and other locations, including some in other countries.

Now if only I knew the secret handshake.


The Jesters try to take the “highest caliber Shriners we can get” who distinguish themselves in the community, Rogers said.  “We try to keep the cream of the crop,” he said.

Nope.  I’m not even going to touch this one.

For future reference, Shriners have their funny hats, Masons have their funny bibs.  And Jesters, apparently, wear black robes or blue uniforms.  Just so you know who’s who.

Ghost of the Flea: Litigants Never Learn

There’s something about Eric Turkewitz at New York Personal Injury Law, that makes people want to spill their guts to him. 

We all remember the Flea, the great anonymous medical blogger who happened to be a pediatrician in a med mal case.  As he learned on cross, the blogosphere isn’t quite as anonymous as some think.  But the visitors to Turk’s blog have learned nothing from the Flea.  

The Turk has posted about a Rico suit against Allstate Insurance claiming that the carrier has put together a group of doctors and IME companies for the purpose of rendering scam opinions that victims of auto accidents are fine and need no further treatment.  One of the docs in the suit sent the Turk a response, which the Turk diligently posted as well.

But  the comments to Turk’s posts about this Allstate Rico action are quite amazing.  Defendants, their wives, mothers, kids, neighbors and the mailman have all decided to get in their licks on this case.  It is a gold mine for one attorney, a nightmare for the other.

What are they thinking?  Of course, these are anonymous posts, assuming that they can’t be identified through their content when they start posting particulars about their situation and why the plaintiff in the case is evil and wrong and disgusting.  But that’s the lesson of the Flea, and it was learned right there at Turk’s blog.

There’s no such thing as true anonymity on the web.  Turk has the email and/or IP addresses of the “anonymous” posters.  He’s already got his back to the wall, thinking what to do when the tall stack of subpoenas show up.  While he’s got no plans on spilling the good (perhaps a product of my good influence?), the fact is that he has no idea what a court will order him to do, and if he’s ordered to disclose the information about the posters, then he will have no choice but comply.

Why do they do it?  I guess civil defendants aren’t a whole lot different than the criminal flavor.  They want to have their say, to argue what they think is their side.  They want a catharsis.  But they surely aren’t thinking about the consequences.  And they surely haven’t learned anything from the ghost of the Flea. 

I wonder if I could post about rats and get all of them to spill their guts here?  Or maybe dirty cops?  But then, I’m no Turk.  It’s just amazing how he gets people to come out of the woodwork and vent.