Author Archives: SHG

One Last Chance To Make It Real

The situation in Pakistan has gotten me thinking this week.  Lawyers are putting their butts, and their lives, on the line for something they believe in.  It sounds so familiar . . .

I’ve posted about a couple of demonstrations/rallies in the United States in support of our Pakistani brethren.  I see that the ABA, perpetually late to the party, has decided to tag along.  But I’ve had the nagging sense that it’s far too little, too meaningless. 

We will march.  Then we will go for a nice lunch.  We will wear dark suits and white shirts.  We bought them at Brooks Brothers.  We have nothing at risk.  We haven’t really had anything at risk in a very long time.

For those of us at the trailing end of the baby boom, this seems rather embarrassing.  Did we not make a promise a long time ago to do something to make the world better?  We have yet to keep the promise.

My joke is that a Republican is a Democrat with a mortgage, and a Democrat is a Republican under indictment.  My truth is that there are very few people who hold a principled view of their existence.  They’re too busy trying to make the Mercedes payments.

Somewhere along the line, we were seduced by material possessions.  We liked all the shiny things we could buy with the money we made, and we needed to make more money to buy more shiny things.  Along the way, our mantra changed from “Give peace a chance” to “Greed is Good.” 

No, I’m not advocating a return to nature, shedding our possessions so that we can get back to the garden.  But I am asking why, now that we have climbed to positions of influence and power, we have forgotten our purpose.

A talking head on TV yesterday raised Springsteen’s line, that we have one last chance to make it real.  We haven’t done a very good job of creating a world that we want to pass down to our children.  We have war.  We have pollution.  We have selfishness and hatred.  We have a desperate need for shiny things that has so severely skewed our priorities that children need Ipods more than love.  We have more people living in poverty and desperation than ever before.  No, we have not done a very good job at all.

We have no one left to blame.  We hold the positions of power.  We are “the man.”  And we exercise that power like grocery clerks, oblivious to why we are in the position and what can be accomplished with it if we only remember right from wrong.  Maybe it’s time that we return to Woodstock and remember what this was all about.

Lawyers in Pakistan have taken risks.  How about you?

Moot Court and Mute Judges

One of the rituals of the first year of law school is Moot Court.  For you non-lawyers, it’s a name given to the exercise of briefing and arguing a pretend appeal based upon a contrived fact pattern.  Law students are given the exercise to learn what it’s like to perform the work that they’ve been spending so much time reading about.  More importantly, they do it to prove their mettle so they can be invited to be on the Moot Court Board, which looks really good on their Biglaw resume and will provide financial security for the rest of their lives.

Modesty aside, I am the best moot court judge ever.  You see, non-lawyers, law schools engage in Moot Court competitions in various areas of law to show that Fordham can kick Harvard’s butt in the real world.  This part doesn’t actually change a student’s chances for a Biglaw paycheck, since the kid from Fordham still didn’t go to Harvard and is therefore deemed intellectually defective by the elites, but it does give him a leg up over his fellow Fordhamites.

The fact patterns used, when well crafted, provide both sides with substantial arguments to offer without either having a winner.   The teams switch back and forth between sides, teaching students to be able to argue out of both sides of their mouth at any given moment.  It’s a skill only a lawyer could appreciate, but a necessary one for an advocate.  Bear in mind, we argue on behalf of our clients, not ourselves.

To run these competitions, law schools reach out to real lawyers to man the benches for the many rounds of argument.  There are usually a lot of arguments, so they require a lot of lawyers.  The benches run from three to five “judges,” and one of the judges gets to “preside.”  This is often a hoot, since the presiding judge sometimes takes the job very seriously.

When they can’t find enough lawyers to fill the benches, they often fill in with law students what are Moot Court members.  This, too, is a hoot, because you have students who regurgitate what they’ve been taught about “the rules” of oral argument by professors who have never actually argued a case.  It’s like performing open heart surgery after being taught by a professor who’s never seen the inside of a chest.  Very funny stuff, unless you’re the patient.  But then, that’s why they invented anesthesia.

But I digress.  So they get a bunch of lawyers in a room to be judges, and we talk amongst ourselves.  It turns out that about 80% of them haven’t seen the inside of a courtroom in the last 20 years.  Some are very distinguished in what they do, but they don’t litigate and have never argued a real appeal.  The totality of their litigation experience is, ta da, doing moot courts.  Ironic, eh?  But they believe with absolute sincerity (like the moot court students) that they are perfectly positioned to judge for just this reason.  A ton of experience judging moot court competitions qualifies them to judge moot court competitions.

Now, law students are taught that there are rules to arguing an appeal.  And these rules are handed down from moot court member to students year after year.  The judges who have never actually experienced arguing an appeal love these rules, and love to pontificate about how the competitors violated a rule in their argument.  They mark them down for these violations.  Rules are rules, you know.

But the primary function of the judges is to ask questions during the argument and comment afterward about the performance.  There tends to be two types of judges: The one who says nothing and the one who can’t shut up.  I’ve seen judges talk so much that the competitors (who are generally given 15 minutes per argument) never get a chance to say anything more than, “May it please the Court . . .”  The judges who say nothing leave the competitors dangling, since asking questions is critical to the competition and, more importantly, uses up a certain portion of the time.  The competitors may have about 5 minutes of schtick, but expect questions and will die at the podium if the bench sits there silently.

So, in anticipation of moot court season starting, I offer Greenfield’s rules on how to be a good moot court judge:

1.  Read the fact pattern before you show up for the free lunch.  The kids have spent a lot of time working on their argument.  Show them the courtesy of spending a few minutes learning your part.

2.  Give the students a chance to shine.  Ask challenging questions, not the “suggested” questions in the bench brief (which are prepared for the benefit of judges who are either too lazy or too challenged to put in two seconds of thought).  If you can’t think of a challenging question, smile benignly and let someone else ask questions.

3.  Give the students a chance to answer.  While non-litigation lawyers may believe that the sound of their voice is endlessly fascinating, the competition isn’t about you.  Let the student answer your insightful question.  And if they don’t respond as brilliantly as you would, suck it up.  That isn’t your cue to launch into a demonstration of your genius.

4.  If the student’s response to your question failed to address your point, maybe your question stunk.  Don’t blame the student because you don’t know how to ask a question.  Keep them short and to the point.  If your fellow judges’ faces are all twisted and contorted, chances are you didn’t do a very good job of it.  Back off.

5.  Stay with the program.  You may know a lot about the substantive law involved in the fact pattern, and want to show the room how much more you know than anyone else.  Guess what?  The students are not experts, and going beyond the scope only proves that you are a pompous jerk.

6.  There are no rules.  Here’s an inside secret, no one wins an appeal because they have ably kept their hands to the sides of the podium.  The point is to be an effective advocate, and that’s the only point.  The rules you were taught in law school are there for baseline context; they really don’t count.  If a student was effective in his argument, the fact that she waved an arm at one point does not mean that she gets marked down.

7.  Remember that they are students.  You are not in the competition, so you don’t need to prove your brilliance by beating them to death.  If you see them struggling or dying, help them out a little.  They are often scared to death, and a little bit of calming would do wonders.  If they stumble, pick them up.  Imagine your kid up there arguing.  Be kind.

8.  Accept defeat gracefully.  Every once in a while, a student will argue brilliantly.  You ask your toughest question, and she swats it aside like gnat.  She can’t be shaken or pushed, and shows a maturity in her demeanor that makes you shrivel up.  Do you continue to fight, beat her to death, prove that you are the lawyer and she is the mere student?  Ladies and gentlemen, this is what it’s all about.  You’ve got yourself a winner.  When a winner argues in front of you, accept it and bow your head in defeat.  This is what moot court is all about.  It’s not just a good thing, it’s a great thing to see someone excel.

9.  Be constructive in your critique.  The tendency to either say “everyone was great” or “everyone stunk” is unhelpful.  They will be arguing again, and want to know what worked and what didn’t.  The gaps in their argument only matter if it is a product of flawed preparation, not because there were holes in the fact pattern.

10.  If you have no idea what you’re talking about, say nothing.  They put you on the bench because they needed warm bodies.  That’s okay.  But lawyers aren’t fungible.  Many lawytheers don’t know anything about litigation.  That’s okay too.  If you say something, they will listen.  If you say something stupid, they will still listen.  Don’t do it to them.  They are trying very hard to do a good job.  There’s no need to make noise that contributes nothing to their effort.  If you have nothing to say, say nothing.  It’s okay.

But What Does The New York Times Think Of Us?

One of the great joys of getting home delivery of the New York Times is that you get most of the Sunday Times on Saturday, meaning that you get to address the editorials before they technically come out.  That said, tomorrow’s Sunday’s NYT will include(s)  an editorial in its regional section about salary increases for New York’s judges.  No shock there, but the justification for it is quite curious.


Imagine a courtroom scene, maybe something out of “Law & Order.”  Then ask yourself which official earns the least of all those important people sitting in front of the jury.  If you guessed the judge, chances are you’re right.

Certainly the defense lawyer, if a private attorney, makes far more in hourly fees than the person with the gavel.  Some district attorneys, in New York City at least, earn more than not only the trial judge but also the chief judge.  There are even nonjudicial employees in the state judiciary system who can earn as much or more than the person who is up there making the most important decisions in the entire courthouse.

Certainly the defense lawyer?  Says who?  Where the hell does the Times editorial board get the right to make such absolutely baseless assertions?  Sure, it wants to promote a salary increase for judges, but at whose expense?  Is it now the policy of the New York Times to just make up crap that supports its position?  Apparently so.

I am not aware of any existing credible basis to establish the average income of private criminal defense attorneys in New York State or City.  As we are all painfully aware, private criminal defense lawyers don’t charge by the hour unless they want to be on welfare.  Yet another Times “let’s pretend we know what we’re talking about moment.”  And then, no mention of the rents we pay for offices, the salaries for staff, the costs for transportation and supplies and services.  Unlike judges or DAs (and I am unaware of ANY line assistant who makes anywhere near a judges’ salary), we pay our own freight, not the taxpayer.  How many judges out there would take a pay raise but be willing to pay market rents for his chambers?

There are two basic problems with a well-intended editorial gone far wrong.  First, it’s an outright fabrication.  Second, don’t push for judicial salary increases on the back of others who are working for a living as well.  It is despicable that the New York Times resorts to such hyperbolic falsehoods to pursue its editorial agenda.  Try telling it all those “wealthy” private criminal defense lawyers who struggle to find clients, get paid, carry their offices and fulfill their oaths, how good they have it. 

Maybe the Times should donate its editors’ salaries to the poverty-stricken judges, but do not offer me up as your sacrificial lamb.  I work for a living.

Judicial Raises: Do It Or I’ll Write Again!

Judicial pay in New York has been a disgrace for a long time now.  And so the leader of the pack, Chief Judge Judith Kaye, has decided to take charge of the situation and . . . write an op-ed piece.  Oooh.  Take that, you legislators.


These past months, actually years, of promised but unrealized salary increases for judges, have of course been highly dispiriting. We have watched the cost of living skyrocket. We have watched the compensation of the pool from which judges are drawn — outstanding lawyers of at least 10 years’ experience — far outpace our own compensation.

Ouch.  Scathing.  Judges are “highly dispirited!” That Judge Kaye, you don’t want to piss her off. 

Today, many recent law graduates, some of them not yet admitted to the bar, earn more than we do. Additional bonuses are being heaped on the bonuses already being added to their salaries. And we have documented the dozens and dozens of public employees who earn considerably more than we do.

True that.  Of course, not too many judges would be able to land a Biglaw job.  In fact, they probably wouldn’t have gotten an interview. 


Upsetting as it is to the judges, this picture should trouble New Yorkers even more. The public, after all, needs and deserves a first-class judiciary. The public needs and deserves to attract, and keep, the very best of the Bar on the bench. Lawyers don’t become judges to become rich. But let’s face it, freezing their compensation at the bottom rung of judicial pay scales is unfair to them. It disserves the public interest.

It disserves the public interest?  That’s it?  That’s the most persuasive, forceful argument she’s got?  No wonder those legislators are shaking in their boots.  The other Judge Judy is on the warpath, her whoop being that it disserves the public interest.

Judge Kaye is, of course, quite right about the disgraceful state of judicial salaries.  But as this lags on, year after year, writing stuff like this is just plain embarrassing.  And if the Legislature ignores you (as they have and will again), what are you going to do about it?  Write another, even more scathing, op-ed? 

A while back, I wrote a piece for  Judicial Reports about the lawyers’ view of the judges’ predicament.  In the scheme of fiscal priorities (remember Herzberg’s Theory of Motivation and Mazlow’s Hierarchy of Needs?), there is probably no group less sympathetic than judges.  You want private lawyer incomes, get off the bench.  But then, I bet that most judges will be just a little surprised by the reality in the trenches.  Every ex-judge doesn’t get a TV show.  And a glut of ex-judges won’t help Biglaw profits per partner.

Judges deserve to make far better money than they’re now getting.  Lawyers in the trenches do as well, by the way, though that never really makes it onto anyone’s radar when they’re busy complaining about themselves. 

How long will the judiciary keep begging for the Legislature to be nice to them?  At what point will our judges decide that the same old argument are just the same old argument?  And when will the judges realize that we are all in this together?   Do you think that the cost of living skyrocketed only for judges?

Yes, Judge Kaye, judges deserve a salary increase.  But you are not going to get it by writing another tired op-ed piece.  And you will not get lawyers on board when the judiciary was all too happy to hang us out to dry when lawyers couldn’t pay their rent.  We are all in this together.  Until that message gets through, you can write as many op-eds as you like about disservice, but it’s not going to do any good.

The Rise of Bernie Kerik, American Hero

Now that Bernard Kerik is under a 16 count federal indictment, coming at a time when it will reflect poorly on his rabbi, Rudy Guiliani, who is running for President as the Hero of 9/11, it’s time to learn a little about how and why Bernie hit the big time, and what was truly wrong about Rudy’s judgment.

Bernie was a high school dropout who went into the army and became an MP.  He obtained his GED and went to work as a security officer for various Saudi entities, until he was thrown out of Saudi Arabia in 1984.  Somehow, he landed a job as Warden of the Passaic, New Jersey, County jail, where he worked until 1986.

Kerik then joined the NYPD as a beat cop back in the days when you didn’t need any college credits to be a cop.  It’s hard to understand how he went from warden of a jail to beat cop in NYC, but apparently he had a knack for ingratiating himself with the right people.  He won some medals for valor in gunfights as a cop, and wound up as driver and bodyguard to Mayor Rudolph Guiliani. 

In 1998, Bernie was appointed Commissioner of New York City’s Department of Corrections, running the array of jails in the City, including Riker’s Island, lovingly referred to as “The Rock.”  He had previously served as First Deputy Commissioner for three years.

During the early Guiliani administration, Bill Bratton was Police Commissioner of the City of New York.  Bratton was a brilliant man, and was widely credited for the turnaround in crime in New York that is now attributed to Rudy.  Rudy couldn’t stand the attention that Bratton was receiving (and Bratton was all too happy to smile for the cameras).  So out went Bratton and in came Bernie Kerik as Police Commissioner in 2000.

At this point, Kerik, high school drop-out, was now in command of the largest police department in the world, though ironically his lack of a college degree would have precluded him from holding any rank higher than captain.  But Bernie had something better than an education.  He was loyal to a fault to his Mayor, and Rudy appreciated it.  And so Bernard Kerik was fortuitously Police Commissioner of New York on September 11, 2001.  Like the Mayor to whom he owed fealty, the adoration of a nation rubbed off on him and he became a hero.

When Rudy’s term as Mayor finally ran out, Bernie left as well, going on to become one of Rudy’s “partners” and making a fortune as a consultant to Taser International.  He was also appointed interim Minister of the Interior of Iraq.

Bernie Kerik’s rise was nothing short of meteoric, and proof positive that who you know matters.  But during this rise, Bernie was still an uneducated street cop at heart, though hob-knobbing with the important people.  What Bernie lacked was the financing necessary to run with a fast crowd. He had filed for bankruptcy in 1987, living higher on the hog than he should.  He had prominence and authority, but he didn’t have much cash.  And as every street cop knows, cash is king.

So his street cop mentality told him that big time players enjoyed the perks of office to “compensate” for their public service.  He was serving the public, right?  So why shouldn’t he enjoy a few benefits in the process.  Until Bernie received more than $6 Million from stock sales in Taser, he had to take his perks where he could find them. 

The world of Bernie Kerik came crashing down when his reach exceeded his grasp on December 3, 2004, when President Bush, at Rudy’s urging, nominated him to replace Tom Ridge as Homeland Security Czar.  He was vetted by Attorney General Alberto Gonzalez and the announcement was made.  But this wasn’t a position where one could slide under the radar with smooth rhetoric and Rudy’s true love.  The national press scrutinized Bernie and he quickly withdrew his nomination.  His world then began to crumble.  First, he was charged in the Bronx with accepting some “illegal gifts,” to which he pleaded guilty of misdemeanors in 2006 and was fined.  Now, he’s been indicted in the Southern District of New York.

Bernie has a  established a website to take donations to pay for his defense.  After all, Bernard B. Kerik is the living embodiment of the American dream.  He is also a reminder of what becomes of government when we love our heroes too much to look behind the curtain.



Gotbaum: Asphyxia by Hanging?

The Maricopa County Medical Examiner  released its findings on the death of Carol Ann Gotbaum :  Asphyxia by hanging.  But there’s a catch.  It was “accidental”. 

The report contains a ton of info about how she was intoxicated. “One expert says that Gotbaum’s blood alcohol level was three times Arizona’s legal limit.”  Good thing she wasn’t driving.  Plus, she had two types of antidepressants, not to mention ibuprofen, in her system.  Plenty of detail about this stuff.  Again.

But how does someone “accidentally” hang themselves then they are cuffed, and the cuffs are connected to a chain that is bolted to a bench?  You see, the physics don’t work.  It’s not like she fell off, say, a chair and the chain accidentally wrapped itself around her throat, causing asphyxiation.  After all, she might well have fallen, but it would have been from the bench to the floor.  And the chain was bolted to the bench.  And the chain was connected to her cuffs.  Picture this in your head and try to imagine a way in which she could hang herself. 

Given that Carol Ann Gotbaum was so significantly intoxicated, one would wonder why she was left unattended to begin with.  But she was, and according to the Phoenix Police, that’s how they do things down there.  Maybe not the best method, but it’s their way.

The family, through their Arizona attorney, Michael Manning, has hired a private medical examiner, though the report won’t be available for a while.  In the meantime, Phoenix’s Mayor “says the autopsy confirms that Phoenix police did the right thing.”

The right thing?  Maybe not the wrong thing, but that’s not the same.  If it was the right thing, the “prisoner” would be alive.  We started out with questions.  We still have questions.  But the autopsy report was supposed to answer the big question.  I still can’t picture how Carol Ann Gotbaum hung herself “accidentally.”

Bits & Pieces

Michael Mukasey is  confirmed as Attorney General.  He’s rumored to be taking a vacation on an island just south of Florida where he’s planning to do a little waterboarding.  We hope he finds it relaxing.

Bernard Kerik is indicted.  My good buddy, Joe Tacopina wants to know if this means he has to give the wristwatch back.

From I Was The State :


Why The Dollar Is Sinking
The Senate overrides Bush’s veto of the pork laden water resources bill. What courage. The same Senate that can’t take a stand on any important issue bands together to save local pet projects. My tax dollars are going to resand Barbara Boxer’s beaches in California, inter alia. Meanwhile, the deficit is officially over $9 TRILLION.

If you don’t think the devaluation of the dollar matters, buy something.  Just because it’s too much for most people to try to understand doesn’t mean that it isn’t making our lives miserable daily.  Thank God we have enough credit left over to borrow money to pay for the war in Iraq.  It would be wrong to “cut and run,” no matter what the price.

Ron Kuby’s radio show with Guardian Angel’s founder Curtis Sliwa is  canceled to make room for the new Imus in the morning show.  Kuby was overheard mumbling under his breath, “nappy headed ho.”



“He gets my job, and I’m told about the high price he paid,” Kuby continued, his voice rising in disbelief. “He’s paid? What about me? The press release ought to say, `Ron Kuby has paid a high price for Don Imus’ mistake.’ He gets $20 million, an eight-month vacation and my job.”


Sliwa was back on the air without Kuby. The beret-wearing broadcaster will end up with a show in a different time slot, operating without [Kuby].

In a related story, Bill Kunstler was heard laughing. 

Arthur Bremer, the man convicted of shooting Alabama Governor and presidential candidate George Wallace, will be  released tomorrow from prison.  He was originally sentenced to 63 years, later reduced to 53 years, and received 17 years off for “good aim behavior.” 

In a related story, Bill Kunstler was heard laughing.  Oh yeah.  He’s dead.

Leslie Crocker Snyder is Back in Town

When the prosecution of ex-FBI agent Lindley DeVecchio for being the inside man for mobster Gregory Scarpa collapsed during the testimony of Scarpa’s former girlfriend, Linda Schirro, it made the prosecution look bad.  Really bad.  And when the prosecution looks bad, somebody has to pay.  Linda Schirro just become “somebody”.

But who can you get to guarantee that the target gets nailed?  Ladies and gentlemen, I would like you all to give a warm welcome to Leslie Crocker Snyder, fresh from her 6 month engagement in New Orleans.  According to the New York Times, former Acting Supreme Court Judge Snyder has been appointed “special prosecutor” by Brooklyn Administrative Judge Neil Firetog.


The Brooklyn district attorney, Charles J. Hynes, requested the appointment to avoid “the appearance of impropriety.”

This is one of the funniest lines ever printed in the Times.  Appointing Leslie to “avoid” the appearance of impropriety?  Leslie is the embodiment of prosecutorial impropriety.  Leslie Crocker Snyder, who slinked away from the New York law scene after an embarrassing loss for District Attorney to Robert Morganthau, comes to the game with perhaps the most overwhelming resume as a prosecutor that anyone could claim. 

The only problem is that she amassed her prosecutorial vitae while a sitting judge.  For this, she is a legend.  When you needed a warrant signed, you went to Leslie.  When you had a case that any other judge would toss, you made sure it got assigned to Leslie.  When you wanted to get a defendant to rat and feared that his lawyer would be a problem, you secretly asked Leslie to invent something called “shadow counsel” to fundamentally subvert the Constitution.

Leslie Crocker Snyder was nothing if not imaginative.  She found ways to prosecute from the bench that no judge before her had even dreamed about.  The avenging angel of the bench, it wasn’t enough to sentence defendants to multiple centuries in prison (just in case), but she had to attack, humiliate, demean them as well.  To the point where she had a full-time security detail to drive her around town in a city-owned car.  You see, Leslie needed protection to the tune of a few hundred thousand dollars a year to preserve her right to spew venom and enrage defendants to the point of threatening her life.  Too bad for all the children who might have enjoyed health care, but wasn’t it more important to spend money to protect Leslie’s right to spew?

So why now?  Well, there’s another District Attorney race a’coming, and Leslie’s name hasn’t been in the paper in a long time.  She wants to be the District Attorney.  It’s what she’s always wanted to be.  And, in all fairness, I’ve spent some quality time with Leslie, having had numerous cases before her.  When I was interviewed by Mike Wallace for a 60 Minutes piece on Leslie Crocker Snyder, I said that I would support her for anything, other than judge.  Judge Snyder thinks that I’m the devil.  Me? I think she is a tad harsh, but then I’m the devil, right?

But that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t know a little something about her.  And poor Linda Schirro, who is so destined to be slaughtered for embarrassing Joe Hynes, doesn’t have a shot in hell.   While I have no clue whether she perjured herself or not, there can be no doubt what the outcome of this “investigation” is going to be. 

Unless, of course, Leslie finds some benefit to exonerating Schirro to shed her image as the Hanging Judge for her upcoming campaign.  After all, only yesterday did Leslie send out an email to all her supporting telling them of her epiphany (at the expense of her arch-enemy and competitor, former Westchester County District Attorney Jeanine Pirro) that she is no longer for the death penalty.  Of course, it helps that New York no longer has a death penalty.

Personally, I am so glad that Leslie Crocker Snyder is back in the game.  There are so many important issues to discuss, and no one better to make a point of what’s wrong with the criminal justice system than Leslie.  Ahem, I meant Judge Snyder.  I didn’t mean to be disrespectful.

Now That It’s Over

My shameless effort at trying to avoid abject embarrassment in the Best Law Blog contest is now at an end.  Needless to say, Simple Justice did not win.  However, we didn’t come in last either, and for that we’re actually very proud.

As Brian Leitner makes clear, this is just a silly contest.  There are great blawgs that aren’t in the running.  There are blawgs that have important things to say that were left out.  There are blawgs that are far, far more popular than Simple Justice that didn’t make the cut.  The problem is that a contest like this mixes apples and oranges, pitting blawgs against each other that are worlds apart in content and audience.

As for me, I was surprised and flattered to make the list.  Given that Simple Justice has been around for a mere 8 months, it was quite an honor.  As  Carolyn Elefant said when voicing her support for Nicole Black’s blawg, Sui Generis, there’s a certain appreciation for those who have stuck it out over the long haul to keep up the effort of writing a blawg that is interesting and fresh. 

Niki has done that.  Like me, she is a solo practicing lawyer, as opposed to the big guys who are either group blogs or paid bloggers.  Niki came in 7th in the voting, and I think my 5 votes for her yesterday helped push her ahead of number 8, Ms. JD.

So what’s the point.  Well, my goal was to not be embarrassed by coming in last.  Not that it really would have been embarrassing, but hey, who wants to come in last?  Beyond that, it was a great way to introduce Simple Justice to people who might otherwise have no reason to come here.  While my content isn’t for everybody, and particularly not for certain audiences (the neo-cons, the libertarians, the lawyer-haters, the Biglaw climbers, and even the lawprofs), diversity of ideas from readers makes for a much more interesting place.

And so, I thank the 7 readers who voted for me, over and over, for keeping me afloat.  I welcome the new readers who discovered Simple Justice and decided to stick around.  And I thank the folks at the Weblog Awards for even thinking that Simple Justice had any business being in the company of the other finalists. 

One last plug:  If you enjoy reading blawgs, particularly this genre of blawg (like these guys), let ’em know.  Trust me when I tell you, gentle readers, that there’s no huge organization or sugar daddy making our writing pay off with year-end bonuses.  We don’t blawg for awards or credit, but it’s nice to know that somebody out there appreciates the effort.

New York Lawyers to Walk the Walk For Pakistan

Yesterday, we  posted about San Francisco (note: I originally wrote “Frisco” to save space in the title, but was immediately admonished that Frisco was just plain uncool) lawyers holding a demonstration in support of the lawyers in Pakistan who are being herded up at gunpoint to protect Musharraf’s authority to emulate American democracy. 

Today, we announce that New York lawyers will be doing the same.  The New York City Bar Association, the New York State Bar Association, the New York County Lawyers‘ Association and the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers and others have coordinated efforts to rally in front of New York County Supreme Court at 60 Centre Street on Tuesday, November 13th at 1:00 p.m.  As in San Francisco, lawyers should try to wear dark suits and white shirts, the uniform preferred by Pakistani lawyers.

Here’s the note that was spread around the New York bar:

As an expression of solidarity with our beleaguered colleagues at the Pakistani bar, the New York City Bar Association, the New York State Bar Association, the New York County Lawyers‘ Association and the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers in conjunction with other organizations invite you to attend a public rally in front of the New York County Courthouse, 60 Centre Street on Tuesday, November 13, from 1:00-1:30 p.m.    

The crude and brutal suspension of law and the legal system in Pakistan, and the repression of judges and lawyers there, require that we take a moment from our own busy schedules and demonstrate our concern. 
 
Because the images from Pakistan show the violent repression of Pakistani lawyers wearing their customary dark suit and white shirt, we request that you appear on Tuesday in similar attire, though this is not required.  What is important is a strong show of support.

We hope to see you there.

There’s no reason why every lawyer in New York City can’t take the time out of his lunch hour to show support.  Let’s do something to prove that we not only talk the talk, but walk the walk.