Big time CEOs use Biglaw to defend them because, well, they’re Biglaw and that makes them better then, say, real criminal defense lawyers, right?
Well just ask former Brocade CEO Gregory Reyes, per this Law.com post courtesy of Andrew Bluestone at New York Attorney Malpractice Blog. Reyes was sentenced by Judge Charles Breyer to an additional 6 months because of an affidavit in support of severance submitted during the case.
U.S. District Judge Charles Breyer sentenced the former Silicon Valley icon to 21 months in prison Wednesday. Breyer also imposed a $15 million fine, but did not order Reyes to pay any restitution. Breyer stayed the entire sentence pending appeal.
Breyer indicated, however, he would have imposed a shorter, 15-month sentence had Reyes not submitted a sworn affidavit to the court saying he did not backdate.
Lest you think the Skadden hourly fee paid for partner Richard Marmaro, not to mention the 37 associates who “assisted” in the preparation of the papers (I’m just making this up here for purpose of exaggerating my point) was high enough, the additional 6 months is a hefty price for careless lawyering.
To be fair, Marmaro proved to be a stand-up lawyer, when the judge came down like a ton of bricks on his client’s head.
Reyes’ attorney, Richard Marmaro, attempted to take the flak for the declaration, telling Breyer he had been the “proponent” of it . . . The language in the declaration was a product of “poor drafting by the lawyers” and was not meant to apply to all of the disputed Brocade stock option grants, said Marmaro, a partner at Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom.
Still, one has to wonder how it is possible that Skadden Arps managed to screw up something that any federal defender would know better than to do? Was the billion dollar legal fee insufficient to get all those Tier 1 law grads to stop thinking about their Ferrari orders and focus on their client’s case?And just to add another thought to the mix, bear in mind that this was yet another plea. Has anybody who pretends to do criminal defense at these big law firms ever heard of a trial? It has been pointed out that this was wrong, and that Reyes was convicted after a jury trial. The exception (particularly given the result) does not, of course, change the rule.
Now to my point: To all you very important, big time corporate white collar defendants. If you were so smart and important, wouldn’t you learn a lesson from watching CEO after CEO go to prison despite their ridiculously expensive and shockingly ineffective defense? Is it just this mindless love of corporate culture, where bigger is better instead of better is better?
Since my dear white collar defendants really never seem to grasp the obvious, I’m going to restate this point more clearly. You are a defendant in a criminal prosecution, no matter how “important” and different you want to believe you are. When you get to the FCI, they don’t let you wear ties and carry cellphones. They don’t call you “sir”. You get a number just like everyone else.
So retain an attorney who is competent to defend you, rather than an attorney who is guaranteed to plead you out hours after your personal well runs dry. And no, you do not need a 1000 lawyer firm with “resources”. You need skill and competency, not secret connections. I understand this is a novel concept, but it’s your life.
