Life was different in 1994, when the original, unaired pilot for now-legendary TV show about the fight of good over evil, 24, was first created. If you watch nothing else today, watch this. . .
H/T Volokh

Life was different in 1994, when the original, unaired pilot for now-legendary TV show about the fight of good over evil, 24, was first created. If you watch nothing else today, watch this. . .
H/T Volokh
Man does not live by law alone. No matter how big the legal fee. To follow in the footsteps of Brandeis, it is necessary to be a well-rounded human being, to have interests aside from the law and have an appreciation of the finer things in life.
That said, allow me to show a little something of my hobbies, the things that fascinate me when my mind is not fully occupied contemplating how to beat the unbeatable case.
As has been previously mentioned here, my primary hobby is the care and feeding of my 1964 Austin Healey MK III, 3000 (Phase 2).
As a by-product of my Healey’s rally heritage, I started collecting Heuer Rally Timers, such as this Rally Master set.
From there, I moved to the famous 1960s racing wristwatches, including this 1964 Omega Speedmaster:
And this Heuer Autavia “Jo Siffert” model.
So, just in case any reader here has any of these that are sitting dusty, unloved, unwanted in a drawer somewhere, shoot me an email. These are the silly things that I enjoy.
This series of videos, courtesy of the ABA Journal. When Columbia B School spends its time beating up on law students, you know you’ve hit rock bottom.
I have to hand it to Apple, I hate their system but love their advertising. And the designs are pretty cool too.
Then why do you need to put down public defenders to sell yourself? Courtesy of Skelly (again) comes yet more of the private defense bars strange compulsion to compare and contrast itself with some strawman argument that public defenders (you know, them freebie lawyers, not them real lawyers) just too darn overwhelmed to do their job. Watch the video:
Now this particular pitch adds a very curious touch. Not only is he experienced, but he’s expensive. Very expensive. So that’s why he’s trying to poach clients from the public defender? I have no idea who Barry Bernstein is, so I offer no comment on the quality of his work. But juxtaposing these conflicting claims leads me to think that this is one ill-conceived way to market oneself, and reflects quite poorly on him. Sorry, but it’s really pretty pathetic.
But there’s more. I’ve questioned my good buddy Kevin O’Keefe at Real Lawyers Have Blogs about calling something a blog when it’s nothing more than a self-serving promotion. So what am I to make of this so-called blog?
YOUR VERY OWN PERSONAL LAWYER
Here’s the “story” from this San Diego criminal defense firm:
A recent article in a popular San Diego newspaper was written which talked about some criminal defense attorneys and their heavy, unmanageable caseload. There are some San Diego criminal defense lawyers whose caseloads get up to 300 and even 800 cases. At Wallin & Klarich, we do not think an attorney can work 300, much less 800, open cases at one time all by him or her self without providing less than desirable service to some clients. Would that lawyer be able to remember your case? Your name? Your face? With hundreds of other clients vying for attention, we doubt it.
Will the public defender be able to remember your name? Give me a break. Is this really necessary to get a client? Is this the best the firm can offer?
It won’t be long until some of the “very expensive,” “very experienced,” name-recalling private criminal defense lawyers start promoting themselves through picture of public defenders drooling and tripping over their over-stuffed brief cases in the well.
Ladies and Gentlemen, have some shred of dignity. Promote yourself all you want, but stop doing it at the expense of the public defenders. It is truly embarrassing. And it is simply wrong. Stop it. Please.
Tom Brady, the purported golden boy of the New England Patriots football club, has been caught in Manhattan “high crime” area Greenwich Village trying to slink into a potential west village crack house incognito.
Greenwich Village, long known for its reefer-smoking, poetry-spouting beatniks, has become Brady’s “comfort zone” while hiding out from teammates and coaches who want to know what happened to the potted plants that were brought in to grace the Patriots locker room following their lucky victory grab from the San Diego Chargers.
Brazen Brady had no qualms about carrying a large satchell, believed to contain the cash from selling off the rights to his jersey number, which is commonly used by low-life drug addicts to purchase their “fix”.
New York Giants injured tight end, Jeremy Shockey, happened to be standing on the opposite side of the street when Brady rolled up, and was believed to be telling Brady that his shoelace was untied.

Former Mayor Rudy Guiliani, asked what he thought about this shocking turn of events, said, “I didn’t know she was my second cousin. That would be disgusting.”
As I always say, when my favorite anomaly, Susan Cartier Liebel speaks, I listen. We had the pleasure of a discussion yesterday about the angst-worthiness of Kirsten Wolf’s message to new lawyers, that the law offers many a future of poverty and misery. Susan took issue with this message. No, Susan completely rejected Kirsten Wolf as the poster child for law student disenchantment.
In the course of this discussion, Susan and I found ourselves squared off on whether brand new lawyers had the professional skills necessary to hang out their own shingle and engage in the practice of law. I contended that these fresh-faced lawyers did not possess the knowledge and ability, the day after their bar admission, to competently fly solo.
Susan, on the other hand, asserted that not only had she done so, but so did “countless others.” I responded that in my 25 years of practice, I was still waiting to meet one of these success stories (Susan aside). In fairness, there was likely some conflicting assumptions underlying our respective positions. I think in terms of litigation, rather than, say, preparing simple wills or residential real estate closings. I also think in terms of New York City, with probably the most lawyers per capita in the world, as opposed to some rural county where there are a grand total of three lawyers within 100 miles. So I do concede, under certain circumstances, that a new lawyer can open a solo practice and succeed, though by default more than anything else.
One tendency that has long been a hallmark of the new lawyer is the belief that they have learned enough in law school to make them a lawyer. Both Susan and I agree that law school does little to train students to practice law. Indeed, most lawprofs, if they have a few beers in them, will readily concede that law school would be great if it wasn’t for all those whiny, snot-nosed students. The notion of teaching them the practice of law is anathema, both because it conflicts with the lawprofs self-image as scholar and because the lawprofs don’t actually know a whole lot about practicing law.
Thus, my view that these newly minted lawyers are not ready for prime time isn’t meant as a condemnation of them, but a simple fact of life. In my experience, there is a huge gap between what they take out of law school and what they need to competently represent living, breathing people. Susan agrees that law schools drop the ball, but we part again on the issue of whether law schools, even if they had practicing lawyers teaching how to engage in the real practice of law, would be able to turn out lawyers competent to be trusted with real people on day 1. In my view, they will still need to hone their skills, get a little experience under their belt, before they can competently go solo.
The reason, by the way, for this difference of opinion is that Susan supports the proposition that going solo offers a terrific alternative to the lawyer as employee mentality that gives rise to so much disenchantment within the profession. Again, I agree in part, though each has its up and down sides. Susan tells me that she doesn’t claim it to be a panacea. I’m not sure I buy that entirely, since there isn’t much discussion of the many issues and problems that accompany solo practice.
But I am a dinosaur. I don’t have a clue what students face today, or what paths are available to them because I’m so far removed from those fresh-faced days when my legal career was all in front of me. I could be absolutely dead wrong about all of this, and Susan may be entirely right.
So, here’s your chance: Am I out of my mind, and totally off-base that brand new lawyers lack the competency to hang out a shingle and represent people the day after they get their ticket? If you’re going to respond and you’re a lawyer, please include a bit of info as to how long you’ve practiced (for statistical purposes only).
Update: So the votes are in, and it appears that I am out of my mind and totally off-base, as per Bennett, Susan and to some extent Carolyn. I remain a little unclear that we are all talking about the same thing, since Mark chose to qualify his endorsement of newly minted lawyers, which Susan then embraced. There are also a number of areas of agreement, such as law schools not doing enough to prepare law students to practice law, and the helpfulness of “adult supervision and mentoring” in bringing a new lawyer into the fold of competency. But my consternation was that this added additional layers to the issue, which may or may not be present and available.
I remain a firm believer that a brand-spanking new lawyer does not yet have the competence to stand alone and represent people. I suspect that most clients would agree with this. I am not at all antagonistic to new lawyers, but I am a strong believer that every new lawyer needs to gain some experience before they can be set loose on the world on their own. But hey, that’s me. Others, who I respect immensely, say otherwise. Their views are set forth in the comments below, as are mine, and you can reach your own conclusions.
Disagreements make for the best vetting of ideas, so despite this post having taken a somewhat abrupt turn to the left, we’ve hashed out our respective positions and now commend it to others to make their own choices. But I must add one thing: If I were a young lawyer who wanted to go solo, I would pay very close attention to Susan Cartier Liebel and Carolyn Elefant, who offer sage advice. If you’re going to do this, then do it right and do the best you can with it.
Gideon, who wasn’t busy enough putting together Blawg Review 143, posts at A Public Defender the results of the long-awaited GHSSS Survey on innocent defendants pleading guilty to avoid jail time. The results are overwhelming, with 60% saying that they would indeed plead guilty to an offense they did not commit if the outcome saved them from going to jail.
This, of course, is not news. Not to criminal defense lawyers. Not to judges. We know it because we see it happen all the time. It is our obligation to advise clients of any plea offer, and so we do. We advise them of the significance of the offer, and often on its consequences, intended and otherwise.
Some lawyers advise clients as to whether they think the client should take the offer as well. Some lawyers, myself included, tend not to offer such advice, as we exert undue influence in a choice that is uniquely personal to each defendant. By suggesting that the client take the plea, we tacitly state that we have no faith that they can defend against the charges. Or more precisely, lawyers communicate to clients that they have no faith that they feel that they can do so. If a lawyer conveys the message that they are going to lose, no sane client wants to test the message with his life.
The law, unfortunately, has long refused to recognize the existence of this reality. Innocent people do not plead guilty as a matter of law. There is no such thing as a plea of convenience, at least in New York where Alford pleas are essentially non-existent. When a defendant agrees to enter a plea of guilty to any but the most trivial offense, he is allocuted, under oath, and required to state the facts that support guilt. The defendant must state in open court that he did the crime. End of story.
The irony of this scenario is that, given the option of committing perjury by openly proclaiming guilt and admitting to the factual acts necessary to prove it, versus holding firm to the truth, comes at great personal risk, to the defendant, spouse and children. Try explaining to your kids why it was better to roll the dice and face 15 years in prison rather than “lie” to the judge by pleading guilty and walking out the door that day.
But this is not a situation without problems. For one thing, these decisions often happen under such coercive circumstances as to preclude a fair assessment of risk/reward. The defendant stands before the Court for an ordinary calender appearance, when out of the blue, the prosecutor or judge tells him, “Here’s your plea offer. You can take it or leave it, but it’s never coming around again and you have 30 seconds to decide.” Manhattan Supreme Harold Rothwax, former Legal Aid attorney and punitive curmudgeon at the end of his career, was famous for doing this. Nobody put the screws to a defendant like Harold.
Knowing of this potentiality, I would always try to prepare my clients well in advance so that they would be somewhat prepared for these shocking twists. But no preparation can truly prepare a defendant to make a reasoned decision under these circumstances. It’s never clear how much a defendant actually hears in the well of the court, or how quickly he can process what’s happening even if he does hear it all. There’s no time for deliberation or discussion of consequences based upon specifics of the offer. It’s do or die. Like the old Meatloaf song, Paradise by the Dashboard LIghts, “what’s it gonna be, boy, yes or no?”
So innocent people plead guilty. Does that really present a problem? Consider the reaction of one commenter to Gid’s post:
I must take issue with your “convictions have nothing to do with justice” premise. The fact is that they almost always get the right guy, and there are a hell of a lot more false negatives than false positives.
Notwithstanding the lack of empirical evidence to support this statement, it’s likely to be fairly accurate. For this commenter, “almost always” is a good enough standard to endorse the efficacy of the system. Would he feel the same if it was his turn in the well? I think not.
What this really tells us is that most people are quite willing to suffer an imperfect system, as long as it’s the other guy who has to take one for the team. They are expendable. We are not. But then, this commenter has obviously never been put to the test. The easy answer is that is because he’s a law-abiding citizen and would have no reason to find himself in the well before a hanging judge. But that ignores the problem, which is that innocent, law-abiding people sometimes do find themselves in this position and are forced to make the decision.
It’s far too easy to view the false positive, the conviction of the innocent by a plea of convenience, as an unavoidable casualty of an imperfect system when it’s not you or someone you love. If you don’t believe this, stand beside an innocent man as someone demands that he either admits false guilt or faces ridiculous odds with unbearable consequences. You’ll see.
Since it’s a quiet day today, particularly noting the absence of New York news on the criminal justice front, I’ve posted about few things that have been bouncing around in my head, and have the time to deal with a few points raised by readers/commenters that have come in by email, with the assurance that I have faithfully reproduced the emails except to the extent that I have decided to change them completely to suit my own purposes.
Greenfield,
I realize that I’ve never contributed anything to your blawg and only go to your blog because one of your posts deals with something I actually care about, but I disagree with you about your use of one word in a post having nothing to do with the point of the post and I want to write about it at great length and argue with you about it all day long. What’s your problem?
For some bizarre reason, some people confuse a blawg with a public forum where they have the right to hijack a thread because of some peculiar personal peccadillo. I generally don’t get involved in deleting comments, except those that needlessly attack others or try to use my blawg to promote commercial ventures. But after allowing someone to make their point, enough is enough.
If you want a place where you can post all day about some tangential nonsense, get your own blog. I’m not under any obligation to spend my day arguing with every nut who shows up here. There are many readers who contribute to the conversation here, and raise significant and interesting points. Then there are people who show up only to argue about nonsense. You hit the nail on the head when you say that you’ve contributed nothing to the discussion.
Greenfield,
You post an awful lot of stuff, but do you think you could take a few minutes and correct the typos, or the obvious errors, or the occasional misstated facts? It really doesn’t seem that it would be too much of a burden to get things right.
You are absolutely right, and I am ashamed. The problem is that I hate editing myself. I love it when other people edit my work, on the other hand. In the first few posts when I started this blawg, my wife read my posts and corrected them. She just loves to correct anything I do. It’s a symbiotic relationship. But then she stopped reading my posts regularly and that was that.
Writing a blawg is not the same as writing legal briefs. This blawg is an opportunity to deal with news, issues and ideas. It’s not about representing clients, and it’s never going to receive the level of attention and detail that goes into my legal work. If I were blawging for self-promotion, I would polish my posts carefully as a marketing tool. But my posts are intended to add to the wealth of ideas in the blawgosphere, and I unfortunately leave behind a few typos that spellcheck doesn’t pick up.
Sometimes I make a factual error. Unlike typos, this is a problem and I try to correct it if it’s significant to the point of the piece. I rely on my sources of information for blawg posts, as opposed to doing thorought background research as I would for my legal work. This is one of the reasons why blawgs do not provide legal advice. But still, I certainly don’t want to include erroneous information and when I make a mistake, let me know and I will fix it, even if it makes me look like an idiot.
I don’t think that these detract too greatly from the discussion, so I don’t let this bother me. I’m sorry that it bothers you, and I hope that you will be able to look beyond the occasional error to the point that I’m trying to make. On the other hand, if you see a mistake, I would be thrilled if you would let me know so that I can correct it.
Greenfield,
I posted a comment and you didn’t respond to it? What am I, chopped liver?
Well, in the figurative sense, yes you are. Some comments just don’t call for a response. Others ask questions that aren’t really relevant (and sometimes just plain dumb). And sometimes, there’s no nice way to respond to a comment, so in the exercise of discretion, I let it go. I invite all comments, but that’s not a guarantee that I (or anyone else) will respond. Sorry that you feel like chopped liver, but it happens.
That’s it for now. If you have anything to add, feel free to send me an email.
Susan Cartier Leibel, at Build a Solo Practice, asks whether Kirsten Wolf is the norm. Wolf is a lawyer whose mission has become telling potential law students to find a different path. Her interview in the WSJ made her the poster child for disenchantment with the legal profession, thus replacing David Wold, who tried to auction his diploma on eBay, as the punching bag for lawyer malcontent.
Susan has nailed part of the problem, that becoming a lawyer is a default career path for people who don’t really want to be a lawyer but mistakenly believe that it is a guarantee of a life of prestige and comfort. When things don’t turn out that way, they are sorely disappointed and blame the profession for their mistaken assumptions.
But there is also substantial intolerance of this mistake, which fails to recognize that this confusion about what becoming a lawyer really means is fostered and enabled by the profession and its gatekeepers, the law schools.
Stories about our noble deeds and great wealth broadcast to the world how wonderful it is to be a lawyer. Rarely does anyone hear of the downside that would scare off those not committed to the work we do. There really wouldn’t be anything wrong with this, except that we simultaneously offer the opportunity to join this wonderful profession to far more students than our society needs or our profession can absorb.
It seems the business of law schools is entirely disconnected with the profession of law. I suspect that law schools, and hence seats for potential new lawyers, exist largely as places for academics to get paychecks while plying their true love, writing law review articles to garner reputations as scholars. I think this because there’s no indication that lawprofs have any real desire to teach law students. Students are the necessary evil that sustains research.
So too many people go to law school. Too many people pass the bar exam. Too many people become lawyers. And then we’re inundated with disenchanted lawyers. Society isn’t all that thrilled about them either.
But are we blaming the symptom, the Kirsten Wolfs and the David Wolds of the world (put aside whether you think his stunt was infantile, and deal with the real issue), and ignoring the disease? Access to becoming a lawyer is simply too easy, and the sheer number entering the profession year after year is simply too large.
One caveat here: It’s not that society doesn’t need better access to lawyers, as there are many instances where ordinary people can’t find affordable and competent representation. But no one wants to fill that niche because they want the prestige and the wealth that they are told is their due. But we don’t seem to do a very good job of serving this segment of society, and few people seem too concerned about it. Of course, who am I to talk? I’m not a public defender, nor have I taken a vow of poverty to serve my fellow man. I may do my part through pro bono work, but that hardly solves the problem.
Those in the bottom 90% of second tier and lower law schools have a rude awakening coming. Some will overcome the shock because of a deep desire to practice law. Some will be left only with the shock. Calling them names, like they are all a bunch of stupid losers who should have known better, does nothing to cure the disease. Nor do individual anecdotes, from those who proclaim that “I knew what I was getting into” prove that everyone else is a worthless moron.
For those inclined to be critical of young lawyers for whom the panacea of wealth and prestige hasn’t happened, be a little more understanding. Kirsten Wolf may not be the norm, but she isn’t exactly alone either. We would do better to put the brakes on the number of people entering the law then to blame those for whom the law hasn’t played out nearly as well as they were told it would. We would have a stronger, more competent and healthier profession if we stopped beating up the symptoms and instead cured the disease.
While the media talks about recession, as if anybody who owns stocks needs to be reminded, I can’t help but wonder whether we are really talking about basic macroeconomics or a fundamental paradigm shift that happened back in 2001, and we just didn’t notice.
After the dot com crash, plenty of people were hurt, and hurt badly, as their saved assets disappeared in a flash. Years of earnings from years of work simply disappeared. And this was the big news. But at the same time, other things were happening as well that changed the nature of the economy.
The U.S. stopped producing things. We kept buying them from other places, but we stopped making them ourselves. In the 1990s, we created companies that existed on ideas and technology, but that went poof with the dot com implosion. During that time, we gave up any hope of maintaining a manufacturing base. Who needed it, we were flush with internet money. Let China and India have the hard work, while we make the easy money.
Then came 9/11, our great excuse for sinking billions of dollars into non-productive use in the name of Patriotism and paying Saddam Hussein back for trying to off Pappy. That money had to come from somewhere, and rather than anger a huge segment of society by sticking the government’s hand so deep into our pockets that it could scratch our knees, they just printed up as many bills as they could and left it for some other day to pay. Now, that money is gone, and it’s never coming back. Were those big bombs worth it, in retrospect?
At the time, our real wages were stagnant or falling, and jobs were hard to find, and our economy, to the extent we had one, simply passed money around in a big circle until it finally got shipped overseas in our new flat world, where money only traveled out and never in.
But we were happy, buying flat TVs based upon a real estate market that never quit. As long as our piggy bank was full, we could spend. But like all upward spirals, two things happened as they always do. First, some scoundrels found a way to scam the system, sucking money from subprime mortgages out the back door. Second, the bill for easy mortgage money came due. Eventually, the bill always comes due.
The short term solution, favored by politicians of all ilks, is for the government to send us a check (as if it’s got a bunch of extra money lying around) for us to go spend on stuff that will be cool for about thirty minutes, and thus rev up our flailing economy and make us all happy again.
I’m not seeing how this resolves any of the systemic problems. While it sinks our country deeper in debt, this money flows out to the producers of the shiny stuff, not to people who need a job since the real estate ATM shut down. At some point, we need to realize that we have a real problem, not just a momentary glitch in the good life. This flat world isn’t good for us, and we had no business mortgaging our future on a war.
The confluence of factors suggests to me that this may not be, despite the TV telling us otherwise, just a recession. We may be at the crest of the hill looking downwards. Unless the United States recognizes that without a manufacturing base, where we create something that someone elsewhere wants to buy, selling off our assets to the Saudis and spending money on a non-productive war might just leave us without anything left.
The boom and bust cycle may be over. We may have hit the final bust this time. Of course, I’m no economist, so I may have no clue what I’m talking about, but I just don’t see where the money is going to come from to bail us out of this one. If the rules have changed, then we either need to bite the bullet and recognize it or we are in for a very long, hard trip. Talk of a “brighter tomorrow” isn’t going to create a viable economy when we’ve run out of money and have nothing left to sell.