Author Archives: SHG

The New York Democratic Primary Primer

If it wasn’t for the telephone call I received yesterday from Hillary Clinton, I might have missed it altogether.  Today is Super Tuesday, though it seems pretty much like an ordinary Tuesday around here.  A few TV adds and one telephone call.  Nothing in the mail at all. 

I’m reluctant to get involved in the subject of presidential party candidates.  No, not because I’m reluctant to post anything political or controversial.  And yes, I have had  a comment or  two about Rudy Giuliani, though my purpose of enlightening non-New Yorkers to the real Rudy is purely educational, and in no way reflects my personal feelings about whether anyone else should vote for him.  Of course, that’s history now, since Rudy  has been rejected by Americans of all types.

After 12 years of campaigning, the race for the Democratic nomination has come down to two candidates, Barak Obama and New York’s own junior Senator, Hillary Clinton.  We never suspected that Hillary had aspirations for higher office when she moved to New York and was elected Senator the following day.

In some ways, it’s hard to distinguish one candidate from the other.  Both support the death penalty.  Both tell us that we will have universal health care.  Neither is a white, Anglo-Saxon, male.

Obama clearly wins the speechifying trophy.  He’s far more inspirational than Hillary.  But Hillary has plans.  She’s far more nuts and bolts than Obama. 

Obama brings the vitality that reminds us of JFK, who uttered those famous words, “Ich bin ein Berliner.”  JFK said other stuff too.  Hillary has experience.  She’s unlikely to get lost walking around the White House, and will know exactly what to serve at State Dinners from day 1.  What Bill is going to do all day long is a huge mystery, but I’m still reluctant to let my daughter work as White House intern.  I’m not saying anything, but better safe than sorry.

Others have made their decision about whether to vote for Obama or Hillary (we use Hillary’s first name to avoid dreaded “C” word).  I can see how the Republicans would drool over Hillary being the Democratic nominee.  The one thing all Republicans agree upon is that they hate Hillary.  She would be the primary galvanizing force for the opposition, even if John McCain, the most statesman-like candidate for the Presidency in generations, is nominated despite the fact that many Republicans think he’s really a Democrat without hair.

I find it difficult to muster an affirmative reason to prefer one over the other.  Both scare me.  Both have virtues. Neither has convinced me that they are worthy of my vote.  

While I consider voting a sacred civic duty, it strikes me that voting for its own sake may not be the best way to exercise that civic duty.  The odds-makers say that Hillary Clinton, a favorite daughter, will win New York.  I’ve never subscribed to the favorite son/daughter philosophy, but then I’m not in line to be attorney general so I don’t see any personal benefit to having New York’s junior Senator in the White House.

It seems wise to leave it to people who want to vote for someone to make the call between Hillary and Obama, rather than just vote for the sake of voting.  I’m going to sit this one out, and hope that whoever ultimately gets the nomination does something that makes me want to vote for him or her.  It’s been a long time since I’ve voted for someone rather than against someone else. 

An Unpleasant View of Seattle

Seattle is often described as a beautiful city, and no doubt it is . . . if you are standing up and your eyes aren’t clouded by blood.  But as a frequent commenter here, Packratt, points out on his blog, the view is different after the local cops apply their “use of force” policy on someone.


Every once in a while, a reporter will grab hold of a problem in a city like Seattle and do an expose.  We gasp in shock at how mean and horrible it can be on the business end of a police baton or taser.  We discuss ad naseum whether the courts address police use of excessive force adequately, or whether it’s excessive force at all.  Of course, we do so from the safety of our homes and offices, rather than from the street where we find ourselves lying in a pool of our own blood.

Packratt has chosen, for personal reasons, to chronicle the state of affairs in Seattle on his own.  The cops there don’t like him for it.  He gets threatened, and harassed.  Try to exercise your right to free speech with a gun to your head.  It’s not easy, and takes incredible intestinal fortitude.  Packratt, who has no reason to believe he’s safe at any time when he ventures outside, takes the risk.  This is what he’s found:

1.   Are black and ask an officer a question.

2. If you are a 125 lb woman and pull your arm away when being violently grabbed from behind by a stranger while offering someone legal advice.

3. If you react in any way to seeing your girlfriend accosted by a truckload of unidentified strangers.

4. If you tense up when being handcuffed and arrested for doing nothing but being an innocent young black man walking down the street.

5. If you run because you’re an innocent person being chased by a bunch of people with guns who aren’t wearing uniforms and didn’t identify themselves.

6. If you flinch a bit while having your head repeatedly smashed into the pavement over a jaywalking offense.

7. Or if you react in any way to seeing your daughter getting roughed up over a jaywalking offense.

It’s one thing to be the target of “aggressive police tactics” as a good whupping is delightfully called.  But how many fathers could stand there and watch their daughter get beaten by police for no reason?  Personally, I could imagine some fine police officer putting a bullet in my head while I tried to stop his brother in blue from beating my child.

Seattle is on the other side of the continent from me, and my information about Seattle comes mostly from travelogues and some sitcom about a radio psychiatrist who drinks a lot of coffee and has dating issues.  Thanks to Packratt, my image has changed.  Now I know that there’s no magic in Seattle that doesn’t exist in every other city across the United States.

I thought you all should know about Seattle.

ALM’s Legal Journalist versus ALM’s Citizen Journalist

I was reminded yesterday that our tendency to ascribe credibility to those people who have jobs that allow them to have their writing published in traditional media is often misplaced.  This is easiest to see when there’s a story where you’re either involved or have first-hand knowledge, and contrast that with what appears on the written page. 

Yesterday, a short piece came out in the  New York Law Journal about Stern v. Bluestone, which I posted about here.  A call came in from the writer, Noeleen G. Walder, last Friday asking me about the decision.  Now there are two ways to look at this case (and most cases), one from the layperson’s perspective and another from the lawyer’s perspective.  Noeleen was not a lawyer. 

Edit: I’m now told that Noeleen is indeed a lawyer and that I should have exercised due diligence to learn all about her before rushing to conclusions based upon our conversation.  Unfortunately, my discussion with her gave no indication that further pursuit of Noeleen’s background was worthwhile.  But armed with this newfound information from some gutless anonymous wonder, I’m constrained to note that it was easier to understand why she didn’t get it when I was under the impression that she wasn’t a lawyer.  It’s far more difficult knowing that she is.

It was clear from the outset that she didn’t get the point of the decision.  That’s not surprising, since there was a primary and a secondary issue, and the primary issue was much harder to grasp than the secondary.  So I explained it to her, together with the implications of the decision with regard to the 1st Amendment rights of lawyers.  She didn’t get it.  I then applied it to something concrete and familiar to her, writing for the New York Law Journal.  She still didn’t get it.

As lawyers, we read these stories in the newspapers of record for lawyers with the implicit understanding that the stories that appear provide us with reasonably accurate information.  We can’t read every decision, and expect a paper dedicated to legal professionals to provide us with trustworthy accounts.

In most instances, the non-lawyer writers for the New York Law Journal are capable of understanding the point of a decision and why it matters for others.  That’s their job.  But Noeleen was over her head on this one, and even with my explanation was totally incapable of getting it.  In part, this was because she really didn’t care.  Her job was to write about it, not understand it.  As long as she posted a story, she earned her paycheck.  She doesn’t get paid more for getting it right.  This, for better or worse, is the professional legal journalist.

Compare another person writing for American Lawyer Media (ALM), the same company that owns the New York Law Journal. Carolyn Elefant blogs for Law.com, ALMs blogging arm.  Unlike Noeleen, Carolyn is not only a lawyer, but an exceptionally astute attorney whose efforts are directed toward insight rather than word count.  But then, Carolyn’s not a “legal journalist,” but a lawyer.

Carolyn wrote about  the same case yesterday, but you wouldn’t recognize it from the content.  Rather than a simplistic view of the decision from the most superficial perspective, Carolyn understood the significant issues and the implications of the decision.  Noeleen may be a professional journalist, but Carolyn “got it.”

The blawgosphere is often criticized and ridiculed by the pros who argue that its unreliable, hyperbolic and undisciplined.  But the flip side is that blawgers, like Carolyn, know their stuff.  Pros like Noeleen just write words for money.  It strikes me that the citizen journalist brings a lot to the table that the professional doesn’t, and can’t.

As for American Lawyer Media, and the New York Law Journal, perhaps they need to pay a lot more attention to what their lawyers have to say about things and have their professional journalists learn a bit more about the subject matter before they let them put word to paper.  And if the pros want to puff their credibility, then they need to put a lot more effort into understanding what they are doing, rather than just pretending they have a clue.

Money Talks Louder Than Fear

Doc Berman is busy having a conversation with himself.  It’s not exactly like those crazy bluetooth cellphone people who chatter like they’re insane the street, but it would be courteous to join in so people don’t start to ask tough questions.

The other day, he  expressed his pessimism on the possibility of any change to crack sentencing in an election year.  It’s long been the rule that no one loses an election because they’re tough on crime.

But Doc’s head has spun around (no, not like the Exorcist, just half way).  After reading an article in the Houston Chronicle, Doc had an epiphany.  The only thing that can push people harder than fear is money.  Money talks (as some lawyers occasionally tell their clients).  Doug Berman listens.

The tough-on-crime crackdown of the 1980s and 1990s is getting a second look in Congress. Some lawmakers, including Houston Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee, are questioning whether the soaring incarceration rates brought about by changes in federal sentencing laws have actually deterred crimes….

When Congress takes a second look, we usually get nervous.  Frankly, when Congress looks at all, we usually get nervous.  It’s like going to the doctor’s; nothing good ever comes of it.

You didn’t think that undoing a generation and a half of tough-on-crime talk was going away easily, did you?  It begins with sweet talk, slowing undermining the assumptions that had such superficial appeal to the common man.  But as Doc Berman astutely points out, this is just the outside of the onion.  Inside is the real reason.  Money.

It was one thing when we were awash in cash, with plenty of moolah to pay for the excesses of political rhetoric.  We could afford mass incarceration, and politicians were loving their ability to flaunt it as proof of how effective they were at saving us from all the bad guys.

But having squandered our vast riches on another loser war, and now with the economy polling way ahead of crime, it’s time to pull the prison plug so they can pass out those savings to the huddled masses.

It had long been a wonderment why people didn’t object to the amount of money the every-increasing punishments cost, though it required people to first connect the taxes they pay to the time that’s imposed.  Granted, that’s a tough one for most people to follow.

Plus, so many years of beating fear into the hearts and minds of people will not be an easy thing to overcome.  Prison may not be the answer, but what to do about the fear?  It’s unlikely to go away.  You can still use those I Heart Fear bumper stickers as soon as somebody invents the next bogeyman, and you can bet someone will.  America is nothing with someone to fear.

But now that our Congress is struggling to find the next American ATM, prisons are just too ripe to ignore.  So while Doc Berman is singing the lead in this song, I want to add my voice to the Hallelujah Choir!  Cha-Ching!

The Forgotten 9th

Norm Pattisposts a review of Daniel A. Farber’s Retained by the People: The “Silent” Ninth Amendment and the Constitutional Rights Americans Don’t Know They Have, (Basic Books, New York: 2007). 

You remember the 9th, don’t you?  Come on, tell the truth.  You know there has to be a 9th Amendment because you’re really good a counting to 10, but you can’t remember what it says.  Don’t feel bad.  You’re not alone.  That’s because nobody uses the 9th.  You never hear anybody in a movie say, “I plead the 9th!” 

The Ninth Amendment says:


The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.

It’s relative short, and has no highly controversial or hotly contested phrases.  It reflects a concern and understanding that the founders appreciated, but that we have long since forgotten.  It’s about time that we dusted it off.

The People see the government as omnipotent.  Because of this, no one questions the power that the government asserts over the People.  This is not only wrong, but dangerous, as our forefathers understood.  It’s the foundation for tyranny of a government over the people.  The government exists only to the extent we allow it to exist.  Or so the theory goes.

You can’t fight City Hall is an old adage, and one to which most people subscribe.  It’s too much, too difficult and too unlikely to win to be worth the effort.  Groups that form to do so are usually seen as a bunch of malcontents and outcasts.  We want to be part of the winning group, not the angry unhappy group.  So we go along to get along.

Having kids studying American Government is a great way to keep current with the Federalist Papers, and they have plenty to say about why our Constitution puts the breaks on government.  Everyone should read them, especially people who seek our vote to national office.  I doubt most of them have. 

Even our beloved judges tend to write about the “rights” of the government.  Of course, the government has no rights.  People have rights.  There are a few that we have allowed the government to take charge over, giving them authority and power to act in our interests.  Then there’s that darn elastic clause that gets trotted out to rationalize the seizure of power when none was given.  What is necessary is one thing; what is proper is quite another.  When in doubt, ask the People.  After all, they’re our rights.

Norm urges lawyers to start including 9th Amendment claims in all 42 USC 1983 actions.  He’s absolutely right.  The Bill of Rights numbered 10 for a reason, and each amendment should be given its due.  It will likely be a while before any judge takes notice of a 9th Amendment claim, but bear in mind that the 2nd Amendment’s RKBA was carved in stone until, suddenly, it wasn’t and everything turned on its head awaiting the decision in Heller. 

Not that I’m paying dues to the Federalist Society, but there is much to be said about giving each of the first 10 amendments a look-see.  Thanks for the reminder, Norm.

The Morning After The Giants Won

Last night, there were a lot of Giants fans around the country, some closer to New York and some farther away.  Many rooted for the underdogs.  Some rooted against New England.  Some just had to pick a team, and the Giants won the toss.

My wife and I inherited Giants season tickets from my father-in-law more than 20 years ago.  She was born and bred a Giants fan.  I came later to the fold, about 1982.  There was one year when the Giants were a powerhouse, with LT the predominant linebacker in the game.  Since then, there have been some painful years, the ugliest being the Ray Hadley years.  This wasn’t supposed to be a big year for the Giants.  

No true Giants fan felt safe when the game was on the line and Eli started the final march.  It’s not that Eli can’t produce a clutch drive, but that it’s a shot in the dark whether he will be the hero or the goat.  He knows how to be the goat.  Then the Favre-like chuck to Tyree, and David Tyree’s unbelievable grab, and hold.  No one would have faulted Tyree if he let go of the ball when he fell on his back.  He barely had his fingers on it.  But he held it. And the Giants remained alive.

The fade to Burress, who was seen as prima donna when he first came on board, who would rather drop the pass then take a hit, who never made the extra effort, but somehow changed after his first season with the team and became a Giant, was a play that the Giants had tried over and over, never successfully.  Eli just couldn’t throw a timing pass.  Whenever he tried to loft the ball, it sailed away.  It never worked.  Last night, it worked.  Perfectly.

If you’re a real Giants fan, you were sweating bullets when Brady got the ball back with 35 second to play.  That’s how it is with the Giants.  They grasp defeat from the jaws of victory.   This was classic Giants, when they are ahead by a field goal and you feel like they are losing.  There’s never a safe margin with the Giants, but a mere 3 points is an invitation to lose.

And the ball was in the hands of a quarterback who had proven that he could win.  Is Brady the best ever?  I still have to think it was Montana, but one thing is sure: The Giants were never a quarterback team while I was watching.  I couldn’t stand Phil Simms, who was a yeoman at best.  And he sucks as a commentator too, though at least he isn’t as biased as Aikman or that sleaze, Moose, who has never had a decent word for the Giants.

Before the game, everyone was certain that the Giants would lose.  Simms was on the radio and predicted a low-scoring game, as opposed to the high-scoring blow-out that everyone else predicted.  He was right, but he’s still boring and impossible to listen to.

The 35 second ran down to 1, and Brady’s passes hit the ground.  The entire defense should have gotten the MVP, or maybe Spagnuola.  The defense was incredible, the same defense that stunk in the first two and a half games.  Tuck played like a maniac.  Strahan was incredible, as was Oci.  Sure, Eli led the team downfield for the touchdown, but the defense held Brady the entire game, playing over their heads and with their hearts.

One thing that made me extremely proud.  No sack dances.  No touchdown dances. No showboating.  They played with grace.  I’m sure that 9 year olds around the country would have enjoyed some foolish dance in the end zone.  They behaved like gentlemen.  Like winners.

I never thought the Giants would get anywhere near the Super Bowl.  They couldn’t beat Dallas, and they certainly couldn’t beat Green Bay.  Tampa Bay they could beat, but big deal.  Somehow they did beat them, even though no one thought they looked like a Super Bowl team.

Last night, the Giants won the Super Bowl.  Last night, they ended the perfect season of the Pats, perhaps the best football team of all time.  The ugly Giants did that.  On any given Sunday. . . if this doesn’t give you hope, nothing will.  GO BLUE!

How Many Blogs Are Too Many?

My good buddy  Kevin O’Keefe makes a prediction for 2008:

For the 1600 blogs the ABA is indexing at the ABA online journal to double. That’s about 4 new law blogs a day.

Is it just me, or does that seem like a lot of blogs?  Is there anyone with the time to read 1600 blogs, no less 3200?

For those engaged in the business of creating blogs for others, this will be a short term boon, but what does it mean for the long haul?  And what are these 1600 new blogs, that Kevin predicts will emerge, going to be about?

I hate to be the wet blanket of the blawgosphere (well, not really), but the idea that there can be an ever-expanding universe of blogs strikes me as insane.  I recently figured out how to use RSS feeds to monitor the blawgs that interest me on a regular basis, and it has definitely helped to keep track of new blog posts.  But even so, it’s a bit overwhelming.  And I limit my interests to blogs that offer substantive content.  None of these pretend blogs that are only there to scream “hire me!” make the cut.  And still there’s just too much.

I believe that this type of overpromotion will end up smothering the blogosphere by its own (dead) weight.  Most of these new blogs will bring nothing to the blawgosphere.  They will sporadically post primarily self-hype of no interest to anyone, under the mistaken understanding that everyone who gets a blog gets business from it.  My notion is that too much garbage in the blawgosphere will drive away anyone who comes by for a look, only to find junk, crap and garbage (or what I would call “marketing”).

Since I have a blawg myself, and would prefer that people read it rather than not, this doesn’t seem like a good thing to me.  If I was selling blogs, I might feel differently, at least for the short period of time that the blogosphere seems like a reasonable investment to lawyers needing blogs of their very own, until the inevitable collapse.  But then I could move on to selling weight-loss supplements or “male enhancement” products.

Kevin recently asked on his blog if anyone wanted to be a guest blogger.  I responded enthusiastically (I’m a very enthusiastic type of guy) that I wanted to do it.  I sent Kevin an email with my guest-blogging post, but never heard back about it, and it never saw the light of day on Real Lawyers Have Blogs.  Hey, I’m a real lawyer.  I have a blog.  It seemed liked a perfect fit, right?

I suspect Kevin didn’t care for my topic.  It was that Real Lawyer have Real Blogs.  This notion is echoed in almost every interview on Kevin’s blog, where everyone stresses that if you want to gain any level of interest, it takes work to produce meaningful content that somebody will want to read. 

If 1600 people want to create real blogs that contain real content over the next year, then I will welcome them with open arms.  I won’t read them all because it just isn’t possible, not even if I dedicated every waking moment to read blog after blog after blog. But I support their right to blawg 110%. 

Somehow, I expect that not all the 1600 blogs are going to offer substantive content, or “join in the conversation” as we like to say.  I suspect most will say nothing, do nothing and go nowhere except clog up the works for people who might otherwise find something worth reading in the blawgosphere.   And once people get the idea in their head that the blawgosphere is just a morass of self-promoting marketing hucksters with nothing to offer, then there will be no one left to visit the other blawgs.  And then the blawgosphere quietly fades into the oblivious of passé fads.

“Dear S–t Face” Is Just Not The Way To Collect

Nationwide Collections, who handles more than 350,000 past due accounts from Columbia House (those are the folks who sell you 27 CDs for a penny, provided you agree to buy 700 more in the future), has an expansive view of effective debt collection, according to the Buffalo News.

Justin Thompson received a letter from his friends at Nationwide about an old debt for $16.39.  But threatening to sue him over this account wasn’t good enough.  No baby, this was a make-or-break debt, and Nationwide went all out to collect.

The envelope was addressed to “S–t Face” and the letter’s salutation read “Dear S–t.

“When I first received the letter, I was shocked. Very upset,” said Thompson, who is 25 and coincidentally works in the payroll department of an area collections company.

Mind you, Thompson’s collections company would never send out rude, insulting or demeaning letters.  They are very professional, and would always insert the “Mr.” or “Ms.” before a name.

Nationwide, on the other hand, says it’s really a bunch of good guys:


Nationwide’s president said the swear word slipped through the largely automated system that handles all of the active accounts for the firm.

“The bottom line is we haven’t done anything wrong,” Phil McGarvey said.

But McGarvey was apologetic and said Thompson won’t have to pay his debt any more.

You would think that would be enough for Thompson, but no, this greedy little s–t face isn’t satisfied with beating Columbia House out of $16.39, and he’s suing Nationwide. 

On the other hand, McGarvey, Nationwide’s president, presents an interesting corporate policy when he says “we haven’t done anything wrong.”  After all, it’s not like these people aren’t a bunch of deadbeats, right McGarvey?

The business of debt collection has never been pleasant, and there are certainly good reasons to look upon some who deliberately refuse to pay their bills with disdain.  But the harassing telephone calls, the abuse and now the name-calling really isn’t the type of conduct that restores dignity to the calling. 

Mr. McGarvey, Nationwide did do wrong.  So stop being a s–t face about it, ‘fess up and deal with it.  And forgiving the guy’s $16.39 just isn’t that magnanimous.

Can The Nonviolent Offender Survive Prison?

From Doc Berman at Sentencing Law & Policy, the story of Tom Coughlin of Wal-Mart (not New York Giants) fame on his resentence after remand from the 8th Circuit.  Coughlin, convicted of wire fraud and tax evasion for stealing gift cards, had been sentenced to five years probation (with 27 months home detention), which the Circuit ruled did not “fall within the range of reasonableness.”

But that was before Gall.  Now is after Gall.


After a three-hour sentencing hearing Friday, U.S. District Judge Robert Dawson again sentenced Coughlin to five years of probation and 27 months of home detention with an electronic monitoring device. Added to Coughlin’s sentence Friday was 1, 500 hours of community service….

Does it not seem that the word “reasonable” is just too much of a moving target to suffice for appellate review?  It has been the root of constant argument, since one person’s reasonable never seems to be the same as another’s, despite the agreement that reasonable people may differ.  Ultimately, the only view of reasonable that really counts is Justice Scalia’s, but he’s way too busy to have to decide “reasonableness” in every instance.  So we have no choice but to let someone else decide from time to time.  But I digress.

Judge Dawson’s adherence to his original sentence in the post-Gall world demonstrates his admirable appreciation of his function.  But the reason for the original sentence is worth another look:


Dawson said he declined to send Coughlin to prison because he had no previous criminal record, because Coughlin had a record of community service, and because of the former executive’s public fall from his position in life and the effect it had on him and his family.  Prison would threaten the life of a nonviolent offender, the judge said. Dawson said he believed the sentence “punished the defendant sufficiently but not greater than necessary.”…

While certainly not a guidelines compatible rationale (thank God), there is one sentence that stands out.  “Prison would threaten the life of a nonviolent offender.”  This statement is huge.  This statement says that the United States cannot maintain sufficient control over its prison system to assure the safety of citizens in its custody.  This is a direct condemnation of the United States Bureau of Prisons.

But it may be just a tad overwrought for a justification for probation.  Coughlin wouldn’t be sent to a Supermax, locked up next to serial killers and terrorists.  He would likely end up at a camp, without barbed-wire or guarded armed to the teeth.  The most likely injury at a federal prison camp is a paper cut, not a shiv.  The only potential for rape would be in a hard-fought game of Gin Rummy.  The feds, unlike our friends in New York, run a fairly good operation when it comes to non-violent, white collar prisoners.  No, it isn’t a pleasant existence (contrary to some assumptions), but it isn’t death-threatening either.

It’s not that I don’t think Judge Dawson’s statement is terrific.  I just don’t think it will bear out.  On the other hand, it has great applicability for vulnerable prisoners who won’t enjoy the benefit of prison camps during their time in government custody.  Some clients, particularly more effeminate gays, will be tortured for who they are, and no one can protect them without imposing restrictions that will make their sentence unbearably miserable, such as protective custody. 

There are massive failings in prisons, all prisons, to safeguard inmates from other inmates.  Harm can, and likely will, befall those inmates who aren’t “tough enough” to handle hard time or defend themselves from others.  Many people couldn’t care less about this, and see it as just part of the deal.  If these prisoners don’t like it, they shouldn’t have committed the crime.  This rationalization, of course, is nonsensical.  The punishment is prison, not rape, beatings or death at the hands of more violent inmates.

But it is extremely doubtful that Tom Coughlin’s life would ever be at risk. Since it’s unlikely that Judge Dawson’s decision would portend the end of incarceration for non-violent defendants, perhaps it would be best that he save that line for people whose life would truly be threatened by imprisonment, rather than squander it.

Campaign to Undermine Counsel, But No Remedy (Updated)

When a witness in a homicide investigation lawyers up, what are the prosecutors to do?  In People v. Carmela Magnetti, 06-1047-02, Westchester County District Attorney’s Office Investigator Peter Becerra came up with what he considered to be a brilliant answer.

It just happened that he was working with the mother of the witness, Gloria Magnetti, in a separate investigation in what is described as a “criminal usury operation,” where she was the willing informant.  Her daughter, Carmela, provided what the police believed to be a false alibi for Anne Travato in the murder of Patricia Mery.

When it became clear that the DA wasn’t happy with Carmela’s statement, she retained counsel and, as is prone to happen to witnesses who don’t give up the information desired, was indicted for murder.  DA Investigator Becerra then embarked on a campaign with Momma Magnetti to disparage, denigrate and ridicule the lawyer her daughter hired. 

Over a 13 month period, he not only made dire predictions of what was going to happen to Carmela, but disparaged the competency, fees and physical appearance of counsel.  The point of this effort was to get Gloria to convince her daughter to get a new lawyer who would allow her to cooperate with the DA’s office against her co-defendant, Travato.  Gloria, who trusted Investigator Becerra, kept pushing her daughter to dump her lawyer throughout this period.

In June of 2007, Becerra was directed to stop this campaign against the lawyer, but by then the damage to the relationship between Carmela and her attorney was done.  He moved to be relieved 2 months later.

To the chagrin of the prosecution, Carmela’s newly appointed attorney didn’t march has down to the DA’s office as hoped, but instead made a Clayton motion, to dismiss the murder indictment in the interests of justice based upon extreme law enforcement impropriety.

In a lengthy and detailed decision, as yet unavailable online, Westchester County Supreme Court Judge Richard Molea found that


With respect to “any exceptionally serious misconduct of law enforcement in the investigation, arrest and prosecution of the defendant” as enumerated in CPL 210.40(1)(e), the Court finds that Criminal Investigator Peter Becerra of the Westchester County District Attorney’s Office pursued a relentless campaign of exploitation against the mother of the defendant over a thirteen month period in an effort to utilize her to persuade the defendant to cooperate with the People in the prosecution of her co-defendant.

That seems pretty clear.  But what do you do about a 13 month concerted effort to interfere with the relationship between attorney and client?  Unfortunately, nothing.

The motion lacked an affidavit from Carmela alleged how she was prejudiced by Becerra’s actions, and the Court found that she was represented by competent counsel at all time, specifically noting that the campaign to manipulate Carmela and get her to cooperate never worked.  Motion denied under the “no harm, no foul” doctrine.

From the perspective of a criminal defense lawyer, this decision, though recognizing that the DA Investigator’s actions were “undeniably inappropriate and objectionable,” is a travesty.  It provides a direct incentive for law enforcement to actively undermine the right to counsel by interfering with the attorney-client relationship.

Why?  If the District Attorney doesn’t get its intended benefit, then the deliberate effort to violate the defendant’s 6th Amendment rights is of no consequence for lack of prejudice.  On the other hand, if they are able to manipulate the defendant into cooperating, then the issue is never raised because it’s always the defendant’s choice to change counsel, as well as change strategies and become a cooperator.  And again, the defendant suffers no prejudice because she’s doing what she has elected to do, become a snitch, and would have no reason to raise her complaint to the court.

Should the intentional interference with the right to counsel, even in the absence of harm to the defendant, be worthy of remedy?  It certainly seems so, for no better reason than to deter unconstitutional law enforcement conduct, much as the exclusionary rule precludes admission of evidence obtained unconstitutionally, not because of innocence.  Unfortunately, the choice made in this decision is to deem the worthiness of the right to counsel of only limited importance, therefore subject to harmless error analysis.

While the Magnetti case involves an unusual quirk, with Becerra involved with Gloria Magnetti on another matter, the potential for law enforcement to try an end run around the defendant by going to family members is always available.  While the relationship of trust between Becerra and Gloria Magnetti certainly impacted on his degree of exploitation, the families of criminal defendants almost always grasp at straws to find ways to help, and would be easy targets for law enforcement to manipulate.  If nothing else, it wouldn’t hurt cops to try.  So the potential for this to happen routinely is certainly omnipresent, and the incentive is now clear.

On the bright side, note that the newly assigned counsel did exactly the opposite of what the DA sought.  Instead of marching the defendant down to the DA’s office to cooperate, he asserted her rights by moving for dismissal.  It was a valiant effort even though it brought no beneficial result.

Update:  Left out a few things the first time around, so now I’m back to clean up my mess.  While the Magnetti decision is not available online, I have a pdf copy of it for anyone who demands proof that I’m not making this stuff up (Orin  Kerr?)  I’m sure that someone could easily upload this pdf and make it readily available to all, but that would require a level of computer expertise that I lack, and so it remains with me unless someone wants to host it for me.

More importantly, the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers filed a letter brief as amicus in this case, brilliantly prepared by Richard Willstatter, my third generation successor chair of the amicus committee (I was chair in the halcyon days of Willie Horton).  While the Westchester DA vehemently opposed the court’s consideration of the  amicus submission (using legal arguments like “Willstatter dresses funny”), on the ground that it was too persuasive, Judge Molea in reciting the papers upon which his decision was based notably omitted that of amicus.  That’s okay.  We know he read it anyway.