Author Archives: SHG

More Welcome PsOV

Thanks to  Grits for bringing two new blawgs to the front.  First, we have a newbie, Deliberate Indifference at the Dallas County Jail, a new blog whose name is taken from an allegation in a federal lawsuit about the jail’s attitude toward providing inmates adequate healthcare. 

While this may be the view from the Dallas County Jail rather than Rikers Island or the Tombs (formerly the Bernard Kerik Tombs), it brings  a street level view of jails to the blawgosphere.  And I venture to say that most jails look pretty much the same from that vantage point.

The other is a blog called Flying Debris by Catanya (as related by Scott Hensen, since the blawg is otherwise anonymous), who describes herself by saying, “I could be a bitch. …if I were nicer.”  Very quaint. 

In a post about snitches, Catanya  explains “a retired outlaw’s” definition of snitching:


For me, the lines were always very clear.



You do your own time -period.



If you snitch and street justice catches up with you. I know nothing. sucks to be you…


If you abuse a child, the elderly, or an animal – I will call the appropriate agency and report your ass so fast it’ll make your head spin.


If you implicate or snitch on me or my partner (husband, significant other), – all bets between you and I are off.


Uninvolved witnesses and innocent bystanders are not snitches. Don’t blame them because your dumb ass wasn’t paying attention to your surroundings.


’nuff said?

Seems like Catanya and me are on the same page.  Maybe I’m not as crazy as Bennett, Norm and Gideon suggest.

As lawyers, we tend to see only two sides to the blawgosphere, defense and prosecution.  But there are a few more points of view that deserve airing, and thanks to Grits for letting this New Yorker know about them.

NYCLU Sues New York Over Inadequate Indigent Defense

This is not exactly breaking news, as the  NYCLU suit was filed on November 8th and Gideon, appropriately, jumped on it.  In a back-handed slap, Gideon then raised the  glaring silence from New York lawyers at Sui Generis’ weekly New York blawg round-up.  Gid was right about that too.

It wasn’t that I was ignoring this very important piece of news, but that I was so deeply ambivalent about it.  On the one hand, a great deal of effort and discussion went into presentations made to a Commission formed by Chief Judge Judy Kaye last year on this subject, addressing the difficult nuanced issues in terms of how to create a statewide indigent defense system that truly provided effective, consistent representation for defendants, and dealing with the inevitable unintended consequences of the various choices that had to be made in the process.

No one, including the Governor and Chief Judge, doubts that the current system does not work very well, and often doesn’t work at all.  As the press release states :


The class action lawsuit charges that a lack of adequate funding, oversight and statewide standards is denying New Yorkers accused of crimes their lawful right to competent, qualified and timely representation at all stages of the justice process, a violation of the U.S. Constitution, the state constitution and the laws of New York.

No question about it, this is all true.  But everyone knows this.  Everyone.  Pointing out the obvious, however, does nothing to solve the problem. 


Gary Stein, a lawyer with Schulte Roth & Zabel, pro bono counsel in the suit, added, “No more studies, no more delay. It is time to act.”

Strong words.  It is time to act.  But act how?  We have a chance to get it right this time, but getting it right is a far harder task than repeating long-standing criticism.

On the one hand, this suit may well push the State to put much greater energy and resources into moving the proposals for a statewide indigent defense commission toward becoming a reality.  Or, it could stop the efforts dead in their tracks while this suit continues.


But Mr. Gordon [spokesman for Governor Spitzer] said a legislative solution would not be possible until the litigation was resolved, helping to clarify constitutional issues.

There are a lot of people with horses in this race, not the least of which are the many indigent defense providers throughout New York State, operating on a county by county basis.  These providers, ranging from New York City’s Legal Aid Society to Bronx Defenders, have no idea what will become of them in a paradigm shift to a statewide defender system.  And then there are the 18B attorneys, putative private lawyers who either earn a living, or supplement their practice, by taking on indigent defense work on a case by case basis.   This group encompasses a substantial portion of the criminal defense bar, and the wholesale elimination of 18B cases would mean the wholesale elimination of their ability to survive.

Would all indigent defense be covered by lawyers in the state’s employ, or would it be outsourced to groups and individuals.  If the former, were would the state get this sudden enormous group of lawyers to fill the work, and how would they do so in the upstate counties where there are currently only a handful of lawyers practicing to begin with.

But if the latter, using the cadre of current 18B lawyers to fill the needs of indigent defense, have we not spun our wheels in a big circle, changing the name at the top but changing nothing else in the system.   After all, this is the same system that everyone complains about now, and the quality of indigent defense is back to being in the individual hands of individual lawyers.  Oversight and accountability, currently non-existent, will still be impossible since every provider will continue to operate independently.

Yesterday, after feeling pushed by Gideon to speak to this matter, I had a long chat with the head of an indigent defense provide in one of New York City’s five counties.  While she hoped that this lawsuit would push the state to move forward, and move faster, on doing something, she had deep concerns that she would have no seat at the table when it came time to talk about the resolution.  On a very practical level, this will not only impact the provision of legal services to the poor, but will impact the livelihoods of thousands of lawyers and continued existence of numerous enterprises.

The process of deciding what to do about indigent defense, how to fix a badly broken system, is going to be ugly.  It’s going to be far uglier if decided by a judge with only a few voices being heard.  While we can all agree that the services provided are inadequate, there is vehement disagreement about who is at fault and why.  Every indigent provider swears that they provide fabulous representation, and its the other guys who suck.  Every 18B lawyer swears that she serves her clients effectively, and it’s the other 18B lawyers who don’t. 

Everyone agrees that the lack of funding is a huge problem.  But if you give more money to the same old groups and lawyers who are dropping the ball today, do you fix the problem or end up with better paid lawyers providing the same old ineffective representation.  How do we quantify and qualify effective representation when every case is unique?

The two statewide criminal defense associations,  NYSDA and NYSACDL, have been involved in this discussion for a few years now, seeking change through the political process.  But now that the NYCLU has brought suit on its own, leaving the criminal bar out of the picture and, essentially, unilaterally dictating the process by pushing ahead on its own.

Is this lawsuit good, bad or indifferent?  My gut is that this lawsuit not only jumped the gun, but may ultimately prove to be the most harmful thing that has happened to creating a viable and effective indigent defense system in New York.  Sure, the NYCLU knows the problems.  But they have no solution. 

Madame Zuwonga Wears Prada

Anne Reed at  Deliberations finally  took me up on my Madame Zuwonga challenge.  In describing my experience with jury consultants, I wrote:


It seems closer to voodoo than science, and it disturbs me that they suggest that they have an ability that belongs only Madame Zuwonga, the Mind Reader.

This is most assuredly not the image that jury consultants want to project.  So Anne shot back:


Where do people get the idea that jury consultants are pushy clairvoyants?  From jury consultants themselves, it seems, or at least a few of them.

So are we on the same page on this?  Not exactly.  Anne goes on to say:

The jury consultants I know [plug omitted] are responsible, thoughtful people who are trying to provide assistance, not magic tricks. 

I can imagine the image that Anne has of my Madame Zuwonga, bright colorful robes floating in the wind, large colorful beaded jewelry dangling from every appendage.  But that’s not my Madame Zuwonga.  Nope, mine wears Prada.  And has a bunch of letters after her name.  She carries papers and a briefcase and wears no very little makeup as far as I’m aware. 

She and her team were very professional and scientific in their approach.  They listened thoughtfully and discussed their thoughts.  They offered no guarantees. 

But at some point, I sought some advice for the small fortune they were paid.  And they told me who to look for and who not to look for.  They attributed qualities and beliefs to people.  Their many letters after their names suggested that they indeed had some psychological basis for their opinions. 

It presented no Taoist dilemma for me; they weren’t vetoing my views in favor or their.  But they presented their views as if they knew something.  I wished they did.  I hoped they did.  They didn’t, at least as far as my jury was concerned. 

I’m sure they were responsible, thoughtful people who were trying to provide assistance.  I know that they thought of themselves that way.  But at the end of the day, a lot of money was spent, and a lot or reliance was placed, on a service that neither bore out its promise nor could do any better than a dart thrown at a list of the jury pool.

 I wish they used magic tricks.  It might have worked better.

Why Not Hire the Best?

A dear friend called me yesterday.  He’s a highly-skilled criminal defense lawyer with a ton of experience.  He’s one of the best.  If I was arrested, I would call him.  He’s that good.

So did he call me to tell me of his latest escapade, thwarting the forces of good in the name of the Constitution?  No.  He was depressed.  After a few minutes on the phone, I was depressed too.

My friend, who we’ll call “Steve” so that I can stop writing about “my friend” (which suggests I’m more likable than I really am), told me that his phone isn’t ringing.  “Is it broken,” I asked?  Yes, I can be thick sometimes.

“No,” he responded in a dreary voice.  “It works just fine.” 

So mustering all the empathy I could find, I asked Steve, “So are you going to tell me what’s wrong or do I have to hang up my phone so I can get some work done today?”

“I’m dead.  There’s no one calling.  I haven’t gotten a new case in a long time.”  Silence.

Now I understood.  This has been coming for a while now.  But to hear Steve say it was hard.  Steve was a star.  Every year, a hundred kids leave the DAs and Legal Aid offices and hang out their shingle, thinking that if those morons can be private criminal defense lawyers, so can I.  They take a few cases off the top, but most usually disappear into the crowd of dabblers in criminal defense when they figure out that they will never make it in criminal defense.

But Steve?  He’s done it for 20 years.  He’s well known.  He’s extremely well respected.  He has earned that reputation from years of success in the trenches.  His business has always come from client and lawyer referrals.  When I asked what happened to the lawyer referrals, he told me that everybody is so hungry that they’re holding on to every case they get.  I know this to be true.

I keep my ear to the ground in the bad neighborhoods of New York.  The word on the street is that nobody is making any money.  How this can be I don’t know, since somebody is still selling drugs and robbing bodegas and murdering others.  But I know that it’s true.  My peeps tell me so.

So Steve and I talked about why.  Sure, it’s not like the good old days when the criminals were more business-like in their dealings, putting money aside for the lawyer when the arrests inevitably came.  These were the guys who saw prosecution as a cost of doing business, and appreciated having a good lawyer to call.  These guys were now retired, if they were fortunate enough to avoid being in the crosshairs of some snitch.

But there are still plenty of criminals, right?  Well, of course, and there always will be.  But that doesn’t help someone like Steve.  He was a high-profile guy.  He could perform miracles, and he charged for the service.  Was the silence of his telephone a sign that nobody believes in miracles anymore?

I’ve posted recently about the lawyers who take felonies at $1,500 a pop.  The New York Times editorial page informed me that criminal defense lawyers are making money hand over fist, unlike our underpaid judges.  I read about others having more work than they know what to do with.  So why is it that nobody calls Steve anymore?

There is plenty of work out there for criminal defense lawyers.  It’s just not the work that anyone wants.  Some will take it because they have no choice, even though they are bringing down the rest of us in their personal struggle for survival.  This plays into my worst fear for the private criminal defense bar. 

When there are fifty lawyers willing to take your case for $1,500, and you have lost faith that the quality of your lawyer matters because (a) no one wins, (b) someone will rat you out anyway or (c) there is no justice, then why bother?  When the great lawyers like Steve aren’t getting any business, they will be forced to leave the law and open up a flower shop.  Who will be left? 

Other lawyers I talk to make it sound like they’re on top of the world.  I don’t believe most of them.  There are a lot of liars when it comes to self-promotion.  This doesn’t help to figure out what, if anything, can be done to stave off the potential implosion of the criminal defense bar.

It appears that things are different in other parts of the country, and that gives me hope that it’s a transitory problem.  But if we can’t thin out the herd on a basis other than price, we will be left with a bunch of lawyers who will take cases at any price just to keep the lights on, but few, if any, stars.  Why anyone would hire some hallway hack to be their lawyer when their life is on the line rather than a honest-to-God star like Steve?  Is this just New York?  I wish I had the answer.

No More D.P. In D.C.

The District of Columbia, the bastion of democracy and home of the brave, has come up with a brilliant idea, according to The Newspaper.  You see, when people got tickets, they showed up at the Department of Motor Vehicles and challenged them.  Sure, it allowed for due process, but it was bad for revenue.

The solution was plain.  If due process was screwing up a great revenue stream, get rid of it.  Duh!  And so they will.  It appears that the DC DMV will no longer allow the lucky recipients of tickets to appear.  They can still send in their objections to the tickets by mail (thus giving the appearance of due process), but DMV employees in a back room somewhere can pull out their “guilty” stamp and make the objections go away en masse.  You get your day in court.  They get their revenue.

You see, it’s a lot harder to say no to a person standing in front of you who has just given an overwhelming presentation on why they should not have received a ticket.  It makes the administrative judges feel very bad when they hear people they know are right but have to find them guilty nonetheless.  Talk about a hostile work environment.  It is so much easier when you don’t have to look into their eyes as you do the wrong thing.

Plus, if there’s nobody in front of you, you don’t have to explain yourself.  After all, nobody would be satisfied with an administrative judge’s decision that goes along the lines of


“Well, Ms. Smith, your testimony certainly explains why you should not have received a ticket, but you must certainly realize that the employees of the District of Columbia need to be paid every week, and the taxpayers feel overwhelmed already so our elected officials feel compelled to avoid a tax increase at any cost.  I’m sure you understand.  Pay the clerk on the way out.  Next!”

So if you live in D.C., or just happen to be visiting our nation’s capital, stop asking what the government can do for you and just write a check.  On the bright side, it’s the first new solution that’s come out of Washington in a long time.  But before you make fun of Washington, D.C. for this stroke of brilliance, bear in mind that this is an idea that’s coming to a city near you soon.

Continuing Legal Education, For Better or Worse

It became apparent to the courts some years ago that as lawyers aged, their knowledge of the law sometimes fell behind.  And so, they mandated Continuing Legal Education (CLE) for all.  In New York,  the requirement is 24 Credits every 3 years, including 4 credits in ethics.

It really made sense to do this, as we were all aware that many attorney just didn’t keep up on the law and it sometimes resulted in an embarrassing show in court, not to mention less than perfect representation of clients.  While the clients may not have known, it was evident to the rest of us.  And what was the big deal anyway?

Well, as Norm Pattis explains here, the big deal is that the promise of CLE was not always met by the performance.  Of course, the requirement applied to all attorneys, since there was no way for officialdom to distinguish those attorneys who kept up on developments in the law on a daily basis from those who never opened a law book or read a legal newspaper.  It was all or none, but that was part of the price of the meal ticket.  So even a lawyer with the knowledge and experience of Norm had to do his time.

As CLEs were mandated, an industry immediately grew around them to benefit from the fees that thousand of lawyers would have to pay to somebody.  Initially, private groups tried to put together fascinating speakers and lecturers to staff the series of CLEs and rise to the top of the industry.  These were rather expensive agendas.

Our bar associations came to the rescue in due course, putting together their own CLEs, which were usually less expensive and the funds would benefit our own associations rather than profit driven enterprises.  They too, at least initially, put together some of the best and brightest of the bar to lecture, and it was really quite fascinating.

But time takes its toll.  Eventually, the fascinating speakers become less fascinating, especially after their 37th time doing the same lecture.  There just isn’t that much to say after a while.  You see, 24 credits is a lot of CLE, and the law moves forward with glacier-like speed.  After giving the “Cross to Kill” CLE for 7 year running, there isn’t a criminal defense lawyer in New York who hasn’t either heard it or taught it.  It just runs out of steam.

For those who get to do the teaching, it became tedious.  We get our CLE credits for our lectures, but coming up with fresh and exciting information in the law was sometimes a stretch.  And so new people came in to lecture, and they weren’t always up to the task.  Too often, the newer teachers were old-timers who think that their war stories are enough to enthrall a room full of lawyers.  They aren’t.  Worse yet, some of these old-timers were the very people for whom CLE was intended.  There’s nothing worse than a CLE lecturer who demonstrated to a groups of lawyers that he was a clueless buffoon.

Then there were the young bucks who desperately wanted to be on the circuit.  They would have highly detailed, well-prepared multi–media presentations.  The problem was that they lacked the experience of the audience.  They were rookies and their presentations simplistic.  It was often painful to watch.

Then there were the new programs.  It all started with great concepts like “Weapons for the Firefight,” but eventually wound its way down to “Reading the Penal Law for Rookies.”  Needless to say, no one signed up for that one. 

So Norm posts about how he signed up for a CLE about counseling clients, a subject he thought would be interesting and helpful.  It turned out, however, to be about the consequences of having sex with a client.  Somehow, I see that subject being a very brief CLE, at least as far as it would apply to me.  It’s one step below the CLE about why we shouldn’t raid the escrow account.  I sincerely hope that Norm didn’t have to sit through a multi-media presentation.  The very notion of naked lawyers is just awful.

When I get the call about doing a CLE, I try to encourage the CLE committee to come up with a fully blown concept, both to bring something worthwhile to the audience and to provide a discrete guide to lecturers.  The last time I taught, we had a decent concept (Expert Testimony in the Eyewitness ID Case), but the CLE fizzled. 

The first speaker, someone who had long sought to become a speaker and was of the view that he was quite knowledgeable about the law (a view not shared by all) got up and gave a sophomoric yet pedantic lecture that touched on a hundred points of interest and made none of them.  This was a paint by the numbers sort of guy, who had the ability to drone on forever without ever imparting any wisdom whatsoever. 

The following speakers tried to salvage the CLE, clearing up the misimpressions and half-baked statements of the lead speaker, but most of the audience was fast asleep by then.  While there is a rule that you have to get to the CLE on time to get credit, there’s no rule that you have to stay awake. 

In all fairness, the people charged with putting on the CLEs have a lot of work to do to try to keep it fresh and interesting, especially to the audiences that may have lawyers with experience that spans 40 years.  And one never knows how good, or bad, a speaker will be until she’s given a chance.  But the promise of CLE to keep lawyers on top of their game has largely turned out to be more of a pointless burden than boon.  It’s not that the need for CLE has changed, but that it’s largely run out of steam.

If anybody has any fresh ideas for criminal law CLEs, I would be honored to pass them along.  But please, no “sex with clients” stuff, especially with multi-media presentations.

Solvency Isn’t Rocket Science

Newsday has been  running a series on the impending doom for many on Long Island as a result of falling property values and mortgage foreclosures.  For many, the problem is painfully real.  But for some of the people interviewed in the Newsday reports, the problem has nothing to do with either value or mortgages.

Consider this example from an article about foreclosures:


The last property of the morning was a house in Freeport. The owner was Alberto Chavez, 77, who had gotten a subprime mortgage a year and a half ago, a $419,000 loan — the full value of the house — that carried an interest rate of 9 percent, leaving a monthly payment of $4,400, according to Chavez’s son, Immar, who lives in the house and attended the auction.

Chavez never made a payment, his son said. Immar Chavez hoped to stop the foreclosure proceeding, explaining that his father had filed for bankruptcy in an online application the night before.

Why would a 77 year old man take out a loan for the full value of his house, requiring a monthly payment of $4,400?  This seems suicidal, yet somebody obvious thought this was a sound financial move.  Of course, when no payments were ever made, foreclosure was to follow.  This smell more like outright fraud by the homeowner than a sympathetic old man.

So here’s the question.  Is Newsday encouraging Mr. Chavez to max out his home, keep the money and have bankruptcy bail him out?  What became of the $419,000 from the mortgage? 

Another example: 

Kari and her husband, Keith, have owned the cape since 2002, when they bought it from her mother’s estate for $301,000. At the time, they had a mortgage payment of $2,100 a month, which they said they could manage.

But after a call from a now-defunct Melville mortgage broker, Global Home Loans and Finance, the Sessas decided to refinance to consolidate their debt. While acknowledging that they made their own mistakes, such as not carefully reading paperwork or bringing an attorney to the closing, they said they thought the mortgage would be one 30-year fixed rate loan.

But instead, they received two loans. One, for about $374,185, had an annual percentage rate, including all fees, adjustments and the total loan cost, of about 9.64 percent. It’s an adjustable loan — starting out at a teaser 6.1 percent rate, but scheduled to adjust in early 2008. The other loan, for $99,000, had a fixed rate of 10.6 percent.

That left them with a new monthly payment of $3,354, about $500 more a month than it would have been with a conventional, 6 percent rate loan.


Welcome to Long Island.  If we add up the numbers, we see that they pulled $473,185 out of their house on the refinance to “consolidate their debt,” apparently accumulated since their purchase from her mother’s estate (which suggests she got at least some of the purchase money back as an heir).  And how did they run up additional debt of $173k in 5 years?  Certainly, they refinanced with a predatory broker.  They admittedly made a mistake by doing so without a lawyer, though it’s unclear how they didn’t realize that they were being given 2 loans instead of one.

If these are the best examples that Newsday can come up with the prove the “mortgage crisis,” then there’s a very real problem.  Both of these examples are about the very human failure of fiscal responsibility.  Accumulating piles of debt is not a human right.  It is not a matter of sympathy.  It’s just foolish, at best, and borderline criminal, at worst.

Everybody on Long Island drives around in a new Mercedes.  Their kids dress in designer clothing and teenage girls all carry Louis Vuitton handbags.  They eat dinner at very expensive restaurants.  And lest you be unaware, they are all very important.  Just ask them.  They’ll tell you.  Every one of them.

This is not intended to belittle those people who suffer from very legitimate problems cause or enhanced by the drop in real estate prices, the market crisis or subprime lending predators.  But it is intended to let all those people who lived like a Saudi prince by maxing out their credit cards and refinancing their homes above their worth and beyond their ability to pay that the bill has come due for spending more than you can afford.

It is irresponsible for a newspaper to suggest that these people are suffering due to extraneous factor.  They may well be suffering, but it is of their own making.  When the were living the happy life, accumulating debt because they assumed that the increased value of their homes would produce generous cash payments whenever needed, they were happy.   Now they are endebted and sad.  And their problems becomes everyone’s problem, as the cost of picking up the pieces of their life is shared by their neighbors.

Newsday got the lesson wrong.  No one is entitled to live beyond their means.  When you spend more than you have, you will eventually crash and burn.  I am sorry that things didn’t work out for these people and I don’t want them to be homeless.  They may well be very nice people.  And I’m sure that there are many people in similar situations who used the money to pay for medical bills instead of new Mercedez Benz’s.  But there are far too many people who made insanely foolish choices and are now in deep trouble.  That’s how it works.

If you really need to know more, watch this video.  It’s pretty clear.  H/T Volokh.

ATL Takes A Bow

Above The Law has finally acknowledged winning the Best Law Blog for 2007, a conclusion reached by the rest of us a while ago. 

Late last week, Above the Law was named Best Law Blog, in the 2007 Weblog Awards. Very exciting! Thanks to everyone who voted, in response to our repeated pleas.

Was the contest “a pretty silly affair,” as our erstwhile evidence professor, Brian Leiter, opined? Sure. Which makes ATL’s victory eminently appropriate, since this is a pretty silly blog.

While ATL may not be everybody’s cup of tea, you’ve got to give David Lat enormous credit for both the huge volume of fans he’s amassed in the year that ATL has been around, and his great humor and humility.  Now if only he could get one of those year end and special bonuses he posts about.

Congratulations David. 

Privacy is So Yesterday

The title is shamelessly stolen from Nicole Black at  Sui Generis because I couldn’t possibly come up with a better one.  According to this AP story, our idea of privacy has outlived its usefulness.


Privacy no longer can mean anonymity, says Donald Kerr, the principal deputy director of national intelligence. Instead, it should mean that government and businesses properly safeguard people’s private communications and financial information.

This statement comes in the context of Congress’ decision to confer immunity on the telecoms for doing whatever the government asks them to do.  Remember, we exist to help the government, which exists to help us.  But somebody has to make the decisions that affect every aspect of our lives, and if you can’t trust  your attorney general to do it for you, who can you trust?

Call me old school, but I like to think that I am in charge of my own privacy.  It’s my privacy, my call.  If I choose to give up certain information, I can do so.  If I choose not to, you may not give me a credit card or a mortgage, but that’s the risk I take.  As far as what goes on in my bedroom, don’t even go there.  I still think I should be able to walk anywhere in the United States without having to give my identity to anyone, and I should be able to pay cash at a store and not be required to divulge a thing about me. 

But that’s my antiquated notion.  The Government thinks differently:


“Our job now is to engage in a productive debate, which focuses on privacy as a component of appropriate levels of security and public safety,” Kerr said. “I think all of us have to really take stock of what we already are willing to give up, in terms of anonymity, but (also) what safeguards we want in place to be sure that giving that doesn’t empty our bank account or do something equally bad elsewhere.”

So the new definition is that privacy is a component of security.  In other words, we can have all the privacy we want, provided it is subject to whatever invasion the government deems necessary for public safety.  We just need to readjust our rights sights, apparently.

I have this vision in my head that there’s some fat man with a shit-eating grin on his face somewhere in the bowels of government muttering to himself, “I can’t believe they’re buying this crap!”

This just isn’t my idea of what freedom was all about.  I had occasion to read Federalist #31 the other night (don’t ask).  In it, Publius (a/k/a James Madison) argues that the power of government to tax isn’t usurpation, since the purposes to which our money is put are those we seek and the decision to tax is made by those we choose.  They would never abuse our trust, Madison contends, because they are us.  We are them.  Our government is what we make our government to be.  I wonder if David Giacolone at  f/k/a will tell me that my interpretation is wrong.  In Haiku.

Benjamin Franklin said, “Those who desire to give up freedom in order to gain security will not have, nor do they deserve, either one.”  It’s disconcerting that our government, far more powerful and distant from the People than Publius ever imagined, has abandoned freedom in its effort to gain control.  Is it really for security, or just because the exploitation of fear has allowed it to finally have the power and authority over us that the institution of government has long wanted and believed it deserved.

What I cannot figure out is how the people who hold power in government for a brief moment really think it’s in the best interest of America to accumulate so much power that our ideals exist only in empty rhetoric?  Surely, they must realize that one day they will be out of power, and their opposition will hold the power that they now accumulate for themselves.  Aren’t they afraid of this?

Regardless, I find myself thinking that Ben Franklin knew better than James Madison.

Politics and Parole

Adam Liptak’s New York Times  column today raises the issue of denied parole.  Oddly, he chose an old Michigan case to make his point.  It’s odd because there are examples much closer to home. 

One of the most basic tenets of criminal law is that the Government can’t change the rules of the game afterward.  The idea is enshrined in the two ex post facto clauses of the Constitution, Article I, sections 9 and 10.  It’s defined as a law the criminalizes or increases punishment for conduct that has already happened. 

It’s wrong because it is purely punitive.  It does nothing to stop the conduct, and the person committing the conduct has no warning of the consequences at the time. 

The function of the Parole Board is to determine whether a prisoner is ready to be released back into society.  The practice of parole in New York has become that the Parole Board sits as a Superjudge for the purpose of resentencing a defendant based upon the original offense and the political determination of whether the original sentence was harsh enough. 

Under the New York sentencing scheme, felony offenders are given indeterminate sentences, such as 15 years to life for an A-1 felony.  This means that they must serve a minimum sentence of 15 years, reflecting a determination by the Legislature that the crime demands at least that long in prison.  

Beyond the minimum of 15 is another matter.  If the judge felt that 15 years was not sufficient, she could sentence the defendant to 20 years to life, or even as high as 25 to life.  But the judge set the minimum with the understanding that, if the defendant behaved in prison, that would be the point of parole eligibility.

The expectation was clear at the time of sentence that unless something happened that compelled a denial, a prisoner would serve the minimum portion of the sentence and be released on parole.  Somewhere during the Pataki administration, that changed.  Instead of viewing the minimum as the ending point of the sentence, it became the starting point of the sentence to be imposed by the Parole Board.

The Parole Board sits back and redecided sentence.  Fifteen not enough?  Parole Denied.  Liberal judge?  Parole Denied.  This was ex post facto at its most insidious, especially for those who took a guilty plea with the understanding of what the sentence meant.  No one anticipated that there would be a paradigm shift in the parole process that would result in the deal being turned upside down.

The problem is that prisoners have few friends in high places.  Addressing these problems happens on case by case basis, and the only way to identify the problem is to look at the very rare individual decisions reversing a parole denial.  The concept, as  explained by former Parole Board chair Ed Hammock,


A reasonable inference to be drawn, then, is that, if due consideration has been given by the court to the length and type of sentence imposed, parole release should occur at the first instance of eligibility.  Under this theory, there should be a presumption that the inmate’s institutional programming and disciplinary record suggest that release to parole supervision is appropriate.  What the board should be doing is making the release assessment is determining the overall comportment of the inmate during the period of incarceration.

In other words, parole deals with what happened between sentence and the parole hearing, not the crime for which the defendant was sent to prison.  That’s for the sentencing judge to decide, and neither the parole board, victims’ rights advocates or politicians should be tweaking the back end of the system to redecide sentence to make it more to their liking. 

But it’s not easy to rein in the parole board when it goes astray.  Since the parole board couches its denial in statutory terms, it’s very difficult to conclusively determine that a denial was improperly based.  Worse still, getting a court to review parole denial is itself a major problem, since the prisoner (who’s sitting in prison) needs to find a lawyer willing to take on the case, and then a judge willing to bang heads with political appointees on the Parole Board.  The stars don’t line up that easily.

One such rarity was the William Phillips case.  The judge in that case, Marcy Friedman, wrote what everyone knew:


“[T]he board impermissibly based its denial on a non-statutory factor – its opinion as to the proper penalty for the crime – while in effect disregarding both that the petitioner has achieved a complete rehabilitation and that the statutory scheme required the Board to take this factor into account,”

But as noted in the New York Law Journal article,


The court, however, declined in a footnote to address Mr. Phillips’ allegation that the board was advancing Governor George E. Pataki’s political agenda rather than following the law.

And, it should be noted, that William Phillips, a former New York City cop, was denied parole 3 times before Judge Friedman put her foot down.