Author Archives: SHG

No Fame. None At All

Every once in a while, there are a spate of seemingly inexplicable mass killings by troubled people.  It’s hard to understand what compels a human being to behave this way, but our lack of understanding doesn’t change the fact that they do. 

The victims of these sick people are truly, wholly innocent.  Men and women just walking around, minding their own business.  There is no relationship whatsoever between whatever is going on the troubled person’s mind and these poor victims.  They just have the great misfortune of being there at the wrong moment.

The mall killings in Omaha, however, gives me pause to think.  The killer left a note behind that said, I’m a piece of (deleted) and now I’m going to be famous.   My thought is that this fellow, whose name is irrelevant, might have committed suicide because of his feelings of worthlessness.  This would have been very sad, but far, far better than what he did by killing others.  The detail that drove him to go to the mall and kill people instead of hanging himself in the bathroom was the lure of fame.  He would be famous.  Sure, it’s a twisted perspective, but what other type of person goes around killing people?

So here’s my point:  Why do we need to make a poor, sad, twisted person famous?  There is absolutely no public benefit from learning the identity of such a person.  It is at best a tidbit of salacious news that adds nothing to public discourse or understanding.  While we can learn much from their histories that led them to take such horrific actions, the actual name means nothing.

So, I propose that the media, as a matter of journalistic responsibility and free choice, make the decision to never against disclose the name of a person who massacres others and then either commits suicide or is otherwise killed.  

There is precedent for such nondisclosure, as the media already generally refuses to publish the identities of rape “victims”,  notwithstanding the idea that they aren’t “victims” until after a crime has been proven to occur.  Indeed, the publication of the names of criminal defendants flies in the face of the constitutional presumption of innocence, and yet the media conceals this one class of alleged victim.  Having chosen that path, the notion that they never disclose the identity of a mall shooter is hardly a stretch.

Would this change have altered the deaths of innocent true victims in Omaha?  Or perhaps have avoided a Columbine?  It’s impossible to say.  But since there is no loss to society by the nondisclosure of the perpetrators names, and it seems that the “fame” that they believe comes from going out in a blaze of “glory” in their otherwise terribly sick and disturbed lives, the potential that it would dissuade someone from committing his own suicide by taking the lives of others seems worth the chance.

If only one massacre is stopped by such an inconsequential change in media approach, it would be worth it.  Think about it.

Trial Men versus Law Men

My first job in law school was with an old school criminal defense lawyer, Milton Rosenberg.  Milt was old then, and showed a baby like me the ropes.  He was a “Trial Man.”  That’s how criminal defense lawyers were broken down, there were trial men and law men. 

Trial men were the gladiators, the gunslingers.  They were Perry Mason or Judd for the Defense.  They were the guys people thought of when they thought of criminal defense lawyers.  It was the sexy job, though there was little sexy about Milton.  Still, as he explained to me on day 1, he was a trial man.

Milt’s knowledge of the law was nearly zero.  He couldn’t be bothered.  It wasn’t what trial men did.  He stood up in front the jury and did his thing.  He schmoozed the judge, who he also assumed knew nothing whatsoever about the law, and charmed the jury.  While he wasn’t sexy, he could be quite charming.  And he was afraid of no one.  He had an ego that couldn’t be beat, and was fearless striding into a courtroom where he believed he knew everything that could be known.  That just didn’t include the law.

Because I was a kid, and because I was working for Milt, I was denominated a law man.  It was my job to tell Milt anything about the law he needed to know at any given moment.  For my $3.25 an hour, I had to know the law and know when to whisper in his ear so he would look like he knew the law.  More importantly, I would write the motions and appellate briefs, because trial men didn’t do stuff like that and somebody had to.  That was a job for law men.

Young Shawn Matlock bemoans the fact that trial lawyers don’t do appeals.  Nobody talks about trial men and law men anymore, but I guess the distinction way back then still has some vitality today.  When I made the switch from law man to trial man after leaving Milt’s employ, I never lost my thirst for knowing about the law.  I never understood how one could be an effective trial lawyer without knowing the law better than anyone else in the courtroom. 

Trials raised a million legal details where a firm knowledge of substantive law enables you to identify issues and address them, cogently and effectively.  There’s no time to stop the proceedings to research an arcane issue.  More importantly, there’s no time to stop and think when argument or testimony is moving forward at the speed of sound.  You either jump in and make your point or the opportunity is lost.

Lawyers today don’t walk around proclaiming their ignorance of the law like a badge of honor.  Milt did, but Milt is long gone.  He’s a real dinosaur of the law.  I can only think of one old time lawyer still practicing that fits that mold, the famous “Don’t Worry” Murray Richmond of the Bronx.  I love Murray.  But the only thing he’s put to paper in the entire time I’ve known him are numbers on a deposit slip.  If you want someone to charm the pants off a jury or schmooze a judge, there is nobody better than Murray.  But don’t ask him law.

My bet is that Shawn’s observation that today’s trial lawyers don’t do appeals is accurate, but not because of the same rationalization.  The reasons are the same, but the excuse is different.  The skills needed to do trials are very different than the skills needed to do appeals.  The former requires an ability to analyze and act at lightning speed.  The primary focus is on people, not law.  Trial lawyers persuade juries, and the ability to persuade is the ability to understand people.  Trial lawyers examine witnesses, and the ability to formulate and reformulate questions in a constant frenzy, all while standing before an audience whose views matter most, is critical.  These are the skills one needs to try cases.

Appellate lawyers are deliberate.  They work in private, researching caselaw meticulously and expressing arguments through the written word.  They agonize over every sentence, over every word.  A good brief has no extra words.  Every word serves a purpose.  They formulate and reformulate sentences to best convey their argument and its support.  They can see the gaps in their points, and know that some appellate judge’s clerks will see than as well.  There is no schmoozing in an appellate brief.  It is cold, hard and, if poorly conceived, exposed for all the world to see the flaws in the lawyer’s thinking or skills. 

The trial man can talk his way through his blunders.  The mind has an amazing ability to skip over logical gaps and inferential leaps, and before one has a chance to ponder the error of a position, it is busy processing the next point and is left with only an impression of whether the lawyer was right or wrong.  There’s no time for parsing words. 

The law man suffers from lengthy scrutiny.  His words stare back at him, and he cannot hide from the flaws of an argument.  There is no talking one’s way past a bad point on appeal, no diversionary tactic that will get the court to overlook the lack of support from precedent or a logical gap in a critical argument.  In appeals, there’s no place to hide and no one to charm.

Young Shawn’s observations are correct.  Few lawyers do both trial and appeals, and few still do both well.  For me, the opportunity to do both trials and appeals is like a vacation, where I get to enjoy doing a totally different job for a while.  It’s a break from the tedium of doing the same thing day after day.  But then, I like to write, as may be obvious, and I particularly love to write appellate briefs.  They are the purest form of legal writing, and they provide an opportunity test one’s logical thinking as well as the edges of the law.  Inside this trial man is a law man dying to express himself.

But the fact that so many trial lawyers don’t do appeals is hardly a bad thing.  Every appellate lawyer sees lawyers stand before the appeals court and get trounced because they don’t have the chops.  It can get really ugly watching five judges rip some smarmy lawyer’s head off for trying to BS his way through oral argument, or presenting a brief written in crayon. 

It’s always best to work toward one’s strengths.  Most people don’t have a clue what their strengths are, and misconstrue success in one small niche with generalized genius.  They can’t begin to figure out why they fall on their face when going outside their little box.  So it’s true that many trial lawyers are smart to stay clear of appeals, even if only because they don’t have the patience or skill to write.  Taking on appeals when they don’t have the skill does not help their client, and they are right to keep far away and leave it to others who are more inclined toward written expression.

Don’t be so harsh on these guys, Young Shawn.  They may be wrong to not develop their “law man” skills, and they may not be helping their clients by pretending to be trial men while lacking the needed “law” piece, but at least they have the good sense to keep their skill-less butts out of an appellate courtroom where they could do some real harm, both to their client and to the state of the law.  Be thankful for little things.

Lied to By A Gecko

The automobile insurance renewal policy arrived yesterday from Geico, or what used to be known as Government Employees Insurance Company before they went Hollywood and threw the doors open to the flotsam of insurance, including criminal defense lawyers.

My last renewal showed a $10 decrease in the premium.  Not much, you may say, but better than an increase.  This time, however, it was not such good news.  The premium went up.  In fact, it went up a lot.  Now I have a few cars, but only one vehicle accounted for the increase.  A 2006 Toyota Prius.  That’s right, we’re green.  So sue me.  I’m a tree hugger, and my wife is ten times the tree hugger I am.  This is the car she chose.

So I called the Gecko.  You know the Gecko, the one who shows up on TV all the time talking about low prices and getting scones with jam over the phone.  I wanted to talk about low prices too, so it seemed the only thing to do.

A lovely young lady answer the phone right away, named Nicole.  When I asked her why, she diligently put me on hold to find out.  After about 10 minutes, she returned with an answer:  The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety made them.  It immediately occurred to me that she misunderstood whoever she got the information from, since nobody could “make” Geico charge more, so I sought to clarify. 

Nicole explained to me that the IIHS found out something about the Prius, she didn’t know what, but it made them change their rating on the car and forced Geico to significantly increase their premium.  She assured me that it was nothing about us that caused the increase.  It wasn’t our fault.  It was the IIHS.  Bad IIHS, but there was nothing they could do.

Naturally, this news caused me great concern.  The  IIHS ratings for the Prius were pretty good, and it was one of the things that makes me feel comfortable knowing that my tree-hugging wife is driving around in one all day long.  So I asked Nicole what had changed to make my Prius a threat to life and limb.  She told me I would have to call the IIHS to find out. 

Now, I get funny when the people who I pay money to tell me what I have to do.  So I asked Nicole who at Geico would know what was wrong with the Prius that would compel them to increase the premium.  She told me no one at Geico would know that, and I would have to call the IIHS (with that tone that suggests that I must be an idiot since she already told me to call them). 

Figuring that poor Nicole was being pushed into an area where she probably was over her head, I asked her who else was there who might know more about this.  She told me to hold, and a few minutes later, her supervisor, Josh, came on the phone.  Now Nicole sounded about 18 years old.  Josh sounded like her much younger brother.  I pictured him with braces and freckles, hoping for the day that he would meet a girl from whom he could steal a kiss. 

While I was on hold, I checked the IIHS website and found that there have been  no changes in ratings for the Prius.  The same was true with the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.  So now I knew that whatever they were telling the children at Customer Service to tell their customers, it wasn’t true.  The Gecko was lying to me.

I put the same question to Josh that I had to Nicole, even though I now knew a little more than I did before.  Josh explained to me slowly that Nicole had already given me the answer.  If I want to know why my premium increased, I would have to call the IIHS.  I explained to Josh, just as slowly but using smaller words, that he did realize that I don’t have to insure my cars with Geico, and if Geico couldn’t explain to me why it was increasing my premiums, I would question why I did.  Josh was dumbfounded.  I suppose that no one had ever told him that we had no obligation to use the company that paid him biweekly, ever since he left his old job at the Dairy Queen.

Josh told me that he didn’t know what to say.  He guessed that if I didn’t want to pay more, then I could always change my insurance company.  So I asked him point blank whether Geico would prefer I change or tell me why they wanted to charge me more.  He started to mumble Insurance Institute, but then trailed off.  Then he said, “that’s what it costs.  If you don’t like it, you can leave.”  Finally, an honest answer.

It’s been my experience that automobile insurance companies give you some very decent rates when you first sign up with them.  Once they think they have you, things change.  So whether you think the Gecko is cute, or prefer the caveman, Geico is just like every other automobile insurance company, and poor Nicole and Josh were forced to answer another pain in the butt insured (me) who expected them to provide truthful answers.  Eventually, Josh did.  The answer was that Geico is every bit as much a business as any other, and I can either pay whatever they demand or find a new insurer.  I wonder how much the next company will save me?

Busted on Mars? Call Me and I’ll Set You Free

Portfolio’s take on Cuomo the Younger’s appeal of the enjoined new NY lawyer advertising rules, getting the boot from the suit by Public Citizen, is that the guy’s just got no sense of humor.

The attorney general’s brief describes the Alexander & Catalano advertising campaign as “frequently embellished with exaggerated images of the firm’s attorneys as giants towering over local buildings, running to assist clients so fast that they appear as a blur, and counseling space aliens on insurance claims.”

Clearly not as funny or deft as Geico’s gecko. But it’s a shot. Some of us might like to see the Skaddens in our midst lighten up a bit, and try this sort of thing. Not Cuomo.

Because the AG thinks counseling space aliens is misleading?  Well, it is.  Definitely.  And maybe it isn’t even as funny as it sounds, though I haven’t seen the commercial.  But that’s not the point.

I agree with Andrew Cuomo 100% that puffery and hyperbole, particularly in promising or suggesting the ability to get particular results, is an evil that has to be quashed.  But does he have to suck the fun out of it?

I can imagine nothing worse than totally serious lawyer ads.  If there is anything that would take the profession’s already spotty reputation and reduce us to the singular most boring people on the face of the earth, it would be lawyer ads as the AG envisions them.

Take a look at my favorite lawyer ad on the sidebar (that’s the column on the left).  Can you tell me that you aren’t laughing as you watch it.  It is hysterical.  Effective?  No, but it would be a lot more fun to see that on the telly than what Andy has in mind.  


[The Supreme Court] has never held that puffery, dramatizations, unverifiable statements of opinion, slogans, or promises, absurd portrayals, extreme use of humor, appeals to emotions, fears or prejudices, special effects, nicknames or other techniques in attorney advertising unrelated to rational decisions about selection of counsel are protected commercial speech,” the attorney general said in his brief.

Mario Cuomo wasn’t a very funny guy.  Clearly, the apple didn’t fall far from the tree.  There is a wide spectrum of possibilities in advertising, ranging from the “Skadden” concept (serious people saying serious stuff) to the Used Car method of  this fellow (which, in my opinion, reflects about the worst deceptive garbage advertising around, though I bet that someone else has something that will trump it).  

I’m with Cuomo that letting lawyer advertising go free market would be a disaster.  There are way too many scoundrels and liars, and they put honest lawyers at significant disadvantage since we won’t guarantee results or lie to steal money.  For any marketing lover who thinks that this is a solution without a problem, you’re way off base.  The problem exists and it’s pretty bad.  But that doesn’t mean the we need a scorched earth solution.  Everything isn’t always black and white.

So does Cuomo really have to try to suck all the fun out of it?  Must lawyers, as a matter of law, be the most boring, humorless people on the face of the earth?  Must we really prove to the public that we are what they think we are?  Wit and humor are not the evils demanding a solution.  Deception and puffery is the problem, so deal with the problem.  In a battle of wits, would you want your lawyer to be unarmed?

Ironically, Andy Cuomo’s position as Attorney General flies in the face of his efforts at advertising his skilled legal services for the years that he practiced privately.   No, wait a second.  That’s right.  Andy Cuomo never has his own law firm, where he had to get clients to earn a living.  He never had to wait for a new case to come in, or a case to settle, to get paid.  He has always been on the government dole, always had a paycheck show up on Friday.  And this is the guy who thinks he understands how regular lawyers get to advertise.

Andy, lighten up.  A little humor won’t kill you, and will certainly do wonders for the profession.  And trust me, no one is going to be misled that I have any special “in” when it comes to cases on Mars.  Of course, I used to be a prosecutor there and I do know the judge . . .  Hey, at least I didn’t use a gecko.

CIA Videotapes Destroyed: Let’s Put On A Play!

As the  news spread yesterday that the CIA destroyed 2 videotapes of “severe investigation techniques,” there was anger and outrage across the board.  Even the CIA’s own lawyer was unaware of it having happened, and Harriet Meiers, the Bush administration’s version of Monica Lewinsky, advised against it. 

Rarely does one find everybody in Washington on the same side of any issue, except for the Director of Videotape Destruction, Jose A. Rodriguez, Jr., and he wouldn’t comment.  So, what do the very important people that run our government plan to do about the fact that they are totally incapable of controlling the CIA?  They want to put on a play!

For those of you who don’t catch the reference, it’s from the “Our Gang” shows with the Little Rascals.  Whenever things got out of control (which was every episode, or else nobody would watch), their answer was to “put on a play.” 

So what does official Washington plan to do about this attack by the CIA on the sovereignty of the United States of America?  Representative Peter Hoekstra, the Michigan Republican who was chairman of the House Intelligence Committee from 2004 to 2006, when the tapes were destroyed, came up with this solution:


I think the intelligence committee needs to get all over this,” said Mr. Hoekstra, who has been a strong supporter of the C.I.A. detention and interrogation program. “This raises a red flag that needs to be looked at.”

Can you feel the palpable outrage in those harsh words, “needs to be looked at?”  But that’s not the end of it  Not by a long shot. 


The Senate Intelligence Committee announced Friday that it was starting an investigation into the destruction of the videotapes.  Senator John D. Rockefeller IV, the West Virginia Democrat who is chairman of the committee, said, “Whatever the intent, we must get to the bottom of it.”

Get to the bottom of what?  The CIA does not exist independently of the United States government.  It has no authority, under any circumstances, to do whatever the hell it pleases and spit in the face of the government that authorizes its existence, funds it and (is supposed) to oversee it.  The government gives the CIA a lot of power to do a lot of stuff “in the national interest” that would make your hair curl or your chest swell with pride, according to your personal political views.  But the one thing the CIA cannot do is act in direct conflict with the very government that legitimizes its existence. 

We learned something very important from this disclosure:  The CIA thinks it exists on its own, and can do as it pleases, without any of those silly suits in Washington having anything to say about it.  The CIA told Republican  Hoekstra and Democrat Rockefeller to take a hike. 

So here’s my problem:  Once you find out that a bunch of men and women who constitute a covert paramilitary force decide that they are no longer subject to the constraints of the government, and in fact operate any damn way they please, what do you do about?  What a pathetic reaction. 

Norm posts that we need to have a special prosecutor.  That Norm, what an idealist.  The idea of a special prosecutor would be great if there was a reason to believe that the CIA cared about what anyone else in government has to say.  So, they will hang out Rodriguez as the bad guy, hand over his head and all is well in the world again.  The CIA can go about its business in the shadows, and we can sleep secure in the knowledge that our system of government, which may not be perfect, has vindicated itself.  Sure.  We’ve righted the ship of state.  The CIA has bowed its head in shame and sworn to never again be a bad bunch of boys and girls.  Right.

Do we now have a new ruling junta in town, because clearly neither the executive nor the legislative branches of our government have any control over the CIA.  And if they don’t, do you think the CIA cares deeply about what the courts have to say? 

The Crime of Juror Honesty in the First Degree

Gideon brings the  story of an Illinois juror (where’s our Chicago maven,  Windy, on this one?) who belatedly let’s the cat out of the bag, only to find that the judge planned to bag him.  The juror, Robert Taylor, was called for duty and admitted during voir dire that he didn’t think he was qualified because he had collapsed and convicted an innocent man, Charles Campbell, back in 1992. 


Taylor testified he and two other jurors believed Campbell was innocent of the armed robbery but after deliberating for over nine hours, the three hold-outs felt pressure to change their votes to guilty.

I bet no one expect that to come out.  But it did.  So Campbell’s lawyer subpoenaed Taylor to testify in a post-conviction proceeding before Ninth Circuit Judge James Stewart. 

Judge Stewart naturally admonished Mr. Taylor for having failed in his duty as a juror by condemning a man he believed innocent to prison, but praised him for demonstrating the bravery to step forward, even at this late date, and admit that this man was wrongfully convicted.  Uh, sorry.  That didn’t happen.   But this did:


Stewart then told the juror there was a possibility of criminal charges being filed against him for jury misconduct depending on his potential testimony. Stewart warned any of his testimony Tuesday may be held against him and advised him of his right to remain silent. “To me, it was not that big of deal,” Taylor said. “I was taught that right always wins. But if it is going to incriminate me, I’m not going to say anything more. Sorry.” Taylor was then dismissed.

Gideon is outraged.  And he wants to know if he’s alone.  No, Gid, you’re not.  I am outraged as well.  Put aside the minor detail of what this Judge thinks this juror’s “crime” might be, but the notion that the judge threatened the juror with criminal prosecution to prevent him from testifying as to Campbell’s constitutional rights being violated is bizarre. 

Adding insult to injury, what are the chances any potential juror reading this story would ever be so stupid as to come forward and admit that they caved in to the majority to be done with deliberations and go home?  

Just in case you’re inclined to feel sympathetic to juror Taylor, the one who was too gutless to hold out for an acquittal, the deciding factor in favor of being an unmitigated pussy was that “Taylor argued if Campbell was not guilty of that crime, he was probably guilty of other crimes.”  Judge Stewart reserved decision.

Lawprof Teaches Taser Relations

We tend to have a different audience here than Volokh, so when Orin Kerr  discovered that Tasers were sometimes put to “questionable” use, the reaction of his readers would provide some fascinating fodder for discussion.

Orin posts this video of a man in Utah who was speeding.  Not your typical perp committing DWB or DWH as would give rise to the compulsory need for force in New York (or New Jersey), but a nicely dressed white male who, even in his anger, spoke to the officer in full sentences and didn’t curse once. 




Apparently, being white in Utah does not insulate one from the use of force. 

The fact that another person was tasered for the offense of not doing what he was told comes as no surprise to me.  The taser has become the weapon of choice to enforce obediance to police, but what do others think about it?

The bulk of the comments at Volokh, even from people who describe themselves as police supporters is that the officer used excessive force.  Then again, you would think everyone would be able to see that.  Not so.  A significant number of people posted that:


1.  The officer rightfully felt “threatened” because the man put his hands in his pockets.
2.  Disobeying a police officer is itself reason enough to taser (if not shoot) someone.
3.  Refusal to sign a ticket gave rise to cause to arrest, and force is part of being arrested.
4.  The driver was “resisiting arrest” and had to be stopped.

How do they explain these views.  Consider these examples:


The driver did not submit to the police officer’s lawful authority. He did not control his anger. He did not comply with any instructions. He tried to control the situation. He kept yapping and refusing to comply even after the officer pulled the taser out. Under these circumstances, tasering was a reasonable way to bring the driver under control.

Nobody likes a “yapper”.  And this one:


No one is saying that police should be able to taser you “just cuz.” The guy in the video reached for his pocket. Should the cop wait to see if a gun is pulled out first? That would be brilliant. Let’s draft a policy that requires a cop to allow a gun to be actually pulled on him before he can use a non-lethal device. No one got shot. No one suffered any long-term health effects. This is not one of the many bad examples of officers using tasers

As for me, this comment pretty much sums it up:


Actually, tasering people who annoy you for fun is one of the sacred privileges that comes with being a police officer. Despite the fact that for some people with certain health conditions, a tasering can be fatal.

What is most striking about the comments that expressed that tasering was reasonable is the effort put into justifying the police officer’s conduct.  This is important to criminal defense lawyers because we forget that not everyone views police conduct with a healthy dose of skepticism.  Many people, even most, will contort all reason to find a way to approve of their cops.  Remember, believing is seeing.

 

Don’t Try This With An Ipod

From today’s New York Post, “a teen shooting suspect’s quick decision to record his interrogation with a hidden MP3 device has played out as a perjury case against a veteran detective and a plea deal for himself.”

Perjury by a veteran detective?  How can that be?


Detective Christopher Perino, 42, emphatically [testified] that he hadn’t questioned the then-17-year-old about a Christmas Day 2005 shooting in The Bronx before the kid’s mother and aunt showed up at the 44th Precinct station.   But Crespo had secretly pressed record on his MP3 player – a small device used to download music from the Internet – hidden in his pocket and captured the bullying interrogation.

So how did this all come out?  “Crespo’s lawyer, Mark DeMarco, kept the recording under wraps until he cross-examined Perino at the trial.”   The transcript fails to support this, but the word in the Bronx is that the ADA rose to object, but only the words, “Oh shit,” came out of his mouth.

So that is the lesson learned?  Carefully search every suspect for an MP3 recorder BEFORE questioning.  Thankfully, the one and only time a detective ever lied under oath was proven because this young man had the foresight not to buy an Ipod.

The Last Peep Show in New York

I don’t usually have cause to stroll around Times Square these days, but I had a particular purpose for doing so today (I can’t tell you what as prying eyes may read this post, if you know what I mean).  In my travels, I saw a sign up ahead that said “Peep Show.”  Imagine my shock.

Times Square used to be famous for its squalor and pandering to prurient interests.  It was a singular sensation.  There was no other place on earth with an assortment of adult entertainment that could compare.  This was one of the many colors of New York City.  New York, just like I pictured it.

No more.  Rudy Guiliani cleaned up Times Square.  Now you can get anything from Pokemon balls to American Girl dolls to Lego anything.  But what you can’t find is a Peep Show.

True, Times Square was way out of control.  It was a bastion of filth and smut.  It was a teenage boy’s dreamland.  There was a time you could stumble from one topless bar to another, unless a bottomless bar got in your way.  It was not family fare.

This is one of the things for which Rudy is given great credit, cleaning up Times Square.  He shut down the porn shops and topless bars and the massage parlors.  When he claims that he changed Times Square, he’s finally telling the truth.

The question that still nags me is whether he turned Times Square into some distorted version of Disneyland, where happy, smiley faces of corporate retail has replaced the sad, pathetic faces of morality challenged men and women plying whatever trade they could.  Can anyone imagine where a remake of Midnight Cowboy would be staged?

It’s hard to argue, or believe, that Times Square was healthy the way it was when New York Mayor David Dinkins left office.  Dinkins was a mess, and the place went all to hell.  But Rudy may have overimproved it.  He cleaned it up, but so totally sanitized it in the process that there’s nothing New York left in it. 

There’s definitely a lesson for me in my observation today.  Next time, take the subway and you’ll get to see the New York you know and love.

The Blog Police Are Coming

My new best friend, Kevin at Real Lawyers Have Blogs, has finally found a cause I can get behind.  A number of big corporate-types are going to rein in the wild west of the corporate blogosphere (note, not blawgosphere, that small city-state where us lawyer-types post, but the world of BigCorp blogs) by developing The Rules.  They are forming the Blog Council, “dedicated to promoting best practices in corporate blogging.”

So, if this is directed toward corporate blogging, what difference does it make to the rest of us?  First, consider this:


“Every major corporation is struggling with the question of how to use blogs and engage the blogosphere the right way,” said Sean O’Driscoll, General Manager, Community Support Services for Microsoft.  “The Blog Council brings together precisely the people who need to explore these issues together, in a productive and private networking environment. We can work together to develop model policies that set the standard for corporate blogging excellence.”

See who’s talking, Mr. Microsoft.  These are the types that start the ball rolling and keep the rest of us out of the dialogue when all the rules are written.  But once they decide on what’s best for them, they start pushing their weight around, and their weight is considerable.

Would it surprise anyone to learn in a few years that there is a new government blue ribbon commission to create rules for blogging?  And what about our friend and protector of justice, the ABA?  Do you think its unlikely that they will be pushed into the fray after the Blog Council does its dirty work?  Or state bar regulators, who will impose “best practices” on us blawgers in exchange for free copies of Microsoft Windows Anti-Vista (this is the program that will remove Vista after it is discovered that Vista was a scam perpetrated by Microsoft to destroy the computerized world). 

The blogosphere is, at present, the wild west.  Our only constraint is ourselves and our ability to slam dunk others who misbehave.  On the one side, there are the many issues raised by Solove in his Future of Reputation.  But on the other side, we are like a herd of feral cats that will never be brought under control.  That is, unless some really big, strong, powerful Blog Council convinces all the powers that can be brought to bear on us to shut us down upon pain of . . . something.

Don’t discount Kevin’s concern.  Or mine.  This is where the future starts.  Where is stops has yet to be seen, but I surely don’t want to have Simple Justice taken down by some geek at Microsoft because I’ve broken one of the Blog Council’s rules.