Author Archives: SHG

Justice Revisited (A Good Thing To Do) (Updated to include Matlock)

Gideon at  A Public Defender posted a mini-rant about justice versus winning.  That got  Malum started, and he laid his cards on the table.  And as we all know, when Malum gets going, so too must  Norm Pattis and Stephen Gustitis.  Other than Bennett, who is in Paris (France, not Texas), it seemed like everybody has something to say.  Except me.  

It wasn’t that I was feeling left out, or that I had no thoughts on the subject.  It was that this was the subject of my  very first post at Simple Justice.  I generally hate repeating myself (if I can remember that I already did something), so I was reluctant to do another post of the issue of justice.  Instead, I figure that I’ll just repost the original, which may not have been on anybody’s radar at the time, as my coda to the blawgveration.

Justice is a Funny Thing

Most people come to a lawyer claiming that they want justice.  Do they?  They want to win their case.  They want to beat the rap.  But winning often has little to do with justice.  And that’s okay.  As a criminal defense lawyer, it’s my responsibility to represent you, not justice.  This point is lost on many clients.  More often than not, new potential clients will come to me with a story about their innocence.  Perhaps they are indeed innocent (it does happen), but perhaps they are not.  Or perhaps they are not as guilty as the police say, but not quite innocent either.

What a new client needs to appreciate is that I do not care whether they are innocent or not.  It has no impact whatsoever on my efforts on their behalf, even though they may find that hard to believe.  For the purpose of representing a client, I assume that everyone is guilty in order to remove that taint they feel and enable them to speak freely to me about what happened.  This is by far the most important thing they can do to aid me in preparing their defense.  As I frequently tell clients, I don’t want to be the only person in the room who has no clue what really happened.  If a client lies to me to minimize their guilt, they have taken away my most valuable weapon on their behalf:  knowledge.

I’m always straight with my clients.  As some will happily tell you, there are times when they would appreciate a little more sugar-coating and a little less honesty, though in the end they truly appreciate the fact that their decisions are based on a real appraisal of the situation rather than the old “don’t worry” approach, until (of course) it’s too late.  In return, I expect them to be straight with me.  It’s not much to ask, and ultimately empowers me to deal with the real situation rather than some pretend set of circumstances that helps neither you nor me.

Update:  Young Shawn Matlock, who was out sick, felt horrible about being left out of this discussion.  And so, he’s now posted his thought(s) on the subject.  Since I don’t want to be accused of cruelty to Republicans, I would be remiss if I didn’t update this post to include Young Shawn.  But I feel compelled to add that while Young Shawn says that I neglected to answer Gideon’s original question, whether we seek justice or victory, he is mistaken.  I’ve just done so in a subtle way, requiring my young friend to do something that Republicans are so rarely required to do:  Think.

The Ugly House Made Me Do It

Ironically, following my  calm and deliberate discussion of the sort of conduct of the people one can expect from those who choose to live is houses that are “really big and butt ugly,” the government has taken it one step further.  Following the slavery conviction of the Sabhanis (that would be the Muttontown Sabhanis), the government has not obtained a verdict of forfeiture for their Manse, per this Newsday story.

Why, you ask?  Is this some form of punishment on top of the long prison sentence that must surely be imposed?  No, Virginia, there is no Santa Claus.  You see, forfeiture is not punitive, so sayeth the Law.  It is merely because the house is the “instrumentality” of the crime, and as such, is forfeited to the King government.  Freeze, or I shoot you with the house.

Forfeiture is predicated on the legal fiction that the “res”, the “thing”, offends the sovereign.  So it isn’t a punishment of the person, even though we all know that it means that very important slaveowners who live in the house lose it, together with their investment in it, as if it were a few million dollar fine.  As you should be able to discern from my language, I am extremely ambivalent in this particular instance, but despite my feelings about what the Sabhanis were convicted of doing, still refuse to sanction forfeiture as a cure.

The logic of forfeiture is in its utter lack of reason.  By pretending that “things” can do wrong, we find a totally new way to punish people (who don’t exist in forfeitureland) without having to give them any of those nasty rights that would otherwise be required.  People have rights.  Things are just . . . things.  Like slaves, I guess.  Alright, I digress.

In this particular instance, the big, ugly house was not the instrumentality of slavery.  It’s just a house.  Big and ugly, but only a house.  Houses don’t cause people to be enslaved.  Houses don’t physically abuse women.  Houses are just houses. 

Punish the Sabhanis according to law, legitimate sentencing objectives and sound discretion.  It that includes a financial penalty, then impose it at the time of sentence.  If the payment of the financial penalty requires the Sabhanis to sell their house (not to mention whatever else they possess), so be it.  But don’t take the house because it is the “instrumentality of the crime,”  any more than the airplane that flew the women over to from Indonesia to Muttontown was the instrumentality of the crime, or the supermarket that sold the food that the women cooked for Varsha Sabhani was the instrumentality of the crime. 

Punishment is warranted. But be honest and call it what it is.  Stop hiding behind forfeitures to mask the punishment the government wants to inflict and circumvent the judge’s imposition of sentence. 

Junk Science: Try Arguing With a Dog

Robert Guest at  I was the State posts some important stuff on drug dogs.  Dog hits, as alerts by a drug-sniffing dog are called, make for some very interesting evidence at suppression hearings.  The significance is huge:  A dog reacts to something in your car (for example) on the side of a road and suddenly the police are free to rip it to shreds.  No, not just look around the interior, maybe the trunk.  But to pull the headliner out and the dash off, to ravage the trunk looking for “clavos”, secret compartments that can conceal drugs.

If you’ve got something in there, the dog hit gives the cops carte blanche to search for it.  If you don’t, you’re left with a car ripped to pieces on the side of the road with a stern warning by the highway patrol about how they will get you next time, as they drive away.  Try explaining that to the triple A.

But who can argue with a dog?  We’ve been indoctrinated to the belief that dogs have magical powers to smell things with such miraculous precision that it’s above question.  If a K-9 alerts, then it must be true.  Dogs are man’s best friend, right?  They can’t be wrong.  They certainly can’t be evil.  They would never do harm. 

As Guest points out, they are wrong.  A lot.  A certified drug dog need only be correct in his certification testing 50.01 percent of the time.  That leaves 49,99 percent of the time when he’s dead wrong.  It’s just a toss of the coin whether the dog alerts to something real, or nothing, or just reacts to a handler who wants the dog to find something.  After all, the dog gets doggy treats when he alerts.  And you get busted.  The dog definitely has the better end of the deal.

I spent a great deal of time learning about drug dogs during a highway drug case in federal court in Kentucky.  The certification process, the record-keeping, the false-positive alerts, are all critical to the determination of probable cause to invoke the automobile exception to the warrant requirement.  The problem is that while we, the defense lawyers, may educate ourselves as to the rigors and problems with our fine, furry friends, getting a judge to care is another matter.

People like dogs, and want to believe in their miraculous abilities.  Judges are people.  Judges like dogs, etc.  If they started looking too closely at the science behind the miraculous abilities of dogs, it would open a big can of worms that they really don’t want to deal with.  Would you want to be the judge who rules that dog-sniffing is junk science?  They might be cute and friendly, but they are not fool-proof by any stretch of the imagination?  Other than a few militant cat people, everyone would hate you.  Nobody wants to be that hated.

Feeding into this dog-loving junk science culture are lawyers who take for granted that dog sniffs are, indeed, infallible.  While it may be an uphill battle, we cannot sit idly by while our clients lose their constitutional right to be free from unreasonable searches because a dog said so.  While you may never get Fido to admit it on the stand, his handler can be crossed.  Demand the paper work that is required. 

Most lawyers don’t even know that there is paperwork that they are required to maintain in order to keep their certification, or even that they need to be officially certified.  The handler saying so doesn’t cut it.  He’s not the expert, and his representation that Fido is always right should be inadmissible.  Handlers handle, they do not certify.  Do you smell anything self-serving about the handler verifying Fido’s qualifications?

If you want a trusted friend, a warm companion, your own private lassie, get a dog.  If you want a scientifically verifiable method of determining the existence of narcotics in a particular location with a better than 50% likelihood of success, forget the dog.  No matter how warm and cuddly they are, dogs are not infallible.  Humans should not be put to task based upon the testimony of a dog.

The Listserv Crutch: Propping Up the Incompetent?

Carolyn Elefant has started  an interesting debate over at MyShingle about the use and abuse of lawyer listserves.  Before anyone rips my lungs out, I concede that my experience with listserves is limited, and that others will have their own experiences which may be completely different.  But since this is my post, I get to write about my experiences.  If you want to write about yours, feel free to comment below, or start your own friggin’ blawg.  But don’t tell me that my experiences are wrong because yours are different.

There are two very divided points of view about these techno-communities where lawyers can maintain a virtual conversation with a thousand of their closest colleagues.  Carolyn took the view that listserves offer a mechanism to improve the competency of the bar by seeking and obtaining help from a broad group of fellow lawyers, thus drawing on the great breadth of experience out there to improve one’s own knowledge base and to aid one’s clients.  So far, so good.

But a comment by attorney  Steve Lombardi raises the uglier downside to this otherwise rosey scenario. 


Lawyers are busy and no lawyer has the same experiences as any other lawyer. Younger, older, more trial experience, different life experiences, different success in the court room, some are better at talking with people and attract more clients, personal interests are different, IQ’s are higher or lower, some have a better work ethic, others are just plain lazy but want the same level of success as those who work hard. You don’t have to be the smartest lawyer to win a case, but you do have to work hard.

The lawyers I’m referring to who misuse the LISTSERV are lawyers with enough experience to know better. They are usually on their own, sole practitioners with a history of taking cases they have no business taking and who regularly settle cases without ever trying one. They advertise themselves as being trial lawyers but have very little trial experience. I once heard a skilled trial lawyer say, “Anyone can settle a million dollar case for one hundred thousand dollars.” Those are the lawyers I’m referring too.

While Steve’s criticism is directed at personal injury lawyers, it holds true for all.  Listserves don’t exist only for the competent lawyers, looking for that one tidbit of information that they were unable to locate after exhaustive research.  They exist for the lazy and incompetent as well, taking on cases that they are grossly unqualified to handle, and seeking a competent lawyer to show them the way so that they can keep the fee while hopefully providing a sufficient facade of competency to sneak past their client.

Some of the queries one sees on a listserv are shocking in their naivety.  Matters that could be easily discovered through minimal research are now put out for the quick and dirty answer of others.  Indeed, matters that any competent lawyer should already know are floated on listserves.  Regularly.  It is scary to think that these are lawyers entrusted to handle people’s lives when they don’t know the most basic aspects of their job.

Before listserves, we did something called research.  We did this because it was what lawyers did to find answers to questions.  We went to primary sources, read and read and read, and learned what we needed to know.  We would often seek out colleagues for their views, but it was never a substitute for doing our own work.  That’s what was expected of us by our clients.  That’s what we expected of ourselves. 

The listserv today has become, for many, a wholesale substitute for effort.  Why spend the time researching when you can type up a short email, put it out on the listserv, and enjoy the experience of others.  Why reinvent the wheel?  The answer is twofold.

First, because there is no assurance that the answers you receive on a listserv are correct.  A recurring theme from those who so dearly love listserves are answers that begin with, “I really don’t know anything about this, but . . .”  They then pontificate (often inaccurately) on a subject that they know nothing, and have admitted they know nothing, about.  Worse yet are the ones who don’t admit ignorance, but clearly are, based upon their responses.  Why post answers to questions when you have no clue what you’re writing about?  The love of posting, and the joy of being a laboring oar in the listserv community. 

Some more experienced lawyers post responses to stupid questions as a marketing tool.  If they create the appearance of expertise, maybe the ignorant will send them work when they get in over their heads.  I don’t know if this happens, since I don’t do it, but by marketing themselves in this fashion they enable incompetence and laziness.  It strikes me as a poor trade-off, enabling bad lawyers in the hope of a referral fee.

Others have argued that helping the incompetent on listserves is not to enable lazy or incompetent lawyers, but to help their poor clients who may have made a poor choice, but shouldn’t suffer imprisonment for it.  While this position has some superficial appeal, it strikes me as ultimately counterproductive.  This is a “give a man a fish” solution rather than a ‘teach a man to fish” one.  While it may help on a particular point, it still leaves the incompetent lawyer incompetent. 

There are many exceptionally good uses for listserves.  The dissemination of news, information about individuals that should be spread amongst the group and questions on sophisticated, nuanced issues of law after the basic research has been thoroughly completed.  But not as a crutch for the lazy or incompetent.

Steve Lombardi’s solution to the downside of listserves is better supervision of posting.  My experience is that everybody hates the listserv “school marm,” telling people what they should and should not post.  Regardless of what is done, there will always be a group to swarm all over the poor supervisor about how wrong they are.  Who needs this?  Everybody wants to be loved by the others on the listserv, or they just stay away altogether.  I don;t think supervision is viable unless its a paid, controlled listserv, and most are voluntary and association-related so that no one has the final authority.  Besides, telling lawyers what they can say amongst themselves is like herding cats.  With fangs.

The most potent force for control over listserves should be the knowledge that by asking stupid, lazy questions, a lawyer reveals to a very large group of his peers that he is a moron.  You would think that this would inhibit some from using the listserv as a primary research tool for people who should have never passed the bar exam.  Unfortunately, it hasn’t worked that way.  Quite the contrary, their true peers, the other lawyers enjoying the benefit of being lazy and incompetent, are busy empowering these types of questions by posting similarly brilliant responses like, “I don’t know nothing about birthin’ no babies, but . . .” 

So, defendants who are reading this, is your lawyer busy “researching” your case on some listserv?

Dueling Cameras: Fighting Fire with Video

In an op-ed in  Popular Mechanics (it makes perfect sense if you think about it), Glenn Reynolds of  Instapundit fame notes that it’s time to fight fire with fire.  Between law enforcement and business, almost every move we make, at least in public, ends up on someone’s videotape.  Why shouldn’t it be ours?

The first step in fixing a problem is to admit we have one.  Society has a privacy issue.  It doesn’t matter if you fall on the side of it being a blessing or a curse, because the ubiquitous surveillance cameras are already in place and rolling.  They have been for some time.  The Orwellian vision of 1984, where no word against the government could be uttered without detection, may have gotten the year wrong, but he was pretty darned close when it came to the concept.  As Glenn put it,


[T]he trend toward constant surveillance is troubling. And even if the public became concerned enough to pass laws limiting the practice, it’s not clear how well those laws would work. Government officials and private companies too often ignore privacy laws. (In a notorious recent case, Hewlett-Packard executives were caught spying on the phone records of reporters covering the company.) Besides, the technology of surveillance is becoming so advanced—biologists are now attaching tiny cameras to crows’ tail feathers to observe the birds’ tool use in the wild—that in reality there’s not much we can do to ensure privacy anyway.

So the problem isn’t that we are under constant surveillance anymore.  The horse left the barn long ago on that one.  The problem is that surveillance is under the other guy’s control.  Given the power and authority of a video, that puts an awful lot into the hands of institutions whose purpose is to assert its authority over people.  As we’ve posted here many times, whether in the  Utah taser video or the unlawful police searches or beatings caught on tape, sometimes the “good guys” do bad things and nobody is going to believe it happened without pictures.

How do we know it matters?  Primarily because of how the authorities don’t want us to do it.  Note the prosecutions of individuals who violated the Massachusetts wiretapping laws because they videotaped the police acting unlawfully.  Note the antagonism of police when mainstream media TV cameras capture them doing their “job”.  Cops like to watch.  They do not like to be watched. 


In the old days, ordinary people didn’t have much privacy, but neither did big shots. By contrast, today’s government officials and big corporations often want to watch us, but they don’t want to be watched in return. Shopping malls are full of security cameras, but many have signs at the entrance telling customers that no photography or video recording is allowed. Police cars have dashboard cameras, cities and counties are posting red-light and speed-limit cameras, and it seems that the dream of many government officials is to put every public space under 24-hour video watch. But try shooting photos or video of police or ­other public officials as they go about their business and you might find yourself in wrist restraints.

So it would be if we left it up to the cops.  But a string of cases that resulted in both the citizen prevailing and the cops and prosecutors getting their heads ripped off for trying to stifle and conceal misconduct have given us hope.  It’s not a done deal by any stretch, as shown by the fact that people are forced to defend themselves against this shocking impropriety, thus being put at risk as well as expense and trauma.  But the message is becoming clearer to police.  We are watching you too.


Under the law, citizens have no right not to be photographed in public places. So why should people who make their living on the taxpayers’ dime enjoy greater freedom from public scrutiny than the taxpayers themselves? Civil liberties groups have begun supporting the trend toward a video-enabled populace. The Eastern Missouri chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union sends out volunteers with cameras, though they have faced police hostility at times.

So this has become another conflict between the authority and the citizens who pay their wages and for whom they are given a gun and shield to serve.  So it doesn’t always work out the way we expect.  Surprise!

Glenn surmises that the cameras are more likely to exonerate police than capture them in wrongdoing.  I suppose this point is made to show that (1) police really are the good guys most of the time, and (2) police have no reason to fear being videotaped by citizens.  This is the “one bad apple” point of view, espoused by the silent majority since the Nixon days, and it misses the point.

We, meaning the common citizen, are entitled to expect law enforcement to obey the law, honor the Constitution and protect us, all the time.  It is not good enough that they do so most of the time.  It is not excusable that they only become the very danger that they are supposed to protect us from some of the time.  And as soon as our expectations of law enforcement are lowered to the point that we feel that 5%, or 10% or 25% of law-breaking by cops is acceptable, we have lost our moral imperative to protect and defend.

So get a little camera and keep it handy.  Think of it as our small way of helping to cleanse society of crime, no matter who commits it.

Sword Falling and Other Fun Lawyer Tricks

Q: Isn’t it true that you’re a lying liar who lied to your client, you liar?
A: Uh, no.

And so I envision Skelly’s cross-examination, when  subpoenaed to testify before a federal court on a habeas brought by a former client.  Skelly was unhappy about being called as a witness, and really hated receiving a subpoena.  But over time and enough clients, it’s bound to happen. 


A week from now, I’ll be on the witness stand answering questions about what I recall discussing or not discussing with a client of mine 5 1/2 years ago, prior to his entry of a guilty plea, and prior to his being maxed out by a judge known as Hang ‘Em Higher.

And so, with extreme trepidation, Skelly prepared himself for the inevitable.  Clearly, he wanted to get on and off the stand without saying anything to hurt his former client, but he was deeply concerned.

After the testimony was over, Skelly exhaled and let us know how it went.


My former client’s federal petition claimed that back in 2002, prior to his guilty plea, I told him that he did have a particular plea bargain, and that I lied when I told the trial judge that he did not. I testified that I did not tell him that he had a plea bargain. I testified that once he and I rejected the state’s first offer, there was no other plea bargain.

Note the accusation that he “lied”.  This would naturally put Skelly’s back to the wall, making it a Skelly versus defendant proposition.  It’s a tactical fiasco, but that’s why the defendant is in prison and desperate, while Skelly is a lawyer able to blawg about his experience.


Waiting and pacing most of the day before testifying, from the fifth floor I had a great view of my old church and the parochial school where I’d gone to CCD. [Ed. note: I’m not sure what this means either] I already was in a penitent frame of mind. However, I wasn’t willing to take counsel’s invitation to confess to something I hadn’t done.

Was counsel surprised that Skelly would confess to lying?  This presents a curious issue.  If the defendant was represented by counsel, why did counsel not communicate with Skelly, investigate what Skelly would say in advance and frame his questions so that Skelly could do as much as possible to help the defendant, rather than put Skelly into an untenable position.  Did the lawyer think that his forceful manner of interrogation would cause Skelly to breakdown on the stand, in a paroxysm of quivering and weeping convulsions, to admit his lying liar ways?

For those who have never had the pleasure of sitting in the chair next to a federal judge, it’s an experience.


What a curious experience, the hours of waiting simultaneously boring and stressful, then suddenly the courtroom door opens. It starts with swearing-in . . . your lawyer brain tries clearly and accurately to explain the who, what, when, why, and how, while it contains the growing urge of your reptile brain to swear at your cross-examiner. It was quite an education to be on the other end of such a cross examination, answering to the best of my recollection, summoning memories, keeping emotions at bay. I did not want to be there today.

Ultimately, Skelly vindicated himself well, telling the truth and doing his utmost not to harm his former client despite the peculiar approach of his current counsel.  It’s the best that one could do under the circumstances.  Still, he didn’t have any fun on the witness stand, and would likely prefer not to be there ever again.

Sued For Dying in New Jersey

One of those rare stories that is so ridiculous as to be more funny than tragic, despite the circumstances.  Kieran Crowley at the  New York Post (h/t Overlawyered) with the exclusive story about the New Jersey Authority suing the victims of a horrible auto accident for getting blood all over their asphalt.

The background is horrible.

The crash occurred after a tractor-trailer with bad brakes, carrying bricks and traveling at 70 mph, plowed into stalled traffic, smashing into a car driven by Theresa Christmas, 41.  Christmas was killed, as was her husband, Charles, 40, and daughter Victoria, 2, sources said. Another daughter, baby Theresa, survived the crash.  The truck then hit a car driven by Norma Ryan, 37, who also was killed.

No matter how hard I strain, I can find no liability on the part of the two families slaughtered by the brick truck.  But when it comes to protecting the New Jersey Turnpike, there’s no need for liability.

The negligence suit, filed by lawyer William B. Ziff on behalf of the New Jersey Turnpike Authority, demanded money from both the Ryan and Christmas families, who lost relatives – including a toddler.

Talk about a toll road.  But is there a happy ending to this shocker?  “After The Post called about the lawsuit, Ziff rushed out to Union County Superior Court and canceled it.”

“It should not have happened,” said NJTA spokesman Joe Orlando. “It was a clerical error. We would like to apologize to the family.”

Could the claim that this was “a clerical error” be just a wee bit disingenuous?  A lawyer for the Turnpike Authority had to draft the papers.  This means that someone had to exert a modicum of thought as to who to sue and why.  It then had to be reduced to writing.  It then had to be approved by someone’s supervisor.  It then had to be served and filed.  A clerical error?  Not likely.  But spokesman Joe is right about one thing, it should not have happened.

Notably, had Kieran Crowley not picked up on this lawsuit, you have to wonder how far down the road of “clerical errors” this would have gone before some judge (hopefully) tossed it.  The minute the Turnpike Authority realized that the media caught on to their scam, they “canceled” it and apologized.  So if Kieran hadn’t called, would there be another clerical error involving 5 hours of depositions?

Just so you know, Kieran Crowley is a good guy.  He did a book about  one of my cases a while back, and I got to know him very well.  Don’t let the fact that he works for the New York Post fool you. 

The View Of North Shore Slavery

It’s hard to imagine what happens inside those  big, ugly McMansions that mar the once-tree lined street of Long Island’s North Shore.  The very existence of these pseudo-palaces reveals much about the mindset of their inhabitants.  Like a child screaming “look at me,” they emit the stink of pathetic neediness for self-importance.

With  the convictions of Mahender Murlidhar Sabhnani, 51, and his wife, Varsha Mahender Sabhnani, 45, we got a view into one such “mansion”, as the  always-reliable newspapers like to call it, in Muttontown, New York.  The litany of horrors that the Sabhanis inflicted on two Indonesian women are bad.  Not the sort of thing that people from Muttontown are supposed to do.  Or people from anywhere else, for that matter.  If you need the details, read the Newsday story.

The Sabhani’s ran a perfume company out of their home, where (if the reports are to be believed), they made many millions.  “You too can smell like the Sabhanis” must be an alluring marketing tool.  I have no idea what scent they sold or why anyone bought it, but apparently they did.

But that wasn’t enough for the Sabhanis  They had their showplace to let all their friends know how important they had become, but that wasn’t good enough.  They needed women to serve them, absolutely and without question.  A King and Queen must have obedient servants.  Not just people who do the dirty chores that important people would never do for themselves, but to do so with total obedience.

Varsha Sabhani came from Indonesia.  So did her slaves.  First one was brought in illegally in 2002, and then, when one was not enough to care for her every need, another in 2005.  It surprised me that Varsha would seek her own people to serve as her slaves, since people tend to always have some other nationality that they prefer to demean in order to elevate themselves.  Varsha certainly appears to be the type who needed to feel elevated above others, so one would have suspected that she would pick women from whoever Indonesians are prejudiced against.  Perhaps Indonesians have no such group to look down upon.  Perhaps using women of her own nationality elevated Varsha higher than some “lesser” people would. 

There was little about this case that made complete sense.  The prosecution’s position, that this was some throwback to the 1800s of slavery in America, certainly didn’t cover the Sabhani’s situation.  They would never have been here back then, or if so, would have been enslaved themselves.  We weren’t the most tolerant people of “lesser” cultures back then.

The defense made even less sense, attributing the thought processes, actions and mindsets of modern day Americans onto these enslaved women, as if they were slaves by personal choice since they could have chosen to be anything they wanted by merely escaping captivity.  Obviously, the “slaved by choice” defense didn’t fly.

But most curious is the sensibility of the sort of folks who inhabit these palaces.  They may have the money to buy or build them, but they have not yet raised their consciousness to the level necessary to handle the life they can afford for themselves.  While I have castigated them as monuments to bad taste, bad taste is the least of the problems with the Sabhanis.  They couldn’t handle their life with the ease and grace that is supposed to come with a life of wealth.  And so, they bought far more than they could handle, including two women who would be their slaves.  Their bad taste was a compliment to their bad souls. 

Is this a cautionary tale for people who one day find themselves unprepared to handle a life of wealth?  Perhaps, though I doubt that too many people, no matter how unprepared they are to deal with too much money, would do harm to other human beings.  But it does suggest that these massive houses are merely the outside indicators of people who cannot handle their success, and their inability to fill the shoes they can now afford to buy is something that we can all see as we pass by.

Victims on Trial: The Everyday Business of Courts

By Jeffrey A. Tucker
Originally published at  mises.org for the Ludwig von Mises Institute and
posted here with permission. (This takes place in beautiful Auburn, Alabama)

JustitiaIt is inherently implausible, if you think about it, that the state could be an effective administrator of justice, for which there is a supply and demand like any other good. Shortages, inefficiencies, arbitrariness, and high costs will be main features of such a system. And because we are dealing here with the meting out of coercion, we can add the presence of inhumane treatment and outright cruelty.  


Even so, nothing had prepared me for what I witnessed in the courtroom the other day. Like a fool, I thought I might be able to beat a traffic ticket I received a block from my home. The policeman says I slowed almost to a stop rather than completely stopping at a three-way stop where there were no cars in any case. So my prize was a ticket.


The officer assures me that I’m not declaring guilt, but I have to sign this form anyway. I can challenge it on my court date. So, again foolishly, I decide not to go the route of everyone else — admit guilt and cough up — but instead to exercise my citizen’s right to make a challenge.  


I show up at court. Except that on my appointed date, the judge wasn’t there. Why? They wouldn’t say. Is he sleeping in? No. Taking a family vacation? Outrageous that I should even ask! OK, then, how about I see the substitute judge? There is no such thing. But if I hadn’t shown up I would go to jail for “failure to appear.” How is it that he can fail to show up and everyone acts like this is normal? The clerk rolled her eyes.


Silly me. This is the state. Different rules apply to it as versus me. So I am given a new court day, 6 weeks later.


I show up again, and tell the clerk that I plan to say that I am not guilty. This moved my papers to the bottom of the stack, which is a very bad omen. I would end up sitting in the court room all morning, listening to some 40 cases of people who are not so foolish as to protest the judgment of the officer of the law.


But then again, it wasn’t so bad. I got an education. It turns out that in a courtroom packed with purported criminals, not even one of the people who appeared before the judge was a danger to society. Nearly all were in for victimless crimes. The two who had perpetrated actual crimes — petty theft from Wal-Mart and the local mall — could have easily been dealt with without involving the state. So far as I could tell, the place could have been emptied out completely and our little community would have been no worse off, and massive human suffering could have been avoided.


But that’s not the way it works. These people, overwhelmingly black and poor but dressed very nicely in the hope of impressing the master, found themselves entangled in the web and thereby elicited the glare and killer instinct of the spider. How painful it was to watch and not be able to do anything about it.


The first case turned out to be typical. This was a person picked up for “public intoxication,” which amounted to overcelebrating following a football victory and daring to walk on the government’s sidewalks under the influence of one too many. Arrested, jailed, bailed out. Now was the time to face the judge.


What is your plea? Guilty, your honor.


What do you have to say for yourself? I’m so sorry that I did this and I won’t do it again.


The judge then decides to be lenient. He gives the minimum fine plus court costs. I couldn’t find any consistency in this pricing scheme, but generally it amounted to between $400 and $1,500. The judge asks the person to pay it now. When he says that he doesn’t have the money, the judge considers a payment plan, contingent on the guilty declaring his income to the courtroom; it averages $400 per month.


How about you pay $100 per month? Fine.


Oh, and there’s one more thing. The criminal’s driver’s license is suspended for six months. How can he get to work? That’s his problem. It is a very special problem since the court has decided to loot the person of a quarter of his income during this very period. How can you keep your job? Hard to say. Life is tough. And that’s the price you pay for drinking a few beers and daring to walk on the sidewalk.


So on it went for person after person. Tragedy all around. Pointless suffering. There were other victimless crimes. There were a few people who smoked pot — and one who carried a joint clip or some other drug paraphernalia in his car. There was a person who made a “false report,” which seems to be lying to the policeman. He was dragged off to jail on the spot.


Another victimless crime of which these people tended to run afoul: “resisting arrest.” I’d never thought about this charge much, since it is a rather stupid thing to be disobedient to the police. Still, we must ask questions. To protect oneself from danger, threat, and capture is the most basic of all human instincts. We resist criminals. We duck when someone tries to hit us. Maybe we fight back if we think we can win. We lock our doors to deter invasion to protect our property and person. The right to resist being captured is the very of the idea of security.


Why is it that we are expected to utterly gut our instinct for self protection when the cops, for any reason they happen to manufacture on the spot, say we must? It doesn’t matter if we are guilty or innocent, whether the cop is wonderful and wholly corrupt, or whether the crime was tiny or big: we must immediately turn into human rag dolls and obey our masters. And if we do not, and instead we walk away or run, we can be tasered and shot unto death. (The highly disturbing video of the Utah cop tasering the fellow who didn’t want to sign a ticket provides fundamental insight here)


Think what it means to criminalize what they call resistence. It means what we believe to be our rights and our freedom are really grants of privilege by the state and they can be instantly revoked on the whim of anyone with a badge. These poor souls in the courtroom were all under the illusion that they were free agents; they therefore ran and resisted when confronted with danger to themselves. Now they are learning otherwise.


But what about the actual crimes in the courtroom that day? A lady had stuffed a package of sliced ham or something into her purse while shopping at Wal-Mart. She was fined $800 and had her license taken away.


What do you have to say for yourself, asked the judge. “I’m very sorry. I need to find other ways to deal with my lack of money,” she answered.


Yes, you do, because “we will not tolerate theft in this town,” unless, he might have added, it is done by the judge under the cover of the law.


Oh, one more thing. This lady was banned from Wal-Mart for life. Now, this sounds extreme, but it was the only decision taken that day that had the feel of something potentially reasonable. Might Wal-Mart have handed down this penalty itself? Isn’t this a good principle, keeping the thieves away from its store? Makes sense, perhaps not for a lifetime but perhaps for a year or two.


But there is one problem. Wal-Mart can’t do that. Its shopping space is considered under federal law to be a “public space,” even though it is entirely privately owned. You can’t decide who you are going to let in or out so long as you charge no membership fee. You have to accept all comers. Only the state can ban people from public property. And so Wal-Mart must use the state’s services. It is coerced like everyone else. A compassionate and reasonable private solution is against the law.


But keep in mind that this was a case of theft. The others, they had done no harm to anyone.


The machine continued to operate. The judge hardly looked up, not even to notice how well these nice but exceedingly poor people dressed in an attempt to impress him. They and their lives meant nothing. It was all about keeping the machine working.


Finally 11 AM rolls around. The court had already raised for itself some $20,000, from my calculation. The judge says that there will be a short recess before he hears the not-guilty cases, mine among them. He will then assign public defenders to those whose income is low enough and then schedule jury hearings.


In other words, I would have to wait and then return at some later date. I realized that there was more involved in beating tickets than I knew. I would need to make it my vocation — and perhaps not prevail.


My kids, who came with me, persuaded me that this was hopeless and ridiculous and very costly. I should declare my guilt and pay the $200 and be free. They didn’t want their dad entangled anymore in this system. This is what I did, and I was free to go and join the multitudes who put up with this system of blackmail and money extraction every hour and know better than to attempt to use the system to challenge it.


Most people in my position would have never gone to court, and they will never seen just how cruel this system is for the poor, for minorities, and for everyone who get tangles up in this web of coercion and legalized plunder.


But now I understand something more fully that I once only understood abstractly. I see how utterly ridiculous it is to think that the state can be the right means to help those who are poor or living at the margins of society. The state is their enemy, as it is for everyone else.




Jeffrey Tucker is editor of Mises.org.

The Citizen Journalist or Irresponsible Blogger

Windypundit brings us an interesting attack and counter-attack on the subject of our “right” as citizens to blog.  What are we, us bloggers, in the grand scheme of things?  There is one thing we clearly are not, and that is “professional journalists.”  The reason, however, is not what you would think.

We cannot be professional journalists, according to Kipesqurie, because there is no such thing.  Journalism is not, despite protests to the contrary, a profession.  Kip states quite convincing reasons for this conclusion, and if you feel compelled to follow a reasonable definition of “profession”, then you will have to agree.

But this arises in the context of some  journalism prof arguing that bloggers, derisively called “citizen journalists” so that no one would ever mistake us for, say, Adam Liptak.  This prof, David Hazinski, says:


Supporters of “citizen journalism” argue it provides independent, accurate, reliable information that the traditional media don’t provide. While it has its place, the reality is it really isn’t journalism at all, and it opens up information flow to the strong probability of fraud and abuse. The news industry should find some way to monitor and regulate this new trend.

It’s not enough that a lawyer could lose his license for being discourteous to a judge, but now the “news industry” wants its piece of the action so that it can “monitor and regulate” us?  Because bloggers are so prone to”fraud and abuse,” that we wreak havoc by deceiving the public.  To take his straw man argument even further, Hazinski writes:


This is like saying someone who carries a scalpel is a “citizen surgeon” or someone who can read a law book is a “citizen lawyer.”

 Oh sure.  Perfect comparison, since posting on this blawg bears striking similarities to open heart surgery.  But let us not castigage the poor prof for one incredible stupid sentence, and let us instead castigate him for the full breadth of his absurdity. 

The idea of a “professional journalist,” as the good professor would call it, or the “occupational journalist” as Kip more appropriately characterizes it, is based upon the occurence of two things:  Some pays someone else to write something, and then it gets published somewhere.  While journalists would like to believe that they function under a code of ethics, do they lose their journalism license when the violate it?  Is something turns out to be false, can they be sued for malpractice?  While there are some fine journalism schools in the country, do all journalists have specialized degrees?

The answer to all of the above is obviously “no”.   We read papers and listen to the news because we want to be well informed.  We believe that the information they provide is reasonably accurate because all the other media outlets will make fun of them if they mess it up.  We know that some are better than others, and that some have biases that others do not. 

So what is the problem with blogging?  We have no editor to proof our stuff before it goes out?  We do it for free?  We might be wrong?  Then I guess we have more in common with journalists than I thought.  Except, we don’t promote our own for-profit entertainment programming as if it were hard news. 

If some news organization somewhere wants to have a say in what I post, they are more than welcome to do so.  Just let me know where to send the bill.