Author Archives: SHG

Resources Depleted, It’s Time To Go

An upstate Supreme has given up.  According to  this article in the New York Law Journal, Oneida County Supreme Court Justice Robert F. Julian has announced he’s resigning because he is “unwilling to further deplete my savings and reduce my lifestyle to continue in office.” 

What is interesting about this is that the wage compression problem is significantly reduced for upstate versus city judges.  The cost of living is just so much less upstate.  Complicating matters, their prospects in returning to private practice upstate aren’t all that great. 

Without either capital or clients, judges do not have strong drawing power in the private sector, especially in New York City. In addition, judges for the most part are generalists and do not have skills highly valued in the private sector with the exception of appellate judges and those who have been assigned to the commercial division of Supreme Court.

Thus, Justice Julian’s decision to leave the bench seems to be a very strong statement.  Of course, he’s not the first judge to walk away.


In 2006, County Court Judge Stewart A. Rosenwasser of Orange County announced his resignation, saying in a statement that he “did not foresee the sacrifices my service would impose on my family” when he took office

And Manhattan Supreme Emily Jane Goodman has been actively seeking a new job for a while now, and openly posted her thoughts at Judicial Reports.

The recurring theme coming out of these judges is that they are forced to eat away at their savings and investments to maintain their lifestyle while serving.  Of course, this what is happening with public defenders as well, just to make sure no one forgets about them.

The countervailing force is that there is no shortage of people seeking the blessing of county political leaders to get onto the ballot for a judgeship, though I tend to think that this is due to a secondary trend, even more unfortunate than the refusal to increase judicial salaries, of younger people wanting robes who come directly from one government job into another.  Having never earned a dollar on their own, they don’t find judicial salaries to be as much of a problem.  At least for now.

But Justice Julian’s point is dulled somewhat by his secondary reason for leaving the bench.


Julian said “merit selection proposals” put forward by the governor and others also had influenced his decision to leave, because they rely on “isolated instances of judicial transgression” to give the governor, Legislature and chief judge “the unprecedented power to appoint the judiciary.”

Exactly what “judicial transgressions” worry him?  Being a judge isn’t exactly like working at the car wash, where the boss can overlook someone coming in late every once in a while.  The obligation, given its impact on the lives of others, doesn’t leave a lot of room for transgressions.  So if that’s the worry, perhaps leaving the bench isn’t such a problem.

Notwithstanding some extremely cynical comments made here recently about the nature of people who want to sit in judgment of others, the system can’t function without intelligent and fair-minded judges.  Since judicial candidates are now a product of superb effort on envelope-stuffing day at the party headquarters, it would be irresponsible to ignore the potential of infusing merit into the selection process.  This is not to say that no local party favorite ends up being a good, even great, judge, but that some (perhaps many) have gamed the selection process to wind up exactly the sort of judge that makes Bennett wretch.

In any event, Justices leaving the bench was the legislature’s worst fear, since they were hoping that the judiciary would be just as political as they were and would hold tight until there was enough cash to spread around to everyone.  This puts their back to the wall, and will do more to bring the issue to a head than  all the op-eds that Chief Judge Judy Kaye could possibly write.  A few more high profile resignations and this could get interesting.

The Underbelly of Brady Revealed

The Appellate Division, First Department decided  People v. Garcia only two days after Christmas, which a more cynical person than me would surmise was planned to make sure that the decision would fly under the radar.  The reason is simple, it rips to shreds the office of Rob Johnson, the Bronx District Attorney.  While they may have been miffed enough to smack him hard, there’s still a degree of professional civility around.  No need to make it a front page story and embarrass Rob any more than necessary.

This story has already made the rounds, including a great post by Nicole Black at Sui Generis, for its strong language castigating the District Attorney’s deliberate concealment of Brady material from the defense, and for the language in their brief arguing that deliberate concealment of Brady constitutes “an arguable lapse of preferred practice.”

While I have nothing against jumping on the bandwagon, that’s not my purpose in this belated Garcia post.  Rather, it’s to bolster my essay (which Dirk Olin prefers to call a polemic) at Judicial Reports on the subject of Brady.  My point then, and now, is that Brady has been reduced to a shell game, dependent on the integrity of any given individual prosecutor to identify evidence as such and then turn it over.  Garcia is the result of this massive failure of law.

In the Garcia case, Bronx Supreme Court Justice Steven Lloyd Barrett tossed the convictions after a 440.10 (post-conviction) motion.  Thus, three intervening and fortunate events occurred.  First, the defense found out that Brady existed.  By definition, the Bronx ADA didn’t turn it over, thus shifting the burden to the defense to “discover” its existence on their own.  What are the chances?  Well, obviously the Bronx ADA didn’t think they were very good.

Second, Garcia’s lawyers, the Office of the Appellate Defender, didn’t close the file and run away.  While most civilians would be appalled at this notion, defendants receive indigent counsel for certain purposes, and counsel not infrequently will fulfill the prescribed function but go no further.  In other words, assigned appellate counsel went outside its zone by bringing the 440.10.  If they refused to do so, chances are strong that Garcia would have either been forced to find a private lawyer to take the post-conviction motion for a fee, or give it up.  He was lucky to have the Office of the Appellate Defender on his side.

And finally, Judge Barrett is a sharp, ballsy judge.  While the Bronx has its share of exceptional judges, it also has its share of duds.  Garcia was fortunate that his judge was one of the strong and smart ones, not afraid to toss a conviction under these circumstances.  And what if Garcia’s case went to a different judge?  We’ll never know. 

If we take away the confluence of the events that led to this decision, what would have happened.  In all likelihood, the ADA’s attempt to conceal Brady would have succeeded and Garcia would be doing his time.  The point is that we tend to feel that the system works great when we have an occasional success as happened in Garcia.  My point is that the success in Garcia represents the exception, and the rule remains that Brady remains a sorry farce.

Where Do Physicians Fit In With Lethal Injections?

On the heels of yesertday’s oral argument in Baze v. Rees, the  New England Journal of Medicine has published an editorial, Physicians and Execution, by Gregory D. Curfman, M.D., Stephen Morrissey, Ph.D., and Jeffrey M. Drazen, M.D. addressing where, from the physicians perspective, they should be in the mix.

After providing an interesting overview of how society progressed from hanging to electrocution, gas chamber and then lethal injection, to “sanitize” the process and thereby make the execution process more humane, the authors posit that lawyers, without physicians, will never be able to come up with a means of killing that will pass constitutional muster.

We are concerned that, regardless of its decision in Baze v. Rees, the Court may include language in its opinion that will turn again to the medical profession to legitimize a form of lethal injection that, meeting an appropriate constitutional standard, will not be considered “cruel and unusual punishment.” On the surface, lethal injection is a deceptively simple procedure, but its practical application has been fraught with numerous technical difficulties. Without the involvement of physicians and other medical professionals with special training in the use of anesthetic drugs and related agents, it is unlikely that lethal injection will ever meet a constitutional standard of decency. But do we as a society want the nation’s physicians to do this? We believe not.

This is a fascinating call to arms by physicians not to be sucked into the frey of capital punishment.  While doctors frequently enjoy playing hobby lawyers, essentially bailing us out of our medical ignorance by providing what purports to be the latest and greatest in scientific proof, the authors jump in to stop their brethren in their tracks.

We believe that . . . all responsible members of the medical profession, when asked to assist in a state-ordered execution, will remember the Hippocratic Oath and refuse to participate. The future of capital punishment in the United States will be up to the justices, but the involvement of physicians in executions will be up to the medical profession.

So are we really on our own, or will the brotherhood of physicians break ranks and give up the medical secret to constitutionally acceptable executions?

Lawline’s Look at CLE

Yesterday, a  comment to an old post of mine on Continuing Legal Education caught my eye.  The commenter used the name “Online CLE” which made me immediately suspect that somebody was out there trolling for free advertising.  Since there’s no free lunch here, I was going to delete the comment.  But upon rereading it, I was unclear where it was heading.


I agree with your evaluation of the state of CLE’s. Lawline.com, my company is trying to put an end to the same old talking head lectures many of us are used to. We are constantly looking for fresh lectures given in alternative formats to try to provide attorneys with an interesting and valuable CLE experience. Please check us out, we would love to hear from anyone.

Obviously it was a come-on of sorts, but was it for lawyers who go there to buy their CLE programs, or lawyers to go there to provide new ideas for CLEs, or lawyers to be the next generation of talking heads.  So, I naturally dove in without looking.

I initially checked out the website  to get a feel for what they did and how they did it.  The faculty is made up of some heavy hitters, a number of whom are friends of mine or at least people I know.  Some, I know very well.  While I can’t vouch for all the lawyers involved, the ones I know certainly know their business, are interesting speakers and would be the guys I would go see if I had to.

So I began a dialogue with the lawline representative, who explained to me that the CLE business grew out of TV show, also called Lawline.  If memory serves, this was put on by a successful PI lawyer name Alan Schnurman as a showcase for him.  Not that he needed it, as he made a killing in Hamptons real estate and has almost as much money as a young investment banker.

While the rep, who never actually gave me his or her name, explained the sale pitch, it was primarily geared to good business:  They are doing this to make money off the CLE requirement, and need to produce high quality and interesting programs if they are going to be able to sell them.  As far as I’m concerned, there’s no better motivation for the provision of high quality services than financial.

But what’s in it for the lawyers who provide the content?  I assume that the guys I know who were listed as faculty on their website are in similar positions as me, having more than enough opportunity to fulfill our CLE requirements by doing bar association CLEs, and so we don’t need to look for more chances to get a few credits.  So, I asked what was in it for the lawyers.

The response was that they get the CLE credit and “some good promotion.”  “Am I wrong to assume that you are a for-profit entity?” I asked.  Indeed they are, but why pay for lawyers when you don’t have to, the rep replied.

So then it was time to check this out with my friends who are on the “faculty”, and indeed, that was the case.  Aside from the potential that Alan Schnurman might toss them a case or two, which apparently never panned out as hoped, it’s viewed as a pretty good opportunity to promote oneself as a big name in their respective field of law, big enough to be worthy of being a faculty member in these pay-to-play CLE courses, and that’s a good enough reason.

I had also asked the rep whether his comment was intended as a means of selling Lawline’s services or to seek new blood for its faculty.  I was told both, that they are in business to provide CLEs to lawyers and are constantly seeking new blood, new ideas and better, more interesting programs and formats.

So it ends up that the comment was, at least to some extent, a grab at free advertising here for the services they sell to lawyers.  But rather than delete the comment, I feel constrained to applaud their efforts at trying to provide a better CLE than the tired, pointless stuff that has been coming out lately.  As for their business model of using top quality lawyers who are willing to work for nothing, how can I fault them for a business model that works?  There appears to be a good reason why Alan Schnurman has become such a big success, and you can’t argue with success.

Adjunct Accused of Misblawgary

BEWARE:  Snarkiness ahead.  Proceed at your own risk.

Ordinarily, I don’t bother to check out the adjunct lawprof blog because, well, it’s generally underwhelming (if you catch my drift).  But when  Susan Cartier Liebel posts about something, it’s worth a look.

This challenge was a great source of amusement to begin with, and just got better as the writer was challenged by the adjunct he criticized, and then claimed he didn’t criticize, after he got nailed for it.  It’s like adjunct professor mud-wrestling, and who could resist that?

So Mitchell Rubenstein (the editor of the blawg) posts about another adjunct, Marc John Randazza (note the use of the middle name, usually reserved for death row inmates).  Randazza includes in his course syllabus a requirement that students blog, worth “10 points.”  Fairly novel approach to student writing, but a great way to push students to demonstrate their ability to express their interests and thoughts in writing. 

Susan loves this idea, but she’s an outside the box kinda gal to begin with, so she’s unlikely to be scared off by anything that enhances a law students education because it wasn’t done by Kingsfield in the Paper Chase.

Rubenstein, on the other hand, is less generous.

This raises some important issues. Is posting on a blog the same as class participation? Will students compete with each other for the most blog postings? Should we encourage this? Is the professor simply trying to increase his traffic? What if students do not have access to the internet?

Uh oh.  Trouble in paradise.   And so comes the lashing from Susan:


I think you may be overreacting. Marc is a First Amendment rights lawyer and is getting his students positioned in marketing, the good, the bad and the ugly of internet, privacy, reputation and the like. It think it is highly progressive and interactive and should be applauded. As for your questions re: drive traffic to his site? Please. And what if students don’t have access to the internet? I don’t know of any law student not carting around their laptop typing away and ignoring their torts professors. But even if the isolated student does not, the law school provides it. Don’t knock creativity and forward-thinking activities which engage the students in practical experience.

And then Marc Randazza shows up.  Showing a level of collegiality that was denied him, he opens with


With respect to the question “Is the professor simply trying to increase his traffic?”… it may smell petty, but I don’t think that Prof. Rubenstein was being as petty and small as the statement might suggest. I’ll speak in his defense. It appears that he just didn’t really read beyond the passage he quoted. We are all busy, and sometimes we miss details that make us seem foolish later on… so, for as long as I live in the same glass house, I’ll cast no stone at Rubenstein.

There’s probably no better way to rip somebody than by excusing this silly attack as a product of missing “details that make us seem foolish later on.”  Foolish indeed.

Oh, but I forgot the law student who chimed in between the two.  I love this comment.


Take it from a student that has been in classes with required posting (on a Lexis web-course)… it lead to a horse-race for just how many times a student could have their name shown for posting (usually consisting of links to New York Times articles, which does not require analytical thinking… http://www.nytimes.com/opinion (that took 2 seconds without thought; OR student posting without actually anything substantive to say).

Mandatory leads to nothing but drivel. The more voluntary, the better, thought-provoking posts there will be.

No. drivel leads to nothing but drivel.  And I’m guessing that you don’t have a bright future at Biglaw, because simply linking to the New York Times editorial page is not blogging and it’s unlikely you’re going to fool anybody that way.

But getting back to the adjunct mud-wrestling match, Rubenstein realizes the error of his ways and tries, in an act of blatant desperation, to backtrack and claim that his original attack on Randazza was no attack at all, but merely a question:


The first commentator [that would be Susan] read the purpose of my posting totally wrong. I actually commend Prof. Randazza for using his blog for academic purposes. Simply because a Prof. raises a question, does not indicate that they disagree. After all, thats what we Profs do.

 Yeah, that’s right.  When he asked if Randazza was trying to use students to pad his traffic, he meant it in the positive sense.  You know, good padding, not that bad evil padding.  Holy cow, did he think he was going to pull his chestnuts out of the fire with that lame crap?

Nobody would fault you for asking questions, but it’s all in the questions you ask.  It’s bad enough that you went after him in the first place (come on now, be honest), but your subsequent attempt to cover yourself was just pathetic.  Own up to it and take your lumps.  Like Marc John says, sometimes we all look foolish.  This was your turn.

Is it just me, or does this sound remarkably like our clients who jump at the chance to try to “explain” their way out of a bust with some ridiculous excuse that later comes back to bite them in the butt?  My advice, Mitch (from one ILRie to another) is bite the bullet.  But thanks for the laugh.

The Bicycle Menace

Steve Gustitis  has admitted his criminal ways.  Well, not quite criminal, but at least a tad less than law-abiding.  How so?  He’s part of the bicycle menace, that gang of two-wheeled threats to life and limb in the name of their own pleasure.

Before I proceed to rip this menace to shreds in the name of public safety, let me affirmatively state that I have nothing against bicycles per se.  It’s the riders.  The ones who challenge the rest of us to do something about their disregard for anyone and anything that impedes their right to do whatever they please.  Bikes don’t kill, people do.

Now I happen to live on a long, winding, tree-lined two-lane road that leads to the Long Island Sound.  When the weather turns warmish, there suddenly appears these large groups of hermaphroditic spandex wearers on bicycles.  When I say large groups, I mean groups of 50 or more.  Like a swarm of killer bees, they take over the road.

These cyclists ride along the side of the road.  And in the middle of the lanes.  And in the middle of the road.  En masse.  They know that this is a road used regularly by cars, given that the cars driving behind the swarm flash their lights and honk their horns.  They don’t care.  They will ride down the middle of the road all they want, daring drivers to do something about it. 

When an opportunity comes to pass this swarm of bicycles, its not uncommon for the boldest among them, the ones who deliberately try to block the cars from getting by, the make a gesture at the drivers to show their disdain.  “Hah!  You may have passed us this time, but we will stop you next time,” they seem to say.

What is a driver to do?  Sure, they appear from the rear like bowling pins, easily enough knocked down to remind them that sharing the road involves a certain degree of cooperation from both sides.  But that would be wrong.  No matter how arrogant and selfish, it’s no excuse to cause harm to anyone.  But what drives these cyclists to challenge a car to do something?  What makes them decide to assert their ability to disrupt the flow of vehicles at their potential personal risk?

The flip side is that cars and their occupants are frequently put at risk as bicycles tear through stop signs (sound familiar, Steve?) and blow through intersections or pass turning vehicles with their blinkers engaged, because they prefer not to stop their energetic flows.  Drivers, in their effort not to take out a cyclist or two, are forced to swerve or stop abruptly, with other cars behind them that would have no reason to anticipate such an action. 

There’s something curious about that wave that says “I’m sorry” from the occasional bicyclist when they realize that their intransigence has almost cause a vehicular collision.  While they may feel bad about their knowing and deliberate refusal to obey the traffic laws that provide for the safety of others, it’s not as if they have any intention of changing their behavior the next time.  They will do the same thing again, and hope that next time they don’t have to apologize.

So I’m not particularly interested in all the health benefits of riding bicycles, or the enjoyment of this pastime by adults who think that their gut isn’t noticeable in spandex.  Your pleasure is not a good enough reason to put my children’s lives at risk, and you have neither right nor justification to ignore the laws that allow all of us to use the road.  The only thing surprising about any of this is that some cop actually handed out tickets to cyclists.  It’s about time.

The First Murder in Lima, Ohio

From Mark Draughn at  Windypundit comes this story of a search warrant execution by the police SWAT team in Lima, Ohio, that left a mother dead and her one year old son shot by police.  As Lima councilman Derry Glenn said, “The first murder in 2008 came from a police officer.”

The facts are nothing unusual.  The SWAT team, which clear enjoys the machismo of weaponry as demonstrated on its website, executed a search warrant for a suspected drug dealer at the home of 26 year old mother of 6, Tarika Wilson at about 8:15 in the evening.  They knew that there were children in the house from the toys on the porch and in the yard.  There were two dogs in the house, identified by police as pit bulls (because poodles don’t carry the implication of killer dogs), though no claim that the dogs were vicious or attacked any officer.  Just to be sure, the police shot them both.

There’s no explanation of how or why Tarika Wilson, holding her 1 year old in her arms, was killed.  The police chief feels badly about it, but has withheld the name of the officer who killed her.  Of course, all other names involved were disclosed, together with as much negative information as possible to make sure that no one feels too badly for the dead woman.

There are police procedures designed to execute search warrants and arrest alleged criminals without giving rise to situations likely to result in the use of force.  They aren’t terribly complicated, and don’t necessarily involve any additional cost or trouble to the police.  They just didn’t happen in Lima.

For example, most warrants are executed in the early morning hours, like 5 to 6 AM, when the occupants of a home are asleep.  Through the swift entry and execution of the warrant on the unsuspecting suspect, the occupants are caught unaware and unprepared to react.  It’s a nasty way to wake up, but no one gets hurt.  On the other hand, 8:15 in the evening is prime time for trouble.

Police can also surveil a residence and await the suspect approaching or leaving the house.  They nab him outdoors so that resistance to the arrest, if any, happens away from the mother and children.  They simultaneously execute the warrant without the threat of potential violence.  Apparently, this too is not a sufficiently special tactic in Lima.

There will be an investigation into how this situation went wrong, though the worst that will come of it is that one police officer opened fire on an unarmed mother holding her child out of either a mistaken fear or just an accidental twitch of the finger.  They will do their best to make sure that everyone is aware that they brought this on themselves by engaging in drug dealing, using the time-honored ploy of smearing the victim to deflect attention from the fact that they killed someone needlessly.

But as Windy implicitly questions, why does Lima, Ohio, a city of 40,000 people, need a 12 man SWAT team?  The problem is that when you dress a bunch of cops in black and give them special weapons, they tend to want to use them.  They mysteriously change from human beings with children of their own to storm troopers exerting their overwhelming power.  It’s so sexy to cops to be part of such a team that it alters their perspective, and too easily ends in the use of force when thought would have been a better choice. 

Windy asks why, given the panoply of available supposedly non-lethal weapons, did the cops come in with guns ablazing.  The best guess would be because this was a SWAT team entering the house of a suspected drug dealer.  In Lima, Ohio, this is about as good an opportunity to take out those automatic weapons as the cops are going to get.  Batons and tasers are for sissies when you’re all dressed in black.,

What is most notable about this story is that there are small police departments across the country where police officers, usually nice guys with good intentions, are managed foolishly and incompetently.  They still have guns and shields, but they aren’t truly competent to use them.  As here, where the execution of the warrant reflects plain, old, ordinary poor police tactics, we see the outcome of poor training and management.  Just because someone isn’t needlessly killed every time a poorly planned and executed raid occurs doesn’t mean that the police tactics aren’t bad.  That is eventually happens is the problem.

Will the administration of the Lima police department, the people responsible for this SWAT team, recognize what went wrong here?  Not likely.  The officer who pulled the trigger will be the scapegoat, as will the officer who shoots first the next time it happens.  And it will happen again, whether in Lima or where you live.

SCOTUS: No Ineffective Assistance Today

At least not today, according to  two summary decisions coming out of Washington.  First, the Court held in Wright v. Von Patten that


it has never required defense lawyers to be physically on hand during every stage of a criminal court proceedings, and thus has never found it unconstitutional for a lawyer to take part in a plea hearing by speaker phone.

They don’t need no stinkin’ appearances.  Well, that’s not quite where they were heading, as “[t]he Court said it was leaving ‘for another day’ the issue of whether ‘telephone practice’ was legally problematic, finding that all that was necessary to decide this case was that there was no ban on a speaker phone appearance that could be found in prior Court precedents.”

The Court’s decision rejected a per se approach to a lawyer appearing by telephone in a criminal matter, something that is uncommon but not unheard of.  Because of the demands on a lawyer’s presence at a given time and on a given day, when different clients are on different judges calenders in different courthouses, or when a judge calls and wants you before her in an hour, and you’re three states away, the telephone may present the only way.  There are also times when the only thing that’s going to happen is to adjourn a case to another day, and there’s nothing of substance required.

But there are also instances where a conference on a real subject will take place by telephone conference, and these raise different issues.  On the surface there’s no reason why a telephone conference in the law is any different than a telephone conference in any other field of endeavor.  Business does it constantly, and it seems to work just fine for them.

Having done my share of conferences, primarily in federal cases where telephone conferences tend to make expeditious and effective use of judges’ and magistrates’ time, I see the problem.  While telephone practice is incredibly efficient, it never has the same feel as being in the same room with your adversary and the judge.  Speakerphones are monumentally bad at allowing cross-talk, or being certain who is saying what or when the opportunity to interject is available.

The only question is why the Supreme Court decided it was worth their while to decide this small piece of the puzzle, that telephone practice does not, alone, violate the Constitution, without addressing the bigger issues.

On a different note, the highly controversial and fascinating issue in Arave v. Hoffman,  discussed here because of the interesting issue of how to remedy ineffective issue during plea negotiations, has folded like a cheap suit.  This wasn’t unexpected, as both parties alerted the court that the question of counsel’s ineffective assistance was off the table, but it leaves us with the same open question of whether a lawyer’s erroneous advice, that forms the basis for acceptance of a plea, is subject to review and remedy.  

On the other hand, if anyone has a case that presents this issue, now would be a good time to seek cert.  I hear there’s an opening in the Supreme Court docket. 

So You’re A Lawyer? With What Firm? (Updated)

Every criminal defense lawyer has been asked the “how could you” question about a zillion times.  We’ve all got our pat responses.  But the question that most annoys me is when I’m asked what I do and tell someone I’m a lawyer.  The next question is usually, “with what firm?”

There is something about the underlying assumption that a real lawyer works for a law firm that makes the question pejorative.  It’s probably just an unwarranted sensitivity on my part, but I really dislike the question. 

I had a law firm for many years.  It eventually came to a natural end (as my partner was 20 years my senior and time and vodka did a number on him).  I enjoyed the camaraderie of other lawyers by sharing offices, and I’ve been “of counsel” to a couple of law firms for years now as well.  But I am a solo practitioner.  The law firm is me.  Sure, I have other lawyers who work for me on an ad hoc basis, and the staff of these firms when needed, but it’s not the same as being a member of a law firm. 

So why do people assume that if you’re a lawyer, you have to work for a firm?  Or be a partner in a firm?  Or have a bunch of associates on the payroll?  The solidity of the old-line concept of a law firm, I believe, is part of the mythology of being a lawyer.  It makes lawyers real, whereas the solo is just some guy or gal who hangs out a shingle and does whatever junk comes in off the street.

I reject that notion.  In criminal defense, law firms are something of a rarity.  While there are numerous groups of 2 to 3 lawyers who put their names on the letterhead together and share the ups and downs of practice, there are far more criminal defense lawyers who have only one name on the door.  There’s a good reason for this.  Clients don’t come to us because of the firm, but for the services of a particular lawyer who has the reputation of providing zealous representation and being a great lawyer.  It’s personal.  When someone comes to me, they want me to be their lawyer.  They don’t want my associate showing up in court, no matter how much better looking he may be. 

This changes somewhat in my white collar defense sphere, where potential clients feel naked unless they see a bustling law firm, with people scurrying about hold sheafs of paper and fetching coffee.  This is the corporate mentality of people who work for and with others.  The concept of a solo having the ability to fight often conflicts with the world that they have always known and makes them feel secure. 

The common wisdom is that a solo can’t handle the voluminous paperwork that usually comes with white collar cases.  Why think this?  Because they’ve never experienced a world of personal responsibility, where there weren’t lower echelon people to do the scutt work that was beneath their dignity.  If one lawyer is good, then 10 lawyers must be better.  And by hiring the firm, they get 10 or 20 or 100 lawyers, right?

Wrong.  More than likely, you get diffusion of responsibility since there is no one who takes ownership of every aspect of your case.  You have no idea of the quality of the underlying work, since you have no idea who is doing the work that is later presented to you by a the lawyer you thought you were hiring.  A chain is only as strong as the weakest link, so when some kid who is 12 minutes out of law school is doing document review (or worse yet, some kid from Bangalore), and misses a critical piece of evidence because he lacks the experience to appreciate why it’s critical or how it can be used a trial to rip your heart out, what are you going to do about it?

This post, stemming from a  New York Times lawyer dissatisfaction article, should give a clearer picture.

At the august Sullivan & Cromwell, partners in 2006 began a program, groundbreaking in white-shoe firms, encouraging the uttering of “thank you” and “good work” to harried underlings, as reported in The Wall Street Journal. Probably not a bad move at a firm that had been hemorrhaging associates at a rate of about 30 percent a year.

These are the people who give you a sense of solidity and confidence?  Do you really believe that law firms have some magic system in place that makes them safer and better than a solo practitioner, who personally reviews every piece of evidence involved because he knows that he’s going to be the guy who looks like a moron in front of the jury if he has carelessly overlooked the smoking gun? 

It’s not that there’s anything wrong, per se, with a criminal defense lawyer being a part of a law firm, aside from the potential client misapprehending that the reputation and solidity of the firm somehow translates into making some former AUSA who has never sat at the defense table in his life is somehow imbued with the competency to be an overnight criminal defense lawyer.  But don’t ask me what firm I’m with.  The fact that others have a hang-up about being part of some larger entity has nothing to do with my practicing law in the way that I believe best serves my clients.  If I were your lawyer, you would understand.

Update:  Within hours of posting, I received a call from a fellow who wanted my advice on who to hire as his lawyer.  He had already considered numerous lawyers, all of whom were “big names” from Biglaw.  His case, in his view, was big, and big cases demand big lawyers.  After he told me the two finalists in his lawyer lottery, I asked him whether he had considered certain other lawyers (not me, since he didn’t ask and I’m too shy to suggest it).  He made it clear to me that he wasn’t interested in any lawyer, no matter how good, who didn’t have a big law firm behind them because his case was very important and he wanted big firm “resources”.  What resources?  He couldn’t say, but he knew with absolute certainty that big was good, or else it wouldn’t be big.  Can’t argue with that logic, now can I?

This is a lesson that’s never learned until afterwards.  Make room, MCC.  There’s another one coming your way.

Banishment, The Perfect Solution

Ken Lammers, star of CLTV (and if rumors are true, may be in line for a seat on The View), has peaked under the skirt of Houston District Attorney Kelly Burke to find that over his 12 years in office, he’s been responsible for banishing 401 people. 

Banishment is back.  How long before drawing and quartering?  And our Supreme Court wastes its time with lethal injections when it could just go back to the variety of all-American punishments that our forefathers considered particularly effective.  Can you say Iron Maiden?

Putting my pointless snarkiness aside, banishment is really the perfect punishment.  No, really.  First, Burke is DA of Houston County, not the world.  His responsibility is to safeguard Houstonians (is that a word?), and by banishing miscreants for the county, he protects his constituents from future harm.  Sure, he shifts it a county or state away, but he wasn’t elected to protect them, now was he?

Better still, Burke accomplishes this basic function at no additional expense to the good people of Houston County.  It costs money to lock up these mutts.  A lot of money.  And then you need to feed them.  Every day.  It never ends.  It’s just money thrown into a big, black hole to keep these grinning criminals fat and happy.  And then there’s cable TV.  Where does it end?

It ends at the county line, that’s where it ends.  One ticket on the Greyhound and problem solved! 

But what about the other side?  Well, it’s not just a punishment, it’s an adventure.  If you’ve made a booboo in Houston, then you get to start over again elsewhere (where they don’t know you).  The relative palatability of a few years in the Texas Georgia (happy, Bennett?) can versus a fresh start in, say, Albuquerque is a no-brainer.  There are plenty of guys who could use a change of scenery, and would jump at the chance.

Banishment has a long tradition in the new world.  The Puritans loved it, to keep those darned Congregationalists from muddying up the gene pool.  It was good for lepers too.  For those in favor of originalism, there can’t be any complaints.

True, the only downside to banishment is that you’ve shift your problem to someone else, leaving the criminal to ply his trade on some unsuspecting Albuquerquian (is that a word?).  But hey, it’s no longer your problem, and isn’t criminal law all about what’s good for you?