Author Archives: SHG

A Message To All My Relatives in Nigeria (and Lawyers Soliciting Links)

About 25 years ago, I learned for the first time that I had family in Nigeria.  Back then, the news came by mail.  Later, by fax, I learned of more relative, all of whom were remarkably wealthy and unfortunately recently deceased.  Now, my relatives are dropping like flies, as I get about a dozen a day that somehow beat my spam filter.  It’s like some sort of plague.

How did I get on some list that is in the hands of every person in Nigeria with computer access?  I don’t have a clue.  It’s not that I don’t appreciate their thoughtfulness for letting me know how I can retrieve my many, many inheritances, but I’m just a simple soul and have no need of the billions of dollars sitting in banks across Nigeria.  If I ever get to Nigeria, I’ll just use it to buy a nice brunch for everybody.  If not, then I hereby donate it to all good causes in Nigeria.  But I have no plans to do anything else about it.  So all of my very helpful friends and relatives in Nigeria can turn their attention to more fruitful endeavors.  You’re wasting your time on me.

But the latest unsolicited come-on in my email box is not from those living so very far away who care so deeply for my welfare.  It’s the sudden influx of emails from lawyers who have just paid someone to create their website, which they title “Blog” so they can free-ride the wave of the blogosphere into the hearts and minds of potential clients surfing the web.

These emails offer to put my blawg into their blogroll, if only I will add them to mine.  They promise to give me access to their huge following of readers, all of whom are potential clients for me and will provide me with great riches and a huge increase in readership.  These blogs, of course, have been in existence for about 37 minutes and say absolutely nothing beyond how wonderful the Funk Law Firm is and why you should retain them immediately.

While I so greatly appreciate your offer to link your “blog”, all about the wonders of you and your firm, to my blawg, I must respectfully decline.  You see, I try to include a little substance in my blawg, the sort of thing that some people might want to read or might want to think about.  That sorta stuff.  You, on the other hand, want only to fish for clients. 

I could be wrong about this, but the use of the word “blog” to describe your personal advertisement really isn’t a good thing for the blawgosphere.  You see, nobody wants to come and read a blog that offers nothing of interest and serves only to self-promote.  It’s boring.  It’s pointless. It’s really pretty slutty.  You are clogging up the blogosphere with this self-aggrandizing crap, and that could drive people away from real blawgs because they get tired of finding lawyer commercials when they think they are going to find interesting information.

It’s not that I have anything against lawyers making money.  Trust me, I don’t.  But lawyer advertising is not blogging, and my blogroll reflects blogs that I read and think other people would be interested in reading.  I realize that whoever convinced you that anyone can create a “blog” and grow their practice told you that this is the way to market, but you may have been oversold.  Real blogs don’t do this. 

But if you’re disappointed that I have no plans to add you to my blogroll, don’t fret.  I have something even better as a quick and easy way to vast riches.  You see, I have a bunch of really rich relatives who recently died in Nigeria, and I’m more than happy to pass your name along because they all have a lot of money problems and are looking for someone to help them out.  If you’re interested, let me know by sending me an email soliciting a link to my blawg.  I’ll get the message.

The Hidden Cost of Our Latest Bailout

I’ve already questioned how our government, intent on pushing us out of our homes and into the shopping mall, is going to pay for this band-aid scheme, given that our federal bank account has been overdrawn for so long.  Yes, I’m such a negative nelly.  I know.

But as our newest get unpoor quick scheme takes shape, no one seems to think about the hidden costs that come as part of the package.  The plan (as of today) is for the federal government to send out checks of $600 per taxpayer ($1200 per family) so that we can go buy shiny stuff made in China that we neither want nor need.  Fair enough, that’s the American way.

But what is the cost behind these checks?  The ink costs money.  The envelopes don’t grow on trees.  Paper has gotten really expensive.  Somebody has to run the machines that put the checks into the envelopes, cart the whole magillah to the door and pass it to the fellow who loads it on the post office truck.  Well, you get the picture.

Why is it that we never think about the amount of money spent to do the mundane, ordinary tasks that are necessary to make these brilliant schemes happen?

Ordinary people (like me, and there’s nobody more ordinary) think about their operating costs when we come up with brilliant ideas.  We do this because the costs associated with our bigger ideas come out of our pockets.  When you actually have to pay for envelopes, you think about what they cost.  You learn to keep your non-productive costs down because making money is good.  Rule to live by: It is better to make money in business than lose money.

The government, however, has no similar motive.  The people in the back office don’t worry about the costs of paper or ink.  The President says mail something, and they mail something.  Same with Congress.  Their is not to reason why, etc.  But these things still have to be paid for, and guess who is doing the paying?

The cost of mailing a whole lotta checks to a whole lotta Americans has got to be huge.  If anybody has a viable number, please let me know.  But I’m going to engage in rank speculation and suggest that we could run a bunch of schools, or a handful of hospitals, or maybe a smallish state, on the amount of money that is going to be spent just to send us our $600 mad money.

I don’t know about you, but I work awfully hard for my money.  It’s not fine with me to have somebody waste it.  So when the government comes up with a great scheme like this, I wonder why I bother to manage my own practice with any degree of thoughtfulness, just so somebody else can reach into my pocket, pull out a wad of cash and flush it down the toilet.  Just wondering.

Heavy Hitters Debate “Judicial Activism”

Over at Volokh, brilliant minds debate the propriety and scope of judicial review.  It started out as a discussion of McCain-Feingold, but quickly turned to the broader issue of constitutional interpretation.  For lesser minds (like mine), this is what is commonly denigrated as “judicial activism.”

On one side of truth and justice is Orin Kerr, arguing that the courts should give a strong presumption of constitutionality to any law passed by Congress because it reflects the majoritarian will.  Or as he puts it:


I think the legitimacy of government is premised on the consent of the governed. Notions of legitimacy are complex, of course, and I don’t want to oversimplify matters too much. But legislatively enacted laws generally deserve respect because they reflect a process involving wide participation of those who will be governed by them through their elected officials. In contrast, judges impose constitutional limitations on their own, either acting individually as trial judges or on panels of a handful of judges. I think the closer connection to the consent of the governed of legislative acts relative to judicial ones provides an important reason judges should be reluctant to latch on to fallible and contested theories that would lead them to invalidate lots of legislation.

Orin tends to use more words than I do, with no apparent fear that he’s going to use up his entire allotment too soon.

And on the other side of truth and justice is Ilya Somins, arguing that this purported reflection of the “will of the governed” is hogwash.  Ilya says:


First, a high proportion of legislatively enacted laws do not in fact represent “the consent of the governed” in any meaningful sense because the vast majority of voters are ignorant about them – often not even knowing of their existence.

Second, to the extent that “the consent of the governed” implies the actual support of the majority of the actual public, it turns out that judicial review has at least as much or more consent-based legitimacy as legislative power does.

Finally, I think Orin oversimplifies when he says that “judges impose constitutional limitations on their own, either acting individually as trial judges or on panels of a handful of judges.” In reality, judges’ decisions are constrained by a political appointment process, by limits on their ability to implement decisions at odds with the views of other political actors, and by a highly institutionalized system of precedent and legal culture that make it difficult for any one judge or small group of judges to make radical changes “on their own.”

I’ve cut some of the explanatory stuff out of the respective arguments for the sake of brevity.  Lawprofs can go on a bit, you know.

So here’s my question, having enjoyed immensely this debate because I am such an intellectual snob and political theorist.  Whatever happened to Madison’s Federalist 10 and 51 in all this?  Hasn’t anybody ever heard of the “tyranny of the majority?”  Are we really a majoritarian society, pretending that pluralism and elitism hasn’t taken control and we just pretend that ordinary people have a say in what Congress does?

Even if we assume that Orin’s position, that Congress better reflects the will of the governed (which I believe to be a huge stretch), judges are constrained to explain their decisions in a constitutional context and yet other judges pass on the validity of their explanations.  If they stray too far, there’s always someone to smack them down and put them in their place.

But what about the Supremes, you ask?  Aren’t they above reproach?  Of course, but that’s part of the scheme.  Madison’s argument that the Constitution, by providing checks and balances, would be available to overcome the evils of faction requires that the judiciary, immune from the transitory whims that influence legislators, step in from time to time to keep the pandering lawmakers in their place. 

It also strikes me as ironic that the expansion of federal crimes, based upon the unrestrained rhetorical breadth of the commerce clause, that is so beloved by conservatives (not to mention legislators of all ilks since it provides a platform to prove how “tough on crime” they can be when they have run out of new legitimate crimes to create) is purely a product of the dreaded judicial activism.  When the political winds blow warm, it’s called justice.  So let’s not get too crazy about the theory when all political theorists have their day in the sun.

It seems to me that Ilya’s argument wins the day.  But then, I’m no scholar, just a lawyer.  What do I know.

Reason #37 Why PI Lawyers Shouldn’t Represent Criminals (Updated)

Glen Lerner is the very picture of a self-aggrandizing personal injury lawyer in Las Vegas.  He bills himself as the “Heavy Hitter” of the PI bar, according to the Las Vegas Review-Journal.


Lerner is widely known for his colorful commercials and catchy jingles. In one, he spins like the cartoon Tasmanian Devil. In another, he boasts that insurance companies sent him more than $25 million in settlements.

But Lerner took one step too far outside his comfort zone when he decided that his genius at settling PI cases extended to representing a defendant accused of murder.  He apparently assumed that cases are cases, and criminal cases were just some minor variation on his ordinary theme of bringing the case to the edge of trial and then settling.  Ah, the life of a civil litigation.  All that swagger ending in just another bluff.

His client, Mario Lino, was facing life in prison for the murder of his wife.  The case was on for trial.  And Lerner was nowhere to be found.  The judge was not amused. 

Judge Michelle Leavitt also was angry because Lerner, a personal injury lawyer, told the district attorney’s office he wasn’t going to appear in court to defend his client, because he was out of state “on sabbatical” and didn’t care if the judge punished him, a county prosecutor said.

Remember, the defendant is standing there in court, no lawyer to be found, about to go on trial and the judge, with jurors waiting, is furious and about to hold his lawyer in contempt.  So what does “Heavy Hitter” Lerner have to say?

Reached in Pennsylvania, Lerner said he didn’t attend the trial because he was out of state and wasn’t prepared to go to trial. He said he called the district attorney’s office last week to work out a deal for Lino, and when that failed he told the prosecutor that he wanted the trial delayed while he prepared for the case.

Now that might be a brilliant plan when handling a PI case (though I somehow think that PI lawyers will think otherwise), but the idea of first preparing the case while the jurors are waiting may be a little too late.

Now I’m sure that every lawyer who thinks that he’s a “player” and can handle a criminal case (and wants to get his hands on that up-front legal fee for some quick cash) thinks that this can’t be that hard and he can do it.  But what does Lerner think of his “representation”?


“I’d rather be sanctioned than railroad my guy into accepting 25 years in prison,” Lerner said.

Well, Glen, there is another option.  How about being competent and prepared?  Obviously, that never occurred to him.  The moral of the story is a simple one.  If you don’t know how to handle a criminal case, send it to someone who does.  A murder trial is no place for amateurs.

Updated:  Eric the Turk of  New York Personal Injury Law Blog reminds me that this is a two-way street for those who think that any idiot can handle a PI case.  He tells a story of incompetence by a well-known criminal defense lawyer (I know very well the lawyer Eric posts about, but has left unnamed, and trust me that this lawyer was as much of a dufus as a criminal defense lawyer, though somehow his clients never seemed to have a clue why he put on such a great show but kept blowing their cases) who decides he can dabble in PI.  Agian, don’t mess with people’s lives when you don’t know what you’re doing.

It Wouldn’t Be The NYPD Without A Scandal

New York’s Finest (that would be the cops) either have a short memory, aren’t too bright or both.  No, that’s not the newsflash.  The news is that we’re all about to enjoy another episode of my favorite game show, Are NYPD Narcotics Cops Dirty!

As reported in the New York Daily News, the latest and greatest scandal is exploding. From Serpico/Knapp Commission, a federal side trip to DEA Group 33, to the Dirty Thirty, New York City has a long history of police being swayed to the dark side by the allure of money and narcotics.  Every so often, a new groups of cops thinks they’ve come up with a way to game the system.  It’s happened again.

This scandal broke when 34 year old Detective Sean Johnstone seized 28 bags of drugs, but only turned in 17.  Nothing new about this, but Sean was just a bit too arrogant about it.


The corruption came to light when a Brooklyn South undercover detective was caught on his own wire bragging about seizing 28 bags of drugs and turning in only 17. He allegedly gave the other bags to informants.

Bragging is what one does when one is proud of oneself.  Johnstone was proud that he found a way to beat the system.  what Johnstone was apparently unaware of was that this was nothing new, but one of the exact things that brought down the Dirty Thirty a decade before.  I know.  I brought the scandal to the New York County District Attorney’s Official Corruption Bureau, which showed incredible integrity in their investigation of the police.

The nature of these scandals is that once the camel’s nose is under the tent, you see plenty of very ugly stuff.  And this one followed course.

The junkie claims she had sex with Officer Jerry Bowens, 41, a member of the Brooklyn South narcotics unit where 20 cops were benched over charges of taking sex, drugs and cash from addicts and dealers.

You see, as soon as cops cross one giant step over the line of legality, everything else is just a variation on a theme.  Dirty cops are dirty.  The job of cop offers a multitude of ways to break the law, commit crimes and have a grand old time.  First, you steal the excess weight in drugs, because no one will miss it and what type of moron will tell that he had more drugs than claimed?  Then it’s stealing the money from the bad guy.  Then it’s sex with their women or trading those excess drugs for a quickie, or maybe just freedom.  There’s no cost in giving some women a free ride for a quickie.

Worse still is the ability of dirty cops to rationalize why it’s not so terrible for them to do so. After all, they’re only stealing from the bad guys, right?  The money is dirty, so why shouldn’t it go in the cops’ pockets instead of the shredder? 

What does NYC Police Commissioner Ray Kelly think about this newfound scandal on his watch?  He worries that busts will get tossed because his cops were dirty.

“Defense attorneys could make mincemeat out of a cop on the [witness] stand if the cop was involved in this mess,” said a source close to the investigation. “And it could force old cases to be reopened, examined and thrown out as well even if the arrests were good.”

Maybe he would have been a little more successful if he was more concerned about his own cops being dirty than about losing the busts?  Naw, the truth is that there is nothing Kelly could have done.  The temptation has historically proven too much for cops.  After every scandal, safeguards are put in place which are supposed to prevent it from happening again.  Yet it always happens again.  It’s the nature of the beast.

The only thing missing in this scandal is a catchy name.  But I’m sure some enterprising young journalist will come up with something, so that ten years from now, when the next narcotics cops scandal comes along, we can refer back to this one and sigh.

The Coffee Mug Defense

The Brooklyn trial of Cesar Rodriquez, 29, for the January 2006 death of his 7-year-old daughter, Nixzmary, opened with a shocker.  Defense counsel Jeffrey Schwartz blamed the mother, and Nixzmary herself, for her fate.  As a general rule, you don’t want to blame a 7 year old child for her own murder at the hands of her father.  It’s unbecoming.

The defense continued down the path of the bizarre when Schwartz introduced a photograph of a coffee mug bearing the words, “World’s Greatest Dad.”  Granted, in a case where the physical evidence against the father, including the chair to which little Nixzmary was bound, and the litter box that served as her toilet, are so shocking and revolting that the defense starts to grasp at straws, anything is fair game.

But a coffee mug?  Is that really the best they can offer?  There are instances where a proffer is so markedly underwhelming that it serves only to highlight the absence of any defense.  This coffee mug defense is such an instance. 

During a break in the proceedings, Schwartz told reporters, “Ironically, I think Nixzmary bought it for him.”  Yes, it would be ironic.  But this isn’t an exercise in irony, it’s a murder trial. 

I can visualize the faces of jurors, as the defense crossed the detective on whether or not it was true that this mug, World’s Greatest Dad, was found in the home.  I can hear the words spoken with sarcasm, with that “ahah” element, as if he’s just ripped the detective’s head off by revealing his outrageous deceit with a masterful blow.

And I can visualize the detective, sitting calmly, and responding to this snarling question, “why yes indeed, we did find that mug in poor, malnourished, scarred and now-dead Nixzmary’s house, where she was tied to a chair, denied food, denied love and ultimately beaten to death at the hands of her parents, the people who she looked to for love and comfort, and instead received death.”  Even though the detective didn’t say this, this is what the jury heard.  It’s what I hear.

The prosecution is still putting on its case against Rodriguez, and it is a case that will cause the hearts of the jury to break.  The defense will get its turn.  But after this stroke of brilliance, crossing the detective about the coffee mug, it’s hard to imagine what evidence the defendant might present that will undo the damage.  The prejudice created by this coffee mug defense will taint any sound evidence or argument to come later.

If this seemed like a good idea for an effective cross at the moment, then the defense needs to seriously reconsider its strategy. 

And Then There Was Rudy (Update)

Important Update:  This just in via  Salon (h/t Kathleen) on Rudy:


Finally, there’s Rudy Giuliani, of whom Joe Biden said, “There’s only three things he mentions in a sentence — a noun, a verb and 9/11. ” Giuliani could have been a contender, but he ran out of verbs and nouns early in the race and, despite federal matching words, could never form a coherent sentence thereafter.

That Joe Biden is a card.  Now back to our regularly scheduled post:

I admit that it’s petty, but it brings me no small pleasure to see Rudy Giuliani, “America’s Mayor,” running a steady 36th in the race for Republican Presidential candidate.  It’s not that Americans have determined that Rudy was a nasty, vindictive, megalomaniac, but that nobody even cares that he’s running. 

But that begs the question, what’s happening on the Rudy front?  Well, thanks to Frank Pasquale at CoOp, parsing the pages of the  New York Times for up-to-the-minute Rudy info, we have an answer. 


In August 1997, James Schillaci, a rough-hewn chauffeur from the Bronx, dialed Mayor Giuliani’s radio program on WABC-AM to complain about a red-light sting run by the police near the Bronx Zoo. When the call yielded no results, Mr. Schillaci turned to The Daily News, which then ran a photo of the red light and this front page headline: “GOTCHA!”

That morning, police officers appeared on Mr. Schillaci’s doorstep. What are you going to do, Mr. Schillaci asked, arrest me? He was joking, but the officers were not.

They slapped on handcuffs and took him to court on a 13-year-old traffic warrant. A judge threw out the charge. A police spokeswoman later read Mr. Schillaci’s decades-old criminal rap sheet to a reporter for The Daily News, a move of questionable legality because the state restricts how such information is released. She said, falsely, that he had been convicted of sodomy. Then Mr. Giuliani took up the cudgel. “Mr. Schillaci was posing as an altruistic whistle-blower,” the mayor told reporters at the time. “Maybe he’s dishonest enough to lie about police officers.”

I can’t speak for anybody else, but I never tire of hearing new stories about what a vindictive, abusive, mean-spirited fellow Rudy is.  He was a petty tyrant as United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York, and was no better as Mayor. 

Did I mention that Rudy gave us Bernie Kerik, reflecting his sound, deliberative judgment about people?

This is not to say that Rudy’s future, after he drops out of the Republican race in abject humiliation, is not bright.  After all, he has the Rudy law firm, the Rudy lobbying firm, the Rudy consulting firm to keep him afloat.  There are plenty of people who will pay Rudy a ton of money to buy his influence.

But if the Democrats take the White House, as they have kinda taken the executive mansion in Albany (if you consider Eliot Spitzer), Rudy’s influence may not be what it used to be.  Don’t cry for Rudy.  Jerry Springer can’t go on forever.

Can Britney Cure Dr. Phil?

My good buddy Mike from the train to the City is always on top of the latest Britney Spears news.  Paris Hilton, too, but that’s not important.  If Mike, who’s rather long in the tooth, thinks something is important, then it’s probably worthwhile to pay attention.  Ordinarily, things Britney are not all that fascinating to me.

Following the latest in Britney’s serial breakdowns, she was paid a visit by her dear friend and fellow entertainer, Dr. Phillip C. McGraw.  Now I have just a smidgen of envy when it comes to Dr. Phil, because he has a TV show (courtesy of Oprah) where he gets to tell people what they should do with their lives.  That’s sounds like great fun.  Who wouldn’t want a platform like that to spout?  His “tough love” approach is applauded by people who don’t have to live up to his standards.

Apparently, Dr. Phil doesn’t have to either.  This is probably old news to all you Dr. Phil aficionados, but he lost his ticket in Texas to practice psychology in 1989.  I just learned this from Jonathon Turley at Res Ipse Loquitur, so it’s new to me.


McGraw gave up his license in Texas before he completed disciplined measure meted out by the Texas State Board of Examiners of Psychologists in 1989. He was accused by a former therapy client of having an improper relationship with her. McGraw gave her a job but denied improper physical contact. He was nevertheless found guilty of violating professional rules and officially reprimanded. He then closed his practice completing the specific punishments.

But clearly that didn’t slow Dr. Phil down.  Not one bit.  On air, we think we’re watching a top of the line pop psychologist, but if that was the case, Dr. Phil would be breaking the law because, you see, he’s not licensed to shrink much of anybody’s head in California either, where he lost that ticket in 2006.  If he isn’t a psychologist, then what is he?  He is, ta da, an entertainer.


It is a felony to practicing without a license in California. McGraw previously gave up his license in 2006. Notably, when they go on his show, participants sign a contract that includes a provision that he is not medically treating them. Notably, when his show began in 2002, the Board investigated whether he was practicing without a license. In what would be an insult to most true doctors, the Board found that Dr. Phil was not in violation because he was acting as an entertainer, not as a psychiatrist.

This certainly takes a lot of wind out of the sails of the Dr. Phil show for me.

So now Dr. Phil has pushed the envelope a little too far again, this time by visiting the poor, mentally-challenged Britney, and then doing what entertainers do when they have something to say that someone wants to hear.  They talk about it.  So Dr. Phil talked, only to put another gun to his psychology-filled head.

Dr. Phil now has to worry about whether his day in the sun, riding the coattails of Britney’s issues, is going to buy him a felony.  To thwart such talk, Dr. Phil had to swallow his professional pride and claim that his visit wasn’t one of psychologist-patient, but rather one of pop-friend/pop-tart.  If his therapeutic visit, and ensuing statements, were the pontifications of one entertainer about another, then no felony follows. 

It’s bad enough to watch the self-destruction of Britney Spears, from clean-cut school-girl pop-singer to white-trash, child-endangering, out-of-control, bald-headed slut.  When she first came on my radar, in her Catholic school attire and wholesome (albeit breathy) voice, she seemed to be a great role-model for young ladies.  Well, that didn’t pan out nearly as well as I had hoped.

But for Dr. Phil to follow suit (except for the slut part, I think) is really pathetic.  This is an educated man who was engaged in a profession geared toward making more thoughtful personal decisions.  Is he really this much of an idiot, that he can impose his tough-love views on others while blinding himself to his own poor decisions?  He’s pretty glib, from what I’ve seen of him, with a pocketful of cute phrases to back up pretty much any advice he gives, but how can we take any of it seriously when he pulls such a bone-headed move?

I don’t know whether Dr. Phil has much of a future as a television entertainer of the psychological persuasion after this affair comes to an end.  Maybe, he will make the requisite mea culpas and will endear himself to the midday audience of home attendance and the chronically unemployed.  But he has clearly learned little from his mishaps with the professional licensing boards in Texas and California. 

Will he learn anything from his ‘friendship” with Britney?  This may be his best defense:  Dr. Phil failed to do much to aid his fellow entertainer, but she served to provide him no small dose of his own medicine.  And just in case the network decides that Dr. Phil is no longer viable to render tough love to the masses, I’m still available.  And I promise to stay far away from Britney.

The Padilla Sentence: Terrorism Unraveling

For the past six years, sensationalist stories of the terrorist threat to our way of life have become a staple of our news diet and a justification for our relinquishment of basic civil liberties in the name of security.  With yesterday’s sentence of former Taco Bell employee, Jose Padilla, to 17 years, 4 months, for  engaging in “a global conspiracy to wage violent jihad,” as prosecutors described it with no shortage of hyperbole, reality is beginning to set in.

United States District Court Judge Marcia Cooke could have easily gone along with the government’s war of words against terrorism, substituting rhetorical heat for evidentiary substance.  No one would have blamed her.  In fact, most people would have thought her bold and forceful for imposing the requested life sentence on Padilla and his co-conspirators.  It would have been nothing more than a result consistent with the carefully calculated impression given the public for years.  We would have understood and embraced such a decision.

But Judge Cooke found herself constrained by the law and reality.  Unlike us, she had to sit through Padilla’s trial and sentence.  Judge Cooke knew things that we did not.  The most important thing that she knew was that Jose Padilla, despite the government’s effort to throw every colorful adjective in the book at him, was never the threat he was made out to be.  This is significant, because our public attitude toward the terrorist threat has been framed by these stories and the understandings they engendered.  We now know that it was decidedly less than we thought.

From the New York Times,


In explaining her decision, Judge Marcia G. Cooke of Federal District Court in Miami acknowledged the gravity of the crimes Mr. Padilla had committed. But she questioned the range and impact of the conspiracy, saying that there was no evidence linking the men to specific acts of terrorism anywhere or that their actions had resulted in death or injury to anyone.

You may recall that Jose Padilla, an American citizen, spend 3 ½ isolated in a South Carolina Navy Brig, subject to secret interrogation, before being “allowed” the rights afforded Americans in a court of law.  He was nicknamed the “Dirty Bomber,” because the government told us that he was planning to detonate a nuclear weapon on American soil in his violent jihad.  At the time, this news was shocking and deeply disturbing.  His purported threat evoked grave fear in Americans, and his capture as an “enemy combatant” made us appreciate all that the government was doing to protect us from this terrible threat, and made us feel justified in turning over our personal freedoms to the government so that it could fight the war on terrorism.

Judge Cooke now tells us that our fears were overstated.  Judge Cooke also tells us that we turned over our rights to the government and received very little in return.  Jose Padilla was never a real threat to anyone.  He made a great poster boy, but only as long as we didn’t know too much about him.  

And then there’s the issue of how the United States, a nation committed to freedom and the rule of law, treated one of our own in the process.


Over the objections of prosecutors, Judge Cooke gave Mr. Padilla credit for time served during his 3 1/2-year detention in a South Carolina military brig following his arrest in 2002 on suspicions that he had been involved in the “dirty bomb” plot, allegations the government eventually discarded.

By calling it “time served,” it diminishes the significance of what happened to Jose Padilla. This wasn’t the stuff that we imagine Jack Bauer defeating in 24 hours, but a threat that was at most idle and stupid chatter by a foolish kid.  Jose Padilla did not have, and never would have, the ability to put action to his bravado.  The most that our government could gain by torturing Jose Padilla was the recipe to the Taco Bell secret sauce.

This case also gives rise to question how the conspiracy to commit terrorism, yet another nuclear weapon in the prosecutors’ arsenal of empty threats, allows for conviction of thought crimes.  The government could not, and did not, prove that Jose Padilla came anywhere close to actually doing anything that had any potential to harm anyone.  While Padilla, a former gang member who converted to Islam, was no model of good behavior, neither was he a model of a terrorist threat.  He “sympathized” with al Qaeda, and perhaps if given a chance, might have done something to aid them in their Jihad.  He just hadn’t done anything yet.  This is what conspiracy had become when the word “terror” is invoked. 

While Jose Padilla is hardly a person who we will remember for having ever done anything good for anyone else in his life, he legacy will prove important.  Without the Jose Padilla’s, we wouldn’t get to look under the majestic robes worn by our important government officials as they tell us all the ways in which they are protecting and helping us.  We would never recognize that the stories of threats have been greatly exaggerated.  We would never come to realize how we’ve sold our birthright as American’s for some flashing rhetoric, over-blown stories and empty threats.  Thanks to Judge Cooke, and to Jose Padilla, we now know better.  It’s now up to us to appreciate the message.

Ode to Howard Bashman

It occurs to me that I there is one individual, one blog, upon which I’ve come to rely more than any other.  While I try to link to whatever source I’ve relied upon in a post, there’s one I’ve tended to neglect, because it leads me to so many other sources, stories and significant information.  This is possibly the singular most important blog on the internet for those of us concerned with, and interested in, the law.  It’s  How Appealing by Howard Bashman

I don’t know how Howard Bashman does it.  People say that I’m prolific, but I’m a piker compared to Bashman.  An appellate lawyer in Willow Grove, Pennsylvania, Bashman’s blog provides source news about all things legal every day.  This is no easy feat.  It takes time, energy and focus.  It is even more amazing that he does this every day, day after day.  It seems we ought to pay for the privilege of reading Howard’s blog, and that he gives all of this to us every day is just a gift. 

Unlike me, Howard provides a constant stream of information about cases, decisions, people and issues, together with links to their sources, largely without commentary or bias.  He’s a legal news aggregator, and has been doing this daily for years.  I cannot stress how valuable this has been to me, and should be to you as well. 

Every morning, I turn to  How Appealing to find out what I should know and where I can find it.  I assume that if I wanted to spend a few hours every day going from media outlet to media outlet, reading story after story, I could accomplish the same result on my own.  But thank heavens that I don’t have to, because Bashman has already done it for me. 

It seems only proper that I acknowledge the importance of How Appealing to my efforts here, and my ability to keep up on legal news in general.  All of us appreciate how time marches on no matter what we try to do to stop it.  Without Howard, I doubt that I would be capable of following as much legal news as I do.  If there is one blog to read to try to stay abreast of developments in the law, as much as I wish it was mine, it’s Howard’s.

I don’t know whether Howard Bashman has ever heard of Simple Justice.  I’m not on his blogroll, and he’s never left me a comment or sent me an email. He’s never linked to any of my posts.  I’ve probably never written anything worthy of making it onto his already overburdened radar.  But he’s certainly become a daily focus of mine.  It seemed that the very least I could do for all that I’ve gained from his blog is to write this brief post and acknowledge how much I appreciate his efforts.  Thanks, Howard.

Update: Somehow,  Howard noticed my Ode!