Author Archives: SHG

1st Amendment: Honor God

Yesterday, I argued an appeal before the Appellate Division, First Department on a case involving the faxing of a lawyer’s newsletter to other lawyers.  The newsletter was a substantive essay about a particular area of law of general interest to lawyers, but the plaintiff, also a lawyer, didn’t want to receive it and sued under the  Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA).

My argument focused on the fact that the newsletter was protected speech under the  1st Amendment to the United States Constitution.  The TCPA prohibits the uninvited commercial solicitation of goods or services via fax, under the theory that it ties up someone else’s fax, and uses their paper and toner. 

Junk faxes are, without question, an annoyance, though their vitality is well past their prime as faxes are no longer a favored means of sending advertisements because the fax is a dinosaur.  I opened with the point that this decision will likely have little impact in the fax world, as the problem had abated under its own weight.  Technology had moved on.  However, the decision would be very significant to this Court’s 1st Amendment jurisprudence, which would be applied to upcoming issues of huge importance, such as lawyer advertising.  Thus, this decision should be viewed in its proper context, as this Court and the bar would live with the consequences of this decision for a long time to come.  The Court didn’t seem terribly interested in this point.

Many of the recipients of this newsletter enjoyed receiving it.  Some called to cancel it (which my client happily did) and others called to ask for it, because they wanted to receive it.  The plaintiff lawyer, after receiving 7 issues, sued.  He also sued for another 7 issues sent to another attorney who had been using his fax number but was no longer in his office.

The attorney for the plaintiff argued zealously that this was a commercial advertisement.  When pushed to the wall by the judges, his only response was “why else?” Why else would an attorney put word to paper and send it out?  The Court was troubled by his argument.  I was offended by his argument.  He was self-righteous.

But a question was posed to me by Justice George Marlow.  He asked, what if my client’s fax was 1000 pages, used up all the paper and all the toner and tied up the fax for hours.

I struggled with this question.  The obvious, and correct, answer is that the 1st Amendment trumps whatever inconvenience (monumental waste and annoyance) one could conjure up by taking the point to its logical extreme.  Why?  Because it’s the price of living in the United States of America, where we have a 1st Amendment that tells government and courts what it cannot regulate.  But Justice Marlow wasn’t buying.

The judge was singularly unimpressed with the 1st Amendment.  He appeared to have some experience with annoying faxes, and he wasn’t letting go.  From what I could see, my first amendment right stopped at his fax machine.  I argued that the TCPA was very limited in its prohibition, and was so held in order to pass constitutional muster.  He didn’t care.  At one point, Justice Marlow’s “question” became more of a rant against the evils of junk faxes.  Not a good sign for me.  Not a detached vision as one would want from a judge.  But that was how it went.

After the argument, I told me client (who was present in the audience) that I wasn’t satisfied with how a dealt with Justice Marlow’s question.  I told him that I just couldn’t come up with a good response.

My client looked at me and said, “Honor God.”

It was perfect.  It was brilliant.  It was THE answer.  I wish I had thought of it.

What he meant was, what if each page of the thousand page fax contained only two words, “Honor God.”  Over and over.  Page after page.  It’s hard to imagine anything more annoying.  But it’s impossible to miss the point that the 1st Amendment precludes any law to prohibit it.  While extreme (and fortunately so), it’s the price of being an American, and a price that every judge must accept.

This morning, one day after argument, it was  announced  that Justice Marlow will be leaving the Appellate Division bench to become the New York State court system ethics czar. 

The Ultimate Judge of Morality

Nicole Black at  Sui Generis posts her  Legal Currents Column about the 4th Department decision in In re Bobbijean P., 2007 WL 2812608.  This was a troubling case in a big picture sort of way.  As Nicole explains it

At issue in the case was the legality of Monroe County Family Court Judge Marilyn O’Connor’s order requiring the appellant, a homeless African-American struggling with drug addiction, to refrain from becoming pregnant “until she has actually obtained custody and care of (her child) Bobbijean P. and every other child of hers who is in foster care or has not been adopted or institutionalized.”


To many, the remedy strikes a chord with common sense.  If this woman can’t manage the life she has already made for herself, then how can she bring yet more children into this world that she can’t manage? 

This is consistent with our Judeo-Christian ethic.  It conforms with our sense of personal responsibility.  It’s how we would conduct our own lives, assuming we were homeless drug addicts.  But as Nicole correctly points out, this isn’t about imposing our personal sense of morality upon others.  It’s about the law.

This is how the law steps onto that slipper slope, by imposing an end result that few people would find troubling.  But once it’s on that slope, the slide downhill is inevitable.

Do we want to give judges the authority to decide who has the right to be pregnant?  While you may agree that Bobbijean is a poor candidate, what about the struggling young lawyer who lacks the income to support a child in a stable home?  What if this law student managed to finance her education by publicly guaranteed loans that remain outstanding?  And a child would have a deleterious effect on the repayment of those loans.  Now, her choice comes at a public cost.  Should she be allowed to make the choice, or does society have a sufficient interest to deny her a child?

Like Nicole, I agree that the issue in Bobbijean’s case is much bigger than one sorry human being’s circumstance.  It’s whether courts should impose personal moral decisions on others that eliminate their basic rights.  The right to procreate (or not to) is a fundamental human right.  It’s one of those lines that should never be crossed, even when crossing it would make a particular case much easier to address.  The 4th Department had an opportunity to draw a clear line in the sand.  Instead, it sidestepped the big issue and ruled on a smaller basis, leaving open the question of whether any law, any court, any judge, can fashion an order prohibiting a woman from having a child.

I suspect the issue will arise again, whether in the 4th Department or elsewhere.  I hope the court will see it as clearly as Nicole does.

Law School Problem Solving 201: The Students

So we’ve let the professors know that they’re boring.  Problem solved?  Not by a long shot.

Students are operating under the very mistaken impression that law school owes them a fascinating time and more.  Wrongo.  They are owed a legal education.  This isn’t a Broadway show, designed for the entertainment of the student consumers.  This is professional school.  There are things to be learned which are boring.  So what?  Grow up and learn what you need to know to be a lawyer.  And please, stop whining.

Did you think this was going to be all touchy feely?  There comes a time when we do what we have to do.  If you want to be a lawyer, then hunker down and do your work.  Put up with some boredom.  Stop assuming (and yes, it is an assumption and a wrong one at that) that you already know everything and that law school is just a waste of time for someone as brilliant as you.

Here’s a little secret from the world of lawyers:  We don’t think kids coming out of law school these days are very good.  They are lazy.  They are whiny.  They expect everything to be handed to them and get all hot and bothered because people don’t treat them nicely. 

Treatment of youth has been changing for a long time, with my generation (the baby boomers) doing a generally poor job of raising children with the right attitude and capability to survive in the grown up world.  We coddled them.  We gave them what our parents couldn’t afford to give us.  Hell, we gave them everything.  This was a big mistake. 

Our kids never learned that the world doesn’t owe them things.  They became jaded because they have everything.  We told them how wonderful they are and they believed us.  We were just trying to bolster their self-esteem (like the experts told us we should),  and now they all walk around like King Tut, thinking their wish is our command.  And to please them and bring that beautiful smile to their cherubic faces, we gave them more still.  So, baby boomers screwed up our children.  Tough luck.  Get past it.

So it should come as no surprise that the very notion of their being responsible for sitting on their little tushies and working hard to learn the law, even when it doesn’t fascinate and charm them, would be foreign.  The little darlings don’t suffer unpleasantness.  At least not happily.  They demand better, because they think they can.  From what I see, they can demand better, because the profs continue to give in to their demands.

To make matters worse, the sweet young inchoate lawyers are hypersensitive.  I agree that far more is accomplished with positive reinforcement than negative, and that no purpose is served by belittling students who don’t perform as well as they should.  But this doesn’t mean that they can take a punch, and every once in a while they are going to get one right in the jaw.  Are they going to cry in court?

They don’t take no for an answer.  They feel empowered to disagree with anyone who says that they need some improvement.  They argue the point.  They ultimately assert, “Well, that’s your opinion,” like a 3 year old.   They are both bold and simultaneously of the view that their opinion is equal to everyone else’s.  No, a law student’s opinion is not the equal of a professors’.  Or a lawyers’.  That’s why we call you “students”

Lawprofs want to treat students like adults.  I would too.  Unfortunately, law students don’t seem to act like adults.  This stunted adolescent behavior, mistaken belief in their perfection and demand to be entertained has skewed their understanding of how they fit into the world.  There’s a pecking order for a reason.  Students have yet to learn what lawyers and professors have.  Like what?  Go to class, practice law for a few years, try a few cases, and then we’ll talk. 

When they go in front of a jury with their brilliant arguments, do they intend to yell at the jury for not showing them the love by their verdict?  When the judge denies their objection, will they respond that they’re going to tell their daddy?  Where are they supposed to learn their role in the law?  If they aren’t learning it in law school, then they won’t know it when they get that $190k job at Biglaw.  Oh yeah, and that job won’t make them think their entitled to be king of the world.  Not much.

So, dear students, it’s your responsibility to learn how to become lawyers.  Every day in law school is not going to be another day in paradise.  Your professor isn’t the third string substitute for Stephen Colbert or Sarah Silverman.  They are professors.  They are scholars.  They may not be the most fascinating people in the world, but they know a whole lot more than you do.  If you don’t want to learn what they have to teach, what they hell are you doing wasting a seat?

Sure, to be effective professors should be capable of engaging you.  But you, dear students, must be capable of being engaged.  By the law, not by a decent floor show.  The law is not always interesting.  Indeed, it’s often quite mundane.  But you need to learn the basics anyway, particularly how to think and analyze like a lawyer.  And that can be a particularly unpleasant activity because you’re not going to do it right for a long time.  No matter how wonderful mommy says you are.

And it gets even worse.  Clients, judges and your boss may not treat you the way you think they should.  Sometimes, they may tell you that you didn’t do very well.  They may even tell you that you’re wrong.  Even that you stunk.  It happens.  It will hurt your delicate feelings. And you can’t cry or lash out about it.  Nobody cares.  Being a grown up takes work, and sometimes a thick skin.  Sometimes you have to shrug it off.  Sometime you have to listen and learn, because you really did stink.

If you want to be a lawyer, don’t take “Law and Popular Movies” in law school.  It won’t come in handy.  This is particularly true if you don’t end up getting one of those $190k jobs, and instead find yourself unable to make the BMW lease payments.  Talk about a rude awakening.  Don’t blame your law school.  Don’t blame your law professors.  Being a professional means making your own way through your profession.  There is no guaranteed pot of gold at the end of law school.  It’s entirely up to you.

And even though you don’t need to work so you can eat tonight, you might want to try getting a job with a real lawyer.  Maybe, just maybe, it will give you a clue what you’re getting into.  It may even teach you what real lawyers do everyday.  Trust me, it’s not going to be as fascinating as listening to law professors drone. 

Enjoy law school.  It’s the last time in your life that you will be able to sit back and pretend that you are working very hard when you’re really shouldering the least amount of responsibility that one can while pretending one is a true grown up.  The day law school is over, you will find all the harsh expectations of the real world without the glamor of your unlimited potential that mommy told you about as she tied your shoe and wiped your nose. 

So stop your bellyaching and go to class.  Listen, even to the boring profs because they still have plenty to teach you.  And appreciate that you don’t know everything.  It’s not much of a price to pay to become a lawyer.

Don’t Force It

My good buddy from the land where the courthouse doors shut promptly at 5, Mark Bennett, appears to getting very philosophical lately.  His variations on Zen proverbs to explain his Taoist leanings to the ignorant masses (like me) make me hear the sweet strains of sitars in my sleep.

But one paragraph from his latest missive caught my eye:

Act without doing anything. Don’t force it. Find the helpful forces at work in your case, and give them room to work. The less you have to interfere, the better off your client is (Bennett’s Chainsaw at work).


This may be one of those concepts that trial lawyers, particularly inexperienced trial lawyers, should have tattooed to their foreheads:  Don’t Force It!  More lawyers have gone down in flames, seizing defeat from the jaws of victory, by trying to make something happen when it’s just not there.

Society prizes action.  When life gives you lemons, make lemonade, right?  If you can, absolutely.  No trial lawyer worth anything doesn’t want to find that tiny crack that he can use to tear down the huge wall.  Just give us something to work with, something to exploit.  It doesn’t have to be flagrant.  Just a little, itty-bitty crack will do.

But sometimes the crack doesn’t come.  Sometimes, no matter how badly we (or our client) wants us to rip some witnesses head off because he’s a lying, scheming dog, there is just no way to do it.  It kills our client, who will grab our arm and squeeze it so hard that the blood stops circulating.  He’s just dying to jump up and scream that the witness is a liar.  We hold him so that he doesn’t.  We talk calmly to him to keep him from doing it.  But the client wants us to do it for him.  He knows we get to cross the witness soon, and he wants us to stand up in front of the jury and let them know the truth.

And sometimes it just doesn’t happen.  Sometimes, the witness doesn’t give us the opportunity.  Sometimes, the witness just sticks to his guns, keeps his cool and repeats what he said on direct.  It is hardly unusual that the witness has practiced his story well enough that the lie sounds more reasonable than the truth. 

This is what a well rehearsed police witness was meant to do, and plenty of our friends in law enforcement testify very well.  They are so very good at lying because they believe that they are doing the right thing.  They feel neither guilt nor shame about being liars.  They believe they are doing God’s work on the stand, and a little lie to put a criminal away is all in a day’s work.

Watching a lawyer force it is most painful when it’s your co-counsel on a multi-defendant case.  It’s not that I’ve never done it, but it’s one thing to blame yourself for a mistake, but another to watch someone else do it, see it coming, know what’s about to happen and then, CRASH, be helpless to stop the bleeding when it does.

When co-counsel forces it, there are two flavors.  The first is plain vanilla, when she wants so badly to make a point, even when there’s no crack, that she asks a question out of desperation and the witness smacks her hard with a well-timed, well-tuned, answer.  This can bring a quick end to an otherwise competent cross-examination, and whatever good was done is undone in a single response.  The lawyer slinks back to the defense table, hoping no one noticed or that the death toll isn’t as high as she knows it is, and sits down before anything else can happen.

The second flavor is Tutti-Frutti.  That’s the one where you’ve just completed a spectacular cross and the witness hasn’t touched the co-defendant.  There is no reason in the world why co-counsel would get up and ask a question.  Not a single question needed.  Nothing.  But she just can’t help herself.  Whether because she needs to show her client that she’s doing something, or she just wants in on your successful cross, she gets up at the judge’s invitation anyway.

This is when you know nothing good could come of it.  This is when you cringe before the first question is asked.  You try to grab her attention to whisper in her ear, “sit down now or I will beat the daylights out of you in the hallway at the next break.”  But she’s not paying attention.  She’s in the zone.  And then, CRASH, it happens.  She asks the question that you just nailed, the one where you had the witness bleeding on the ground, gasping for breath, wiping tears from his eyes as he broke down in front of the jury.  It’s been asked.  It’s been answered.  It’s perfect.  And then she asks it again.

Only this time, the witness has collected his thoughts.  He’s engaged in that human ability to think of exactly what to say one minute after the wrong thing came out of his mouth.  One minute too late.  Unless someone asks the question again.  As co-counsel just did. 

The killer instinct makes us want to push the envelope just one fraction of an inch farther than it should go.  It’s that last push that constitutes forcing it.  Perhaps the way to stop ourselves from complete self-immolation is to think Tao or Zen, as Bennett tells us to do.  Or maybe we just need to remember at that critical juncture when we are ahead of the game, even if only by one point, to shut up and sit down.  Whichever way you want to think of it, just don’t force it.

Blog Awards – Putting Lipstick on a Pig

Simple Justice was born on February 13, 2007, after the blog award season of the preceding year.  So I really didn’t know much of anything about awards.  But we’re here in the thick of things for the 2007 season,

To the extent that I “get it,” these awards serves the useful purpose of getting one’s blog on other people’s radar,so that they will come, read and, if they think you’ve got something to say, read it again another day.  When you write day after day, you hope somebody will read.  You also hope somebody will see some merit in your thoughts, or better yet create some friction that will generate an interesting discussion.

But in the blog world, there are big one and small ones.  Simple Justice is a relatively small blog.  There are wittier, smarter, cutting-edgier blogs than Simple Justice.  There are blogs whose popularity dwarfs us by far.  These are the blogs that win awards. 

Some may complain that it will result in stagnation if the same handful of highly popular, well-known blogs win.  After all, how can a new blog compete with one that is already so well-known and popular that it’s going to win any internet beauty pageant hands down.  While it would be in my interest to join in this complaint, I really can’t. 

The most popular blogs are so popular for a reason.  They obviously appeal to a broader spectrum of readers, or even the same spectrum but do a much better job of providing readers with something they want to read.  That’s how it goes.

Simple Justice has won a couple of kudos, for which I am humbly grateful.  We were one of the 10 Best Criminal Law Blawgs from Jamie Spencer’s survey.  We were named by a few different blogs in Le Meme Chose.  And Anne Reed passed along a Thinking Blogger Award (in tandem with our next-door neighbor, Defending People by Mark Bennett).  I was honored by these honors.  I was honored just to make a list.

We’ve been nominated for Best New York Blawger and Blawg at Sui Generis.  We’ve also been nominated for a 2007 Weblog Award for Best Law Blog.  Some blawgs are openly stumping for votes.  They really want to win.  I’m not quite that shameless (How shameless am I?), plus I don’t think that Simple Justice is really in the running anyway, so there’s no good reason to waste the bandwidth.  Blawgs like Above the Law, Quizlaw and Overlawyered have far more readers than Simple Justice, and if popularity dictates the winner, then they should win.  And perhaps they have more readers because they are more, ahem, interesting?

Simple Justice was never created for mass appeal.  I don’t try to court readers, and don’t present a single-minded agenda that will win the hearts and minds of millions of readers.  Some blogs don’t want to make enemies, and thus avoid controversy.  Controversy doesn’t bother me at all.  I don’t try to create it, as much as don’t avoid it if it happens in the course of making a point.  We’ve had some dust-ups here with other bloggers, whose single issue agendas lead them to write things that I believe are very wrong.  Sometimes these end up creating some great dialogue.  Other times they devolve into crap.  A good quality dialogue takes two sides contributing, so I can’t do it alone.

This will drive some readers who don’t agree with me away.  While I would rather them stay and make their case, the beauty of blogs is that you can just move on whenever you feel like it.  To them, Simple Justice is just a pig, unworthy of their time.  I could try to keep them here and become the most popular law blog on the internet, but it would just be putting lipstick on a pig.  I would rather just write about the things that matter to me, and if it interests you, helps you or gives you a reason to come back and read again, then it makes it worthwhile.  Thanks for reading.  Thanks for the nominations.  But mostly, thanks for coming back and reading again.

The Ethicist Tackles the Tough Issues

If anyone doesn’t know, the Sunday New York Times Magazine has a column by Randy Cohen called “The Ethicist.”  I’ve never been clear on what makes one an Ethicist, or how Randy got the nod, but since he’s got his own New York Times column and I don’t, he has to know something that I don’t.

Today, Randy responds to two questions.  The first is about a roommate who has turned to prostitution to pay the rent.  Right, like that’s something new.  The second, however, presents an interesting question.  It is about the loss of 3 pairs of shoes that cost $2,000.

$2000!  Are we talking about bespoke shoes, made by some fellow in a grotto outside of London who has lovingly prepared a “last” of this woman’s dainty yet misshapen foot to conceal its orthopaedic demands?  No.  Apparently, these are just shoes.  No mention of Jimmy Choo or alligators or any of the things that would make one say, “Ah, so that’s why they cost so much.”

Since the exposure of Imelda Marcos’ (see how I work a little criminal law into this otherwise OT post) closet, women’s footwear has been a running joke.  Popularized on “Sex in the City,” where Carrie somebody preferred shoes to regular eating habits, I’ve wondered why.  No man that I’m aware of looks at a woman’s shoes.  No man that I’m aware of says to himself, “Sure she’s intelligent and witty, but would you take a look at those awful pumps.”

My assumption is that women judge each other by their footwear.  If a woman wants to be taken seriously, be well-liked, even admired, by other women, she must prove her mettle through her shoes.  Why do I assume this?  Because it makes no sense otherwise.  There are starving children in Darfur, and women spend $2000 on 3 pair of shoes?  No one can possible be this shallow and uncaring, right?

Wrong.  These are not twinkies who care about no one and nothing.  These are cosmopolitan women, women who will march for good causes (in sneakers) and who are well-educated and erudite.  But they have these deep, secret, need for shoes.  Do they all have a hidden desire to be like Imelda?  Is there a status issue that has been concealed by modern women from men? 

I don’t know.  I don’t get it.  It’s one thing to get a decent guffaw out of such silliness, but it’s not just a joke.  And if Randy Cohen doesn’t understand why, then how would a guy like me?

Practical Blawgosphere: The Dozier Demand Scam

While this has floated around blawgs as the joke of the week, I wanted to make sure that my amigos in the practical blawgosphere were alerted to the Dozier Demand Scam, as noted by my good buddies, the Turk at New York Personal Injury Law, here and here, and Andrew Lavoott Bluestone at New York Attorney Malpractice Blog. (BTW, Andrew has a post about strip clubs right beneath it, if you need a little motivation to go there.)

The hubbub is all about a demand letter sent by a lawyer who has dubbed his biz The Dozier Internet Law Firm (which I believe reflects the fact that they can put you to sleep faster than any other internet law firm) to Public Citizen.  This guy Dozier sends a “cease and desist letter” on behalf of its client to take down a complaint website about “scams” that defamed the client.  This aspect is no big deal, since it happens fairly regularly and these letters tend to produce scorn and laughter around the blawgosphere.

But Dozier added a new twist that elevated him to new heights of blawgosphere ridicule.  He claimed that his cease and desist letter was itself copyrighted, and therefore directed Public Citizen not to publish the letter itself on the internet.  So naturally, that’s exactly what they did.

The scuttlebutt around the blawgosphere is whether this is a cynical attempt to get the Dozier name out there amongst the blawgs to up their google page rank and get this firm on the radar of people who would otherwise never have heard of it.  If so, then Dozier deserved more credit than he’s given.  But this motive has been met with skepticism since Dozier has been universally viewed as a jerk, and worse yet, a jerk whose actions have hurt his client by alerting as many people as possible to the allegations of scam and discontent.

Regardless, for those of us who are so focused on our little corner of the blawgosphere that we don’t hear about things like this, be aware that if you get a letter like this, it makes for great posting fodder and will do wonders for your google page rank.

And by the way, Dozier is a Super Lawyer!  His motto?  “You better know when to hold ’em, know when to fold ’em.”  Methinks Public Citizen called his bluff, and he had nothing in his hand.

Law School Problem Solving 101: The Professors

As regular readers know, I often digress into non-criminal discussions because, as Gideon correctly pointed out, it’s my blawg and I can write what I want.  So, no comments from criminal defense lawyers or New York lawyers who want to chastise me for going beyond the scope.  Today is law professor day, because I say so.  If you don’t care, click here.

Recently, we’ve discussed a number of problems that are apparently rampant in law school and affecting the self-image of lawyers as well as efficacy of law school.  The students are disconnected and miserable and the LawProfs want to change everything to alleviate the misery.  All in all, things are not working very well.

The LawProfs are angry at me because I poke some fun at them and don’t (in their eyes) show sufficient respect for their efforts.  I have been told, in plain language, that it’s just as hard to be a law professor and stand up in front of a class of law students as it is to try a case before a jury.  There was a bit of throat clearing heard in the background over all the scoffing when this came across the broadband.

I didn’t raise this comparison, nor do I think it matters.  This is from the profs side, and I apparently touched a nerve by the perceived suggestion that being a lawprof is less worthy than being a lawyer.  We need lawprofs (assuming we need law schools, which I do) to teach law students.  They play an important role in our system and whether or not their job is comparable to that of a trial lawyer is irrelevant. 

But now we get into the nitty-gritty.  Law students complain, and complaint bitterly, on the various lawprof blogs about what they are getting out of law school.  I will address some thoughts about the complaints from the students side in another post.  Today, it’s all about the professors.

The students’ complaints can be wrapped up in one word:  disengaged.  They are bored.  They fail to see the relevancy of what they are being taught to what they hope to be.  And mostly they are bored. 

What do the professors see as the solution?  Eliminate compulsory attendance.  Sorry, wrong answer. 

First year isn’t as much of a problem, as the students arrive bright eyed with their empty 3-ring binders and Law School t-shirts, ready to learn.  They will take whatever the lawprof dishes out, because they don’t know much of anything.  They’ve seen The Paper Chase (or perhaps Legally Blond) and anticipate the Socratic method as their challenge.  They’re ready for it.

Second, and most particularly, third year students are not as easy.  Within the insular world of law school, these are the big guys, the ones who have been there and done that.  BMOCs.  These students fall into two groups:  The ones who want to succeed at being law students (the law review types) and the ones who want to succeed at being lawyers.  The former complain because law school is too low-brow for them, believing that they need intellectual stimulation so that their brilliant minds don’t atrophy.  The latter complain because they’ve come to realize that little of what they’re hearing will do them any good when they get out in the real world.

Both of these complaints are wrongheaded.  Lawyers, unlike physicians, go out into the world as generalists.  Once we pass the bar exam, we are entitled to take on any legal matter under the sun, plus gain immediate access to licensure in other areas (such as Real Estate Broker).  To an unsuspecting public, the mere fact that we are lawyers entitled us to take money from people to advise or represent them in matters as diverse as estates and contracts and criminal prosecutions.  We have no initials after our names that let people know we are fellows in the American Academy of Pediatric Nose Hair Tweezing.  We are, simply, lawyers.

And so, students must leave law school with a reasonable overview of the law, not merely to pass the bar exam (as is a major concern of law schools determined to up their ranking in the US News and World Reports tier system) but because real people will one day ask them a question and rely on their answer.  Even if Little Timmy wants to specialize in “deep well law,” he needs to know something about real estate and even copyright. 

But Little Timmy doesn’t care, you parry.  Ah, this is where the demands on the Lawprofs become critical.  Make him care.  Engage him.  Worry less about how real estate law impacts the rights of Hogwarts versus the Ministry of Magic, and get down to the real world.  If you cannot find a way to make your subject of interest to law students, then you aren’t doing your job as a law professor.

Lawyers tend to be natural raconteurs.  We use our skills to weave a story to make a point.  We take our experiences (of course, you need to have experiences to make this work) to explain why some arcane piece of law matters today.  If our actual experiences don’t quite match our purpose, we take some literary license because we know that a story only works if its interesting and on point.  Is there a reason that lawprofs can’t do this as well?  Hey, you’re lawyers.  Figure it out.  You can be interesting.  You can engage your students.  And if you can’t, then you are not doing anyone any good as a lawprof.

Next, we have the disconnect between law school and law reality.  Students want to learn how to be lawyers.  By third year, it generally dawns on them that they don’t have a clue what being a real lawyer is all about.  Sure, they’ve read 942 Supreme Court decisions, but a few will come to realize that they won’t be arguing before SCOTUS in their first 6 months of practice.  So what are the capable of doing?  Nothing.  Zero. Nada.

When I went to law school, a lot of us were relatively poor and needed to earn a living if we wanted to eat on a fairly regular basis.  This forced us to get jobs with lawyers.  Law review was for the rich kids who didn’t need to work.  We learned to prepare motions.  We learned to deal with clients.  We learned to figure out stuff effectively and then make it happen.  If we didn’t, we’d lose our jobs and have that whole eating problem again.  We liked to eat, so we didn’t screw up.

This apparently doesn’t happen anymore.  The why will be discussed when I get to the student end of the problem, but the point here is that law school has lost the connection between training lawyers and training law students.  Lawprofs want to be scholars.  How nice for you.  Third year law students need lawyers, not scholars.  They need lawprofs who have had real experience and can connect the theory to the application.  Law students need to be taught what lawyers actually do and how they do it.

If you want to enga
ge a third year law student, teach him how to be a lawyer.  Teach him strategy and courtesy.  Teach her why one makes a summary judgment motion and why one doesn’t.  Teach them how to do it.  When I read that most law professors aren’t even admitted to practice law in the jurisdiction where they teach, I nearly gagged.  You’ve got to be kidding?  How can a lawprof teach practice when they have never seen the inside of a local courtroom?   Who are you to tell them the right way from the wrong way when you don’t have a clue? 

Lawprofs need to get out of the ivory tower where they hide from the viscitudes of real law and spend some time in the trenches, where their students will soon be heading.  That’s where lawyers are.  That’s where your students want you to be.  No student cares how many law review articles you’ve published.  Actually, no one cares, except you and possibly your tenure committee.  If you want to teach law, know law.  If you want students to listen to you, have something to say.  If you want to engage your students, stop being a bore and start earning your salary by teaching them what they’ve come to law school to learn.  But whatever you do, stop blaming your students because you’re a bore and have nothing to offer them.

Act Like a Lady

It’s not necessary to be a hooker in Huntington, West Virginia.  It’s enough to act like a hooker, according to the New York Lawyer.

Under the new law, suspects can be arrested for beckoning passers-by with conversation, attempting to stop traffic by waving their arms, circling an area in a vehicle or trying to stop pedestrians. An arrest can also be made if a suspect asks if a potential prostitute or patron is a police officer.

So let me play this out a bit.  My wife makes a wrong turn into a “high crime” area (a la Bonfire of the Vanities) and her car breaks down.  She tries to flag down a passing vehicle for help and . . . she’s a hooker?  Let’s try a variation.  She sees a white guy wearing white socks and sensible black shoes, but otherwise looking like a skel walking down a street and goes up to him, with a hopeful look on her face, and in a demure voice inquires, “Are you a police officer? . . . she’s a hooker?

The law has 2 qualifications: 

The offense must occur in a public place known to police as a high-crime area, and must be committed by someone who has been convicted of a prostitution offense within the past two years


Now there’s no official place known as a “high-crime area.”  These areas exist in the facile statement of police officers such that every area outside the Vatican qualifies.  And as to the second prong, a conviction for a prostitution offense within the past two years, can someone explain to me how a police officer would know that just by looking at some waving person on the street?  Could this be one of those arrest first, inquire later type laws?

Prostitution is apparently a blight on Huntington, West Virginia.  Has it occurred to anyone that arresting waving women on the street is not going to address the root of the problem?

Lynne Stewart: Bainbridge Has Fleas

Professor Bainbridge, who comes by his conservative politics honestly, has some unpleasant things to say about Lynne Stewart.  What support does he have for his views?  None other than the renown expert on Lynne Stewart, Walter Olson.

At the very least, if you lie down with fleas, you get up with fleas. Yet, Walter Olson observes that Stewart is more than just a lawyer representing a client:

Secret prison wiretaps leave no doubt that Stewart broke the law in the manner alleged. And she has forthrightly acknowledged her ideological solidarity with Abdul Rahman as a foe of American imperialism, and her support for “directed violence” against “the institutions which perpetuate capitalism, racism, sexism, and at the people who are the appointed guardians of those institutions.”


I really don’t mean to pick on Walter, who has lately made a cottage industry of being the Lynne Stewart expert.  But his conclusory observations are, well, mistaken?

Lynne wasn’t convicted because of her views on American Imperialism, or her admiration for the blind Sheik’s sincerity of belief.  There are certainly plenty of red-blooded Americans who stand firm in support of Palestinians who like to bomb busloads of Israeli children.  Does it matter that these aren’t American children?  Maybe to them.

Walter also raises the specter of the first World Trade Center bombing in 1993.  This one failed, but not because of desire.  Walter blames Lynne for this.  But this was what Lynne’s client, the blind Sheik, was charged with, not Lynne.  She was defending him for it, not participating in it. 

Lynne violated the SAMS.  Walter never talks about the SAMS.  Neither does Bainbridge.  The detail is lost in such hyperbole as “She gave material aid and assistance to a convicted terrorist.”  Sounds horrible, but not much detail.  Let’s try to put some flesh on these bones.

The SAMS are Special Administrative Measures that the government unilaterally imposed on prisoners  when the government believes “that there is a substantial risk that a prisoner’s communications or contacts with persons could result in death or serious bodily injury to persons, or substantial damage to property that would entail the risk of death or serious bodily injury to persons.”

When a lawyer represents such a prisoner, the lawyer is required to agree to the SAMS or is denied access to the client.  No negotiation.  No discussion.  If you don’t sign, you can’t see your client. 

Now, unbeknownst to Walter, the SAMS were there but universally viewed as one of those bizarre excesses of a certain right-wing Attorney General and Administration.  Ironically (and unmentioned by Lynne’s detractors), former Attorney General Ramsey Clark was Lynne’s co-counsel in the case.  He too signed the SAMS.  He too violated the SAMS.  He wasn’t prosecuted.

The government’s prosecution was based upon the allegation that Lynne Stewart signed the SAMS but never intended to abide by them.  How would they know?  They secretly tapped her attorney-client communications with the blind Sheik under the  1994 Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act warrant targeting her client.

On October 31, 2001, Attorney General John Ashcroft, secretly amended the SAM regulations – without notice to the public. As amended, the regulations allow the Bureau of Prisons to conduct videotape and audiotape surveillance with respect to attorneys’ communications with people in federal custody.


Included in this secret amendment was the authority to include attorney client conversations in the warrantless taps. 

From this, the government learned that Lynne was present when Mohammed Yousry, an interpreter, and Ahmed Abdel Sattar, who was acting as a law clerk, served as a conduit for the blind Sheik to communicate with the outside world, including composing a letter in arabic that was alleged to be a message to his followers.  In 2000, Lynne released a statement from her client that “withdrawing his support for a ceasefire that currently exists,” encouraging, according to the government, the Sheik’s supporters in Egypt to engage in violence.   Not a single act of violence was shown to have resulted from any of this. 

There you have it.  SAMS and eavesdropping on attorneys via secret amendments.  Did Lynne provide “material support” to terrorists?  If guys like Walter were to work with the facts rather than the overarching hyperbolic conclusory assertions, my guess is that this wouldn’t get him on cable TV news.  The real story is far less damning, and far less interesting. 

Also, it really doesn’t make the government look all that good, and there are plenty of red-blooded Americans who might not be so thrilled with the idea that defendants are denied their right to counsel if counsel won’t sign the SAMS, or that we have secret rules here that allow the warrantless eavesdropping on attorney client communications.  But mostly, a lot of Americans just wouldn’t get all that worked up if they knew what was meant by such screaming attacks against Lynne Stewart.

So Bainbridge is right on target when he says “if you lie down with fleas, you get up with fleas.” (Note to self, check this quote, because I always thought it was “if you lie down with dogs, you get up with fleas.”  But who am I to question Professor Bainbridge?)  I wonder who’s scratching themselves more these days, Walter or the good Professor?

Thanks to Elaine Cassel for her post at Findlaw for so many of the links used in this post.