Author Archives: SHG

Privatization of The Police Power

Labor history is replete with the pleasures of  Pinkerton’s busting the heads of striking workers for the good of the country.  Well, maybe not so much the country, but it was awfully good for the factory owner who needed to break the strike and remind the workers who was the boss.

But this country has a short memory, and we are slowly returning to the days when the government’s police powers are being turned over to private business again, slowly but surely.  First, we have  the recording industry going after children under pain of destroying family’s financial survival by monumental and unjustifiable fines. 

Then we have the airlines, where ordinary people’s lives are being toppled by flight attendants who don’t like the way they look, protected by governmentally endowed immunity to encourage them to harm people at will. 

And of course, there are the telecoms, who exist to serve the Department of Justice, their nice TV commercials notwithstanding.  Well, if you thought the idea of post-hoc immunity for violating your privacy wasn’t good enough, they are back again to help us even more.

Always thoughtful lawprof Frank Pasquale at  CoOp posts about the latest, greatest craze in telecom intrusiveness.  This time, they want to help us by screening our communications to make sure that they don’t contain illegal content, like copyrighted songs or pictures of your mother-in-law. 


AT&T announced that it is seriously considering plans to examine all the traffic it carries for potential violations of U.S. intellectual property laws.

Okay, so maybe not picture of your mother-in-law, according to who you married.  But what business does a private corporation have in vetting our communications for what it deems to be illegal content?  Does it flow downhill from there, with screening calls and emails for anti-American sentiment that might support terrorism?  And then there’s content that suggests a crime?  And content that doesn’t say nice things about AT&T?  Or it can sell other corporations on its power to screen and keep bad content about them from crossing the air?

This scheme of treating private business as if it was endowed with the power to police us is disastrous policy.  The public has no control over how private business will abuse this police power.  Where do you go to argue that a telecom has wrongfully intercepted your communications?  You can sue them, at huge expense and with years of litigations ahead, but this offers no real remedy.

We are already well down the slippery slope of confusing the limited police power that government derives from the People with corporate fiat allowed and endorsed by our government to keep people in their place.  It is happening already, and, as shown by this wonderful new idea, will continue to increase its hold on us. 

It’s bad enough that our government is  comprised of people who think that their whims are above the law, but when corporate America actively assumes the role of America’s policeman, who will you complain to?  There’s no 4th amendment for telecoms.  Do you expect to get justice from a call to the customer service rep?

Martin Luther King Today

Blawg Review 143by Gideon at Public Defender Stuff honors the memory of Dr. Martin Luther King in exemplary fashion.  When you’re in this business,  there “is much in Dr. King’s message that resonates even today within the criminal defense community.”

But on a day to remember the influence Dr. King had on America, there’s a discordant note.  As brought to our attention by Defending People, a post rife with the legacy of discrimination appeared at a prosecutor’s blog in an attempt to explain yet more discrimination against blacks.  Remarkably, there is neither apology nor recognition of the inherent racism it promotes. 

At Harris County Prosecutors blog, where a prosecutor posts anonymously to avoid any personal responsibility, there is a shocking effort made to justify why they try to bump blacks off juries while claiming that they aren’t racist. 


Prosecutors are very much aware of the fact that probably every African-American member of a jury panel has been treated like crap at some point during his or her life by a member of law enforcement, or perhaps even a District Attorney’s office

This isn’t offered as an apology, but rather as an explanation.  It doesn’t occur to the writer that this reflects a fundamental problem, such as why “every” black on the jury has “been treated like crap.”  Some people would stop right there and say, “so the solution to your problem is to stop treating black people like crap.”  Not this prosecutor, who apparently take it as a given that black people will always be treated like crap because that’s the way it is and the way it should be.

Now this post was just written this past Saturday.  Martin Luther King was assassinated on April 4, 1968, a mere 39 years ago.  His work was clearly not finished.  But this Harris County prosecutor, 39 years after the murder of Dr. King, doesn’t even get the idea that treating people this way is a problem.

From this acknowledge of reality, our anonymous prosecutor argues that this is a sound reason to keep blacks off the jury:


A potential juror who is going to let their bad experience with law enforcement shape their verdict shouldn’t be on a jury, regardless of their race. I think prosecutors are very aware of the fact that in dealing with an African-American potential juror.

What is amazing is the apparent sincerity of this statement, oblivious to the basic purpose of a jury and the inherent racism in the argument. 

The jury exists to reflect the community, for better or worse.  The prosecutor wants members of an entire race, who are treated like crap, off the jury because they can’t “be fair” to the prosecution.  So the alternative can be expressed in two alternate ways.


The prosecutor wants only people on the jury who have had good, pleasant, happy experiences with police, because jurors inclined to like police witnesses are “fair”.  Or

The prosecutor wants a jury that hasn’t suffered at the hands of police, inclined to treat them like crap, so that they will accept the police testimony about how they would never beat, shoot, and lie about defendants.  We certainly can’t have a “fair” jury whose life experience might suggest otherwise, now could we?

Nowhere does this prosecutor consider the possibility that neither police nor prosecutors are entitled to a free pass from their racist treatment of blacks in order to have a jury made up only of their favored race.  The jury is intended to reflect the community, for better or worse.  That a significant segment of the  community has been treated by them like crap is a problem of their own making, and they are not entitled to hide from the product of their own racism.

It is not merely sad that this still remains the mindset of those who sincerely believe they are doing the right thing by trying to exclude an entire race from the jury, it is an affront to all of us who believe that racism is inexcusable.  Where is Martin Luther King today?  Hopefully, he’s in Harris County, trying to make our anonymous prosecutor understand the problem better.

THE GIANTS ARE IN THE SUPERBOWL (Updated)

Giants 23
Green Bay 20

Eat my cheese!

Update:  It’s now the morning after.  Having watched the news and read the paper, the Giants are still going to the Superbowl.  It wasn’t just a dream.

And the Pats don’t look unbeatable.  Better than the Giants?  Of course, but so did Dallas and Green Bay, and look where it got them.

But why is Tom Petty playing at half time?  Even if he has a costume malfunction, no one will care.

Practical Blawgosphere: Attack of the Coward

Mark Bennett, the Texas Tornado, has been the subject of attack lately, following his in-depth series about the disgraced Harris County, Texas, district attorney and the race to take his place.  Along the way, he framed this opposition the mean girls, but it’s now gone way past any gender issue.

As validation of the accuracy of Mark’s posts, a new  Harris County prosecution blog has come into existence to counter the negative image of the office, and provide a forum to bash Mark.  Naturally, the bashers all wear hoods to protect their identities.  Cowards have always hidden behind anonymity.

But the mean girls ventured over to Ken Lammer’s CrimLaw, where prosecutor Ken was enjoying the Harris County soap opera, to spew as well.  But Ken wasn’t having any of it on his blawg, and put a quick end to it.

From my perspective, this attack on Mark reflects the impact he’s having on the public awareness of the disgraceful internal problems within the Harris County District Attorneys office.  When you can’t attack the message, attack the messenger.  Mark has been caught in the dilemma of whether to defend himself or laugh at the stupidity of it all.

Unfortunately, the nature of the blawgosphere means that attacks can be viewed independent of their causes.  If one googles Mark’s name, one can see these absurd, shameless attacks on him by anonymous posters without realizing that they are pathetic reactions to his damning posts.

Many readers can’t appreciate that there are many perils to blawging, provided that your blawg takes positions rather than posts fluff.  Blawgers can become targets of irate readers who disagree and decide to go on the attack.  Blawgers become targets of crazy people who become obsessive and decide that they are going to be the troll of the blawg.  Blawgers end up in the cross-fire of strange folk who are obsessed with peripheral issues who try to hijack a post to push some tangential concern of their own.

There are a lot of strange and angry people out there.  These things happen with some frequency.  Sometimes we ignore it.  Other times, we just make the stuff posted by nutty people go away.  Having a blawg doesn’t mean you have to put up with loonies, even if they don’t get the idea that this isn’t their forum to express whatever insanity brews inside their heads, no matter how much they believe that they have a “right” to do so.

By putting his name to his posts, Mark stands behind his views, critiques and positions.  It doesn’t matter if you agree with him, entirely or in part.  Indeed, Mark and I have quibbled over nuanced positions on numerous occasions.  But he says what he believes, and he isn’t afraid to put his name to anything he posts.

At the Harris County prosecutor’s blog, the anonymous author responds to Robert Guest’s statement that he can’t take seriously any attack posted by someone without the guts to put a name to it, by writing, “Wow. Whatever happened to Freedom of Speech?”  Sure, even cowards have the freedom to post their anonymous attacks.  And the rest of us have the freedom to reject their attacks as the spewing of cowards.

Ed Note:  This post was originally titled Attack of the Mean Girls, but upon reflection, I decided that the title needed to be changed.

A Nation of Men, Not Law

John Yoo, now a lawprof at the University of California, Berkeley, as well as Visiting Scholar at the American Enterprise Institute (those would be the tort reformers a la Overlawyered) after leaving his post as Inquisitor General, has gone on  the offensive in his war against the  use of the courts as a means of resolving disputes.  Yoo has written a piece for the  Wall Street Journal explaining why the Padilla suit against him will bring the downfall of Western Civilization.

Side note to defendants:  You have the right to remain silent.  Yoo’s polemic is yet more proof why you should do so.

Yoo’s opening salvo makes clear his vision of what Padilla v. Yoo means for the nation.


If [Padilla’s lawsuit] succeeds, it won’t be long before opponents of the war on terror use the courtroom to reverse the wartime measures needed to defeat those responsible for killing 3,000 Americans on 9/11.

I was unaware, until now, that John Yoo was personally so critical to our nation’s defense that a lawsuit against him meant that America would be subject to annihilation by terrorists.  What, you say?  Jose Padilla had nothing to do with the attack on the Twin Towers?  He came later?  Well, you only say that because you haven’t read the rest of Yoo’s piece.


Under Padilla’s theory, the U.S. is not at war, so any citizen killed or captured by the CIA or the military can sue. In November 2002, according to press reports, a Predator drone killed two al Qaeda leaders driving in the Yemen desert. One was an American, Kamal Derwish, who was suspected of leading a terrorist cell near Buffalo. If Padilla’s lawsuit were to prevail, Derwish’s survivors could sue everyone up the chain of command — from the agent who pressed the button, personally — for damages.

But that happened in the desert of Yemen, so that’s a little different, no?  Okay, there’s more.


In the spring of 2002, I was a Justice Department lawyer asked about the legality of Padilla’s detention. There is ample constitutional precedent to support the detention of a suspected al Qaeda agent, even an American citizen, who plans to carry out terrorist attacks on our soil. During World War II, eight Nazi saboteurs secretly landed in New York to attack factories and plants. Two of them were American citizens.

After their capture, FDR sent them to military detention, where they were tried and most of them executed. In Ex Parte Quirin, the Supreme Court upheld the detention and trial by military authorities of American citizens who “associate” with “the military arm of the enemy” and “enter this country bent on hostile acts.” If FDR were president today, Padilla might have fared far worse than he has.

But WWII was an actual war with a declared enemy in Germany, right?  Wow, you are one tough customer.  What about this?


None of that matters to the anti-war left. They failed to beat President Bush in the 2004 elections. Their efforts in Congress to repeal the administration’s policies have gone nowhere. They lost their court challenges to Padilla’s detention. The American public did not buy their argument that the struggle against al Qaeda is not really a war.

So instead they have turned to the tort system to harass those who served their government in wartime. I am not the only target. The war’s critics have sued personally Donald Rumsfeld, John Ashcroft, Robert Gates, Paul Wolfowitz and other top government officials for their decisions in the war on terrorism.

Finally, we’re getting to the bottom line.  America owes a debt of gratitude to these visionaries who stand between our way of life and the marauding forces of international terrorism.  They saw it coming long before and were bold enough to do the job that needed to be done.  If the “anti-war left” had it’s way, we would all be praying to Mecca and wearing burkhas right now, upon pain of our heads being chopped off with scimitars.

[Note to lawprofs: Is this what you would consider sound academic scholarship?]

John Yoo concludes with his incisive view of what will happen when the final domino falls:


The prospect of having to waste large sums of money on lawyers will deter talented people from entering public service, leading to more mediocrity in our bureaucracies. It will also lead to a risk-averse government that doesn’t innovate or think creatively. Government by lawsuit is no way to run, or win, a war.

Patriots like Yoo need not constrain themselves to the unworkable confines of our laws and this abuse of our tort system will keep other Patriots, who know better than anyone else, from becoming the talented public servants that staff our bureaucracies in the future.  If we can’t trust in a nation of men, we are doomed.  So says John Yoo.

What scares me most about Yoo and his ilk is that they truly believe that they, a handful of brilliant Patriots, should be entrusted to do whatever they deem necessary, without constraint or oversight, because they understand what no one else does.  There is nothing we, the People, can say or do that could ever change their view, since they are right and everyone else is wrong.

Is Texas a “Rogue” State?

The last bastion of liberal thought, the Wall Street Journal, profiles R. Ted Cruz, solicitor general of the Nation State of Texas and why Texas puts so many more people to death than anywhere else.  One particular exercise, dealing with a condemned defendant named José Ernesto Medellin has created a particular problem.

After Texas courts imposed and affirmed the death penalty for Medellin, a citizen of Los Estados Unidos de Mexico, his lawyers went to the International Court of Justice at the Hague to seek recourse under the Vienna Convention, which requires that “a consular post to be notified if a citizen of its nation is arrested.” 

Before you jump to the conclusion of who cares what some jerks in the Netherlands has to say, consider what this means for Americans sentenced to death by a court in Somalia.  It works both ways, and if we don’t respect treaties as applied to other nations, they won’t respect them as it applies to ours.

In an ironic twist of fate, President Bush ordered Texas to revisit Medellin’s punishment and Texas refused. 


The Texas court rejected Mr. Bush’s order on constitutional grounds. In an amicus brief filed in Medellin v. Texas, the Bush administration holds that the court’s action undermines presidential authority to determine “how the United States will comply with its treaty obligations.”

According to Ted Cruz, Texas has pretty simple view of the situation.


“When a sentence is legally and justly imposed, the state of Texas carries it out,” says Mr. Cruz. “And in the judgment of the Texas Legislature and in the judgment of the significant majority of Texans, the death penalty is fundamentally a matter of justice.”

Texas doesn’t take its marching orders from anybody, including the Hague or the President of the United States.  It is a sovereign state and can make up its own mind.  Texas doesn’t need anyone’s permission to put people to death.  And it doesn’t need to answer to anyone for its choices.

This presents a rather interesting problem, one that has caused such opposites on the political spectrum as John Yoo and Erwin Chemerinsky to find themselves on the same side.  What does the United States do when Texas says they just don’t care what anyone else thinks about the way they put people to death there?  

As  Baze v. Rees is pending before the Supreme Court, Ted Cruz wrote an amicus brief for Texas stating that they’re fine with the three-drug cocktail used to execute people in Texas.  What if the Supremes rule against the use of the cocktail and Texas chooses to use it anyway?  Clearly, Texas has decided that the ICJ doesn’t trump their courts.  The President has no business telling Texas what to do.  Cruz takes the position that the Texas legislature, reflecting the will of Texans, is all the authority needed.


“The Constitution gives democratically elected legislatures the principal responsibility of making policy determinations,” says Mr. Cruz. “And before the Supreme Court, Texas has frequently been defending the proposition that the federal courts should respect the determinations of the democratically elected legislatures.”

Is it only a matter of time before Texas decides that it has had enough of outsiders meddling in its business?  You gotta love Texas, if for no other reason than that it has been able to accomplish something that no one would have ever believed possible: “It is an unusual case that features Ed Meese and Jerry Brown, now attorney general of California, on the same side.”  I’ll say.

One Nation, Under God, Under Attack

The  New Hampshire Union Leader posts about a federal case against the Hanover School District attacking the inclusion of the words “under God” in the pledge of allegiance, added in 1954 at the request of President Dwight D. Eisenhower to distinguish America from the heathen commies.

This isn’t a new challenge, but one that seems to bring out strong feelings each time it rears its head.  The basic argument is that the Establishment Clause forbids the government to support theism as opposed to keeping its nose out of religion altogether. 

The opposition position, as stated by Jay Sekulow, lead counsel for the intervenors, The Center for Law and Justice, is as follows:


The Pledge and the phrase ‘one Nation, under God’ should not pose a constitutional crisis,” Sekulow said. “There is ample precedent — including from the Supreme Court — that underscores the fact that patriotic exercises with religious references are consistent with the First Amendment. We’re hopeful the court will see this suit for what it is: a legally flawed strategy to purge all religious references from American public life.

What makes this argument interesting is that the argument for inclusion of the phrase has to be carefully framed in the negative, since its real purpose would likely defy the constitutional prohibition. 

In other words, they can’t argue that America is indeed a nation under God because we were formed in accordance with the Judeo-Christian ethic of our forefathers, who were careful to make sure that we, unlike England, would never have a state religion, but similarly believed that the general parameters of this ethic were the norm.  At the time, the idea that America would include Hindus and wiccans was just too ridiculous to consider.  Atheists, well, were best used for clogging holes in the Puritan dike.

Thus, the argument is based upon precedent that the inclusion of religious references in patriotic exercises has been with us since the beginning, and continued unabated.  This is clearly true, from the Declaration of Independence to our daily coinage and the writing on the wall over our judges’ heads (In God We Trust).  But it really doesn’t answer the question.

The opposition to those who would remove religious references in government is that it constitutes an attack on religion, on God.  These secularists would have a society devoid of people who believe in a deity and rejecting their belief in such things as the Golden Rule.  Some have argued that it is an attack on Christianity, and that the United States, like it or not, was born a Christian nation.  Again, there is a lot of support for this proposition, though the support doesn’t suggest that it was intended to be a Christian nation, but rather that our forefathers viewed life through the prism of Christianity because that was their normal perspective.

And then, there’s a third view on this issue, which suggests that it’s a total waste of time and who cares anyway.

What remains unclear to me is how removing religious references from government, its patriotic exercises, buildings, coinage and the wall behind the bench, will be the end of religion.  Let there be a crèche in front of every Christian home across America.  Let every child offer a prayer to the deity of his choice every morning and every evening.  Nothing stops this from happening.  My religious beliefs have nothing to do with my government, and I assuredly don’t need their permission to believe as I do or their support to make me feel better about my beliefs.

Given that there are a multitude of ways for individuals to engage in the practice of their religion, what does the government have to do with it?  There is a logical disconnect between the government including the words “under God” or “In God We Trust” and any belief I, as an individual, may hold or practice.  If those words disappeared overnight, it wouldn’t alter my beliefs one iota.  So what?

But then, I have never gone into a courtroom, seen the words over the bench, and felt personally affected.  The ubiquitousness of the word “God” around us results in a diminished recognition that it’s there.  It’s just part of the background noise of our world, there but ignored.  It’s goofy and unnecessary, but generally inoffensive since it’s of so little consequence.  That isn’t always the case, however.

Others feel differently.  Others see the word and feel the offense that comes from a government stating something different than they believe.  I feel this when I’ve gone to public school commencement exercises and had the opening benediction include a prayer to Jesus Christ, Our Savior.  First, this doesn’t comport with my beliefs, but more importantly, this has no place in a public school.

It reminds me of people who argue that Christmas trees aren’t religious symbols, but merely seasonal, fun symbols that bring joy and pleasure to many.  While I agree with the latter, I disagree with the former.  They are indeed religious symbols.  That’s why they call them “Christmas Trees.”  So let home after home sport a Christmas Tree and we’ll have more than enough to go around and we can all enjoy the beautiful lights and the joy of the season.  But keep it out of our government buildings.  There’s just no need for it to be there.

The notion that America will fall into moral decay if we don’t include the word God here and there is just silly.  We can fall into moral decay no matter how much religion is injected into our government.  The removal of all religious references from our government is of no consequence to our belief in God, or lack of belief in God.  While separation of church and state is a phrase that appears nowhere in the Constitution, the concept is sound to express the import of the Establishment Clause.  Believe what you want.  Practice it however you want.  Just don’t make it a part of our government.  Religion doesn’t need government’s permission.

Biglaw Poised To Make A Killing on Subprimes

You may recall that I  warned you back in August that federal investigations into mortgage lenders, particularly those who were eating up the subprime market, was the next big thing.  Well, you may not have believed me, but Biglaw certainly did.  I knew that those guys read me religiously.  After all, how else would they be able to tell their backsides from their elbow?

This article from  New York Lawyer is particularly timely given  my post just yesterday about Skadden’s absurd handling of Brocade CEO Gregory Reyes’ case.  While criminal defense lawyers went about their humdrum work of representing people, Biglaw was busy positioning themselves to suck all the money that hasn’t been spent on fast cars and loose women from the mortgage crowd.



A litigation army is massing at major law firms to fight the wave of investigations, class actions, and bankruptcies that are expected in the coming months — and years — in the wake of the subprime-mortgage mess.


Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom alone says it has roughly 100 lawyers across the firm working on subprime-mortgage fallout.


Skadden again?  Now I have no doubt that they will do an exemplary job at handling paper.  As everyone agrees, nobody kills more trees than Biglaw.  They relish the work.  They stay afloat in a sea of paper.  Paper is their life.  But despite the many brilliant, and exceptionally well-paid, young lawyers who will shuffle reams of paper from one side of the table to the other, and despite the foregone conclusion that they will bill many millions, perhaps even billions, of dollars to clients who could never imagine that they would find themselves seated in the defendant’s chair in a criminal prosecution, they will be more responsible for filling up our prison camps than any group of aggressive prosecutors in the nation.

I realize that I keep harping on this point, but it never seems to sink in.  Not to white collar defendants.  Not to Biglaw.  Hiring a few former assistant United States attorneys does not give you a “white collar defense” group.  They have never defended anyone in their careers, and they just don’t know how.  It’s different to prosecute than to defend.  There is no “inside track” or secret handshake that they bring to the table. 

Their “connections” to the kids they left behind means one thing only.  In your first meeting, you will be stroked.  You will be told how horrible the Government can be, and how it overreaches when it goes after fine citizens like you instead of spending its time convicting drug dealers and terrorists.  How dare they investigate you, the lawyers (there are always more than one) will tell you, sharing your pain and anger and humiliation at being so wrongfully accused.  You will be assured that they have the juice, the power, the “resources”, to do everything possible to restore your reputation, to protect you from this unduly aggressive government, to keep a good person like you from every seeing the inside of a federal prison.  They can do it because they were prosecutors themselves (insert various war stories) and know how it works.

After going through the routine that happens at the commencement of every criminal prosecution, and billing you for their time, their associates time, their conferring partners’ time, their research, their document review ad naseum, and making certain that they have taken from you  every remaining penny from your years of work, legitimate or otherwise, they will tell you that the risks are too great.  The old chestnut about how even innocent people can end up convicted get tossed on the fire.  You begin to shake.  If these guys, the best money can buy, say so, then so it must be.

They will explain to you, in accurate detail, all the reasons you should take a walk with them to the United States Attorneys office.  You will come to see how you, because you’re not “really” a criminal, should talk to the prosecutors, work something out, trust the government.  The government will work with you, because your lawyers used to be government lawyers.  Your lawyers know people.  Your lawyers can talk to their friends about you.  It’s good to have friends, you think.  Thank heavens your lawyers used to be prosecutors.  They will explain everything to their dear friends in the United States Attorneys office, and everything will go away.

This is where the shoe falls.  You do what your very expensive lawyers tell you to do, because there’s no purpose in having a lawyer if you aren’t going to listen to him.  You take that long walk to the United States Attorneys office.  They embrace you.  They bring you into the fold.  In your newfound comfort, you speak freely.  Finally, you are at the table with the good guys, the people with whom you want to bond.  People like you, who wear suits and ties and dream of vacations with the wife (girlfriend?) and kids.  Your type of people.

After all, you aren’t a criminal.  You don’t rob old ladies with a bat, or sell drugs on the street.  They are criminals.  You are just a businessman, a banker, doing your job.  This whole thing is just a big misunderstanding.  Now you can talk with your new chums and straighten out this whole mess.  You will all have a big laugh about the misunderstanding, and you can go home and have a stiff drink and thank God the nightmare is over.  You think to yourself, it may have cost me a fortune, but it really pays to have hired this huge multinational law firm with the “resources” to fix everything. 

And then the other shoe falls.  There’s just one detail remaining, that isn’t mentioned until the end of the meeting.  You will have to execute this plea agreement, where you admit to the commission of the crimes and agree to go to prison, forfeit everything that’s left and pay restitution in an amount with many zeros to the victims you left behind.  Your head spins.  How did this happen?  What went wrong?  It wasn’t supposed to happen this way.

This story has been replayed over and over.  Read the papers.  One CEO falling after another in disgrace.  The failure to defend has been of massive proportions.  Biglaw’s purpose is to earn partner profits.  You are the source of those profits.  The reason is simple: You are a believing that bigger is better, bigger has powers that smaller doesn’t have and the most expensive is always the best.  You believe in magic tricks because you want to believe.  You believe that you aren’t really a criminal defendant because it conforms with your self-image.   You accept the lack of a defense because it absolves you from blame. 

There are winners in this game.  You just won’t be one of them.  The winners are quietly receiving the representation that you are too proud and important to seek.  They are putting up a real fight, a fight for their lives, because they aren’t fooled by the promise of “connections” and “resources”.  Chances are that these were your COOs, CFOs, CIOs (any other “C”s I missed), managers and brokers, the little people who can’t afford Biglaw. 

Afterward, you ask yourself how these people who were always beneath you managed to accomplish what you could not.  How is it possible that they walk free while you sit in a prison camp, your life in ruins.  You aren’t feeling as smart as you used to, but you must rationalize your situation because the plain truth is too unbearable.

And ironically, it’s not that Biglaw couldn’t produce a defense with a viable chance of succeeding.  It’s that they chose not to.  They feel  much more comfortable sitting around the office with these former AUSAs who can honestly say that their hands were never sullied by a fight.  Biglaw doesn’t engage real criminal defense lawyers.  We’re not really their kind of lawyer.  They won’t bring one in to head up the defense, as that would be demeaning and inconsistent with their self-image.  They too want to believe that their ex-government hires have the ability to use their connections and wrap up cases.  Of course, they aren’t too concerned about how the cases end, only that the bills are fully paid.  It’s a business, you know.  That’s why New York Lawyer calls it a “feeding frenzy.” 

It’s your life.  Do whatever you must.  But I can’t help you afterward, when you are lying awake in your prison bed in the middle of the night wondering how everything went wrong.

Witness For The Defense

Clients want to explain why the prosecution’s case is wrong.   Sometimes it’s because of their perception of the law (but there’s no pictures of me doing it, so they have no proof), but more often it’s a dispute on the facts (he’s a liar, I never did/said that).  With this introduction, we enter the Wide World of Witnesses (with apologies to Roone Arledge).

It’s not that lawyers don’t believe their client.  To the contrary, we hear the same thing over and over, and truly believe it’s accurate.  The problem is that a factual dispute is resolved by a trial.  We don’t trot down to the prosecutor’s office, explain that our client tells us that it never happened, obtain a heartfelt apology for the cops’ mistake and everybody goes home happy.  This is what we fight about.

The analogy of the criminal defense lawyer’s weapons is always good for matters such as this.  Witnesses are the bullets in our gun.  Without them, we are shooting blanks.  Yes, we can cross the cops to death about their story, but they are trained to hold firm in their position and use vague language on the stand to avoid getting caught in a trap.  Even though we may score a few points, rarely does a cop or agent break down on the stand and admit he fabricated something.  It’s happened, but very rarely.

We prove things through evidence, including the testimony of witnesses.  This is where a defendant’s understanding tends to get a bit fuzzy.  On day 1, defendants tell us that they have witnesses.  Tons of them.  They have friends, family, pastors, co-workers, all of whom will definitely come forward and tell the truth.  We tell them how wonderful that is, and that we look forward to interviewing them and preparing to defend against this spurious lies. 

But criminal defense lawyers know a few things that criminal defendants have yet to learn. 

1.  Nobody loves you when you’re down and out.  When you get arrested, you find out who your real friends are.  People who were only too happy to hang with you before suddenly won’t take your calls.  They avert their eyes when they see you on the street.  They are always busy and can’t stop to speak with you.  You want to believe their excuses, but you eventually realize that they want nothing to do with you.  You have become a pariah.

2.  Nobody wants to put themselves in the line of fire.  Standing behind the defendant puts a witness on the opposite side of the government.  It taints the witness as a friend of a criminal.   It makes the witness a target.  It’s bad enough that the defendant is the subject of a criminal prosecution, but nobody wants to invite the scrutiny of law enforcement.  Why paint a target on your own back and beg the government to try its luck?

3.  The pressure is overwhelming.  One of the requirements of the defense is to provide basic pedigree information to the prosecution in advance of calling someone as a witness.  We are obligated to give the government a chance to check our witness out beforehand, another one of those one-way requirements that the law imposes to make sure that defendants don’t get a level playing field.  We know that the witness will get a knock on the door by the cops or agents, reminding them in veiled language (or if the witness is not too bright, in quite vivid language) that they will become the enemy of law enforcement if they help the criminal, and are likely to be prosecuted for obstruction of justice because they will, by definition, be lying on the stand when they challenge what the cops or agents have to say.  This is not, by the way, witness intimidation, but merely good police work.  Even though I tell witnesses in advance to expect this, it is still has a remarkable impact on their willingness to testify.

4.   Good testimony is hard to find.  Witnesses are always prepared in advance, by teaching them how to listen to questions, respond in an appropriate fashion, deal with objections and not cut their own throats by vomiting words to fill the silence.  No competent lawyer puts an unprepared witness on the stand.  And still, it’s about 50/50 that it ends in disaster.  Being a trial witness is unlike anything else a person has ever done.  While being prepped, they can’t stay in role, ask questions back and break every rule of testifying that they’re given.  They insist they will do it differently when it’s the real thing.  They won’t.  They never do.  If they can’t testify properly in the lawyer’s office, they will invariably collapse under the pressure of the courtroom.  Testifying is counterintuitive.  It lacks the give and take of normal communication, and defies our normal desire to work with the questioner to get to the points we want to make.  It isn’t at all like it appears on TV.  It requires giving up control to the questioner, something people find extremely difficult to do.  While it may be understandable, it’s unhelpful.  It means that even if we can find a witness and get him on the stand, we may still be unable to get him to give us what we need in a manner that will help.  And he may, inadvertently, cut our throat.  And his.

There are plenty of variations on the problems faced by the defense with witnesses, and I’ve hardly exhausted them in my short list.  These are the realities faced by criminal defense lawyers who have had the pleasant experience of trying cases and putting (or trying to put) witnesses on the stand for the defense.  Imagine the troubles faced by the lawyer who hasn’t had the experience.  Prosecutors don’t have the same problems as defense lawyers.  That’s another reason why their experience doesn’t translate well.

These problems aren’t insurmountable.  We do get witnesses to testify, and we get them to provide the testimony needed to mount a viable defense.  It just takes a lot of work and experience.  But that’s why people retain us.

Why Is It Never The Majority That Gets It? (Updated)

This  concurring opinion, by Justice Richard T. Sanders of the Washington Supreme Court, speaks volumes.


I understand that the majority’s view to be the state legislature is virtually unrestrained except insofar as the legislative action countervenes some express prohibition in the state constitution.  Although this claim has been repeated by rote in several of our decisions, I am unable to find a single one which explains its rationale, much less critically examines its premise.  I challenge the majority to either do so here or dispense with this careless rhetoric.  The assertion seems to be based on an erroneous presumption that state governments have inherent powers — a presumption that contradicts the basic premise of all American governance that all power resides in the people except insofar as it has been delegated to the government.  As such, the claim flies in the face of article I, section 1 of the state constitution, which plainly and expressly provides: All political power is inherent in the people, and governments derive their just powers from the consent of the governed, and are established to protect and maintain individual rights.

This section hardly evidences our state government has the inherent power to do anything.  Rather, it stands for precisely the opposite.

From here, it just gets better:

I also note with alarm the seditious doctrine sometimes embraced by our majority that even our Declaration of Rights is itself trumped by exercise of the state’s police power, a power which a majority of my colleagues seems to believe with their new-found wisdom has no limits whatsoever.

How long has it been since there was a majority decision that recognized that the United States doesn’t exist as a vessel for the exercise of police power over the rights of the governed?  By the way, as Eugene’s people point out, it would seem “pernicious” would be a better word choice than “seditious”, but I’m not complaining.

I have often explained that the police, the state, the government, has no “rights”.  Only people have rights.  The government has only as much authority as the people grant it to do the job asked of it.  And yet, America has become a nation of government sycophants, believing that it’s patriotic to comply with whatever the government demands, following the instructions of those in power, or well armed, because that’s what good Americans do.

As Justice Sanders explains, they got it all backwards.  The government exists for us, not us for it.

Update:  Note also Justice Tom Chamber’s concurring opinion.  Here’s the majority opinion.

H/T. Eugene